At this point I would not make this trade. Gurley had a strange last few weeks in a timeshare with anderson. like Gally, i am assuming he is injured and that the coaching staff insisted he was healthy to make other teams game plan for him. I would rather have a player than the 1.1 if you wanted to get a trade done before the nfl draft.
I would in a heartbeat. Let's consider them dead even going forward (I think Barkley is better). Would you give up a 1.1 pick for 3 additional years of a 3 down back with the best physical skills in the league? Would you give up 1.1 if you could turn the clock back and get a 21 year old Gurley again?