Holy Schneikes said:
Just Win Baby said:
stbugs said:
Just Win Baby said:
Birdie048 said:
Nowrood is a good outside runner, but struggles between the tackles on anything like 1st and 10 when they are expected to run the ball.
I'm not saying you are wrong, because I can't find exact splits that fit your statement. However, I did find these:Left Sideline - 15/54 (3.6 ypc)Left Side - 9/36 (4.0 ypc)Middle - 20/145 (7.3ypc)Right Side - 10/57 (5.7 ypc)Right Sideline - 15/91 (6.1 ypc)This equates to:30/145 (4.8 ypc) outside the tackles39/238 (6.1 ypc) between the tacklesAlso, on 1st & 10 - 24/132 (5.5 ypc)All of this looks fine to me. It does not appear to substantiate your claim, though it's not a direct fit. Norwood only has 8 carries on third down (compared to 27 on 1st down and 34 on 2nd down), so I can't tell from the splits that he has padded his stats in non-running situations.
I understand splits, but in the current offense, when Norwood is in the defense plays pass and when Turner is in they play run. Sure, the Falcons might not be that simplistic in the calls, but Turner sure isn't getting any receptions, so I would think that Norwood does benefit from less men in the box. Not saying he isn't talented, just that even on first down the defense with Norwood in could be playing pass.Also, many draws go right up the gut.FYI, Turners run to reception ration is 50+ to 1 and Norwood's is 3 to 1 and that doesn't count any pass plays he is in on that he didn't make the catch or stayed into block.
First off, let me say I'm not arguing that Norwood can be a feature back. I agree it is doubtful he will ever have more of a role than what he has now in Atlanta. I just don't think the facts back up what people think about him.As for 1st and 10, I'm not buying that they play the pass when Norwood is in. He has 24 carries and 2 catches on 1st and 10. On 1st down overall, he has 27 carries and 2 catches. That's an example of the facts not backing up people's impressions.To continue the theme, on 2nd down, he has 34 carries and 6 catches. On 3rd down, he has 8 carries and 15 catches. To me, this is just typical progression. Defenses would typically play the run more on 1st and 2nd down and the pass more on 3rd and medium to long situations (and Norwood has only 1 carry in 3rd and short, since that is Turner's role). Defenses study tendencies. I see no reason to believe they are leaving the box when Norwood is in the game on 1st and 2nd down, any more than situations normally dictate against typical offenses. And I'm sure they are well aware that Norwood is more likely to catch a pass than run on 3rd down and try to defend him accordingly.So I think it is impressive that Norwood has averaged 5.5 ypc on 1st down, 4.4 ypc on 2nd down, and 7.3 ypr on 3rd down, since that shows he has performed well despite the defense generally knowing whether he is likely to run or catch in each situation.ETA: Not sure where to find info about men in the box, but splits do show that 66 of his 69 carries and 21 of his 24 catches occurred when the defense had 4 defenders on the line.
Plus, even if what he said were true (that defenders were playing pass when Norwood is featured on 1st down), my thought is "so what?" or even "So much the better!". If defenses are so scared of Norwood's receiving ability that they avoid stacking the box and it allows him to beat them inside, that's a GOOD thing, not a bad one. Not sure that's a 100% cause and effect there, but in any case, for the MOST part, success on 1st and 10 is success on 1st and 10.The only thing I can figure is that the team really, truly does not believe Norwood can hold up to featured usage and wants to keep him available as much as they can throughout the season. Because as you point out, and despite the prevailing misconceptions, Norwood has been REMARKABLY effective in nearly ALL situations they put him in (except maybe pass protection/blocking?). As an owner I would LOVE to see what he could do as a featured runner, but it has become clear to me that isn't going to happen in Atlanta.
OK, well the "as an owner" statement kind of clouds the comment, but I never said he wasn't effective. I in fact am a Norwood owner in one keeper league. Unless he signs some sort of #1 RB deal in the off season, I won't keep him, but as a Turner owner in another league, I know how well both have done.All I said is that Norwoods touches have a 3 to 1 ratio and Turners are 50+ to 1, rushes to receptions. That to me shows that Norwood is in on a lot more pass plays than Turner is. If that doesn't make sense then not sure what to do. If you really think the defense isn't thinking more about the run when Turner is in and more about the pass when Norwood is in, then I can't help here.Also, just because Norwood doesn't get a reception, doesn't mean it isn't a passing down. If Roddy White catches it, while Norwood is in, it isn't reflected in Norwood's stats.If Just Win Baby can show me the split of pass play percentages while Turner is in versus Norwood and it shows that Norwood is in on more running plays percentage wise, then I will change my tune. The 24 rushes and 2 receptions shows nothing to me about passing. Norwood may get touches 90% when he is in on first down and 25% on 3rd, which means he plays way more on 3rd downs even though he has more "stats" on first down. Again, I would bet a lot of money that Norwood is in on a higher percent of pass plays than Turner is.