What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

*** KC @ NYG Game Thread *** (1 Viewer)

The Giants and their reffing staff are really pretty good.
Click to expand...
Great challenge.Better get it right - he was down.

And guess what - tackling goes down when you make bad personal foul calls. They second guess on D.
Click to expand...
Agreed,If Another chief had come in and leveled him, they would have thown the flag for a lete hit saying he was down.

Neither of those personal fouls penalties should have been called.

 
The NFL will apologize to the Chiefs this week for getting that call wrong. If any part of your body other than your hand or your foot touches the ground -- you are down.

Clearly, the top part of his foot/ankle/shin area touched the ground.
Click to expand...
That was not at all clear to me. It was very close, to be sure, but I can't say with confidence that it did or did not touch.
 
The NFL will apologize to the Chiefs this week for getting that call wrong. If any part of your body other than your hand or your foot touches the ground -- you are down.

Clearly, the top part of his foot/ankle/shin area touched the ground.
Click to expand...
If thats the rule then im wrong a shin did hit.
 
Horrible officiating this game. KC has gotten jobbed about 4 times now.

And I'm a Giants fan!!
Click to expand...
Are you tryin got say the knee hit.
Click to expand...
No, I am saying that his lower leg clearly was on the ground.Too bad for KC. This is OUR HOUSE BABY!

 
Horrible officiating this game.  KC has gotten jobbed about 4 times now.

And I'm a Giants fan!!
Click to expand...
but there's no way that call should have been reversed. inconclusive. just cuz you can't see daylight between his shin and the ground does not mean it touched.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Worst call I've seen in a while and at the worst time. I'm glad I'm not a Chiefs fan. :thumbdown:
Click to expand...
The replayed showed that the shin might not have hit at all. The replays didn't prove 100% that the shin hit, so it can't be overturned. It looked like there was a space when FOX paused it.
 
What did Plaxico do? Pull a Moulds? Does Eli hate him or does he just suck and can't get open like he did earlier in the year? Not watching the game. How come only one catch?

 
Worst call I've seen in a while and at the worst time. I'm glad I'm not a Chiefs fan. :thumbdown:
Click to expand...
The replayed showed that the shin might not have hit at all. The replays didn't prove 100% that the shin hit, so it can't be overturned. It looked like there was a space when FOX paused it.
Click to expand...
???? They freeze framed it right on the ground. Thank God the refs are on the Gints payroll today. We needed it. :D
 
What did Plaxico do? Pull a Moulds? Does Eli hate him or does he just suck and can't get open like he did earlier in the year? Not watching the game. How come only one catch?
Click to expand...
Eli can't hit the side of a barn.He's been open.

 
Horrible officiating this game. KC has gotten jobbed about 4 times now.

And I'm a Giants fan!!
Click to expand...
but there's no way that call should have been reversed. inconclusive. just cuz you can't see daylight between his shin and the ground does not mean it touched.
Click to expand...
Ref should say inconclusive..... IMO.
 
The Chiefs are getting rapped by the officiating. The few times they have actually wrapped up on tackles, they get flags thrown on them.

 
I agree that the knee never hit, but anyone,even a Giants fan who thinks that the Ref saw taht tiny space from 20 yds away is a liar. What sucks and has been sucking this entire game is the benefit of the doubt being given the Giants. The personal foul calls have been generous to say the best and downright collusive to say the least. Parker gets hist late and jumps up to look the fdefender up and down and gets 15 yds for unsportsmanlike conduct. Barber gets his right at the whistle (according the replay with sound) and KC gets 15 personal foul.Its tough to beat 22 Giants, and damn near impossible to beat 30.

 
wow chiefs are doing horrible at short yardage situations.also when do they allow the play, when it's a false start penalty?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I agree that the knee never hit, but anyone,even a Giants fan who thinks that the Ref saw taht tiny space from 20 yds away is a liar. What sucks and has been sucking this entire game is the benefit of the doubt being given the Giants. The personal foul calls have been generous to say the best and downright collusive to say the least. Parker gets hist late and jumps up to look the fdefender up and down and gets 15 yds for unsportsmanlike conduct. Barber gets his right at the whistle (according the replay with sound) and KC gets 15 personal foul.

Its tough to beat 22 Giants, and damn near impossible to beat 30.
Click to expand...
well, i'm a giants fan. when i watched it live on TV (even better view than the refs) I had no idea he even came close to being down.
 
wow chiefs are doing horrible at short yardage situations.

also when do they allow the play, when it's a false start penalty?
Click to expand...
False starts on the Offense are prior to the snap - dead ball - must take the penalty (unless declined).The "free play" for the O comes when the D jumps at the snap, but not too much - then it is "unabated to the QB" and blown dead.

 
Worst call I've seen in a while and at the worst time. I'm glad I'm not a Chiefs fan. :thumbdown:
Click to expand...
The replayed showed that the shin might not have hit at all. The replays didn't prove 100% that the shin hit, so it can't be overturned. It looked like there was a space when FOX paused it.
Click to expand...
???? They freeze framed it right on the ground. Thank God the refs are on the Gints payroll today. We needed it. :D
Click to expand...
:rolleyes: I guess you failed to see the shadow of the shin, and you failed to hear when the announcers pointed out the tiny space.

I'm not a Giants' fan, if anything I'm a Chiefs fan.

 
wow chiefs are doing horrible at short yardage situations.

also when do they allow the play, when it's a false start penalty?
Click to expand...
False starts on the Offense are prior to the snap - dead ball - must take the penalty (unless declined).The "free play" for the O comes when the D jumps at the snap, but not too much - then it is "unabated to the QB" and blown dead.
Click to expand...
it was a rhetorical question... i just can't believe they would allow the play to go on, when they called a false start.also, nfl.com called must be a giants fan, it was of course changed

3-6-KC 35 (11:30) T.Green pass to T.Gonzalez to NYG 40 for 25 yards (G.Wilson, J.Butler). PENALTY on KC, Illegal Formation, 5 yards, enforced at KC 35 - No Play.

 
How happy am I- I am in the semi finals and have both Tiki and LJ. They are both having a monster game!!!!! gotta luv the playoffs!!!!

 
So do I. NE DEF too. Imagine if everyone who did made a thread about it. No one cares :IBTL:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
LJ owner missed our playoffs  :pickle:
Click to expand...
the rest of his team must have been absolutely pathetic.
Click to expand...
He was just in the wrong division... I'm playing a guy the went 7-7 the guy with LJ was 9-5 but in the division with the best team. 4 teams make it. 3 division leaders and a wildcard
 
Wrong Week to go up against Tiki...man he looks like he is covered in butter the way defenders are just sliding off him.Could you please let Shockey get something? :D

 
Worst call I've seen in a while and at the worst time. I'm glad I'm not a Chiefs fan. :thumbdown:
Click to expand...
The replayed showed that the shin might not have hit at all. The replays didn't prove 100% that the shin hit, so it can't be overturned. It looked like there was a space when FOX paused it.
Click to expand...
But the replay DID show that the top of the foot and ankle CLEARLY was laying on the ground = same thing.
 
I agree that the knee never hit, but anyone,even a Giants fan who thinks that the Ref saw taht tiny space from 20 yds away is a liar. What sucks and has been sucking this entire game is the benefit of the doubt being given the Giants. The personal foul calls have been generous to say the best and downright collusive to say the least. Parker gets hist late and jumps up to look the fdefender up and down and gets 15 yds for unsportsmanlike conduct. Barber gets his right at the whistle (according the replay with sound) and KC gets 15 personal foul.

Its tough to beat 22 Giants, and damn near impossible to beat 30.
Click to expand...
:goodposting: From that first unsportsmanlike conduct (for taunting) penalty on Parker, it's been obvious that the ref's in general, and the Head Linesman in particular, have been bending over backward for the Giants. The NFL must REALLY want the Giants in the playoffs!! At least 5 calls (phantom calls and calls that are never made in other games) have been called for the Giants.

Of course, I can't really blame the NFL. Lots more viewers in NY than KC.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

joey
All-The-Same-Bye-Week Team (by ADP)
Replies
10
Views
841
Hot Sauce Guy
Hot Sauce Guy
renesauz
Make Your Call
Replies
27
Views
1K
Hot Sauce Guy
Hot Sauce Guy
T
Crowd sourcing a plug and play waiver wire WR
Replies
15
Views
815
The Dude
T

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top