What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Gun Control Laws - Where are we really? Where to go? (2 Viewers)

Can you be more specific what you mean when you write this?   
Case in point, gun control advocates want to talk about suicides, but guns aren't what causes the massive numbers.

Beyond suicides, mental health obviously plays a huge role in these mass shootings.

It's like people want to avoid the topic for some reason. It's much easier to blame the gun.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
why do we have so many more crazy evil people wanting to mass kill today vs 30-40 years ago ?

why do you think ?
I really don't know other than parenting has gone downhill. I see it coaching kids.

That said, kids are subjected to a lot more than I was since the age of social media, but it's not an excuse. You really have to be vigilant over your kids in today's world.

 
Figured I'd discuss body armor too... 

Most quality Level IV or Level 3+ ST (Special treat) body armor will stop AR ammo, but NOT .277 Fury..... but also won't stop 300 Win Mag, 50 Cal, and other existing rounds. 

The armor I own is Duritium GT2 which is IMO the best available to civilians when you factor in weight, and effectiveness (multi-hit rated vs 5.56 M855). 

That said...hits from any of these rounds may save your life, but it's going to knock you on your ### and likely send you to the hospital. The pearl clutching over the idea of guys running around like unstoppable cyborgs killing people while absorbing round after round is Movie-inspired silliness. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Case in point, gun control advocates want to talk about suicides, but guns aren't what causes the massive numbers.

Beyond suicides, mental health obviously plays a huge role in these mass shootings.

It's like people want to avoid it for some reason. It's much easier to blame the gun.
A few follow up questions:

1.  Do you honestly believe us who talk about the suicides believe the guns cause the suicides?   If yes, does that make sense? If no, what are we actually saying when we bring them up with relation to gun control?

2.  What role does mental health play in mass shootings?  Remember how mass shooting is defined and what the majority of them are.    

People talk about this side of it quite a bit in here.  I actively encourage people to learn more about it, so they understand it more.  Not sure how that qualifies as avoiding it, or "blaming a gun".    As far as I can tell it's people like you and SC, who continually bring up mental health and mental illness,  who seem the least willing to talk specifics or talk about it properly.   

 
A few follow up questions:

1.  Do you honestly believe us who talk about the suicides believe the guns cause the suicides?   If yes, does that make sense? If no, what are we actually saying when we bring them up with relation to gun control?

2.  What role does mental health play in mass shootings?  Remember how mass shooting is defined and what the majority of them are.    

People talk about this side of it quite a bit in here.  I actively encourage people to learn more about it, so they understand it more.  Not sure how that qualifies as avoiding it, or "blaming a gun".    As far as I can tell it's people like you and SC, who continually bring up mental health and mental illness,  who seem the least willing to talk specifics or talk about it properly.   
Let's stop referring to suicide numbers as it relates to gun control then. It's obviously not the problem.

Just about all the mass shooting perps seem very troubled. What role do you think mental health plays in the vast majority of mass shootings?

 
Not to me, but I am also asking what the level of responsibility for leaving it in your vehicle is.   I thought you'd know.  

I didn't think a locked car would be enough, but I honestly don't know.  
Locked car is NOT enough. 

Vehicle break-ins targeting firearms in Memphis, for example, are RAMPANT.  Pickup trucks are targeted for obvious reasons. IF I need to store my carry pistol in my car it's always hidden in the trunk... NEVER in the passenger compartment.

I actually just picked up a LifePod VaulTek biometric pistol safe (Costco Clearance : $40) that I'm getting mounted in my trunk for this purpose. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Not to me, but I am also asking what the level of responsibility for leaving it in your vehicle is.   I thought you'd know.  

I didn't think a locked car would be enough, but I honestly don't know.  
There's no law requiring a safe in your car. I either put mine in the glovebox if I'm in and out real quick or the trunk depending on various factors. Cops keep rifles and shotguns in their trunks, as well.

Basic, common sense stuff.

 
Let's stop referring to suicide numbers as it relates to gun control then. It's obviously not the problem.

Just about all the mass shooting perps seem very troubled. What role do you think mental health plays in the vast majority of mass shootings?
No, I won't drop it.  Access to firearms increases the lethality of suicide attempts by a factor of something like 10-15x.  That is huge.   The guns aren't CAUSING the suicide attempts, they make them way more deadly.   Part of gun control is safe storage and keeping the weapons out of the hands of other people, so it's part of the equation, even though you obviously don't like to talk about it.  

I am asking you, I have answered before.    The majority of mass shootings aren't the mall/school type shootings - they are domestic shootings and inner city shootings.    Do you think that addressing mental health will significantly effect the shootings and death in that gang/inner city shooting category? 

 
Locked car is NOT enough. 

Vehicle break-ins targeting firearms in Memphis, for example, are RAMPANT.  Pickup trucks are targeted for obvious reasons. IF I need to store my carry pistol in my car it's always hidden in the trunk... NEVER in the passenger compartment.

I actually just picked up a LifePod VaulTek biometric pistol safe (Costco Clearance : $40) that I'm getting mounted in my trunk for this purpose. 


There's no law requiring a safe in your car. I either put mine in the glovebox if I'm in and out real quick or the trunk depending on various factors. Cops keep rifles and shotguns in their trunks, as well.

Basic, common sense stuff.

 
Locked car is NOT enough. 

Vehicle break-ins targeting firearms in Memphis, for example, are RAMPANT.  Pickup trucks are targeted for obvious reasons. IF I need to store my carry pistol in my car it's always hidden in the trunk... NEVER in the passenger compartment.

I actually just picked up a LifePod biometric pistol safe (Costco Clearance : $40) that I'm getting mounted in my trunk for this purpose. 
That's a good practice. I've been in situations where I felt it would be more secure inside the vehicle instead of the trunk. And that's simply because I didn't want somebody noticing me putting it in the trunk.

 
No, I won't drop it.  Access to firearms increases the lethality of suicide attempts by a factor of something like 10-15x.  That is huge.   The guns aren't CAUSING the suicide attempts, they make them way more deadly.   Part of gun control is safe storage and keeping the weapons out of the hands of other people, so it's part of the equation, even though you obviously don't like to talk about it.  

I am asking you, I have answered before.    The majority of mass shootings aren't the mall/school type shootings - they are domestic shootings and inner city shootings.    Do you think that addressing mental health will significantly effect the shootings and death in that gang/inner city shooting category? 


are they using AR15's to kill themselves? semi-auto rifles ?    no, they're using handguns, these upcoming bans will have ZERO impact on suicides

zero

and no, domestic/inner city shootings will still happen just as much, they'll use different guns 

 
I looked and saw regulation of having a shotgun or rifle in the car in OK, but didn't anything about the rules for a handgun.   Must have missed something.  

 
You're trying. I'll give you that, LOL.

In the post before this one, I explained why I don't put it in the trunk if I believe it's more secure inside the vehicle.

Everybody's mileage may vary. If I was in a local where there were a lot of vehicle break-ins, I might reconsider.

 
That's a good practice. I've been in situations where I felt it would be more secure inside the vehicle instead of the trunk. And that's simply because I didn't want somebody noticing me putting it in the trunk.
It's situation dependent.... people like to frame things as black and white issues and it's rarely the case. 

My statement of locked car NOT being enough was based on my general tendency to assume worst case and operate off that.  That said, MANY communities don't have the issues Memphis does. I know buddies who leave guns in unlocked cars without issues. Would I do it? No.  But odds are extremely high it's a non-issue in their community. 

Few things in life are truly Black & White. 

 
I looked and saw regulation of having a shotgun or rifle in the car in OK, but didn't anything about the rules for a handgun.   Must have missed something.  
Handgun is 100% legal to have in a car in most places, technically all places now thanks to Bruen. As with all things... know your law. Good list of state by state laws here

IF there is anywhere it is illegal, the arresting officer would get his ### handed to him/her in court if you were charged, thanks to Bruen. 

 
You're trying. I'll give you that, LOL.

In the post before this one, I explained why I don't put it in the trunk if I believe it's more secure inside the vehicle.

Everybody's mileage may vary. If I was in a local where there were a lot of vehicle break-ins, I might reconsider.
I don't CC, and I am curious about all the logistics.   

Like Icon's post about the regulations of the business owners' signs that I found interesting, I am interested what the exact steps CCers are supposed to take for situations like needing to have the gun in the car because a location you are going to doesn't allow it.    :shrug:    I assumed most had some sort of safe like he is talking about written in, but you seemed to be saying different.  

 
No, I won't drop it.  Access to firearms increases the lethality of suicide attempts by a factor of something like 10-15x.  That is huge.   The guns aren't CAUSING the suicide attempts, they make them way more deadly.   Part of gun control is safe storage and keeping the weapons out of the hands of other people, so it's part of the equation, even though you obviously don't like to talk about it.  

I am asking you, I have answered before.    The majority of mass shootings aren't the mall/school type shootings - they are domestic shootings and inner city shootings.    Do you think that addressing mental health will significantly effect the shootings and death in that gang/inner city shooting category? 
I thought we were talking mass shootings & AR-15s...that angle.

The inner-cities are so ####ed up I don't know where to start. Do you? Maybe start voting in some people who can make a difference.

 
Handgun is 100% legal to have in a car in most places, technically all places now thanks to Bruen. As with all things... know your law. Good list of state by state laws here

IF there is anywhere it is illegal, the arresting officer would get his ### handed to him/her in court if you were charged, thanks to Bruen. 
Thanks.  Makes sense why I couldn't find info on the handguns then.  :lol:     Appreciate the link.   

One of those things, since it's not something I plan on doing, I don't dig super deep into the ins and outs how to go about CCing.  

 
I don't CC, and I am curious about all the logistics.   

Like Icon's post about the regulations of the business owners' signs that I found interesting, I am interested what the exact steps CCers are supposed to take for situations like needing to have the gun in the car because a location you are going to doesn't allow it.    :shrug:    I assumed most had some sort of safe like he is talking about written in, but you seemed to be saying different.  
Safes are a fine idea. 

I live in Oklahoma so I can't even remember the last time I had to unholster my gun when I was carrying. I've done it a few times, though.

 
I thought we were talking mass shootings & AR-15s...that angle.

The inner-cities are so ####ed up I don't know where to start. Do you? Maybe start voting in some people who can make a difference.
Yes, this is a HUGE issue with this topic and why I am asking specific questions.     Those are still mass shootings by definition (which varies, but is usually 3-4 people shot not including the shooter), and they are included when you look up mass shooting stats.   Just like suicides make up the biggest % of the gun violence stats, these domestic/gang shootings dominate the mass shooting stats.   

I would start with education, ending the war on drugs, and general focus on those neighborhoods effected.   IMO those types of shootings have little to do with mental health, and I don't think most gun regulations would significantly help that category of mass shootings.  

ETA:  local and state, I vote D, R, and 3rd party.  I also don't live by an area really dealing with these types of shootings, so not sure what that last comment has to do in the scheme of things.   Milwaukee would be the closest, but not sure what vote of mine really affects them besides the top level votes - which again, I spread around.  

 
Last edited by a moderator:
IF we're talking the Sig MCX line.... the MCX Rattler in 300BLK would be my ideal "trunk gun". 

https://www.sigsauer.com/sig-mcx-rattler-sbr.html

Only 16" long with the folded stock/brace means it fits nicely into a smaller safe, backpack etc... but when unfolded is an extremely functional platform out to 200yds and beyond.  

For now, my Stribog SP9A1-K does the trick: 
https://gunzonedeals.com/product/grand-power-stribog-sp9a1k-model-with-a3-tactical-side-folding-brace-for-sale-at-gun-zone-deals

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yes, this is a HUGE issue with this topic and why I am asking specific questions.     Those are still mass shootings by definition (which varies, but is usually 3-4 people shot not including the shooter), and they are included when you look up mass shooting stats.   Just like suicides make up the biggest % of the gun violence stats, these domestic/gang shootings dominate the mass shooting stats.   

I would start with education, ending the war on drugs, and general focus on those neighborhoods effected.   IMO those types of shootings have little to do with mental health, and I don't think most gun regulations would significantly help that category of mass shootings.  
Drugs are behind most of it.

 
Basically just federal buildings?  Libraries, schools?


Right, which I rarely enter.


There is a low hanging joke there that I won't take.   :P  

I get what you are saying though.  The dynamic in OK is that it's probably 99% for CC to begin with, so my scenarios wouldn't arise.   I honestly don't know how common it would be here either, but it's something I will note as I head into Madison the next few times.   

 
There is a low hanging joke there that I won't take.   :P  

I get what you are saying though.  The dynamic in OK is that it's probably 99% for CC to begin with, so my scenarios wouldn't arise.   I honestly don't know how common it would be here either, but it's something I will note as I head into Madison the next few times.   
Haha. Well, there's a difference between being educated and being smart.

Just remember who's going to thrive (comparatively) if things go to ####, LOL.

Many people around here have real survival skills (gardening/canning, hunting/fishing, construction/mechanical ability, etc.). I'm guessing the vast majority of city folks would do rather poorly with that bachelor's degree. ;)  

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Haha. Well, there's a difference between being educated and being smart.

Just remember who's going to thrive (comparatively) if things go to ####, LOL.

Many people around here have real survival skills (gardening, canning, hunting, construction/mechanical ability, etc.). I'm guessing the vast majority of city folks would do rather poorly with that bachelor's degree. ;)  
Oh, I have 0 illusions on this front.  I am about the least mechanical person you could come across, never hunted, probably couldn't take a fish off a hook, etc..    End of times comes, and my family and I are goners.  

 
Oh, I have 0 illusions on this front.  I am about the least mechanical person you could come across, never hunted, probably couldn't take a fish off a hook, etc..    End of times comes, and my family and I are goners.  
BTW, it doesn't have to be the end of times...just a reset.

I hope not, though (I like modern conveniences too much, LOL).

 
Last edited by a moderator:
BTW, it doesn't have to be the end of times...just a reset.

I hope not, though (I like modern conveniences too much, LOL).
No it doesn't.   Even if I frame it in a way where any scenario arises where I or my wife has to grow, catch, or kill for our food we are probably screwed.  :lol:     I would put higher odds on her because she is a vet and at least handles animals and is around death.   

 
[icon] said:
Locked car is NOT enough. 

Vehicle break-ins targeting firearms in Memphis, for example, are RAMPANT.  Pickup trucks are targeted for obvious reasons. IF I need to store my carry pistol in my car it's always hidden in the trunk... NEVER in the passenger compartment.

I actually just picked up a LifePod VaulTek biometric pistol safe (Costco Clearance : $40) that I'm getting mounted in my trunk for this purpose. 
Have two of them, great little safe, fits full size and compact 9mm's. I have mine secured under the seat but don't like the placement. Have to get out of the vehicle to to dig it out from under there. Need to find an easier point of access.

 
[icon] said:
My right to carry is constitutionally protected. A fake sign that doesn't carry force of law is worthless in the courtroom. Show me two cases of this being successfully prosecuted. 

The only way trespass charge MAY hold is if you are told to leave and refuse. 
Your right to carry does not extend onto private property where you are told not to.   That's not state action.   You seem very confused about how laws work.

 
Football Jones said:
Case in point, gun control advocates want to talk about suicides, but guns aren't what causes the massive numbers.

Beyond suicides, mental health obviously plays a huge role in these mass shootings.

It's like people want to avoid the topic for some reason. It's much easier to blame the gun.
we've been over this dozens of times.   

this Harvard Public Health article summarizes why you can't ignore guns in the equation:

Indeed, more people in this country kill themselves with guns than with all other intentional means combined, including hanging, poisoning or overdose, jumping, or cutting. Though guns are not the most common method by which people attempt suicide, they are the most lethal. About 85 percent of suicide attempts with a firearm end in death. (Drug overdose, the most widely used method in suicide attempts, is fatal in less than 3 percent of cases.) Moreover, guns are an irreversible solution to what is often a passing crisis. Suicidal individuals who take pills or inhale car exhaust or use razors have time to reconsider their actions or summon help. With a firearm, once the trigger is pulled, there’s no turning back.


Gun owners and their families are much more likely to kill themselves than are non-gun-owners. A 2008 study by Miller and David Hemenway, HICRC director and author of the book Private Guns, Public Health, found that rates of firearm suicides in states with the highest rates of gun ownership are 3.7 times higher for men and 7.9 times higher for women, compared with states with the lowest gun ownership—though the rates of non-firearm suicides are about the same. A gun in the home raises the suicide risk for everyone: gun owner, spouse and children alike.

 
[icon] said:
Handgun is 100% legal to have in a car in most places, technically all places now thanks to Bruen. As with all things... know your law. Good list of state by state laws here

IF there is anywhere it is illegal, the arresting officer would get his ### handed to him/her in court if you were charged, thanks to Bruen. 


You don't really understand what Bruen says.   You keep citing it like it magically exempted gun owners from state laws.

 
Here we go again, LOL. Lawdy.

We already know you're more likely to die by gunfire if you have a gun. I'm sure you're also more likely to drown if you have a pool. These are elementary-level stats. Not to mention the absurdity of the suicide issue. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to know people would still kill themselves if there wasn't a gun in the house.

Anyway, what I'm curious about is what percentage of households with a firearm have negligent deaths? Anybody know?

 
Here we go again, LOL. Lawdy.

We already know you're more likely to die by gunfire if you have a gun. I'm sure you're also more likely to drown if you have a pool. These are elementary-level stats. Not to mention the absurdity of the suicide issue. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to know people would still kill themselves if there wasn't a gun in the house.

Anyway, what I'm curious about is what percentage of households with a firearm have negligent deaths? Anybody knhiow?
Yep, still don't get it.   The bolded is not true.   Like I said, people don't seem to bother reading about these things or understanding them.  

Yes, attempts would stay the same.  Been shown many times that attempts with a gun are faaaaaar more successful than any other method.  Then combine that with stats on if they try again after a failed one to understand the situation.  

 
Now keep them out of the hands of people with no training, mental health issues, or criminal backgrounds and I'm good.


I agree, but the problem is who gets to decide who is deemed to have mental health issues. Better not be you (or your proxies).

 
Here we go again, LOL. Lawdy.

We already know you're more likely to die by gunfire if you have a gun. I'm sure you're also more likely to drown if you have a pool. These are elementary-level stats. Not to mention the absurdity of the suicide issue. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to know people would still kill themselves if there wasn't a gun in the house.

Anyway, what I'm curious about is what percentage of households with a firearm have negligent deaths? Anybody knhiow?
Yep, still don't get it.   The bolded is not true.   Like I said, people don't seem to bother reading about these things or understanding them.  

Yes, attempts would stay the same.  Been shown many times that attempts with a gun are faaaaaar more successful than any other method.  Then combine that with stats on if they try again after a failed one to understand the situation.  

 
Yep, still don't get it.   The bolded is not true.   Like I said, people don't seem to bother reading about these things or understanding them.  

Yes, attempts would stay the same.  Been shown many times that attempts with a gun are faaaaaar more successful than any other method.  Then combine that with stats on if they try again after a failed one to understand the situation.  


I totally get it. But I'm not cool with laying down my 2A rights to save suicidal people. I feel for them, but 2A rights are more important than they are. That's the truth that most here don't want to say and others don't want to accept.

Promote/mandate safes all you want to help suicidal peeps. But don't use them as blanket justification to ban guns, please.

 
I totally get it. But I'm not cool with laying down my 2A rights to save suicidal people. I feel for them, but 2A rights are more important than they are. That's the truth that most here don't want to say and others don't want to accept.

Promote/mandate safes all you want to help suicidal peeps. But don't use them as blanket justification to ban guns, please.
Jfc you guys-  this is not hard.  I have not done the bolded, nor has anyone in this thread to my knowledge. 

 
Frustrated post, Fitz, I admit.  Just so tired of posts telling me not to do something I have not done.  

Maybe since you understand it, you can explain it to FJ and others.  Maybe they will listen to you more? 

 
Jfc you guys-  this is not hard.  I have not done the bolded, nor has anyone in this thread to my knowledge. 


Ok, clarify your position. What exactly should we do in terms of gun regulation to limit suicides (besides safes, which you and I already agree are an easy solution)?

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top