May 29, 2007
What do Texans have in Walter?
Jerome Solomon, Houston Chronicle
Uh oh, Texans fans.
Two words/phrases that typically mean you're not that good: overachiever, go-getter. That is how teammates and coaches describe No. 2 receiver Kevin Walter.
Not to slam Walter - he is a battler and his teammates respect his practice work - but you have to question just how productive he will be and whether he brings enough to the table to keep defenses honest in defending Andre Johnson. This is one area I expected the Texans to do more in during the offseason.
I like an "overcoming odds" story as much as the next guy, but is this one of them? This seems like more of a "We don't have a better choice at this time" tale doesn't it?
Well, maybe not. Surely, somewhere - probably at about the same point in their careers - someone made that argument against two of my favorite NFL players - two guys I know quite well - who set examples for Walter to follow.
Walter was the 255th pick in 2003 - going in the seventh round to the Giants - only seven spots from being Mr. Irrelevant.
Keenan McCardell, a proud Waltrip Ram, was the 326th pick in 1991, going to Washington in the 12th round, just eight picks from Mr. Irrelevant. Troy Brown was the 198th pick in 1993, being claimed by New England with the second pick of the eighth and final round of that year's draft.
After four seasons in the league, Walter's best statistical year is 2005 with the Bengals, when he had 19 catches for 211 yards.
Four years into his career, Brown's best numbers were 21 grabs for 222 yards; McCardell's best season four years in was 13 receptions for 234 yards.
Thus far, only one TD for Walter, who has never started an NFL game. McCardell had four TD catches in his first four seasons (all in that 13-catch year), while Brown did not find the end zone in his first four years in the league.
Year 5: McCardell, after having been officially released five times, had 56 catches for 709 yards and four scores. Brown, a return man who had been cut a couple of times, was pulled from kick and punt return duties and made 41 catches for 607 yards and six TDs.
McCardell, a free agent who plans to play this season, has gone onto to be No. 8 on the NFL's career receptions list. Brown, also planning to play another season, is New England's all-time leading receiver and Mr. Patriots in my book.
You think this is going to be a breakout year for Walter? Will his career come close to McCardell's or Brown's?
LINK