I actually disagree. I believe there should be "reparations" for black America, but not in the traditionally conceived manner as most would conceive of it.
The reality is the failures of black America to succeed, on the average ( obviously there are exceptions) is a gigantic tax on our entire society/culture. The cost is staggering. It impacts education, the court systems, law enforcement, property values, the birth rate, substance abuse, domestic abuse, the overall economy, the health care system and on and on and on.
You know what I said about gay marriage years ago here? If you support gay marriage, then you do. If you don't, then you should want them to get married anyway, since who is married and happy in this life? Most married people I know despise each other. Many wish they were never married at all. Which means everyone, if we are looking at functional outcomes, should have supported gay marriage when it was an active discussion point.
People who generally like black America will want them to succeed.
People who are neutral to indifferent would prefer the cost savings on their taxes and society in general
People who don't like black America will look positively on any kind of reparations that simply detach them from day to day interaction with African Americans, which some forms of reparations will actually do.
Offer Detroit. You can have the abandoned homes and you won't have to property taxes ever. But you must live in that secure residence. Also it's an entirely black area, all hospitals are mandated to have black doctors, nurses, staff, etc, etc. All police in the area are all black officers. Black firefighters. Black owned businesses. Entirely black everywhere. Black celebrities will be pressured to start small businesses in these areas. No more struggle with white police officers shooting black suspects. If black suspects are going to get shot, it will be by black cops.
Once you move in, you've gotten reparations. A home, cost free, if your lineage can trace back to slavery, and no property taxes ever. If you stay, it's yours. True land ownership in America. If you move, you can't sell the house, it's forfeited back to the program and you cannot ever get the same offer again.
For pro black America, true land ownership is very "American" at heart. Here's your chance to show the entire world that a community that's all black and no interference from any other race will show what black Americans can do on their own.
For anti black America, it's a zero complaint structure. If it fails, black America has no one to blame but themselves. They got what many said they wanted, a society without white people in it. Go for it. See if you can make it work.
Think about it, everyone here with a mortgage. No rent, no mortgage, no property taxes. Ever again. How would you feel about that? You could work a little job and buy groceries and do utilities and live without some of your pressures. It's not perfect, you'd have to rebuild the home. But it's yours. The land underneath it is yours. The community, if it can be saved, is yours.
This is the kind of "reparations" I'd be OK with voting for and supporting. An actual litmus test of what black America can do on it's own.
Most of Detroit is abandoned anyway. It's not like giving black America Detroit is damaging other communities. Some will shout that there's no infrastructure, no stability, no support. Well, you got the land, make something of it. That's true America right there - Create the paradise you dreamed about. Make something great out of it. Build something you can leave behind for your children with pride and honor.
Charles Barkley said it best. That signs on jerseys and one the court are mostly pointless. Black America needs wealthy and powerful blacks building businesses and creating jobs and black centric communities. With that economic and power base, now you have actual political leverage.
And then I want silence. Pure silence. You got true ownership and a chance to build your own true community, that's more than many people have, so no more shouting and rioting and screaming and cancel culturing and woking everything into oblivion.
Anyone here have a problem with this?