*** OFFICIAL *** 13/14 Off-Season Dynasty Trade Thread (3 Viewers)

[maxhyde]

Randle

For

Eifert

Eifert

Yeah I like Randle more than most but I would easily take Eifert here

 

[DansRams]

12 team ppr qb rbrb wrwrwr te flex (rb/wr/te)

Team A trades Romo and Bryce Brown

Team B trades 2015 1st (likely 8-12) and 2015 4th

 

[slackjawedyokel]

Randle for McCluster, ppr qrrwwtfdd 16t

 

[cdubz]

Randle for McCluster, ppr qrrwwtfdd 16t

As in Joseph? If so, guess I would take McCluster as a fill-in RB for that deep of a league.

 

[slackjawedyokel]

Randle for McCluster, ppr qrrwwtfdd 16t

As in Joseph? If so, guess I would take McCluster as a fill-in RB for that deep of a league.

Reuben actually. Not involved.

 

[cdubz]

Randle for McCluster, ppr qrrwwtfdd 16t

As in Joseph? If so, guess I would take McCluster as a fill-in RB for that deep of a league.

Reuben actually. Not involved.

Yeah, that's not even remotely close then. Reuben by far. Even if the dude busts, process over outcome - bad move by the former Randle owner IMHO.

 

[Zyphros]

10 team .5 PPR 2QB 3WR 2RB 2TE 1WR/RB 1WR/RB/TE

Team A gave: Jared Cook 4th

Team B gave: Tim Wright

Same league different teams

Team C trades: Joique Bell

Team D trades: Devonta Freeman, 2015 2nd

I am the one receiving Bell. My current RB's were Shady/Mathews/Ingram/B. Pierce/Hill/McKinnon and I wasn't comfortable with Ingram as a weekly flex. I am definitely a contender.

 

[Adam Harstad]

I think part of the value of the four random 1st round picks is that all four have a chance of being a high pick. In this case, only one does. Additionally, Latimer probably more commonly went in the 2nd round than he went in the top 6,

Right, which is why I came down on the Calvin side of it.

Regardless of where Latimer commonly went, I'd draft him at 1.06/1.07 today. So that's how I'd value him in a trade.

Really? You could just trade back and still get him

Maybe, maybe not (I've seen him go as high as 5th), but we're talking about a league that's already drafted. And if I were trading with someone else who owned Cody Latimer, and I was attempting to place a value on Cody Latimer for that trade, I would place a value roughly equivalent to the 1.06/1.07 pick.

 

[Acrobat7]

QB Ben Roethlisberger PIT

TE Jordan Cameron WAS

2015 2nd

for

WR Antonio Brown PIT

TE Dwayne Allen IND

2015 4th

edit: 12 team PPR QB/QB/RB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/WR/TE/K/D

 

[maxhyde]

10 team .5 PPR 2QB 3WR 2RB 2TE 1WR/RB 1WR/RB/TE

Team A gave: Jared Cook 4th

Team B gave: Tim Wright

Cook still for me

 

[maxhyde]

QB Ben Roethlisberger PIT

TE Jordan Cameron WAS

2015 2nd

for

WR Antonio Brown PIT

TE Dwayne Allen IND

2015 4th

edit: 12 team PPR QB/QB/RB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/WR/TE/K/D

Give me Brown

 

[maxhyde]

Randle for McCluster, ppr qrrwwtfdd 16t

Randle

 

[maxhyde]

12 team ppr qb rbrb wrwrwr te flex (rb/wr/te)

Team A trades Romo and Bryce Brown

Team B trades 2015 1st (likely 8-12) and 2015 4th

1st is a good deal here

 

[maxhyde]

Crabtree

2015 2nd

for

Kelvin Benjamin

Crabtree for me

Agreed

 

[FUBAR]

Crabtree

2015 2nd

for

Kelvin Benjamin

Crabtree for me

Assuming that's Michael and not tom, the pick is on the wrong side

 

[valhallan]

Randle

For

Eifert

Eifert by a mile. Steal.

 

[valhallan]

QB Ben Roethlisberger PIT

TE Jordan Cameron WAS

2015 2nd

for

WR Antonio Brown PIT

TE Dwayne Allen IND

2015 4th

edit: 12 team PPR QB/QB/RB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/WR/TE/K/D

Great move to get Brown.

 

[r0llin_game]

QB Ben Roethlisberger PIT

TE Jordan Cameron WAS

2015 2nd

for

WR Antonio Brown PIT

TE Dwayne Allen IND

2015 4th

edit: 12 team PPR QB/QB/RB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/WR/TE/K/D

This is Allen and the fourth for free. If it was TE premium then it'd be way closer, but I'd still prefer the Brown.

 

[Skeletore Eh]

I think part of the value of the four random 1st round picks is that all four have a chance of being a high pick. In this case, only one does. Additionally, Latimer probably more commonly went in the 2nd round than he went in the top 6,

Right, which is why I came down on the Calvin side of it.

Regardless of where Latimer commonly went, I'd draft him at 1.06/1.07 today. So that's how I'd value him in a trade.

Really? You could just trade back and still get him

Maybe, maybe not (I've seen him go as high as 5th), but we're talking about a league that's already drafted. And if I were trading with someone else who owned Cody Latimer, and I was attempting to place a value on Cody Latimer for that trade, I would place a value roughly equivalent to the 1.06/1.07 pick.

Regardless of how you value latimer that's not representative of his market value, which is pretty firmly in the late 1st to 2nd round range

 

[maxhyde]

I think part of the value of the four random 1st round picks is that all four have a chance of being a high pick. In this case, only one does. Additionally, Latimer probably more commonly went in the 2nd round than he went in the top 6,

Right, which is why I came down on the Calvin side of it.

Regardless of where Latimer commonly went, I'd draft him at 1.06/1.07 today. So that's how I'd value him in a trade.

Really? You could just trade back and still get him

Maybe, maybe not (I've seen him go as high as 5th), but we're talking about a league that's already drafted. And if I were trading with someone else who owned Cody Latimer, and I was attempting to place a value on Cody Latimer for that trade, I would place a value roughly equivalent to the 1.06/1.07 pick.

Regardless of how you value latimer that's not representative of his market value, which is pretty firmly in the late 1st to 2nd round range

I would agree. His consensus value may not be the same as his value to you. In any case this is a very cheap price for Calvin. Unless somebody likes Latimer > Evans/Watkins I think most would say the best player at his position was traded for a handful of magic beans.

 

[Adam Harstad]

QB Ben Roethlisberger PIT

TE Jordan Cameron WAS

2015 2nd

for

WR Antonio Brown PIT

TE Dwayne Allen IND

2015 4th

edit: 12 team PPR QB/QB/RB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/WR/TE/K/D

This is Allen and the fourth for free. If it was TE premium then it'd be way closer, but I'd still prefer the Brown.

In a 2-QB league? I'd prefer the Roethlisberger/Cameron side by a decent margin.

 

[Adam Harstad]

Maybe, maybe not (I've seen him go as high as 5th), but we're talking about a league that's already drafted. And if I were trading with someone else who owned Cody Latimer, and I was attempting to place a value on Cody Latimer for that trade, I would place a value roughly equivalent to the 1.06/1.07 pick.

Regardless of how you value latimer that's not representative of his market value, which is pretty firmly in the late 1st to 2nd round range

And the market is free to value him there, but I thought we were supposed to be giving our own personal thoughts on trades, not the market's thoughts on trades. If all anyone ever wanted was what the market thought of their trades, they could just go look up startup ADP value, and I'd stop coming down on the Harvin/Gronk side of every fair-market Harvin/Gronk trade posted in here.

Any time someone gets Cody Latimer for 1.06/1.07 prices, I think they did a pretty good job, because I believe that's what his value is. Any time they get Cody Latimer for late 1st / early 2nd prices, I think they got a steal. The market can feel free to disagree- and, in fact, as a potential buyer of Cody Latimer, I sincerely hope it continues to do so.

 

[Henry Ford]

I think part of the value of the four random 1st round picks is that all four have a chance of being a high pick. In this case, only one does. Additionally, Latimer probably more commonly went in the 2nd round than he went in the top 6,

Right, which is why I came down on the Calvin side of it.

Regardless of where Latimer commonly went, I'd draft him at 1.06/1.07 today. So that's how I'd value him in a trade.

Really? You could just trade back and still get him

Maybe, maybe not (I've seen him go as high as 5th), but we're talking about a league that's already drafted. And if I were trading with someone else who owned Cody Latimer, and I was attempting to place a value on Cody Latimer for that trade, I would place a value roughly equivalent to the 1.06/1.07 pick.

Regardless of how you value latimer that's not representative of his market value, which is pretty firmly in the late 1st to 2nd round range

If you believe his actual value is higher than his market value, you pay more. Happily. Nobody in the NFL is happy about passing on Marques Colston in the 7th because he graded out as a free agent.

 

[Archer]

Not involved but went down in my 12 team PPR dynasty league

Team A gets: Larry Fitzgerald

Team B gets: Benjamin, Manziel, Martavis Bryant

 

[Archer]

Another one, 12 team PPR dynasty league

Team A gets: Adams, Maclin, Randle

Team B gets: Crabtree, Stills, Crowell, 2nd in 2015

 

[Henry Ford]

Not involved but went down in my 12 team PPR dynasty league

Team A gets: Larry Fitzgerald

Team B gets: Benjamin, Manziel, Martavis Bryant

I'd take Benjamin side, unless it was a win now year.

 

[Archer]

Another 12 team PPR dynasty trade

Team A gets: Jeffery, Olsen, Miller, Moreno

Team B gets: Ball, Justin Hunter, Moncrief, Amaro, Hillman

 

[Childress]

Team A in Championship window gave Gronk

Team B fighting for playoffs gave ASJ, 2015 1st (playoff contender) and another 2015 1st (Worse than a playoff contender)

:X

What was so gross? Moving gronk in a championship window? Or the haul that Gronk was received for?

 

[Rolling_akg]

Rosterbaters gave up Bush, Reggie DET RB;Smith, Steve BAL WR; Year 2015 Round 3 Draft Pick from Bronze Medal Special Olympian

Jack Attack gave up West, Terrance CLE RB;Gordon, Josh CLE WR

 

[r0llin_game]

QB Ben Roethlisberger PIT

TE Jordan Cameron WAS

2015 2nd

for

WR Antonio Brown PIT

TE Dwayne Allen IND

2015 4th

edit: 12 team PPR QB/QB/RB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/WR/TE/K/D

This is Allen and the fourth for free. If it was TE premium then it'd be way closer, but I'd still prefer the Brown.

In a 2-QB league? I'd prefer the Roethlisberger/Cameron side by a decent margin.

Whoops, completely missed that!

 

[One More Rep]

Not involved but went down in my 12 team PPR dynasty league

Team A gets: Larry Fitzgerald

Team B gets: Benjamin, Manziel, Martavis Bryant

Fitz

 

[Adam Harstad]

QB Ben Roethlisberger PIT

TE Jordan Cameron WAS

2015 2nd

for

WR Antonio Brown PIT

TE Dwayne Allen IND

2015 4th

edit: 12 team PPR QB/QB/RB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/WR/TE/K/D

This is Allen and the fourth for free. If it was TE premium then it'd be way closer, but I'd still prefer the Brown.

In a 2-QB league? I'd prefer the Roethlisberger/Cameron side by a decent margin.

Whoops, completely missed that!

Honestly, I did too until your reply led me to reconsider the original post.

 

[JetMaxx]

Reed

For

R. Mathews

 

[Lott's Fingertip]

10 team, 1/2 ppr for WR/TE only, start QRRWWT + flex, 5 year max contracts, 5 man rookie squad, 2 man 2nd yr player squad

Gave:

Ben Tate (4 yrs), J.McKinnon, Bridgewater, 3rd rounder (prob late)

Received:

2015 1st rounder (7-10 range), 2nd rounder (same), 4th rounder (same), Z. Mettenberger

I was in a roster crunch with cutdown at midnight... my remaining RBs are Spiller, Stacy, Foster, Mathews, Pierce, J.Stewart, Sankey, K.Davis, B.Cunningham

Thoughts?

 

[Adam Harstad]

10 team, 1/2 ppr for WR/TE only, start QRRWWT + flex, 5 year max contracts, 5 man rookie squad, 2 man 2nd yr player squad

Gave:

Ben Tate (4 yrs), J.McKinnon, Bridgewater, 3rd rounder (prob late)

Received:

2015 1st rounder (7-10 range), 2nd rounder (same), 4th rounder (same), Z. Mettenberger

I was in a roster crunch with cutdown at midnight... my remaining RBs are Spiller, Stacy, Foster, Mathews, Pierce, J.Stewart, Sankey, K.Davis, B.Cunningham

Thoughts?

Biggest key to building dominant squads in dynasty is getting future firsts for non-core players. So kudos.

 

[Skeletore Eh]

Maybe, maybe not (I've seen him go as high as 5th), but we're talking about a league that's already drafted. And if I were trading with someone else who owned Cody Latimer, and I was attempting to place a value on Cody Latimer for that trade, I would place a value roughly equivalent to the 1.06/1.07 pick.

Regardless of how you value latimer that's not representative of his market value, which is pretty firmly in the late 1st to 2nd round range

And the market is free to value him there, but I thought we were supposed to be giving our own personal thoughts on trades, not the market's thoughts on trades. If all anyone ever wanted was what the market thought of their trades, they could just go look up startup ADP value, and I'd stop coming down on the Harvin/Gronk side of every fair-market Harvin/Gronk trade posted in here.

Any time someone gets Cody Latimer for 1.06/1.07 prices, I think they did a pretty good job, because I believe that's what his value is. Any time they get Cody Latimer for late 1st / early 2nd prices, I think they got a steal. The market can feel free to disagree- and, in fact, as a potential buyer of Cody Latimer, I sincerely hope it continues to do so.

That's a fine approach if you're ok with losing value in your trades. I would just say its a losing proposition in the long run. Especially when you're trading the best player at his position

 

[Henry Ford]

Torrey Smith

For

2015 1st

 

[Buffaloes]

.5 PPR mandatory start 3 WR w/ a flex 10 tm

Larry Fitz was traded for a conditional pick(s):

if it's a top 3 pick it's Fitz for 2015 1st rd pick

if it's pick 4-6, it's Fitz for 2015 1st and 3rd round picks

if it's pick 7-10, it's Fitz for 2015 1st and 2nd round picks

 

[pghrob]

12 teams 25, man rosters. PPR, All tds = 6 pts.

Line up: q, r,r, w, w, t, f, d/st, k

Team A gives Aaron Rogers

Team B gives RGIII, Brian Hoyer, Jonathan Stewart, Jordan Reed

 

[Acrobat7]

12 teams 25, man rosters. PPR, All tds = 6 pts.

Line up: q, r,r, w, w, t, f, d/st, k

Team A gives Aaron Rogers

Team B gives RGIII, Brian Hoyer, Jonathan Stewart, Jordan Reed

So basically Rodgers for RGIII and Reed? What the hell?!

 

[One More Rep]

Torrey Smith

For

2015 1st

Torrey

 

[One More Rep]

12 teams 25, man rosters. PPR, All tds = 6 pts.

Line up: q, r,r, w, w, t, f, d/st, k

Team A gives Aaron Rogers

Team B gives RGIII, Brian Hoyer, Jonathan Stewart, Jordan Reed

Rodgers

 

[JetMaxx]

12 teams 25, man rosters. PPR, All tds = 6 pts.

Line up: q, r,r, w, w, t, f, d/st, k

Team A gives Aaron Rogers

Team B gives RGIII, Brian Hoyer, Jonathan Stewart, Jordan Reed

Rodgers and it ain't close

 

[ConnSKINS26]

14 team PPR devy league. TE premium.

Gave:

Marqise Lee

Housler

Got:

Devin Funchess

2014 Devy pick (probably late, we only draft 1 round)

 

[DexterDew]

Funchess and Devy.

[disclosure: Funchess owner and view him as a more fluid Benjamin, curious if combine times vaults him to Evans range]

 

[ConnSKINS26]

Funchess and Devy.

[disclosure: Funchess owner and view him as a more fluid Benjamin, curious if combine times vaults him to Evans range]

Exactly where I am, I also see him somewhere on that Benjamin---Evans scale.

 

[False Start]

Just went down in my start 2QB PPR Flex

Josh Gordon and Bernard Pierce

for

Ryan Mathews and Anquan Boldin

 

[BearsFan4Life]

Thoughts on this... 14 team no ppr

Gave: Stafford TRICH Vereen

Got: Foles L Bell Hillman

 

[One More Rep]

Thoughts on this... 14 team no ppr

Gave: Stafford TRICH Vereen

Got: Foles L Bell Hillman

Foles/Bell in non ppr for me

 

[False Start]

Funchess and Devy.

[disclosure: Funchess owner and view him as a more fluid Benjamin, curious if combine times vaults him to Evans range]

That kid is a phenom with unreal talent and size. Watch what this kid does to the Big 10 this year. If Michigan was an elite team, he would be up for the Heisman.