man the smokies are pretty awesome but i like the north carolina side a lot better than the tennessee side which is so super crowded although i will say that you enjoy the nature a lot more after an hour of driving through pigeon forge and gatlinburg to get to it take that to the bank bromigos
Other than the close proximity I don’t totally associate Pigeon Forge and Gatlinburg with the Smokies. I think it’s easier for me living relatively close by but for me the Smokies is all about camping and hiking.
where you do stay bromigo our first trips were through the gatlinburg entrance and we found it pretty crowded and basically a big traffic jam then we went north carolina side and it was still busy but much better for us and we camped as well but id have to dig to figure out what the campgrounds were named take that to the bank
I’ve stayed in every manner of campground, shelter, cabin and hotels in that area for 30-40 years. As with most things the answer is “it depends”. I love to camp and don’t mind roughing it and I love to save money. Problem is my wife won’t do that. So, it always depends on who else is going and what the intent of the trip is and how much money you want to spend.
Any other towns you'd suggest other that gatlinburg that are close (within 20 minutes) of the good stuff? The one thing I'm liking about gatlinburg is there's plentiful airbnb options with kitchens so I should get a good price. I don't mind the tourist trap feel but a few well rated eateries would be nice. Just did a cursory look, but that's one thing gatlinburg seems to be lacking.
One of the challenges with navigating the park is it's so huge. It's the largest national park. There's a road that bisects the park - Newfound Gap Road and it's 31 miles in length and runs from Gatlinburg to Cherokee. The road to Clingmans Dome is off this and is one of the best "easy" hikes with great views - but the road closes with bad weather and for portions of winter. Almost all the places to stay around the perimeter of the park would have good to great to phenomenal hikes and views, waterfalls, etc. so my recommendation would be to figure out what you want to do and work backwards.
I completely agree with SWC that avoiding the congestion of Gatlinburg is ideal unless you plan to walk the strip or spend the day there. All of that is another discussion and I could give suggestions there also. You could also stay closer to Cherokee if you want/plan to visit the casino. Since this is about hiking, I'll assume that is the focus and for that you can't go wrong being with easy access to Alum Cave Trail to Mount LeConte, Clingmans Dome and Charlies Bunion - all can be accessed off Newfound Gap Road.
Sounds like you want to do day hikes and then stay somewhere. I would just get a cabin maybe off 321 with access to Gatlinburg and the park.