Watching shows like this must suck for those of you that think everything is rigged or manipulated. I thought the black box was actually the worst competition for Donny at the time. It just so happens that everytime Christine gave Caleb a bone, it didn't fit. Do you think the producers opened a back door and kept handing her bad bones? I would think Donny loses this competition 8 out of 10 times. Caleb and Cody probably put 10 bones up to Donny's 5, but all of his fit.
I do think that black box comp was fair, but am also pretty sure the game as a whole is manipulated by production. (Caleb did say to Zach after the comp that production made him give back the bones Christine was handing him. Whether that's true or not, we'll obviously never know. We also heard production cheered Donny on and cheered his victory at this comp. Not exactly unbiased, again if true. We'll never know.)
How would production tell Caleb that he had to give them back? Wouldn't Donnie hear this conversation?
I don't have a good answer to this without sounding too much like tinfoil hat guy, but we do know that the host of the comps wears an earpiece and has production in their ear giving them instruction, so maybe the competitors also had their own earpieces getting their own instruction and what not. Or maybe when he took the bone production simply stopped the comp and said Caleb, stop that, and then resumed.
I don't want to believe production manipulates the comps themselves as they're happening, and I don't really. This is more my bitterness that us live feeders don't get to watch the competitions live and, while the feeds are blocked and the comps are going on, I start to wonder why we aren't allowed to watch them. We do get to watch the HOH comps as they happen, and those are the most important, so I can't complain too much.