10. Singing Cowboy
Albums: Four Sail (1969) and Reel to Real (1974)
Writers: Arthur Lee and Jay Donnellan
"Singing Cowboy" seems like a pleasant ditty on the surface, but actually it's a veiled threat.
Love's Arthur Lee was tormented by a lot of things, including the pervasive racism of 1960s America. He was convinced that if he toured nationally, he would be assassinated, which is why Love never played outside of California until 1970. "Singing Cowboy," recorded at the 1968-69 warehouse sessions and selected by Elektra as one of the 10 tracks for
Four Sail, was his message to white racists that he would respond to their threats, including with violence, if he had to.
Singing cowboy
Gotta lasso in your hand
Will you ever understand?
It's a do or die, boy
You know your life is up to you
So when you say goodbye
Don't you cry, 'cos look out kid
I'm coming after you
Singing cowboy
Got a gun around your waist
Wanna shoot a little taste
At me and my boy
Just what's gotten into you
You gonna shoot me through
I'm gonna follow you
Well look out kid
I'm coming after you
Coming after you
And I'm on my way
Look out
"Singing Cowboy" was one of three Love songs that appeared in my 1969 countdown. What I said there:
Arthur Lee was at a crossroads after Love's masterpiece Forever Changes. The flip side of that record's incredible use of orchestration was that a lot of it was there because Lee's bandmates weren't technically capable of reproducing the sounds he heard in his head. So he dissolved the band and put together a new one using the same name.
The output of this version of the group isn't as storied as that of the first version, but it's still of very high quality, just different. This incarnation had a muscular, blues rock sound and featured lots of wailing, fuzzed-out lead guitar. Likely this was a product of Lee's friendship with Jimi Hendrix, whom he had known since 1964 (they did record together before Hendrix' death; one song appeared on a 1970 Love album).
Another factor in the move toward a harder sound may have been that Lee was warming up to the idea of touring. The original incarnation never played outside of California because Lee, an African American, feared for his safety. Perhaps seeing that Hendrix had pulled off successful national tours inspired him to put together a band geared for the stage. The new incarnation did indeed play outside California in 1970 and 1971.
Forever Changes came out in late '67, and the new band wasn't in place until early '69, and Lee had written a ton of songs in the interim. The band recorded three discs' worth of songs in an LA warehouse. It owed one more record to Elektra, its original label. Elektra selected the 10 songs it liked best and released them as Four Sail in September. The rest of the songs were released in December by their new label, Blue Thumb, as the double album Out Here.
Both records are fantastic and are among my favorites of the year, though Out Here has some filler, as you might imagine. One of the high points is Four Sail's "Singing Cowboy", a defiant statement against the racists he found so threatening, backed with chilling lead guitar work from Jay Donnellan.
I saw Lee/Love in 1994 (just before he was jailed) and in 2002 (just after he got out). He played this at both shows, with absolute glee (at the second show, while taunting a guy who was being removed for unauthorized videotaping).
The song was important enough to Lee that he recorded it again for 1974's
Reel to Real, this time faster, with his vocal in a lower register and with slide guitar at the forefront instead of Hendrixian pedal work. I think the alternate take on the deluxe version is better than the take that made the album.
"Singing Cowboy" appeared regularly in Love sets between 1969 and Lee's death, often serving as the show closer between 2002 and 2005. Its importance to the band's live set is underscored by the title of the live compilation
Coming Through to You: The Live Recordings (1970-2004) being taken from a line in the song. My 1994 show was the first time I heard the song, as
Four Sail was out of print in the '80s and '90s. The Love Band with John Echols performed it at some shows in 2023.
Extended version on deluxe edition of
Four Sail:
https://open.spotify.com/track/0I9BsQe5RUGcnhCzsEdUUK?si=c21959eb18614884
Reel to Real version:
https://open.spotify.com/track/3Ng464nda60xBRatZuPoPy?si=ea49aebabaf844bb
Alternate take of
Reel to Real version (bonus track on deluxe edition):
https://open.spotify.com/track/2wDGgN1RBFQUTWgZELcKXg?si=4147bc31d75b4420
Live version from "England" in 1970 (appears on
The Blue Thumb Recordings):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y_tR04ZAGjs
Live version from San Francisco in 1970:
https://youtu.be/BfzKhRguxwU?t=1171
Live version from LA in 1978 with Bryan MacLean (follows
Reel to Real arrangement; all other live versions I've heard follow
Four Sail arrangement):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3w4VcU5f8k
Live version from London in 1996:
https://youtu.be/EEnhCsX7UQI?t=1970
Live version from London in 2003 with Graham Coxon of Blur and with horns and strings on the closing jam (this is the show that
The Forever Changes Concert was taken from, but "Singing Cowboy" doesn't appear on the album):
https://youtu.be/IZ32HxoriZA?t=924
Partial live version from Falls Church, VA in 2004:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8GPSPBOSuqg
Live version from London in 2004; this 10-minute version serves as the closer to the
Coming Through to You: The Live Recordings (1970-2004) live compilation:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DN5LUa_l5UU
The Love Band with John Echols live in Cardiff, UK in 2023:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGJMJH6oRic
At #9, the highest-ranking song from
Out Here, the warehouse songs that Elektra didn't want.