Yeah, liked this whole sequence alot (minus the starbucks cup). Made the obvious problems with the rest of the show more painful
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Game of Thrones, tv only, books don't exist, no backstory...NERDS already ruining a series that hasn't started (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter belljr
- Start date
Gr00vus
Footballguy
He's going to (try to) kill Cersei and his unborn child to save the kingdom - kingslayer to the end, doing the right thing while coming off as a villain. That's the ending to his story that makes the most sense to me. If they really go full circle, we'll find out Cersei's loaded up on the wildfire beneath the entire city again, and is more than willing to blow it all up once she realizes she's done - then Jamie saves the day, returning the daughter of the king he killed to the throne.
Godsbrother
Footballguy
It wasn't perfect but I thought this episode was a coming back to form for the show. I enjoyed it.
I'd say Tyrion is more likely to go down for treason than Varys - Daenerys already has expressed doubts about Tyrion's loyalty - particularly when it comes to Cersei - this latest fiasco won't help.
supermike80
Footballguy
Ohhh!!!! Tyrion will be on the executioner's table and Jamie will pull his executioner's hood off like they did in Bill and Ted's excellent adventure!! And everyone will be SAVED!!!
Last edited by a moderator:
Bob Sacamano
Footballguy
Yeah, I don't think that's why he left. Not with all those sentences ending in "for Cesei".
Might be where he ends up, though.
Gr00vus
Footballguy
I do expect him to make his way back into her presence, and then some sort of confrontation between him and Euron in which Jamie ridicules Euron with the knowledge that the child in Cersei's belly is Jamie's and not Euron's. Could go a few different ways from there. I do enjoy snarky Jamie, so I hope we get one more scene's worth of that.
Another vote for another great episode. Minor whining is mostly ridiculous.
I love that Arya said she won't be back. That really makes you wonder what she is up to or planning or thinking will happen. Since she is with Hound, I think it lends a lot of credence to the Hound going through the Mountain to get to Cersei with Arya right there. Jamie, and possibly Tyrion, will be there also so any are still options to take her out.
I love that Jamie is taking off and you don't really know for sure whether he is for or against Cersei. He had a chance at happiness but couldn't leave it alone.
Interesting that Cersei didn't have Tyrion shot. That was a big moment. Too big to be a plot flaw, imo. My initial thought though is it comes back to haunt her like 'she had her chance back when he was at the wall.'
I'm thinking Hound takes out Mountain. Arya takes out Jamie who is defending Cersei. Tyrion gets Cersei. Varys takes out Dany somehow w Jon defending.
I love that Arya said she won't be back. That really makes you wonder what she is up to or planning or thinking will happen. Since she is with Hound, I think it lends a lot of credence to the Hound going through the Mountain to get to Cersei with Arya right there. Jamie, and possibly Tyrion, will be there also so any are still options to take her out.
I love that Jamie is taking off and you don't really know for sure whether he is for or against Cersei. He had a chance at happiness but couldn't leave it alone.
Interesting that Cersei didn't have Tyrion shot. That was a big moment. Too big to be a plot flaw, imo. My initial thought though is it comes back to haunt her like 'she had her chance back when he was at the wall.'
I'm thinking Hound takes out Mountain. Arya takes out Jamie who is defending Cersei. Tyrion gets Cersei. Varys takes out Dany somehow w Jon defending.
The show runners were ambiguous about it in the after-show interview. I think they said he was going “to” Cersei. My read was that he was going to finish her off and continue his path of atonement, but I could see it playing out the other way as well.
Bob Sacamano
Footballguy
"Cersei is a lying whore, she's been ####ing Lancel and Osmund Kettleblack and probably Moon Boy for all I know."
I think the books would prevent him from going back there for that alone. But maybe not. Maybe Euron serves that purpose in the show once he sees them.
I think the books would prevent him from going back there for that alone. But maybe not. Maybe Euron serves that purpose in the show once he sees them.
I also like the Hound's line 'only 1 thing can make me happy'. You are supposed to believe that 1 thing is killing his brother. That is straight forwards but maybe he's going to try to save him. Maybe that's the 1 thing. Or maybe it is dying. They spent a fair amount of time on Hound's redemption training with the religious group. Not going by Hound anymore. Joining Brotherhood. Saving things instead of destroying. Just an idea. Might be a crazy one, but I'd like to see him forgive his brother and try to save him.
Gr00vus
Footballguy
I always forget what a great character Sandor is until they give him another scene. Might be my favorite character on the show.
Spin
Footballguy
Was hoping we'd get some more backstory on the NK/three-eyed raven this episode, and exactly wtf Bran was doing. Was really hoping Bran would give some speech or explanation about how he's been setting it all up for this moment etc. For the last ~6 seasons, we've seen Bran claim to be training for his upcoming battle with the NK, and they've been hinting at something significant coming from that. And for what? So he could sit around and do... nothing?
The way they handled the undead army was completely pointless. This whole series it's been about how them bickering over the throne, while ignoring the greater threat was going to be the end of them all, and now it's gone. I'm ok with Arya being the one to finish the NK. Her entire story was heavily linked to death and her becoming a super stealth assassin. But now that that's over, then this episode they immediately go back to where they were, fighting over the throne. So what was the point of the White Walkers then, if they just ended up being another stepping stone before they get to Cersei? It's just lazy that they built up this giant force, that used to represent what would happen if people didn't give up their greedy power struggles, only to have it disappear, and ultimately leads to nothing as we're now back to exactly where we were without them.
"Ok, now that we've somehow manager to destroy this super powerful wizard-zombie and his horde of the undead, let's see if we can somehow manage to beat this old drunken lady and her stealth pirate"
I know GRRM has said that the series will end similar to LOTR, with the hobbits having to retake the shire, and maybe that's what is going on here? But it just feels like a lot of time spent building up characters for moments was just thrown away.
The way they handled the undead army was completely pointless. This whole series it's been about how them bickering over the throne, while ignoring the greater threat was going to be the end of them all, and now it's gone. I'm ok with Arya being the one to finish the NK. Her entire story was heavily linked to death and her becoming a super stealth assassin. But now that that's over, then this episode they immediately go back to where they were, fighting over the throne. So what was the point of the White Walkers then, if they just ended up being another stepping stone before they get to Cersei? It's just lazy that they built up this giant force, that used to represent what would happen if people didn't give up their greedy power struggles, only to have it disappear, and ultimately leads to nothing as we're now back to exactly where we were without them.
"Ok, now that we've somehow manager to destroy this super powerful wizard-zombie and his horde of the undead, let's see if we can somehow manage to beat this old drunken lady and her stealth pirate"
I know GRRM has said that the series will end similar to LOTR, with the hobbits having to retake the shire, and maybe that's what is going on here? But it just feels like a lot of time spent building up characters for moments was just thrown away.
bicycle_seat_sniffer
Smells like chicken
tommyboy
Footballguy
i watched the entire 7+ seasons to current in 2 weeks. Never once felt disappointed in any of it. Even if its predictable today, its still way better than anything else i could watch on TV
Gr00vus
Footballguy
The production really got painted into a corner when they ran out of books to work off of. I don't think this is exactly how it would have been written, and it appears they haven't found/developed another screen writer who could fully complete/realize Martin's vision. It's still a good show, but maybe not all it could have been if they'd had complete source material (freely admitting that the source material itself wasn't perfect).
jhib
Footballguy
No, that wasn't Alys Karstark, but someone a little older and much prettier.
I hadn't noticed her and Pod in the background approach the girl that the Hound just rebuffed and Pod putting a smile right back on her face. Thanks for pointing it out.
Mr. Mojo
Footballguy
Count me in as another who doesn't get all of the love for this episode. Too many characters doing things out of character. The whole Jamie/Brienne thing didn't work for me, especially after he left so suddenly. Danerys suddenly going semi-crazy and more megalomaniac (after all she's been through previously). I liked the Arya scenes, those were the highlight. Cersei has Tyrion dead to rights but doesn't have the bowmen mow him down? You can't have the dragon circle behind the boats and fry them? I thought it was one of those weaker, set me up for next week types of episodes.
Really? We are okay with dispensing realism with dragons, zombies, magic, etc but not a giant crossbow?
Btw, roman ballistas could fire over a 1000 yards. In fact, london had a defensive arrangement similar to kings landing.
The largest ballistae of the 4th century could throw a dart further than 1200 yards (1,100 m). The weapon was named ballista fulminalis in De Rebus Bellicis: "From this ballista, darts were projected not only in great number but also at a large size over a considerable distance, such as across the width of the Danube River."[8] Ballistae were not only used in laying siege: after ad 350, at least 22 semi-circular towers were erected around the walls of Londinium (London) to provide platforms for permanently mounted defensive devices.[9]
And at the Salarian Gate a Goth of goodly stature and a capable warrior, wearing a corselet and having a helmet on his head, a man who was of no mean station in the Gothic nation, refused to remain in the ranks with his comrades, but stood by a tree and kept shooting many missiles at the parapet. But this man by some chance was hit by a missile from an engine which was on a tower at his left. And passing through the corselet and the body of the man, the missile sank more than half its length into the tree, and pinning him to the spot where it entered the tree, it suspended him there a corpse.[11]
Last edited by a moderator:
jhib
Footballguy
It's just the best seeing his momentary glee at hearing how Sansa gave Ramsay what he deserved: "Hounds."
El Floppo
Footballguy
and with a giant, ornate crossbow. but it still gave us more bronn with both brothers, where he's usually at his best. any scene with those three is going to be worth watching, even if the setup is wonky.
I know you're shrugging, so not pot-committed, but... if she can't see them from the air, how are they supposed to see her first, and then take the time to set sail and get their crossbows perfectly aimed?I think they tried to play this off as Euron's fleet was lying in wait on the other side of Dragonstone, and would have theoretically been blocked from view until they came around the island.
again- I have no problems with them taking out a dragon- and actually liked that they did, as they've had time to revise and rework those crossbows. but it was the was way this was written that felt weak, which is made especially evident when so much has been so strong. I've spent most of these seasons not contemplating these kind of writing issues because they're usually minor and not plot-driving. for me, they started popping up more with the bronn/jamie dive into the knee-deep for horses, bottomless for diving, river to escape the dragon fire. since then, there's been a handful more TWD writing problems that I find distracting.
lol- didn't notice pod with two women... saw him wander off with the one.
sansa and the hound have developed into my two favorite characters- loved to see that scene and how it played out. tormund gets the easy laughs, but the hound is right there with him, but gets to play a fuller, more developed character... amazingly well.
loved seeing him ride out with arya- another great scene that's setting us up for the remainder of the season.
I do think tyrion has to rat him out, and varys ends up dying by friendly hands. another fantastic scene watching that play out and watching tyrion go through the varied thoughs- is dany going bad, wtf does he do about john, where should he be aligned... dinklage killed it- yet again. will be sad to see varys go if it ends up that way- an amazing character and actor.
he did all those things for cersei. but I still believe he's realized all those things are horrible (and said as much), including the realization that she's sent Bron to kill him. I think he's going after cersei to kill her, not get summadat, and knows he's a dead man for doing it- which is why he's tried to be a #### to the lady of tarts, to get her to more easily get over him.
interesting. I never gave a thought to the mountain being redeemed and kinda like it... would be a little like luke turning darth vader on the emperor and might be interesting. I do think another method of redemption, or at least saving, is just ending his life as a re-animated monster.
I do think this season would be better if released Netflix-style. Let people finish on their own schedules without forced weeklong stoppages.
El Floppo
Footballguy
I think it was bostonfred who broke down the NK/three-eyed raven thing and bran.... at least for the episode and scene in the castle. the second the NK sees bran's ravens, he starts a full-out assault on the castle, including flying in himself. so bran, as bait, lured the NK in. otherwise he'd have stayed safe from harm pulling the undead strings until everybody in the castle was dead.
I actually like that the living went back to bickering- felt appropriate to the heart of series, and not lazy or pointless to me.
tommyboy
Footballguy
why didn't miss sandy just grab cersei and pull her off the wall with her.
problem solved
El Floppo
Footballguy
I love the wait. also love the community and discussion the weekly episodes develop.
season-long drops kill that.
Zow
Footballguy
Whoa. I've been present for a few very-public proposals such as this I always wondered if this had ever actually happened (because I had never seen it). Apparently it had. Crazy - that's gotta be soul-crushing.
pantherclub
Footballguy
I havent caught up on this thread yet but just finished and my only question is why didnt Dany simply fly around behind the ships and burn them up? All of the crossbows were on the front aimed one direction, same with the red keep. That was almost Walking Dead level bad.
But they kept insinuating the the dragon is going to toast Kings Landing so maybe it is being implied that he can fly behind the defenses or even attack at night.
Varys is going to get himself burnt up.
But they kept insinuating the the dragon is going to toast Kings Landing so maybe it is being implied that he can fly behind the defenses or even attack at night.
Varys is going to get himself burnt up.
Wingnut
Footballguy
Google Brienne naked. And yes, it's real.I was really hoping for a full Brienne shot tbh...
pantherclub
Footballguy
My total guess for the finale in a couple of weeks is that Jon ends up killing danys as she is going to far and burning too many people up. They have hammered the point home throughout the series about how the Targeryons are obsessed with fire and all of them turn out crazy.
pantherclub
Footballguy
Maik Jeaunz
Footballguy
in his head, Jon was probably like "you're a good boy Ghost, but I have a dragon now."
um, Jon...wait...
Ilov80s
Footballguy
I was thinking that or they kill each other. I can't see a scenario where The Hound just kills him and lives.
culdeus
Footballguy
Ok that's interesting, but these you describe were basically siege weapons. Not anti-aircraft that could be aimed. I mean even in 1944 AA batteries would have to throw up a crap ton of rounds to even ding one of the planes. Things like flak were more effective.
It does sound like the range of the situation described would be within 100m though.
Yes, I get it dragons and all that crap.
mozzy84
Footballguy
That was awesome overall. the dragon death scene was poorly done being it made no sense, she would have flown ahead to dragonstone and scoped it out before hand. That said it did look really cool at least and now we are down to one left.
hope tormund is coming back the last two shows here, I love that guy. Him just leaving and going back to being a wildling is kinda lame!
hope tormund is coming back the last two shows here, I love that guy. Him just leaving and going back to being a wildling is kinda lame!
pantherclub
Footballguy
The dragon death scene is the first thing I think I can really be negative about with this series in a long long time. I am willing to kindof overlook it because unlike this stuff happening in every scene of tWD I tend to think GOT will hash it out.
Maik Jeaunz
Footballguy
I liked Jaime giving Brienne the "it's not you, it's me" talk. he's got business to attend to.
beer 30
Footballguy
I'm going to quote the post below from @Yankee23Fan until y'all quit trying to make this Jamie thing him going back to defend his sister. He's going back to end her, not defend her. Cersei will inevitably confront Jamie, probably with Euron to rub in her new "love". I could see Euron killing Jamie in a confrontation.
I was going to mention the Google Brienne in the noods but I see you eager sick beavers are already on it.Yankee23Fan said:
CletiusMaximus
Footballguy
It seems farfetched the way it happened in the episode last night, but that's Euron's schtick - sneak attacks on the open sea where he completely surprises the enemy. That's how he destroyed Yara's fleet from Dorne last season. I'm not sure how much it was covered in the show v. the books, but his main ship is named "Silence" and he cut the tongues out of all of his crew so the ship is entirely manned by mutes.
El Floppo
Footballguy
the crossbows are on pivots- they're not fixed in one direction. that said- you come from downwind, they'd have to shoot through their sails first (and see through them- but they saw through that island's hills, so sails shouldn't be a problem)
I'm with you. and Arya takes the mountain out aftwards, with hound's face... just to #### with the mountain.
KL maester, urine, jamie, tyrion.
I think that's it.... at least until the point tyrion yelled it to the world.
Bob Sacamano
Footballguy
El Floppo
Footballguy
whoa. not covered.
also probably not going to help them spot and get the drop on a dragon from behind an island before it spots them... but pretty cool anyways.
the moops
Footballguy
