I've watched every snap and here's what I've noticed.As is with all things Reid, he is trying to jam a square peg in a round hole. He (& Castillo) have a defensive scheme where Asomugha, one of the two best man coverage guys is always in a zone. He is a tremendous bump and run guy because of his long arms. This scheme almost never utilizes him in that. Then last week, several times I watched Samuel (an undersized zone corner who is lousy in bump & run) get beat trying to jam bigger receivers on the line. As has been said here many times, the wide 9 is fine, but we don't have the LBs for it. The WIP guys made an interesting point, where else in the world do you hire a D-Line coach BEFORE you hire the coordinator? It probably caused most interested coordinator prospects to look elsewhere knowing they wouldn't get to utilized their own scheme.Kelce is not good right now. Jackson should be in there. Kelce may be good some day, but shouldn't be playing right away. Watkins was okay (despite the killer penalty which was iffy). He may have a decent future. Peters was playing outstanging before he got hurt. King Dunlop even played surprisingly well behind him. Other than the short yardage debacles (100% Reid's fault) and a few poor turnovers the offense has been solid. McCoy has been truly unbelievable and is becoming one of the best and most exciting backs in the league.Casey Matthews is terrible and shouldn't get back on the field in 2011. I think everyone hoped he would be half the player his brother is, but it's just not there. Brian Rolle has been very solid against the run and fantastic in coverage. Rolle and Chaney are playing way above where they were drafted and are actually improving the defense. The biggest problem is without question the strong safety spot. Coleman shouldn't be on the roster. Page is average on his best day, a true journeyman. I have hope for Nate Allen. He may develop into a solid starter, but we shouldn't be hoping for the next Dawkins there. You can attribute at least one critical huge play or touchdown to easy, must-make tackles or blown coverages attributable to Coleman or Page in each game. These are all one score games and that position is responsible for at least three losses.