There are always some players who put up big numbers on Thursday who are overdrafted on Friday and Saturday - short memory?
How about Kevin Ogletree last year? 31 points in the Thursday game was almost a third of what he had for the whole season
BTW in an online FFPC draft earlier today Peyton Manning went second - NOT second QB ... 1.02
Somebody couldn't resist putting 50 points into his Week 1 lineup ... but I doubt Manning scores that many in any of his remaining games
Had a draft last year that took place after that first game. LOLZ all you want, it was the only time the group could all get together to make it work.
I took Ogletree...I think in maybe the 12th or so?...because our league rules said if you drafted a guy and designated him a starter, you got points already accumulated. I picked him up with every intention of dropping him come Monday, which I did.
The opportunity cost for doing so proved to be Randy Moss, who was the top guy on my board at the time, thinking it might be worth the upside gamble if they decided to use him as a goalline jumpballer. So I certainly didn't lose out by picking Ogletree instead, and did in fact win week one by less than the difference he made in my lineup, relative to what my "regular" starter would have put up.
It's not worth 100% writing off these games.
All that said, Manning ain't Ogletree. Even if you have to pick 1.01 to get him, it's still only a marginal leap in value over what you would have had to pay for him anyway. And every pick that goes by without taking him goes closer and closer to giving the guy who ultimately does get him that much huger a value -- for Manning's expected output, plus the slam dunk week one victory.
I'm honestly not sure how to value a guy like that right now. But if there were serious entry cash on the line, I wouldn't fault anybody who wanted to reach for him as early as first overall. A one-game head start is a really big value, and Manning's a damn good QB anyway.