What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

My wife, she's... overweight. (1 Viewer)

Thanks for the update.

Of course she's angry with you. Not sure how you didn't see that one coming. She's looking at what could be a pretty challenging future for her, one that it seems like she hadn't contemplated until very recently. I'll bet it is scary as #### for her. That's what all that lifelong commitment stuff is about, I'd imagine.

I think having each of you meet alone with the therapist is a good idea. If you honestly don't think there's anything your wife can do to make you want to stay in the marriage, you can tell him in your private meeting and that will undoubtedly shape any future conversations. It makes sense for you and your wife to try to make peace with your relationship, since you'll be interacting a lot for a long time (at least while the kids are still in school). But I agree with you that the "retreat getaway" thing would be a big waste at this point.

Good luck, keep us posted.
She had a huge wakeup call on Memorial Day. But it's complete bull#### for one person to have to be THIS close to leaving before the other one starts taking things seriously. She is scared, that's for sure. But it's not scared of losing me.

I'm going to be pretty honest with the therapist.

 
How did it go? Feel free to tell me to shut up if you want to keep things private, but I've been following this thread closely and have great interest in updates.

Oh yeah, happy Father's Day.
Therapist wants to meet once with each of us alone, then back together. I don't know. :shrug:
Follow through with this. I'm not saying it is easy, but...
I am. The "I don't know" was more in general, not relating to seeing the therapist again.

 
She is angry because a lab can love her unconditionally but you can't. Death do us part, yada yada yada. Sorta get it. But I'm with you on this one 100%

 
How's the sex life? I mean outside of attraction issues. Frequent? Good quality? Does she try to ruin it by doing things to turn you off?

 
She is scared, that's for sure. But it's not scared of losing me.
What do you mean by this? Just that she's scared of being alone?

I sympathize with your frustration about the lengths you had to go to to convince her to take things seriously. There doesn't seem to be any way to convey the seriousness of the situation without coming across as a big jerk.

 
How's the sex life? I mean outside of attraction issues. Frequent? Good quality? Does she try to ruin it by doing things to turn you off?
Well... it's bad.

In general I'm the only initiator when I just can't deal with it any more [not lately... I haven't initiated in a long time]. Healthy marriage frequency was still only a few times a month. I don't want to talk too much crap about her, but she's not good in bed. Little to no passion/feedback/etc. She's a terrible kisser.

Her definition of sex initiation is literally "I'm going to go up to bed. You can/are welcome to join me if you want." Some times, if she's feeling extra frisky, she might tell me that she would LIKE me to join her. Woooo!!!!

 
She is scared, that's for sure. But it's not scared of losing me.
What do you mean by this? Just that she's scared of being alone?

I sympathize with your frustration about the lengths you had to go to to convince her to take things seriously. There doesn't seem to be any way to convey the seriousness of the situation without coming across as a big jerk.
She's scared of the marriage failing. In my opinion it's mostly a social stigma/thoughts about the kids thing for her. At least that's the only interpretation I can come up with when considering her actions and responses.

 
How's the sex life? I mean outside of attraction issues. Frequent? Good quality? Does she try to ruin it by doing things to turn you off?
Well... it's bad.

In general I'm the only initiator when I just can't deal with it any more [not lately... I haven't initiated in a long time]. Healthy marriage frequency was still only a few times a month. I don't want to talk too much crap about her, but she's not good in bed. Little to no passion/feedback/etc. She's a terrible kisser.

Her definition of sex initiation is literally "I'm going to go up to bed. You can/are welcome to join me if you want." Some times, if she's feeling extra frisky, she might tell me that she would LIKE me to join her. Woooo!!!!
Was she a terrible kisser and bad in bed before you were married?? Why were you so attracted to her to get married again? These are sorta bad signs. Just sayin...

 
How's the sex life? I mean outside of attraction issues. Frequent? Good quality? Does she try to ruin it by doing things to turn you off?
Well... it's bad.

In general I'm the only initiator when I just can't deal with it any more [not lately... I haven't initiated in a long time]. Healthy marriage frequency was still only a few times a month. I don't want to talk too much crap about her, but she's not good in bed. Little to no passion/feedback/etc. She's a terrible kisser.

Her definition of sex initiation is literally "I'm going to go up to bed. You can/are welcome to join me if you want." Some times, if she's feeling extra frisky, she might tell me that she would LIKE me to join her. Woooo!!!!
Was she a terrible kisser and bad in bed before you were married?? Why were you so attracted to her to get married again? These are sorta bad signs. Just sayin...
Pretty sure I already mentioned that I got married when I was young and stupid.

 
Not surprised she is angry with/at you. It is easier for her to be angry at you for wanting out of the marriage, than it is for her to be honest about her role in getting to where you are today. She'd rather direct her anger at you, than direct it at herself for screwing up your marriage.

 
Invaded? said:
Judge Smails said:
Invaded? said:
Sabertooth said:
How's the sex life? I mean outside of attraction issues. Frequent? Good quality? Does she try to ruin it by doing things to turn you off?
Well... it's bad.

In general I'm the only initiator when I just can't deal with it any more [not lately... I haven't initiated in a long time]. Healthy marriage frequency was still only a few times a month. I don't want to talk too much crap about her, but she's not good in bed. Little to no passion/feedback/etc. She's a terrible kisser.

Her definition of sex initiation is literally "I'm going to go up to bed. You can/are welcome to join me if you want." Some times, if she's feeling extra frisky, she might tell me that she would LIKE me to join her. Woooo!!!!
Was she a terrible kisser and bad in bed before you were married?? Why were you so attracted to her to get married again? These are sorta bad signs. Just sayin...
Pretty sure I already mentioned that I got married when I was young and stupid.
My bad. Not trying to pile on. Sorry, but that combo plus no willingness to better herself means she would have to be Mother Theresa like in every other aspect to make it worthwhile to spend the rest of your one shot on Earth with.

 
Invaded? said:
Sabertooth said:
How's the sex life? I mean outside of attraction issues. Frequent? Good quality? Does she try to ruin it by doing things to turn you off?
Well... it's bad.

In general I'm the only initiator when I just can't deal with it any more [not lately... I haven't initiated in a long time]. Healthy marriage frequency was still only a few times a month. I don't want to talk too much crap about her, but she's not good in bed. Little to no passion/feedback/etc. She's a terrible kisser.

Her definition of sex initiation is literally "I'm going to go up to bed. You can/are welcome to join me if you want." Some times, if she's feeling extra frisky, she might tell me that she would LIKE me to join her. Woooo!!!!
Does she typically go to bed before you, and you stay up checking the internet or watching sports awhile longer?

 
Invaded? said:
Sabertooth said:
How's the sex life? I mean outside of attraction issues. Frequent? Good quality? Does she try to ruin it by doing things to turn you off?
Well... it's bad.

In general I'm the only initiator when I just can't deal with it any more [not lately... I haven't initiated in a long time]. Healthy marriage frequency was still only a few times a month. I don't want to talk too much crap about her, but she's not good in bed. Little to no passion/feedback/etc. She's a terrible kisser.

Her definition of sex initiation is literally "I'm going to go up to bed. You can/are welcome to join me if you want." Some times, if she's feeling extra frisky, she might tell me that she would LIKE me to join her. Woooo!!!!
Does she typically go to bed before you, and you stay up checking the internet or watching sports awhile longer?
Yes. This is a problem that I have admitted to contributing to over the years. It's not a recipe for a healthy intimate relationship. But it's a bit of a chicken and egg problem. It wasn't always that way.

 
It's the man's job to initiate sex. It's that simple to be honest. Women have responsive desire.
Well, this is problematic when the man has no interest in having sex with the woman.
True. Very true. But that doesn't really change the biology involved. Sounds like there are serious attraction issues on both sides of the marriage. I guess from that perspective he can either tolerate the marriage as-is, work to change the attraction dynamic and hope she responds, or deep six the marriage.

I'd never stay in a sexless marriage and when my marriage started to inch that way, I got in better shape and started leading my family. I'm a big fan of Athol Kay's stuff. I think there is just a lot of truth in what he says about the marriage dynamic. He's been on here before. But I've followed his advice and instead of going backwards into our seperate corners, in my marriage (14 years) we broke new sexual ground just last weekend.

 
It's the man's job to initiate sex. It's that simple to be honest. Women have responsive desire.
Well, this is problematic when the man has no interest in having sex with the woman.
True. Very true. But that doesn't really change the biology involved. Sounds like there are serious attraction issues on both sides of the marriage. I guess from that perspective he can either tolerate the marriage as-is, work to change the attraction dynamic and hope she responds, or deep six the marriage. I'd never stay in a sexless marriage and when my marriage started to inch that way, I got in better shape and started leading my family. I'm a big fan of Athol Kay's stuff. I think there is just a lot of truth in what he says about the marriage dynamic. He's been on here before. But I've followed his advice and instead of going backwards into our seperate corners, in my marriage (14 years) we broke new sexual ground just last weekend.
I've read some of the Married Man Sex Life stuff, and I think it probably does do a decent job of explaining the dynamic in most marriages. I didn't find that it was particularly helpful for my marriage, though. A lot of it is centered around how to get your wife to want to have sex with you. That's not really the issue for me (or Invaded?).

 
I disagree. The real crux of the site is making yourself the best man you can be. I think you misunderstand the point there. If you are a fit, financially stable, friendly, flirty awesome version of yourself, your life gets better. If you were the best (or at least a much better version) of yourself, many of your problems would be dealt with. If you suck at money and suddenly got much stronger financially, she'd probably response positively to that. If you dress like a bum and suddenly started dressing much better due to improved physique and clothing, she'd probably respond positively to that. And if she didn't, you'd be in a much better place mentally to deal with that as well.

I think Athol's hook is improved sex life. But that's really just a side effect. I think the way he puts it is something like this "become the best man you can be and you will get the life you deserve. It just might not be with your current wife."

You can't make your wife do something. She can choose to do nothing. But if you are getting interest from higher quality women than your wife she will probably up her game. If she doesn't well, you will be in a better spot to deal with that.

 
It's the man's job to initiate sex. It's that simple to be honest. Women have responsive d

It's the man's job to initiate sex. It's that simple to be honest. Women have responsive desire.
That's really not what the article says.
Sure it does. Tons of articles out there on Female Responsive Desire. I just picked the first one that wasn't from a manosphere blogger. More importantly I've found that my wife has responsive desire. What about your's?

esire.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Kind of a summary of the different types of sexual desire. Obviously not everyone can be painted with this broad brush but I find it to be true in my marriage.

“Responsive desire” is when motivation to have sex begins AFTER sexual behavior has started. As in, you’re doing something else when your partner comes over and starts kissin’ on ya, and you go, “Oh yeah! That’s a good idea!” Or you and your partner set aside Friday night as Sex Night, and then Sex Night gets here and you’re like, “Oh, Sex Night. But I’m so tired…” But you made a deal, so you get started… and before long you’ve forgotten you were tired.

This is contrasted with “spontaneous” desire, more typical of male sexuality, which works more like this: you’re walking down the street and for no immediately obvious reason you think, “Hm. I’d like to have sex!” Or you’re taking a shower getting ready for bed and you think, “Hm. I’d like to have sex!”

 
Oh great, 1-size-fits-all Alpha guy is here.
Me? I'm far from an Alpha guy. I did find I was lacking Alpha male characteristics in my life though. And since addressing those, my life has become much better. Obviously there are a ton of issues that might be involved. But taking the lead in my family's finances alone has really helped my marriage.

 
I disagree. The real crux of the site is making yourself the best man you can be. I think you misunderstand the point there. If you are a fit, financially stable, friendly, flirty awesome version of yourself, your life gets better. If you were the best (or at least a much better version) of yourself, many of your problems would be dealt with. If you suck at money and suddenly got much stronger financially, she'd probably response positively to that. If you dress like a bum and suddenly started dressing much better due to improved physique and clothing, she'd probably respond positively to that. And if she didn't, you'd be in a much better place mentally to deal with that as well.

I think Athol's hook is improved sex life. But that's really just a side effect. I think the way he puts it is something like this "become the best man you can be and you will get the life you deserve. It just might not be with your current wife."

You can't make your wife do something. She can choose to do nothing. But if you are getting interest from higher quality women than your wife she will probably up her game. If she doesn't well, you will be in a better spot to deal with that.
Yeah, I think this is a fair characterization of his stuff. The problem for me (and Invaded?, I think) is all of the caveats at the end. Both of us already have a significantly higher "sex rank" than our spouse (to use Athol's terminology). Our wives have not "upped their game."

 
Kind of a summary of the different types of sexual desire. Obviously not everyone can be painted with this broad brush but I find it to be true in my marriage.

“Responsive desire” is when motivation to have sex begins AFTER sexual behavior has started. As in, you’re doing something else when your partner comes over and starts kissin’ on ya, and you go, “Oh yeah! That’s a good idea!” Or you and your partner set aside Friday night as Sex Night, and then Sex Night gets here and you’re like, “Oh, Sex Night. But I’m so tired…” But you made a deal, so you get started… and before long you’ve forgotten you were tired.

This is contrasted with “spontaneous” desire, more typical of male sexuality, which works more like this: you’re walking down the street and for no immediately obvious reason you think, “Hm. I’d like to have sex!” Or you’re taking a shower getting ready for bed and you think, “Hm. I’d like to have sex!”
I know it says that. But the greater point of the article is empowerment for women and them taking on a more "spontaneous desire" role in relationships. Responsive/Spontaneous desire roles are pretty much 1950s relics. Women certainly have the capacity for spontaneous desire and men can act responsively. Limiting either gender's role in the sexual dynamic is ludicrous.

I'll be dropping this though, as I don't want to hijack the thread.

 
I disagree. The real crux of the site is making yourself the best man you can be. I think you misunderstand the point there. If you are a fit, financially stable, friendly, flirty awesome version of yourself, your life gets better. If you were the best (or at least a much better version) of yourself, many of your problems would be dealt with. If you suck at money and suddenly got much stronger financially, she'd probably response positively to that. If you dress like a bum and suddenly started dressing much better due to improved physique and clothing, she'd probably respond positively to that. And if she didn't, you'd be in a much better place mentally to deal with that as well.

I think Athol's hook is improved sex life. But that's really just a side effect. I think the way he puts it is something like this "become the best man you can be and you will get the life you deserve. It just might not be with your current wife."

You can't make your wife do something. She can choose to do nothing. But if you are getting interest from higher quality women than your wife she will probably up her game. If she doesn't well, you will be in a better spot to deal with that.
Yeah, I think this is a fair characterization of his stuff. The problem for me (and Invaded?, I think) is all of the caveats at the end. Both of us already have a significantly higher "sex rank" than our spouse (to use Athol's terminology). Our wives have not "upped their game."
Yes that is a problem if that's the case. You either have to live with it or give her an ultimatum that she is required to do X Y and Z or you are gone? But if you don't have the true desire to follow through on leaving, the ultimatum is fake and she'll probably sense that and laugh it off. You can't very well tell her your won't tolerate a behavior and then go on tolerating it. Of course you might give her the ultimatum on Wednesday and get served divorce papers on Friday. It's a game of chicken for sure. But if you situation is intolerable, you can't really lose. You either get her to wake up and become a wife. Or you get divorced and can move forward with a better wife.

 
Kind of a summary of the different types of sexual desire. Obviously not everyone can be painted with this broad brush but I find it to be true in my marriage.

“Responsive desire” is when motivation to have sex begins AFTER sexual behavior has started. As in, you’re doing something else when your partner comes over and starts kissin’ on ya, and you go, “Oh yeah! That’s a good idea!” Or you and your partner set aside Friday night as Sex Night, and then Sex Night gets here and you’re like, “Oh, Sex Night. But I’m so tired…” But you made a deal, so you get started… and before long you’ve forgotten you were tired.

This is contrasted with “spontaneous” desire, more typical of male sexuality, which works more like this: you’re walking down the street and for no immediately obvious reason you think, “Hm. I’d like to have sex!” Or you’re taking a shower getting ready for bed and you think, “Hm. I’d like to have sex!”
I know it says that. But the greater point of the article is empowerment for women and them taking on a more "spontaneous desire" role in relationships. Responsive/Spontaneous desire roles are pretty much 1950s relics. Women certainly have the capacity for spontaneous desire and men can act responsively. Limiting either gender's role in the sexual dynamic is ludicrous.

I'll be dropping this though, as I don't want to hijack the thread.
Oh they are? Why do you think strapping 6'2" like yourself nail all the hot chicks then? And nice 5'7" chubby guys like my (back in my early 20s) get stuck in the friend zone?

 
I disagree. The real crux of the site is making yourself the best man you can be. I think you misunderstand the point there. If you are a fit, financially stable, friendly, flirty awesome version of yourself, your life gets better. If you were the best (or at least a much better version) of yourself, many of your problems would be dealt with. If you suck at money and suddenly got much stronger financially, she'd probably response positively to that. If you dress like a bum and suddenly started dressing much better due to improved physique and clothing, she'd probably respond positively to that. And if she didn't, you'd be in a much better place mentally to deal with that as well.

I think Athol's hook is improved sex life. But that's really just a side effect. I think the way he puts it is something like this "become the best man you can be and you will get the life you deserve. It just might not be with your current wife."

You can't make your wife do something. She can choose to do nothing. But if you are getting interest from higher quality women than your wife she will probably up her game. If she doesn't well, you will be in a better spot to deal with that.
Yeah, I think this is a fair characterization of his stuff. The problem for me (and Invaded?, I think) is all of the caveats at the end. Both of us already have a significantly higher "sex rank" than our spouse (to use Athol's terminology). Our wives have not "upped their game."
Eh, you either choose to live with it or you don't.

 
Sorry for the hijack.

Invaded? As I see it, you have four options:

1. Keep asking you wife to change (You cannot make her change if she's not motivated to change)

2. Improve yourself in hopes that she follows your lead and comes around. (Add some motivation for her to change. Maybe she'll realize she needs to up her game to keep you and you are the best she can get).

3. Tolerate the marriage until one of you dies.

4. Start hiding money.

 
Kind of a summary of the different types of sexual desire. Obviously not everyone can be painted with this broad brush but I find it to be true in my marriage.

“Responsive desire” is when motivation to have sex begins AFTER sexual behavior has started. As in, you’re doing something else when your partner comes over and starts kissin’ on ya, and you go, “Oh yeah! That’s a good idea!” Or you and your partner set aside Friday night as Sex Night, and then Sex Night gets here and you’re like, “Oh, Sex Night. But I’m so tired…” But you made a deal, so you get started… and before long you’ve forgotten you were tired.

This is contrasted with “spontaneous” desire, more typical of male sexuality, which works more like this: you’re walking down the street and for no immediately obvious reason you think, “Hm. I’d like to have sex!” Or you’re taking a shower getting ready for bed and you think, “Hm. I’d like to have sex!”
I know it says that. But the greater point of the article is empowerment for women and them taking on a more "spontaneous desire" role in relationships. Responsive/Spontaneous desire roles are pretty much 1950s relics. Women certainly have the capacity for spontaneous desire and men can act responsively. Limiting either gender's role in the sexual dynamic is ludicrous.

I'll be dropping this though, as I don't want to hijack the thread.
It's cool, there is some good discussion to be had on the subject. It's a pretty important part of a relationship.

 
Re: improving yourself/myself

I think I mentioned in this thread at some point that a few years ago I was in the best shape of my life. I've never been fat/out of shape, and I'm not a big muscly guy, but I was super toned and just all around in about as good a shape as I can be. There was zero response from my wife, and I'd say that was about the start of our real problems.

I'm very comfortable and confident in my looks, personality, job, etc. I'm not saying I can't improve, you always can, but there are not HUGE strides to be made here. I'm not cocky, just trying to lay out the reality of things.

She has not made any of those efforts, and she's probably in the WORST shape of her life. I look at our wedding picture, in which she truly was one of the most beautiful women I'd ever seen, and I don't even recognize her now. I don't expect her to look like that... people change, I get it. But the lack of effort/caring is almost impossible to overcome at this point.

 
That's a bummer. So what is your plan moving forward? I don't think it's fair to divorce her without layout out some expectations is it? I mean I don't think you have to get a chart out with weight on one side and weeks on the other but what about other things like sex? Have you explained to her what you need from her?

Sounds like her attitude needs a serious adjustment, even moreso than her fitness.

 
That's a bummer. So what is your plan moving forward? I don't think it's fair to divorce her without layout out some expectations is it? I mean I don't think you have to get a chart out with weight on one side and weeks on the other but what about other things like sex? Have you explained to her what you need from her?

Sounds like her attitude needs a serious adjustment, even moreso than her fitness.
Well that's what the last two years, and specifically last 9 months have been about.

Telling her I'm unhappy with the level of affection and that I need X, Y, Z. I can't even get X. Now I don't even want X.

 
If she's unresponsive. Then you only have two options. Tolerate or leave. Just remember, it's her choice too. She made the choice to not give a #### and close up shop. You are just the one turning out the lights.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you had an honest discussion about what you need from a marriage, those needs were reasonable, and your wife is not willing to even put in EFFORT to TRY to fulfill them, you probably need to walk away.

 
Has anyone out there ever become completely detached from your wife and somehow come back from the ledge to fall in love with her? Is it even possible once you hit that point?
2 years ago this fall I told my wife I wanted a divorce (thanks alcohol)

A year ago she asked me if we were just good friends who made the mistake of getting married.

This after being together for 18 years.

Since then we have worked at it (no counselling) and are in a great place.

We hit the point where we each realized the other was not exactly who we wanted in a mate. Maybe it took us longer to get there than others.

The turning point was deciding that we still wanted to be together anyway and re-fell in love with who they were instead of being bitter about who they were not.

Maybe I should write a book.....
Going back to this post. Why did this work? Because we both put in the effort. I gave her three things I needed from her, she did the same. We agreed to touch base weekly to assess where we are at so that neither of us goes too long with our needs being unmet.

 
Has anyone out there ever become completely detached from your wife and somehow come back from the ledge to fall in love with her? Is it even possible once you hit that point?
2 years ago this fall I told my wife I wanted a divorce (thanks alcohol)

A year ago she asked me if we were just good friends who made the mistake of getting married.

This after being together for 18 years.

Since then we have worked at it (no counselling) and are in a great place.

We hit the point where we each realized the other was not exactly who we wanted in a mate. Maybe it took us longer to get there than others.

The turning point was deciding that we still wanted to be together anyway and re-fell in love with who they were instead of being bitter about who they were not.

Maybe I should write a book.....
Going back to this post. Why did this work? Because we both put in the effort. I gave her three things I needed from her, she did the same. We agreed to touch base weekly to assess where we are at so that neither of us goes too long with our needs being unmet.
Good on you Duff Man.

 
Has anyone out there ever become completely detached from your wife and somehow come back from the ledge to fall in love with her? Is it even possible once you hit that point?
2 years ago this fall I told my wife I wanted a divorce (thanks alcohol)

A year ago she asked me if we were just good friends who made the mistake of getting married.

This after being together for 18 years.

Since then we have worked at it (no counselling) and are in a great place.

We hit the point where we each realized the other was not exactly who we wanted in a mate. Maybe it took us longer to get there than others.

The turning point was deciding that we still wanted to be together anyway and re-fell in love with who they were instead of being bitter about who they were not.

Maybe I should write a book.....
Going back to this post. Why did this work? Because we both put in the effort. I gave her three things I needed from her, she did the same. We agreed to touch base weekly to assess where we are at so that neither of us goes too long with our needs being unmet.
I will admit that while I did try for a while after we had lots of these conversations, I really did, at some point, when I didn't see any changes, I just lost it. I lost all connection with her, I lost all hope, I lost all attraction. And after that I just haven't put much if any effort in. I just can't do it any more, I can't be the one that tries to keep things going, make things better by myself.

So in reality, there is fault that lies on me right now for that, for not trying harder at the current time. It just got to the point where nothing makes me think things can ever be good together and I've given up, really. I can't see a happy life with her.

It's sad to me that at no point, even after she got "shocked" on Memorial Day, has she ever just broken down to me and cried and said how much she loves me and how much she doesn't want to lose me. She's just been defensive, and recently, angry. Which says to me that there's nothing I can do.

 
Has anyone out there ever become completely detached from your wife and somehow come back from the ledge to fall in love with her? Is it even possible once you hit that point?
2 years ago this fall I told my wife I wanted a divorce (thanks alcohol)

A year ago she asked me if we were just good friends who made the mistake of getting married.

This after being together for 18 years.

Since then we have worked at it (no counselling) and are in a great place.

We hit the point where we each realized the other was not exactly who we wanted in a mate. Maybe it took us longer to get there than others.

The turning point was deciding that we still wanted to be together anyway and re-fell in love with who they were instead of being bitter about who they were not.

Maybe I should write a book.....
Going back to this post. Why did this work? Because we both put in the effort. I gave her three things I needed from her, she did the same. We agreed to touch base weekly to assess where we are at so that neither of us goes too long with our needs being unmet.
I will admit that while I did try for a while after we had lots of these conversations, I really did, at some point, when I didn't see any changes, I just lost it. I lost all connection with her, I lost all hope, I lost all attraction. And after that I just haven't put much if any effort in. I just can't do it any more, I can't be the one that tries to keep things going, make things better by myself.

So in reality, there is fault that lies on me right now for that, for not trying harder at the current time. It just got to the point where nothing makes me think things can ever be good together and I've given up, really. I can't see a happy life with her.

It's sad to me that at no point, even after she got "shocked" on Memorial Day, has she ever just broken down to me and cried and said how much she loves me and how much she doesn't want to lose me. She's just been defensive, and recently, angry. Which says to me that there's nothing I can do.
I have a hard time finding fault with you giving up. You tried before and nothing happened. Sounds like you may have tried multiple times and nothing has happened.

It sounds to me that you have not only lost your love for that woman, but you have lost respect for her too. Until she does something, none of that will change.

 
Has anyone out there ever become completely detached from your wife and somehow come back from the ledge to fall in love with her? Is it even possible once you hit that point?
2 years ago this fall I told my wife I wanted a divorce (thanks alcohol)

A year ago she asked me if we were just good friends who made the mistake of getting married.

This after being together for 18 years.

Since then we have worked at it (no counselling) and are in a great place.

We hit the point where we each realized the other was not exactly who we wanted in a mate. Maybe it took us longer to get there than others.

The turning point was deciding that we still wanted to be together anyway and re-fell in love with who they were instead of being bitter about who they were not.

Maybe I should write a book.....
Going back to this post. Why did this work? Because we both put in the effort. I gave her three things I needed from her, she did the same. We agreed to touch base weekly to assess where we are at so that neither of us goes too long with our needs being unmet.
I will admit that while I did try for a while after we had lots of these conversations, I really did, at some point, when I didn't see any changes, I just lost it. I lost all connection with her, I lost all hope, I lost all attraction. And after that I just haven't put much if any effort in. I just can't do it any more, I can't be the one that tries to keep things going, make things better by myself.

So in reality, there is fault that lies on me right now for that, for not trying harder at the current time. It just got to the point where nothing makes me think things can ever be good together and I've given up, really. I can't see a happy life with her.

It's sad to me that at no point, even after she got "shocked" on Memorial Day, has she ever just broken down to me and cried and said how much she loves me and how much she doesn't want to lose me. She's just been defensive, and recently, angry. Which says to me that there's nothing I can do.
I don't know that your ultimate conclusion is wrong, but I don't know that I'd agree with the bolded.

I think that it could be a natural reaction to get defensive and angry once one actually realizes the seriousness of the situation. Maybe it's good that she at least has some emotional reaction and means she actually has awareness and could be moved through a process.

You certainly know better than any of us what's going on and again, your overall feeling doesn't seem unreasonable. Just adding a thought about that part.

 
It's sad to me that at no point, even after she got "shocked" on Memorial Day, has she ever just broken down to me and cried and said how much she loves me and how much she doesn't want to lose me. She's just been defensive, and recently, angry. Which says to me that there's nothing I can do.
I don't know that your ultimate conclusion is wrong, but I don't know that I'd agree with the bolded.

I think that it could be a natural reaction to get defensive and angry once one actually realizes the seriousness of the situation. Maybe it's good that she at least has some emotional reaction and means she actually has awareness and could be moved through a process.

You certainly know better than any of us what's going on and again, your overall feeling doesn't seem unreasonable. Just adding a thought about that part.
I suspect that she probably doesn't even like him very much right now. I think it's sorta unrealistic to expect her to cry and say she loves him under these circumstances.

 
It's sad to me that at no point, even after she got "shocked" on Memorial Day, has she ever just broken down to me and cried and said how much she loves me and how much she doesn't want to lose me. She's just been defensive, and recently, angry. Which says to me that there's nothing I can do.
I don't know that your ultimate conclusion is wrong, but I don't know that I'd agree with the bolded.

I think that it could be a natural reaction to get defensive and angry once one actually realizes the seriousness of the situation. Maybe it's good that she at least has some emotional reaction and means she actually has awareness and could be moved through a process.

You certainly know better than any of us what's going on and again, your overall feeling doesn't seem unreasonable. Just adding a thought about that part.
I suspect that she probably doesn't even like him very much right now. I think it's sorta unrealistic to expect her to cry and say she loves him under these circumstances.
You're probably right.

Whether it's unrealistic or not, I needed to see SOMETHING along the way to indicate to me that she cared about how I feel, about making me happy.

I'm not sure there is a solution if you have one person who has given up, is not attracted, and is not in love with the other person, while the other person just sets in a defensive stance being angry.

 
I think she is testing his resolve. What is your resolve invaded?

Are you ready to pull the ripcord?
I don't think she is testing his resolve. I think she is trying to avoid doing anything, just like she seemingly has been for years.
I think it's less a cognitive decision to not change, or not to make efforts to change, and more a simple inability to do so. She's just not capable.

 
I think it's less a cognitive decision to not change, or not to make efforts to change, and more a simple inability to do so. She's just not capable.
I'm not sure there is a solution if you have one person who has given up, is not attracted, and is not in love with the other person, while the other person just sets in a defensive stance being angry.
I agree with both of these assessments.

 
If she's not capable, or willing, then a choice has to be made. Till death to us part is not automatic. Sorry. Each party is entitled to happiness and fulfillment. If somebody becomes an alcoholic, drug user, felon, batterer is it until death? Of course not. What about if they become verbally abusive and won't change? I wouldn't stay. How about if they become a hoarder? I can't live like that, so after umpteen attempts at counseling I'd be gone. If they stop caring for themselves physically or deny intimacy I'm gone too. Of course after multiple attempts at therapy. You married her, she deserves a shot.

I will say that after my wife saw that 70% of my friends are now divorced she tries even harder to make our marriage great. Doesn't take me for granted, and hasn't turned down an initiation for sex in 5 years. Also doing Cardio Barre religiously. Smart woman - she knows what we have is great and wants it to continue. By the way, all of the guys (40's and 50's) who now have fractured families and twenty something's they are sleeping with said they would switch places with me tomorrow. But I was lucky or smart in choosing a great life partner, and it's better now than it was when we married 28 years ago. But we've always been best friends too. Don't think we've ever had a real fight.

But if my wife even refused to acknowledge an issue, and made zero attempt even if it was important to me, it would be rough to stay. I would think she thinks the same way. You get what you put into all relationships. And if your wife isn't putting in she just might not have a relationship to worry about anymore.

 
I think she is testing his resolve. What is your resolve invaded?

Are you ready to pull the ripcord?
I don't think she's testing his resolve. I think she's mentally ill. Maybe suffering depression along with other illnesses. Mental illnesses like bi-polar, various personality disorders, etc. are spectrum disorders and people who are higher functioning are tougher to diagnose.

 
I think she is testing his resolve. What is your resolve invaded?

Are you ready to pull the ripcord?
I don't think she is testing his resolve. I think she is trying to avoid doing anything, just like she seemingly has been for years.
I think it's less a cognitive decision to not change, or not to make efforts to change, and more a simple inability to do so. She's just not capable.
You say that now, but the sad thing is, if you leave her, she'll lose weight and change her attitude in a heartbeat, just long enough to snag another man. It's what a lot of women do.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top