Simon Shepherd
Footballguy
Well you already aren't projecting them, so a zero projection gives me the exact same information and analysis that you are already providing me by not projecting them at all. I'm not losing anything with that.
What I'm gaining is that the reports I run and analyze on my own are now accurate. A huge part of the benefit of this system is that we have one interface to run all our leagues from. I can bookmark 10 different MFL stat pages and go to each one and run 5 pulldowns on each one, or I can do all of that on a single page here. Some of your reports are even more robust than the MFL equivalents are and I strongly prefer to use this page to consolidate all of that info - that's a huge value-add. But it loses its luster if it's wrong and I have to run that stuff on MFL to trust it.
The #1 thing we do is project. I do think that's the main goal of Footballguys, to help with projections given your scoring.
I can see the added value in historical stats and the like across your leagues. I get that. I don't want you or anyone else to think we don't do things just because we're being obstinate! So I will share some details as to why that's not an easy hit-a-button-and-make-it-happen feature.
All our pages are built to deal with leagues both imported, and manually added.
That means the pages that deal with stats for past performances operate over two things:
1) the scoring system we have on file for that league
2) the stats that we have on file for the NFL
We combine those to get the fantasy points for past weeks for any given player.
What I think you're suggesting is that we show historical points scored for all leagues, regardless of if we support that scoring.
The issue is that we'd need to import that data. Which we don't currently do; just scoring. Stats are also proprietary data, just check out how much Stats LLC charge for an annual subscription! So while we pay our own sub (to a stats provider) for subscriptions, re-publishing scores, that are based on other stats, directly from another site may have its issues.
The secondary thing I can see there is people seeing we have the historical stuff there and then asking why we don't have the projections too. That would be particularly confusing when viewing a matchup on a Monday. All the Sunday players would have their scores correct there, but the MNF guys would be off, which would be strange.
Some of your leagues specifically have punters; we don't have those in our database. So that's going to cause issues when trying to display the full statistics too (same goes for head coaches).
This thread wouldn't exist if we weren't constantly looking to improve the services we offer and the ease with which we integrate with your league providers. So the feedback is for sure noted and taken on board (I have put it in our "Ideas" column on our kanban board for this project). This is a constant moving thing, never a finished product now, and we'll always be seeking to make this better and improve it. So thank you for taking the time to explain this to me!