What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Game of Thrones, tv only, books don't exist, no backstory...NERDS already ruining a series that hasn't started (1 Viewer)

I thought the greyjoy fleet were going to Dorne to get their army to attack KL. now wihtout that fleet, Dorne can't attack... I think?
This is a fairly big deal, but I guess details are next week.  Also looking at the map the distance from dragonstone to CR by sea is about 3x as long as the mereen to dragonstone voyage.  But they will make it all in half an episode that took 3 seasons previously.  It's not like they have tried to hide the geography in the past.  They painted the GD map on the floor in E1.

 
This is a fairly big deal, but I guess details are next week.  Also looking at the map the distance from dragonstone to CR by sea is about 3x as long as the mereen to dragonstone voyage.  But they will make it all in half an episode that took 3 seasons previously.  It's not like they have tried to hide the geography in the past.  They painted the GD map on the floor in E1.
Time is passing faster in Season 7 than in previous seasons, yes. There are probably only 11 episodes left for the whole damn show. They need to move some things along...

This article does a pretty good job of explaining (and criticizing, to some extent) that fact.

 
There were two things in this episode that were off to me. The conversation between Varys and Danaerys - not that it happened, but when it happened. That conversation would have more logically occurred when Varys first showed up at Danaerys's place back in Mereen. The other thing is that there's little plausibility of anyone believing anything Cersei has to say at this point, particularly anyone related to the Tyrells. She just blew up half the family - it's not some big secret either. A guy like Tarly would never have shown up for a meeting in the first place, much less consider helping her out. It's even worse considering she's not a legitimate ruler of Westeros by blood.

The rest of the episode was solid (except some parts of the battle scene).

Sam curing Jorah of greyscale would be a huge deal in a lot of ways. I don't understand people saying those scenes are a waste of time.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
There were two things in this episode that were off to me. The conversation between Varys and Danaerys - not that it happened, but when it happened. That conversation would have more logically occurred when Varys first showed up at Danaerys's place back in Mereen. The other thing is that there's little plausibility of anyone believing anything Cersei has to say at this point, particularly anyone related to the Tyrells. She just blew up half the family - it's not some big secret either. A guy like Tarly would never have shown up for a meeting in the first place, much less consider helping her out. It's even worse considering she's not a legitimate ruler of Westeros by blood.

The rest of the episode was solid (except some parts of the battle scene).

Sam curing Jorah of greyscale would be a huge deal in a lot of ways. I don't understand people saying those scenes are a waste of time.
I thought there was an "official" spin to the explosion?  

 
There were two things in this episode that were off to me. The conversation between Varys and Danaerys - not that it happened, but when it happened. That conversation would have more logically occurred when Varys first showed up at Danaerys's place back in Mereen. The other thing is that there's little plausibility of anyone believing anything Cersei has to say at this point, particularly anyone related to the Tyrells. She just blew up half the family - it's not some big secret either. A guy like Tarly would never have shown up for a meeting in the first place, much less consider helping her out. It's even worse considering she's not a legitimate ruler of Westeros by blood.

The rest of the episode was solid (except some parts of the battle scene).

Sam curing Jorah of greyscale would be a huge deal in a lot of ways. I don't understand people saying those scenes are a waste of time.
Dany was gone when Varys first showed up there. After she returned there wasn't time immediately because she was conquering the masters.

Logically, it would've occurred on the long boat ride to Dragonstone but the writers didn't want to waste time with the sailing part of the trip so they had the conversation occur right when they got to Dragonstone which, in my opinion, is fine. But there was really no time for it to have occurred in Mereen. 

 
There were two things in this episode that were off to me. The conversation between Varys and Danaerys - not that it happened, but when it happened. That conversation would have more logically occurred when Varys first showed up and Danaerys's place back in Mereen. The other thing is that there's little plausibility of anyone believing anything Cersei has to say at this point, particularly anyone related to the Tyrells. She just blew up half the family - it's not some big secret either. A guy like Tarly would never have shown up for a meeting in the first place, much less consider helping her out. It's even worse considering she's not a legitimate ruler of Westeros by blood.

The rest of the episode was solid (except some parts of the battle scene).

Sam curing Jorah of greyscale would be a huge deal in a lot of ways. I don't understand people saying those scenes are a waste of time.
Very strong points.

 
I thought it was to show that she isn't who she was anymore......but I thought it was redundant with the Hot Pie scene in which it seems like they were showing us that she isn't who she was anymore. 
In the Hot Pie scenes, her mannerisms were almost identical to the Hound's when they were traveling together.  And now, the Hound is acting like Arya used to be (kind and trying to spare people).  Interesting transference of character traits.

 
In the Hot Pie scenes, her mannerisms were almost identical to the Hound's when they were traveling together.  And now, the Hound is acting like Arya used to be (kind and trying to spare people).  Interesting transference of character traits.
The most quotable is the "one or two" line, which is now getting the meme treatment.  It was a good line, she's sort of turning into half her dad half hound character.  

 
The conversation took like 5 minutes.
I just remembered - Varys wasn't in Mereen when Dany returned. He was off trying to secure the Dorne/Tyrell alliance.

First time he was with Dany was on the boat ride which is logically where the conversation would have occurred. 

 
I just remembered - Varys wasn't in Mereen when Dany returned. He was off trying to secure the Dorne/Tyrell alliance.

First time he was with Dany was on the boat ride which is logically where the conversation would have occurred. 
O.k. then that's when that should have happened. That's the first discussion you have with the guy.

 
In the Hot Pie scenes, her mannerisms were almost identical to the Hound's when they were traveling together.  And now, the Hound is acting like Arya used to be (kind and trying to spare people).  Interesting transference of character traits.
Good catch. Arya definitely was acting like The Hound in that scene. 

 
People are going to nit-pick no matter what. I also thought the episode was great. Can't wait to watch it again and pick up on more of the details. With only 11 or whatever episodes left, I think they are doing a great job of wrapping up loose ends already while advancing plots.

Nymeria - people want to know what happened. Loose end that needed ending and it was down expertly with great symbolism and lines as already pointed out. 

Hot Pie - if the series ended without seeing him again, all would go to heck! Loose end that was tied up - he's done - and advanced the plot of Arya going back. 

Well done on wrapping up these loose ends. 

Continually love the non-Hollywood outcomes including Nymeria and Theon. Yeah - a typical Hollywood fashion would be for him to rescue his sister at the end or go down trying. Not GoT - he stayed true to character. He wants so badly to be a Greyjoy, but he was robbed of it being sent to Winterfell and then..Reek.
i agree about loving the non-Hollywood outcomes, but didn't Arya say "you are not Nymeria" in the episode. I took it to mean that there are more dire wolves out there, and that Nymeria is somewhere else, perhaps a leader of a pack. and i think they always talked about how Dire Wolves are smart, so who knows

 
There were two things in this episode that were off to me. The conversation between Varys and Danaerys - not that it happened, but when it happened. That conversation would have more logically occurred when Varys first showed up at Danaerys's place back in Mereen. The other thing is that there's little plausibility of anyone believing anything Cersei has to say at this point, particularly anyone related to the Tyrells. She just blew up half the family - it's not some big secret either. A guy like Tarly would never have shown up for a meeting in the first place, much less consider helping her out. It's even worse considering she's not a legitimate ruler of Westeros by blood.

The rest of the episode was solid (except some parts of the battle scene).

Sam curing Jorah of greyscale would be a huge deal in a lot of ways. I don't understand people saying those scenes are a waste of time.
In the world of Westeros, or do you think that Jorah is going to have a big impact on a plotline with Dany or something?   I just don't see what the point is besides they didn't seem to know what else to do with these guys so they are there together.  A lot of us get the feeling they are in hurry up mode for these episodes, so scenes like that just stick out as dragging it down for me. 

Personally, I just don't like Sam and I get greedy when his scenes are on.  I know it's not a this or that thing, but I would rather have just about any other person on screen and I start thinking - "well, we got this for 10mins, but 0 of The Hound". 

 
I was thinking about it last night and Sam is one of the bravest characters in the entire show. 
There's a general understanding that Sam Tarly is George Martin's alter-ego, and I believe he has more or less confirmed that in interviews.  Anyone thinking Sam's storyline isn't important is not paying attention.

 
Agreed.  And there isn't going to be anything close to a happy ending IMHO.  Everything is going to be bittersweet I think.  At best.
I don't know how it will end but I love how all these various stories are all converging and coming together. Seeing all the characters meeting up and everything pointing in a single direction instead of 10 or 20 is something I'm really enjoying.  

 
i agree about loving the non-Hollywood outcomes, but didn't Arya say "you are not Nymeria" in the episode. I took it to mean that there are more dire wolves out there, and that Nymeria is somewhere else, perhaps a leader of a pack. and i think they always talked about how Dire Wolves are smart, so who knows
Arya said "that's not you". She didn't mean that the wolf wasn't Nymeria, she meant that being a domesticated pet for a human isn't what Nymeria is.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't see it that way. I see the writers making a choice that spending time on the boat ride over wasn't important and I agree with that. 
They could have staged the same exact 5 minute conversation on the docks before they set out, or a room in Mereen. They didn't have to "spend time" on the boat ride. It's a somewhat glaring misstep to have that conversation after they've spent weeks/months together already.

 
Sam curing Jorah of greyscale would be a huge deal in a lot of ways. I don't understand people saying those scenes are a waste of time.
I'm wondering if there isn't a surprise-afflicted-person that Sam cures (after using Jorah as a guinea pig) that will provide a bigger plot twist than simply Jorah. Someone like Howland Reed? Just speculating (I don't know what books are)...

 
Yeah, I am the opposite with my #####ing and moaning.  Sure the huge spectacle scenes are great but the quiet moments and character development isn't what it used to be, and for my money that is what it really excelled at through the first 4 seasons. 
but how much character development can there be 5 seasons in, without constantly adding new characters? i think we are still seeing the development of plenty of characters (Sansa has become interesting as of late, and her character arc is intriguing), and they need to focus on the plot. i think if you go too much focus on character development you get a product like the Leftovers which basically has plot holes galore, seemingly put into the story as a setting/environment simply to better articulate character

 
Am I correct in this interpretation?

=================

The 3 sand snake girls are half sisters

Of the 3, only Tyene is Ellaria's real daughter

Tyene was the sand snake captured with Ellaria

This allows some symmetry where Cerci can kill the real daughter of Ellaria like Ellaria killed Cerci's daughter.

 
That anti-dragon spear is a complete joke.  Sure, if a dragon is sitting completely still in the middle of an assault and is not actively burning the people operating the spears, then you can drive one into its skull.  It's that easy!  Can't wait for the dragons to lay waste to the Lannisters.

I loved the part where Tyrion suggested sending the unsullied and dothraki to Casterly Rock and everyone just kind of looked dumbfounded like is this guy really suggesting to sack his hometown?

 
They could have staged the same exact 5 minute conversation on the docks before they set out, or a room in Mereen. They didn't have to "spend time" on the boat ride. It's a somewhat glaring misstep to have that conversation after they've spent weeks/months together already.
Didn't bother me at all. Sorry. I thought the scene was exceptional.

 
In the world of Westeros, or do you think that Jorah is going to have a big impact on a plotline with Dany or something?   I just don't see what the point is besides they didn't seem to know what else to do with these guys so they are there together.  A lot of us get the feeling they are in hurry up mode for these episodes, so scenes like that just stick out as dragging it down for me. 

Personally, I just don't like Sam and I get greedy when his scenes are on.  I know it's not a this or that thing, but I would rather have just about any other person on screen and I start thinking - "well, we got this for 10mins, but 0 of The Hound". 
I used to feel that way about Sam, but he is turning into a lynchpin in the whole drama, IMO. Even though he isn't directly involved in most of the action, he was the one who discovered that Dragon Glass can kill a White Walker. And now he has discovered where vast reserves of Dragon Glass exist. And he is going to cure Jorah, who will go on to do something very important.

In some ways, I see Sam as the "good guy" equivalent of Little Finger. He is off to the side, doing things that are absolutely crucial to the events that others are actively engaged in. 

 
Nice summary.

I'm with you, I don't get what the complaining is about.  It was dumb how euron found theons bunch at sea but I'm willing to let it slide.  
There seemed to be a lack of drama, tenseness, urgency - all the while moving plots along very quickly.

The scene around the big Risk Map was like a meh hollywood movie, felt more like the dramatic gravitas of a Star Wars scene, with a lack of depth and subtle pinch points that represent to usual tension you feel with this show.

That tension just seemed to be missing. :shrug:  

 
I used to feel that way about Sam, but he is turning into a lynchpin in the whole drama, IMO. Even though he isn't directly involved in most of the action, he was the one who discovered that Dragon Glass can kill a White Walker. And now he has discovered where vast reserves of Dragon Glass exist. And he is going to cure Jorah, who will go on to do something very important.

In some ways, I see Sam as the "good guy" equivalent of Little Finger. He is off to the side, doing things that are absolutely crucial to the events that others are actively engaged in. 
Yeah Sam's storyline has become quite significant. Don't forget he also has a Valyrian sword that should be rather important as well. 

 
In the world of Westeros, or do you think that Jorah is going to have a big impact on a plotline with Dany or something?
They've kept Jorah around this long - seems obvious he's got some significant part left to play himself. Maybe surviving greyscale will help him hold up against the others/zombies in a way regular mortals can't?

Beyond that, curing greyscale is, in itself, a big deal. It may have repercussions in regard to treating other circumstances that lead to zombification. Maybe greyscale zombification is the other side of the coin to white walker zombification? Greyscale isn't in this story just for the heck of it, it will link up with the larger plot at some point.

Beyond that, it shows that Sam is pretty brilliant, and pretty courageous in his own way, and it may mean he'll have knowledge that will come into play later on as well.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
The dany varys dialogue was cringeworthy bad.  Does everyone have to rep their slave cred?  
other than what Groovus mentioned above and that that conversation and some others flew in the face of all the seasons of nuance and intrigue, I actually didn't think it was as bad as that. but- and it's a small point- I noticed something weird about the lighting in that scene that felt after-school-special to me. distracting. 

 
That anti-dragon spear is a complete joke.  Sure, if a dragon is sitting completely still in the middle of an assault and is not actively burning the people operating the spears, then you can drive one into its skull.  It's that easy!  Can't wait for the dragons to lay waste to the Lannisters.

I loved the part where Tyrion suggested sending the unsullied and dothraki to Casterly Rock and everyone just kind of looked dumbfounded like is this guy really suggesting to sack his hometown?
Yeah, but if you have a dozen or two of those things......that's a game changer. 

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top