What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Missing Malaysian jet news (2 Viewers)

Did anyone mention Payne Stewart's plane in 1999 IIRC? The plane went too high or the cabin lost pressure, the inside froze up. The US sent several planes to intercept it or make contact and eventually it just ran out of fuel and the Air Force or whichever branch it was just escorted it down and made sure it wash't gonna hit anything but they never fired upon it and could not even see inside the plane due to the ice inside of it covering the windows.

Freak type event, had a celebrity on board so it made news obviously. Wonder if something similar could happen here. Until we have full reports from the fishermen in the area of where this plane went down we probably won't have all the details or correct information.
I don't think this explains the turns west, then south.
It was going West to Houston from Orlando and ended up in North Michigan I think. It went way off the trajectory as well. That was 15 years ago, maybe the planes do a few different things now. Also that was a small plane, nothing the size of a 777. I was just asking, been waiting for someone to bring it up, no one had to my knowledge.
Actually crashed in South Dakota. So, turning from a East/West course North, is not too far fetched. The Malaysian plane could have turned South from and East/West course
Wait. So now we think the triple 7 is in South Dakota?

 
Did anyone mention Payne Stewart's plane in 1999 IIRC? The plane went too high or the cabin lost pressure, the inside froze up. The US sent several planes to intercept it or make contact and eventually it just ran out of fuel and the Air Force or whichever branch it was just escorted it down and made sure it wash't gonna hit anything but they never fired upon it and could not even see inside the plane due to the ice inside of it covering the windows.

Freak type event, had a celebrity on board so it made news obviously. Wonder if something similar could happen here. Until we have full reports from the fishermen in the area of where this plane went down we probably won't have all the details or correct information.
I don't think this explains the turns west, then south.
The west then south could have been to land at that one long runway from a few pages back. Then things could have gotten worse and the Payne Stewart thing happened and the plane then flew until it ran out of fuel.

I remember the Payne Stewart one. They needed to lower in Charlton Heston to board the plane and land it.
The things that stop me there are:

  • Failure to communicate with the ground altogether; not even a notice of maybe possibly having any kind of issue.
  • They must have done two turns, not just one.
  • They were able to get down to 12,000 feet at one stage, which I think would eliminate the hypoxia issue (or am I wrong in that?).
I don't even know if we can believe anything that has been said about altitude of the plane. seems like they were making #### up as they went along....the reporters that is.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Did anyone mention Payne Stewart's plane in 1999 IIRC? The plane went too high or the cabin lost pressure, the inside froze up. The US sent several planes to intercept it or make contact and eventually it just ran out of fuel and the Air Force or whichever branch it was just escorted it down and made sure it wash't gonna hit anything but they never fired upon it and could not even see inside the plane due to the ice inside of it covering the windows.

Freak type event, had a celebrity on board so it made news obviously. Wonder if something similar could happen here. Until we have full reports from the fishermen in the area of where this plane went down we probably won't have all the details or correct information.
I don't think this explains the turns west, then south.
It was going West to Houston from Orlando and ended up in North Michigan I think. It went way off the trajectory as well. That was 15 years ago, maybe the planes do a few different things now. Also that was a small plane, nothing the size of a 777. I was just asking, been waiting for someone to bring it up, no one had to my knowledge.
Actually crashed in South Dakota. So, turning from a East/West course North, is not too far fetched. The Malaysian plane could have turned South from and East/West course
Wait. So now we think the triple 7 is in South Dakota?
It's as good a guess as any other :shrug:

 
Did anyone mention Payne Stewart's plane in 1999 IIRC? The plane went too high or the cabin lost pressure, the inside froze up. The US sent several planes to intercept it or make contact and eventually it just ran out of fuel and the Air Force or whichever branch it was just escorted it down and made sure it wash't gonna hit anything but they never fired upon it and could not even see inside the plane due to the ice inside of it covering the windows.

Freak type event, had a celebrity on board so it made news obviously. Wonder if something similar could happen here. Until we have full reports from the fishermen in the area of where this plane went down we probably won't have all the details or correct information.
I don't think this explains the turns west, then south.
It was going West to Houston from Orlando and ended up in North Michigan I think. It went way off the trajectory as well. That was 15 years ago, maybe the planes do a few different things now. Also that was a small plane, nothing the size of a 777. I was just asking, been waiting for someone to bring it up, no one had to my knowledge.
Actually crashed in South Dakota. So, turning from a East/West course North, is not too far fetched. The Malaysian plane could have turned South from and East/West course
Wait. So now we think the triple 7 is in South Dakota?
Might as well be.

 
Doesn't the transponder have less than two weeks left max? I really hope they find it. At least if they have a general location some conclusions can be drawn. If they find nothing at all there will never be any kind of closure.

 
Did anyone mention Payne Stewart's plane in 1999 IIRC? The plane went too high or the cabin lost pressure, the inside froze up. The US sent several planes to intercept it or make contact and eventually it just ran out of fuel and the Air Force or whichever branch it was just escorted it down and made sure it wash't gonna hit anything but they never fired upon it and could not even see inside the plane due to the ice inside of it covering the windows.

Freak type event, had a celebrity on board so it made news obviously. Wonder if something similar could happen here. Until we have full reports from the fishermen in the area of where this plane went down we probably won't have all the details or correct information.
I don't think this explains the turns west, then south.
It was going West to Houston from Orlando and ended up in North Michigan I think. It went way off the trajectory as well. That was 15 years ago, maybe the planes do a few different things now. Also that was a small plane, nothing the size of a 777. I was just asking, been waiting for someone to bring it up, no one had to my knowledge.
Actually crashed in South Dakota. So, turning from a East/West course North, is not too far fetched. The Malaysian plane could have turned South from and East/West course
Wait. So now we think the triple 7 is in South Dakota?
It's as good a guess as any other :shrug:
My money is still on either Al Qaeda Airlines or the 777 is traveling at the speed of light and will return again in 30 years with all of the passengers only being 3 minutes older than when they left.

 
Doesn't the transponder have less than two weeks left max? I really hope they find it. At least if they have a general location some conclusions can be drawn. If they find nothing at all there will never be any kind of closure.
For us or the families??????

 
It is pretty amazing that a plane that size could just disappear with no plausible explanation. At least in this day and age where everything is tracked and monitored so heavily.
I believe the solution is to make planes bigger than oceans. They would be impossible to lose.
We could make it illegal to crash a plane into the ocean. Just create crash free zones in all water deeper than 10 feet.

 
It is pretty amazing that a plane that size could just disappear with no plausible explanation. At least in this day and age where everything is tracked and monitored so heavily.
I believe the solution is to make planes bigger than oceans. They would be impossible to lose.
We could make it illegal to crash a plane into the ocean. Just create crash free zones in all water deeper than 10 feet.
Has anybody recycled the horrid stand-up line "Why don't they just make the whole plane out of the black box?"

 
It is pretty amazing that a plane that size could just disappear with no plausible explanation. At least in this day and age where everything is tracked and monitored so heavily.
I believe the solution is to make planes bigger than oceans. They would be impossible to lose.
We could make it illegal to crash a plane into the ocean. Just create crash free zones in all water deeper than 10 feet.
Has anybody recycled the horrid stand-up line "Why don't they just make the whole plane out of the black box?"
or styrofoam

 
I still don't get the hypoxia theory without additional complications if the plane did descend to 12,000 ft. at some point. 12,000 ft. is breathable air. If they were conscious when they got to 12,000 ft, they would likely be OK unless there was another complicating issue, i.e. a fire. If they were passed out and auto-pilot got them to 12,000 ft, there's no reason I can think of why they'd then climb back up to altitude.

 
So Malaysia says everyone is dead yet there is virtually no sign of any plane besides unidentified wreckage, and some pings.

This is like the show LOST, amiright?

 
So Malaysia says everyone is dead yet there is virtually no sign of any plane besides unidentified wreckage, and some pings.

This is like the show LOST, amiright?
They said everyone on the PLANE is dead. Lots of people in Malaysia are still alive. At least, that's what the media is saying. If you believe them. I haven't been to Malaysia, so who knows if there are still living people there.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
It is pretty amazing that a plane that size could just disappear with no plausible explanation. At least in this day and age where everything is tracked and monitored so heavily.
I believe the solution is to make planes bigger than oceans. They would be impossible to lose.
Too expensive. Best solution would be to just make the planes out of whatever they make the black boxes out of.

 
Actually it was discusseda lot early on, and this was mentioned, which is interesting:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Airways_Flight_522

I think one reason it was excluded was the weird behavior of the plane, going off radar, west then south so quickly as opposed to in a long arc.

However as the facts keep changing it might be good to revisit old conclusions that were previously ruled out based on old facts.
That was an interesting wiki. I hadn't read about that flight before. I didn't realize that auto-pilot would keep a plane in the holding pattern. It's terrifying to think that the pilots were incapacitated, but the cabin crew were OK. I guess it makes me second-guess the locked cockpit concept a little.

It needs to be locked, but SOMEBODY needs to be able to unlock it in an emergency via either code or signal transmitted to the plane in this kind of situation.

 
Doesn't the transponder have less than two weeks left max? I really hope they find it. At least if they have a general location some conclusions can be drawn. If they find nothing at all there will never be any kind of closure.
For us or the families??????
Obviously it's hardest on the families, but I have concerns about why planes might disappear as well.

If it was mechanical failure, what failed? If it was terrorist related, how did the terrorists get on board? If the pilot went nuts, why? How can it be prevented?

 
Aviation question:

Can you fly over the south pole?

For example, given the right amount of fuel, airplane, etc, could you fly out of South America heading directly south and at some point reach North America / Canada or does it not work like that?

 
Aviation question:

Can you fly over the south pole?

For example, given the right amount of fuel, airplane, etc, could you fly out of South America heading directly south and at some point reach North America / Canada or does it not work like that?
Ummm....

 
Aviation question:

Can you fly over the south pole?

For example, given the right amount of fuel, airplane, etc, could you fly out of South America heading directly south and at some point reach North America / Canada or does it not work like that?
Flying over the south pole causes an electromagnetic quantum-thermal disruption in the earth's magnetic field. You theoretically could, but then the toilets in Australia would flush in the opposite direction.

 
Aviation question:

Can you fly over the south pole?

For example, given the right amount of fuel, airplane, etc, could you fly out of South America heading directly south and at some point reach North America / Canada or does it not work like that?
Flying over the south pole causes an electromagnetic quantum-thermal disruption in the earth's magnetic field. You theoretically could, but then the toilets in Australia would flush in the opposite direction.
Hmmmm...

 
Aviation question:

Can you fly over the south pole?

For example, given the right amount of fuel, airplane, etc, could you fly out of South America heading directly south and at some point reach North America / Canada or does it not work like that?
Sounds like MoP teaching geography here.

 
Aviation question:

Can you fly over the south pole?

For example, given the right amount of fuel, airplane, etc, could you fly out of South America heading directly south and at some point reach North America / Canada or does it not work like that?
You cannot travel N/S over the poles. Haven't you ever played Civilization 3?

 
London: A new, unprecedented satellite tracking technique is what gave Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak enough confidence to announce that Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 went down in the remote south of the Indian Ocean.

British firm Inmarsat was behind an earlier analysis that indicated the plane had been flying in one of two big ‘corridors’, one in the northern hemisphere and one in the southern.

However last week it went back to its data and tried a new mathematical analysis, which concluded on Sunday.

The new analysis allowed them to discard the northern corridor, and focus more precisely on the southern route.

Based on this new information, Mr Najib announced on Monday that MH370’s last known position was in the middle of the Indian Ocean, west of Perth.

The nature of the pings indicated that the plane was still moving during that time.

“This is a remote location far from any possible landing sites,” he said. “It is therefore with deep sadness and regret that I must inform you that … flight MH370 ended in the southern Indian Ocean.”

The aeroplane had Inmarsat’s ‘Classic Aero’ satellite system, which collects information such as location, altitude, heading and speed, and sends it through Inmarsat’s satellites into their network.

This ‘ACARS’ (aircraft communications addressing and reporting system) was switched off or interrupted early in the flight, meaning no such information was available to track the plane.

However the Classic Aero system still sent hourly ‘pings’ back to Inmarsat’s satellite for at least five hours after the aircraft left Malaysian airspace, the company discovered.

These pings contained no data – they were just a simple ‘hello’ to keep the link open – however their timing and frequency contained hidden mathematical clues.

The company looked at the ‘Doppler effect’ – tiny changes in the frequency of the ping signal, caused by the relative movement of the satellite and the plane (the Doppler effect is the reason why, for example, police sirens are a different pitch or frequency depending on whether they are travelling toward you or away from you).

This analysis allowed Inmarsat to map two huge ‘corridors’ for the plane’s possible location, in big arcs stretching thousands of kilometres north and south of the point where the last radar contact with MH370 was made.

Australian and US experts took this information, added some assumptions about the plane’s speed, and narrowed the southern option into an area of ocean that could be realistically searched.

Meanwhile, Inmarsat went back to its satellite data. Its new analysis found that the northern route did not quite correlate with the frequency of the pings from the plane – meaning the plane must have been heading south.

It also suggested that the plane had been travelling at a steady cruising altitude above 30,000 feet.

They compared satellite data from MH370 with that from previous Malaysian Airlines Boeing 777 flights, going back a few weeks, in order to better model the movement of the plane.

“This really was a shot in the dark,” Chris McLaughlin, senior vice president of external affairs at Inmarsat told the BBC. “It’s a credit to the scientific team that they managed to model this.

“Just a single ‘ping’ can be used to say the plane was both powered up and travelling. And then by a process of elimination comparing it to other known flights and established that it went south.”

The UK’s Air Accidents Investigation Branch also contributed to the analysis.

 
They shouldn't have said everyone is dead. While it's true barring some huge miracle, the families will eventually put the pieces together for themselves in their own time especially since reports have been all over the place about what happened.

Also I just love how a camera man is literally inches from a woman who is wailing in grief falling to the ground. :no:

 
Aviation question:

Can you fly over the south pole?

For example, given the right amount of fuel, airplane, etc, could you fly out of South America heading directly south and at some point reach North America / Canada or does it not work like that?
That wouldn't work because if you keep flying south then you will crash into the south pole.

 
Doesn't the transponder have less than two weeks left max? I really hope they find it. At least if they have a general location some conclusions can be drawn. If they find nothing at all there will never be any kind of closure.
For us or the families??????
Obviously it's hardest on the families, but I have concerns about why planes might disappear as well.

If it was mechanical failure, what failed? If it was terrorist related, how did the terrorists get on board? If the pilot went nuts, why? How can it be prevented?
Get real. There are 34 million flights each year in the world. We need to take reasonable precautions, of course, but perfect safety under all circumstances is a pipe dream. You might as well say: "How can we prevent anyone from dying accidentally from any cause?"

 
Aviation question:

Can you fly over the south pole?

For example, given the right amount of fuel, airplane, etc, could you fly out of South America heading directly south and at some point reach North America / Canada or does it not work like that?
That wouldn't work because if you keep flying south then you will crash into the south pole.
And maybe kill a pole dancer in the process.

 
Doesn't the transponder have less than two weeks left max? I really hope they find it. At least if they have a general location some conclusions can be drawn. If they find nothing at all there will never be any kind of closure.
For us or the families??????
Obviously it's hardest on the families, but I have concerns about why planes might disappear as well.

If it was mechanical failure, what failed? If it was terrorist related, how did the terrorists get on board? If the pilot went nuts, why? How can it be prevented?
Get real. There are 34 million flights each year in the world. We need to take reasonable precautions, of course, but perfect safety under all circumstances is a pipe dream. You might as well say: "How can we prevent anyone from dying accidentally from any cause?"
Excellent point!

Forget about trying to figure out what happened. Why try and prevent this in the future. Let's stick our heads in the sand and move along. Air travel safety is "good enough".

 
Excellent point!

Forget about trying to figure out what happened. Why try and prevent this in the future. Let's stick our heads in the sand and move along. Air travel safety is "good enough".
This thread is the perfect answer to that. We've spend almost 5,000 posts or so trying to figure out what happened. And it will probably run a few thousand more. So we don't need to worry about sticking our head in the sand. But perfect safety will forever elude us.

 
It is pretty amazing that a plane that size could just disappear with no plausible explanation. At least in this day and age where everything is tracked and monitored so heavily.
I believe the solution is to make planes bigger than oceans. They would be impossible to lose.
It is pretty amazing that a plane that size could just disappear with no plausible explanation. At least in this day and age where everything is tracked and monitored so heavily.
I believe the solution is to make planes bigger than oceans. They would be impossible to lose.
We could make it illegal to crash a plane into the ocean. Just create crash free zones in all water deeper than 10 feet.
I feel like I've barely used my likes the past few days and I'm still out. IOU.

 
Did anyone mention Payne Stewart's plane in 1999 IIRC? The plane went too high or the cabin lost pressure, the inside froze up. The US sent several planes to intercept it or make contact and eventually it just ran out of fuel and the Air Force or whichever branch it was just escorted it down and made sure it wash't gonna hit anything but they never fired upon it and could not even see inside the plane due to the ice inside of it covering the windows.

Freak type event, had a celebrity on board so it made news obviously. Wonder if something similar could happen here. Until we have full reports from the fishermen in the area of where this plane went down we probably won't have all the details or correct information.
No, nobody mentions this yet. Certainly not about 300 times.

 
Aviation question:

Can you fly over the south pole?

For example, given the right amount of fuel, airplane, etc, could you fly out of South America heading directly south and at some point reach North America / Canada or does it not work like that?
I think you'd hit this pole if you flew directly over it...

 
Get real. There are 34 million flights each year in the world. We need to take reasonable precautions, of course, but perfect safety under all circumstances is a pipe dream. You might as well say: "How can we prevent anyone from dying accidentally from any cause?"Excellent point!

Forget about trying to figure out what happened. Why try and prevent this in the future. Let's stick our heads in the sand and move along. Air travel safety is "good enough".
I feel the government should come up with a new set of federal flying safety regulations that you could opt into for a fee. They could even have people sign up on a website, but they'd have to guarantee that I can keep flying my preferred airline.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top