'SSOG said:
'Neil Beaufort Zod said:
In my mind it's Moss or Ray Rice & Joe Flacco. I'll be happy for either side. Either way, Joe Flacco has delivered the kind of playoffs that make haters shut their pie holes.
This hater's pie hole is wide open- he's exactly who he always was. An above average QB struggling to crack the top 10. Just because he's almost as good of a QB in the playoffs as Mark Sanchez doesn't mean he's as elite as he thinks he is.
Wow. I guess you see what you want to see. I'm sorry Lee Evans couldn't catch an easy pass last year, or you might have already changed your mind. And I'm not sure what Sanchez has to do with it, since Flacco's played in twice as many playoff games. But, as they say, haters gonna hate.
Right. Because if there's one thing that's true about me, it's that wins in the playoffs trump everything for me. I've demonstrated that over and over again around here. If only Flacco had one or two more playoffs wins, I wouldn't question his eliteness. Just read some of the Manning/Brady threads for 5 seconds and you'll see how blatantly obvious it is.

As for me seeing what I want to see... why would I want to see Flacco not be elite? I like the guy. I've been complimentary of him in the past. For years I was arguing he was a better QB than Matt Ryan (I can dig up the archives, if you want). I love the fact that the SB QBs are from Nevada and Delaware (home of those vicious Blue Hens). I thought he would have taken a much bigger jump by now. I was wrong; he hasn't. I don't WANT to be wrong. I would rather never be wrong, actually. But I see what actually is, and what I see is that Flacco is not as good of a QB as Peyton, Tom, Aaron, Drew, Roeth, Luck, Bob Griffin, Wilson, Ryan (another guy I was sadly wrong about), Romo, and probably Jay and Eli (another guy I was sadly wrong about). Once upon a time, I'd take Rivers and Vick, too, but they've fallen off a cliff. I might take Stafford, Schaub, and Kaep depending on my mood. That puts Flacco at 12-16. These aren't guys I'd take to build around, these are guys I'd take if I just had a single season to play. Instead of calling me a hater who intensely wanted Flacco to prove my faith in him unfounded, how about you mention which of those names you think Flacco is better than today.