What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Getcha passports ready - the middle-aged dummies are going to the British Isles! Top 31 song countdown. (2 Viewers)

A few positive, Thumper-approved thoughts to share for the end of the countdown:

- New-to-you songs or artists that you particularly love or want to check out more from. My current new-to-me-favorite playlist comprises 88 songs, so there will be a lot to make my way through!
- Songs or artists that you were happily re-introduced to through the countdown. I have, among many others, Level 42 and Go West for songs, and ELO and Oasis for artists, on this list.
- Surprises! Artists or songs that you didn't expect to find you enjoyed as much as you did. I'll throw out a bunch of these...tomorrow.
 
Artists or songs that you didn't expect to find you enjoyed as much as you did.
I think my biggest surprise was finding a Elton John song I really liked. The guy is super talented, but just doesn't play I style I would normally go out of my way to listen to. But Funeral For A Friend/Love Lies Bleeding (which was a completely new to me song) was something of a "Wow!" moment.
 
Whups! I forgot to post this earlier - here's the latest standings in the charity contest. Now, if things break just right, cosjobs may still have a chance!!

(Also, note that even though Baba O'Riley got passed for the top overall scoring song, it's still the top non-"Big Three" song on the list, so it's still getting the two points.)

PersonScore1234567TopSongSong By…
Manster8Def LeppardPink FloydElton JohnDavid BowieDepeche ModeThe WhoU2The BeatlesBaba O'RileyThe Who
New Binky the Doormat8Elton JohnDavid BowieThe WhoPink FloydU2Def LeppardGenesisThe BeatlesBaba O'RileyThe Who
Westerberg8David BowieThe WhoElton JohnVan MorrisonElvis CostelloRadioheadPink FloydThe BeatlesBaba O'RileyThe Who
Just Win Baby7The WhoPink FloydThe CureU2The KinksElton JohnDavid BowieThe BeatlesWish You Were HerePink Floyd
Pip's Invitation7Pink FloydThe WhoDavid BowieElton JohnU2The CureThe KinksThe BeatlesWish You Were HerePink Floyd
Eephus7The WhoThe KinksPink FloydDavid BowieU2Black SabbathElton JohnThe BeatlesWish You Were HerePink Floyd
Val Rannous7Pink FloydOzzy OsbourneThe KinksDavid BowieU2The WhoElton JohnThe BeatlesCrazy TrainOzzy Osbourne
scorchy7Pink FloydDavid BowieElton JohnThe WhoRadioheadVan MorrisonThe KinksThe BeatlesWish You Were HerePink Floyd
AAABatteries7Van MorrisonThe KinksElton JohnU2David BowiePink FloydRadioheadThe BeatlesZombieThe Cranberries
Mrs. Rannous7The KinksElton JohnJethro TullU2The WhoThe EurythmicsPink FloydLed ZeppelinBaba O'RileyThe Who
The Dreaded Marco6David BowieU2The WhoThe KinksElton JohnBlack SabbathThe ClashThe BeatlesHeroesDavid Bowie
higgins6Pink FloydRadioheadThe WhoJohn LennonDavid BowieU2Elton JohnThe BeatlesWish You Were HerePink Floyd
Chaz McNulty6U2Elton JohnThe WhoPink FloydDavid BowieRadioheadColdplayThe BeatlesTiny DancerElton John
Dr. Octopus6The WhoPink FloydU2Elton JohnThe CureVan MorrisonRadioheadThe BeatlesInto the MysticVan Morrison
Doug B6U2David BowieThe WhoPink FloydOasisThe KinksElton JohnU2HeroesDavid Bowie
Chaos346U2Pink FloydElton JohnDavid BowieThe WhoVan MorrisonRadioheadThe Rolling StonesBitter Sweet SymphonyThe Verve
MAC_325U2Pink FloydThe WhoDavid BowieThe ClashRadioheadThe CureThe BeatlesMaybe I'm AmazedPaul McCartney
falguy5Elton JohnPink FloydU2The WhoDavid BowieThe CultThe CureThe Rolling StonesComfortably NumbPink Floyd
Uruk-Hai5David BowieElton JohnThe ClashThe WhoThe KinksThe AnimalsDusty SpringfieldThe BeatlesGoodbye Yellow Brick RoadElton John
DrianMalcolm5Elton JohnDavid BowiePink FloydThe WhoCreamElvis CostelloAmy WinehouseThe BeatlesSon of a Preacher ManDusty Springfield
Hov345David BowieThe WhoU2Elton JohnPink FloydArctic MonkeysYesThe Rolling StonesHeroesDavid Bowie
simey5Pink FloydVan MorrisonDavid BowieIron MaidenElton JohnThe CureU2Led ZeppelinBadU2
Don Quixote5David BowieThe KinksThe WhoRadioheadElton JohnU2Sex PistolsThe Rolling StonesWaterloo SunsetThe Kinks
jwb5Pink FloydVan MorrisonElton JohnDavid BowieU2YesIron MaidenThe Rolling StonesInto the MysticVan Morrison
Karma Police5David BowiePink FloydThe WhoU2RadioheadVan MorrisonCreamLed ZeppelinSon of a Preacher ManDusty Springfield
Hawks644Iron MaidenOzzy OsbourneElton JohnPink FloydThe WhoThe ClashRadioheadThe BeatlesFameDavid Bowie
cosjobs2The WhoBlack SabbathTrafficElvis CostelloFleetwood MacJethro TullVan MorrisonThe Rolling StonesLow Spark of High Heeled BoysTraffic
 
Happy #1 Song Day!
🎧

As perfect of a day for it for me here. It's 40 degrees, raining, and I have the day off. I've fallen behind on the last few, so I had planned to get to the new-to-me songs from the last 4 days and then listen to the #1s.

Today I am going to listen to all the songs no matter how many times they have come up so far. I want to make sure I listen to everybody's favorite song for the draft.
 
Last edited:


Happy #1 Song Day!
🎧

As perfect of a day for it for me here. It's 40 degrees, raining, and I have the day off. I've fallen behind on the last few, so I had planned to get to the new-to-me songs from the last 4 days and then listen to the #1s.

Today I am going to listen to all the songs no matter how many times they have come up so far. I want to make sure I listen to everybody's favorite song for the draft.
Even if it's a bunch of Beatles songs?
 


Happy #1 Song Day!
🎧

As perfect of a day for it for me here. It's 40 degrees, raining, and I have the day off. I've fallen behind on the last few, so I had planned to get to the new-to-me songs from the last 4 days and then listen to the #1s.

Today I am going to listen to all the songs no matter how many times they have come up so far. I want to make sure I listen to everybody's favorite song for the draft.
Even if it's a bunch of Beatles songs?

Good preparation for the boy band draft.
 

Ah sorry, I don't know that I should have lumped your post in with the other. It's a grey area between saying "not my cup of tea" and directly insulting, and I admit it's hard to say where that line is. I just know that early in this countdown we saw some of this, and a few of us commented about this thread being more negative than the US one, but the "feel" of it has continued that way for me. The US one employed the Thumper Rule much better. Anyway, we're almost done here, so I don't want to bring anyone down (again). Sorry!

I'll cop to contributing to this in the early stages of the thread prior to actual selections coming out, where I made my feelings about certain bands known. I'll refrain from that in the future.*



* - does not apply to the Eagles

I thought I was goofing around. It has been brought to my attention that it didn't come across that way.

I'm sorry for any hurt feelings. It wasn't my intention.
How can you be so obtuse?😉


Once I told my 8-year-old daughter that she said something obtuse and she said, "Are you saying I'm fat?"
 
I thought I was goofing around. It has been brought to my attention that it didn't come across that way.

I'm sorry for any hurt feelings. It wasn't my intention.
We’ll just get you back when your Bryan Adams song is reveiled during next countdown.

So for perspective when Andy ****s on Lennon, Zeppelin and Bowie, just remember he likes Bryan Adams. It’s takes some of the sting away.
 
I thought I was goofing around. It has been brought to my attention that it didn't come across that way.

I'm sorry for any hurt feelings. It wasn't my intention.
We’ll just get you back when your Bryan Adams song is reveiled during next countdown.

So for perspective when Andy ****s on Lennon, Zeppelin and Bowie, just remember he likes Bryan Adams. It’s takes some of the sting away.
See? I'm not even offended.

Miffed, sure. But not offended. And certainly not indignant.
 
And I’m only joking based on “the topic” - anyone can like or dislike whatever music they want.
Andy D is good stock - has also been around here forever. Maybe different tastes in music, but that’s what makes these threads go around.
Thanks for that.

It's a running gag among my friend group that my taste in entertainment is undefinable.

Food too. I don't like ground beef tacos. But then I do eat sloppy Joes. :shrug:
 


Happy #1 Song Day!
🎧

As perfect of a day for it for me here. It's 40 degrees, raining, and I have the day off. I've fallen behind on the last few, so I had planned to get to the new-to-me songs from the last 4 days and then listen to the #1s.

Today I am going to listen to all the songs no matter how many times they have come up so far. I want to make sure I listen to everybody's favorite song for the draft.
Even if it's a bunch of Beatles songs?
😱

Yes.
 
And I’m only joking based on “the topic” - anyone can like or dislike whatever music they want.
Andy D is good stock - has also been around here forever. Maybe different tastes in music, but that’s what makes these threads go around.
Thanks for that.

It's a running gag among my friend group that my taste in entertainment is undefinable.

Food too. I don't like ground beef tacos. But then I do eat sloppy Joes. :shrug:
That's a generous way to phrase it. ;)

I think some of us have a way to poke at others that might come off as negative sometimes. I for sure do this, and I honestly never mean anything by it. Honestly, if I am poking fun at something it's not out of hate, just more not my thing and/or I actually like it well enough. Most of the music I've taken shots at in here: The Beatles, Elton, Bittersweet, The Clash,Zombie, etc.. are actually good things, just not MY thing. They have either been overplayed for me or just don't click like other artists do.
 
I think rock said it well in the US thread here.

I do think that this exercise is best without negativity about music/song selections. Even if someone does not take it personally, whining about songs needing to use up Spotify skips for or whatever is going to make people feel like their contributions are viewed as a waste of other’s time instead of just part of the mutual enjoyment of music.
 
Last edited:
My selection today is "Beware of Darkness" by George Harrison. I can't even be mad that I don't get to own my #3 song, because I'm happy that Dr. O saw fit to put this under-appreciated track on his list. Please take a listen to this on today's playlist even if you caught Dr. O's before, as I specifically chose a different, "naked" version of the song, which I prefer to the Spector-ized one, though both are outstanding.

I dedicate my selection to Dale/wikkid. I remember being floored that in the midst of my post-Beatles Beatles thread, I not only got him to re-listen to All Things Must Pass, but that he found a new appreciation of it and wrote what I consider one of his most lovely and haunting posts (which as you know is huge praise). Here's what I said in the RIP wikkid thread:

"Today I'll do a Dale music post again, in honor of my Beatles class. This one is kind of a downer, but I thought at the time (about three years ago) that it was one of the most sublimely deep and deeply stunning things I'd read from him. I had alleged that Side 3 of George Harrison's All Things Must Pass might be the best side of an album in history. So Dale re-listened to it, and what he wrote is what I think of every time I hear it now. :heart: "

And this was wikkid's post:

"I've heard ATMP a thousand times but have listened to it maybe thrice. As someone who always hated bliss, i usually gave it short shrift. During my runaway years, i encountered dozens of alternative communities filled w Blissies and all this city boy could think of was "we've spent 200 years fighting our way out of the yolks of altar & throne........for THIS?! Just trade it all in for yet another myth?!" And, unfortunately, Harrison was the unofficial captain of the "oh....yeah.....cool......peace" movement, so i gave his music much less attention & respect than it deserved. My loss.

I check out that side one more time and i hear everything i want to hear from a side - invention, melody, humor, wisdom and, most important, the ability to hold my sway for a while. That's one thing artists seldom understand any longer, the responsibility of being better than other people being to make other people better. The power to make them offer to put themselves in the palm of your hand that they may be comforted, enlightened, inspired, relieved of life's awful burdens for a short time and given a view from above it all.

He warned us. George Harrison was a product of what he saw, not what he knew, as most great artists are in their approach to their work. And, relieved of the onus of great inner fire, he was able to say, quite early on in counterculture terms, "It's all bull####, don't you know. Find peace in your heart and you will see that it's so. I don't have to be complicated and neither do you. Here are some songs about complicated people and how silly is all they do."

Beware of Maya. Beware of illusions which become delusions. Open your heart before you open your mind and it will go oh so much more easily. And now, almost 50 years on, almost everything is Maya. My gen did indeed cast the bliss aside and what for? Identity & individuality, liberty & license, consumption & concupiscence. Now all we look for is peace, take pills for peace, be mindful for peace. ####ed out, tensed up, pissed off, shut down are we. Oh....yeah.....cool......peace. Sounds pretty good all of a sudden. All things must pass."
A. I tend not to remember too much of what people wrote in the past, but I did remember this post from Wikkid, especially the last paragraph.

B. This time I listened to the "naked" version of Beware of Darkness more closely than I did when it topped your solo Beatles countdown. It is stunning, and completely unlike anything else George did. It is as raw, gritty and weary (and maybe even as bitter) as much of the John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band material. George did not wear his heart on his sleeve like John did, but here he does, peeling back himself to reveal how painful the Beatles breakup and the issues associated with it were to him. It may be the only George performance where one can detect palpable anger from him, without pleasant-sounding arrangements to hide behind. We can hear his frustration on tracks like Wah-Wah and Sue You, Sue Me Blues, but nothing to the extent of this.
 
I think rock said it well in the US thread here.

I do think that this exercise is best without negativity about music/song selections. Even if someone does not take it personally, whining about songs needing to use up Spotify skips for or whatever is going to make people feel like their contributions are viewed as a waste of other’s time instead of just part of the mutual enjoyment of music.
There are forty five selections per round for thirty one rounds.

If there's not some sort of critiquing or banter about some of those picks seems like an awful waste of time. And anyway, I think oftentimes the defense of art causes a deeper appreciation of it than just allowing it to sit there undiscussed.

What I have noticed over the years - in real life, not just here - is that some take their preferences more personally than others. What I mean is that some derive their identity from the art and/or entertainment they enjoy more than others. The result is that for the former, when you deride the media you deride the person.

I'm of the type that doesn't care what people think about what I do or don't like. So when I throw out an opinion, I just think it'll be received as I do. But obviously that's not always true.

So, then we're left with a quandary - do we keep our opinions to ourselves because of the sensitivities of and/or sensitivity toward others? Or should we speak (and be allowed to speak) our minds with the understanding that the other "side" can call our opinion a load of crap from their perspective?
 
Last edited:
Bryan Adams and Joan Jett are coming to Minneapolis. How many tickets do you all want?

I saw Joan Jett in 2016 (I think - it was with Heart and Cheap Trick). She was great and blew the other two bands away (especially Heart, who disappointingly mailed it in). But she really brought it, and had way more hits than I remember her having.
 
I saw Joan Jett in 2016 (I think - it was with Heart and Cheap Trick). She was great and blew the other two bands away (especially Heart, who disappointingly mailed it in). But she really brought it, and had way more hits than I remember her having.
Since The Sex Pistols have been taken, and this track is ineligible ... it won't be a spotlight: Joan Jett with Steve Jones and Paul Cook (the 'other' Pistols) before the formation of The Blackhearts.
 
It's a running gag among my friend group that my taste in entertainment is undefinable.
In the past, I've defined my taste in music as "A Whitman's sampler for the ears".
Partially that's out of a sense of variety of genres and styles, with bits here and there. But there's also the idea that, while in general most find it pretty good, there will be some things you love and others that you can't stomach. With the amounts of each being completely personal.
 
Bryan Adams and Joan Jett are coming to Minneapolis. How many tickets do you all want?
I've actually seen both under different circumstances. Adams performed "Everything I Do (I Do it For You)" when I went to a taping of the Letterman show. Its not a great song, but he performed well. I saw Joan Jett on the beach in Seaside Heights a long time back as one of the acts playing for a radio station live remote event. She was good (and looked great).
 
My Idiots #1

Scooter

Take Me Home – Phil Collins

Doug
Baba O’Riley – The Who

Jeb
God Save the Queen – Sex Pistols

Chap
While My Guitar Gently Weeps – The Beatles
I like three of those four. :scared:
I would agree that, imo, the Sex Pistols song is more "important" than "good" - but now two people have had this song in their Top 2, so for some, it's much more than just "important".

I have a feeling my assumption of which song you don't like is correct.
 
My Idiots #1

Scooter

Take Me Home – Phil Collins

Doug
Baba O’Riley – The Who

Jeb
God Save the Queen – Sex Pistols

Chap
While My Guitar Gently Weeps – The Beatles
I like three of those four. :scared:
I would agree that, imo, the Sex Pistols song is more "important" than "good" - but now two people have had this song in their Top 2, so for some, it's much more than just "important".

I have a feeling my assumption of which song you don't like is correct.
I'll NEVER tell! :lol:
 
I think rock said it well in the US thread here.

I do think that this exercise is best without negativity about music/song selections. Even if someone does not take it personally, whining about songs needing to use up Spotify skips for or whatever is going to make people feel like their contributions are viewed as a waste of other’s time instead of just part of the mutual enjoyment of music.
There are forty five selections per round for thirty one rounds.

If there's not some sort of critiquing or banter about some of those picks seems like an awful waste of time. And anyway, I think oftentimes the defense of art causes a deeper appreciation of it than just allowing it to sit there undiscussed.

What I have noticed over the years - in real life, not just here - is that some take their preferences more personally than others. What I mean is that some derive their identity from the art and/or entertainment they enjoy more than others. The result is that for the former, when you deride the media you deride the person.

I'm of the type that doesn't care what people think about what I do or don't like. So when I throw out an opinion, I just think it'll be received as I do. But obviously that's not always true.

So, then we're left with a quandary - do we keep our opinions to ourselves because of the sensitivities of and/or sensitivity toward others? Or should we speak (and be allowed to speak) our minds with the understanding that the other "side" can call our opinion a load of crap from their perspective?

If folks are listing it in their favorite 31 songs and you don't like it, I think it goes without saying that they view your opinion on it as different from theirs. There are ways that critiques could be approached, but I don't think comparing Bittersweet Symphony to a middle school band or the Pit of Despair and whacking a bag of cats with a rubber hose is going to cause someone who put in their list to re-think and go "You know what, I thought I really liked that song, but you are right, The Verve does indeed sound like someone whacking a bag of cats with a rubber hose. My bad." Or really open up any positive dialogue on the qualities of the song, more generally. My two cents anyway.
 
If folks are listing it in their favorite 31 songs and you don't like it, I think it g Ioes without saying that they view your opinion on it as different from theirs. There are ways that critiques could be approached, but I don't think comparing Bittersweet Symphony to a middle school band or the Pit of Despair and whacking a bag of cats with a rubber hose is going to cause someone who put in their list to re-think and go "You know what, I thought I really liked that song, but you are right, The Verve does indeed sound like someone whacking a bag of cats with a rubber hose. My bad." Or really open up any positive dialogue on the qualities of the song, more generally. My two cents anyway.
It wasn't intended to get anyone to rethink their choices. It was meant to be ridiculous.

Which is how this is all starting to seem. I'm sorry I underestimated the seriousness.
 
I think rock said it well in the US thread here.

I do think that this exercise is best without negativity about music/song selections. Even if someone does not take it personally, whining about songs needing to use up Spotify skips for or whatever is going to make people feel like their contributions are viewed as a waste of other’s time instead of just part of the mutual enjoyment of music.
There are forty five selections per round for thirty one rounds.

If there's not some sort of critiquing or banter about some of those picks seems like an awful waste of time. And anyway, I think oftentimes the defense of art causes a deeper appreciation of it than just allowing it to sit there undiscussed.

What I have noticed over the years - in real life, not just here - is that some take their preferences more personally than others. What I mean is that some derive their identity from the art and/or entertainment they enjoy more than others. The result is that for the former, when you deride the media you deride the person.

I'm of the type that doesn't care what people think about what I do or don't like. So when I throw out an opinion, I just think it'll be received as I do. But obviously that's not always true.

So, then we're left with a quandary - do we keep our opinions to ourselves because of the sensitivities of and/or sensitivity toward others? Or should we speak (and be allowed to speak) our minds with the understanding that the other "side" can call our opinion a load of crap from their perspective?

If folks are listing it in their favorite 31 songs and you don't like it, I think it goes without saying that they view your opinion on it as different from theirs. There are ways that critiques could be approached, but I don't think comparing Bittersweet Symphony to a middle school band or the Pit of Despair and whacking a bag of cats with a rubber hose is going to cause someone who put in their list to re-think and go "You know what, I thought I really liked that song, but you are right, The Verve does indeed sound like someone whacking a bag of cats with a rubber hose. My bad." Or really open up any positive dialogue on the qualities of the song, more generally. My two cents anyway.
Didn't OH submit a song that included a bag of cats being whacked with a rubber hose?
 
That is one of his best solo songs IMO.
When I listened on our playlist, I actually was surprised by how much I liked it. I'd heard it before, of course, but not in years and years.

Did you guys calculate a winning artist among the five of you?
I did not - but my guess is it would be the Beatles since everyone had a least one, and many several. I'll try and figure it out - there's no spreadsheet or anything but I did make a playlist (although I substituted when the same song was picked, but the song was the same artist).
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top