What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

*** OFFICIAL *** COVID-19 CoronaVirus Thread. Fresh epidemic fears as child pneumonia cases surge in Europe after China outbreak. NOW in USA (33 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is that a .1??

1 percent is the absolute lowest you should be at.  Even South Korea, a model for testing and efficiency, has slowly drifted above 1 percent.  .5 is wildly optimistic. 

Building a model around a .1 fatality rate is building a model around the flu, not the coronavirus.
Please dont speak in facts, we are all speculating and creating projections here.  In a post a couple above I have stated why I believe that's my number.  You are welcome to disagree with it.  To be fair, my range is a mortality rate of .1 to .5.  Confidence internal?  Meh, 35%?

 
Aren't there UV-resistant fabrics that are often used in jerseys like these? If they are able to get the weave super-tight with UV-resistant fibers, they could put out masks that are re-usable many times after taking UV "baths" to sanitize.

EDIT: Heck, even this ten-dollar jersey is UV resistant (SPF 30). This is the kind of thing I was thinking of.
They were tested over the weekend with St Luke’s in Philly...will follow up with more details.

 
I thought the same thing. The only issue is that I'm not confident that we ever got the true death rate from the cruise ship. Everyone went to their home countries and I kind of feel like they got mixed into the numbers with everyone else.  If you've seen an article where journalists have found the actual numbers for those passengers, I'd love to see it.

1% really is a best-case scenario
It is worse since I read the article. 712 cases. 10 dead. 105 still sick with 15 listed as serious. 1.4% with a chance of rising

 
I don't necessarily disagree with any of that.  We are streaming services, using Zoom, etc as well.  And we've had great response like you have.  Maybe it's cause I'm more gregarious, but online just isn't the same.  I get that you say we're still "meeting" and in some respects we are.  But it's not the same.   We shall see.  Thanks for your thoughts.
I agree, it’s not the same as in person for sure. That’s true for our adults but even more so for our kids. Tough to continue those programs in any meaningful way and as a church that is over 50% under the age of 18, that is big for us. But what happened in South Korea really sticks in my mind. Their biggest exposure and transmission happened when a woman who was positive went to her mega church and gave it to a bunch of people. We certainly don’t want to base our decisions in fear, but the reality is that churches that decide to ignore orders not to meet are probably going to be viewed as uncaring towards their local community as those meetings would, at least appear, to increase the danger to the larger community.

I don’t want to put limits on God or ignore that He may very well have plans that don’t make sense to me, but if you’re a church and you’re making decisions that in their face seem to increase the damage to your surrounding community and be viewed as selfish rather than caring, you’d better be absolutely 100% beyond a doubt sure that you’re following God’s calling and are in line with Scripture in the process.

 
Please dont speak in facts, we are all speculating and creating projections here.  In a post a couple above I have stated why I believe that's my number.  You are welcome to disagree with it.  To be fair, my range is a mortality rate of .1 to .5.  Confidence internal?  Meh, 35%?
You can believe in whatever you want.  But if you're going to post it in here, I'm going to show you when you're wrong.  You literally just said in a different post "each season we have between 20k and 50k flu deaths.  If this season we doubled the flu death it wouldn't be that bad."

That slippery slope crap is what a lot of people are starting to do and it's going to get a ton of people killed. 

You have a right to believe whatever you want.  But when your belief is in direct contradiction to what the entire scientific and healthcare community believes, you're not going to post it in here without being told you're wrong.

 
We aren't rooting for people to die. We are rooting for and others you to open your ####### eyes and see that people are dying now, and many more will die if folks continue to think "this is no big deal, let's get the economy going again already"
It’s all an overreaction until a beloved family member is getting unplugged from life support.

 Case in point - that idiot woman a few pages back who is backpedaling from her “just the flu bro” comments a few days earlier. Now that she’s quite sick.

 
It is worse since I read the article. 712 cases. 10 dead. 105 still sick with 15 listed as serious. 1.4% with a chance of rising
Wow that's interesting.  That falls right in line with South Korea.  South Korea, by far, has done the best job of any country in testing.  Their death rate, in my mind, represents the absolute best case scenario for a country.  They are currently at 1.4%.  Thanks for the update.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
The LA governor was on the radio a couple hours ago. He said they are in the process if installing 1100 hospital beds. IN THE CONVENTION CENTER. In anticipation of the next couple of weeks. And working on getting more set up, because they don't anticipate that to be nearly enough. He has had a serious tone in his press conferences for several days now, but today was different. Today was somber and a little bit pissed off. Pleading with the people to listen to and comply with the directives given.  

 
 He said they are in the process if installing 1100 hospital beds. IN THE CONVENTION CENTER. In anticipation of the next couple of weeks. And working on getting more set up, because they don't anticipate that to be nearly enough.
Unless we think every governor, who have much more inside info than we do, are lying - well...

 
Suffolk County reported the following confirmed cases and deaths due to COVID-19 through 2:30 p.m. on 3/26/2020

2735  confirmed cases  (up 475 from the 2,260 cases that were reported at 2:30 p.m. on March 25)

287 patients are hospitalized (up 81 from March 25), 103 of those are in the intensive care unit (up 36  from March 25)

22 deaths (up 2 from March 22) Of the 22 deaths, 7 were related to a local senior community

A breakdown of cases by township reported through 2:30 p.m. on 3/26/2020 - Note: this breakdown comprises the information from 2,351 records available to Suffolk County at this time. 

Islip -- 548

Huntington -- 504

Brookhaven -- 398

Babylon -- 367

Smithtown -- 140

Southold -- 123

Southampton --59

Riverhead --45

East Hampton -- 18

Shelter Island -- 1

Township not known -- 148

Source

I'm in Brookhaven. East Setauket.
drive thru the white castle for me.  i keep getting crave case coupons and can’t use them.

 
You really don't need to use the US numbers to calculate death rate. This isn't a different virus in this country.  We've been tracking and discussing the death rate for 2 months in here.  The WHO has numbers, epidemiologists have numbers, other countries do a GREAT job of testing.  The numbers are out there.  Any belief that .1% is the death rate is not reasonable, it's blind optimism.  I'd love for you to be right, but there's literally zero evidence for it. 

Again, .1% is flu numbers.  They wouldn't shut down the whole world for a virus with similar death rates to the flu.
Why country do you want to use?  Italy?  Their population demographic is incredibly different than ours.  In addition, we have like 5435235432234 more acres of land for the virus to cover.

Please stop speaking in facts.

How about this bet - my $100 to your $10,000 that the mortality rate in the US will be below 1% by Aug 1st.  Now, you aren't going to take this bet because you know there is a reasonable chance your assertions are wrong.  I mean, if you unequivocally believe I'm wrong, then take the bet - right?

 
Im skeptical that data like that is available.  Cool none the less.  Scary if true (on multiple fronts).
The CDC actually used something like that here in NJ for the Red Bank Regional high school case. That's how they identified the 51 students that had close contact with the girl and quarantined them and their families. My friend and his daughter were part of it so that's how I know. The high school makes all the kids register their phones at the beginning of the school year, so they already had that monitoring in place.

 
Not throwing stones at you. Going to assume you arent 78 with multiple comorbidities. 
Younger, fully healthy people are in the hospital with this. And even if you have a mild case you can pass to someone like you described above. There are bunch of cases already in my neighborhood. I'm staying on lockdown.

 
Why country do you want to use?  Italy?  Their population demographic is incredibly different than ours.  In addition, we have like 5435235432234 more acres of land for the virus to cover.

Please stop speaking in facts.

How about this bet - my $100 to your $10,000 that the mortality rate in the US will be below 1% by Aug 1st.  Now, you aren't going to take this bet because you know there is a reasonable chance your assertions are wrong.  I mean, if you unequivocally believe I'm wrong, then take the bet - right?
I’m not betting on a death rate man.  Geez, I’m outta here for awhile.

 
You can believe in whatever you want.  But if you're going to post it in here, I'm going to show you when you're wrong.  You literally just said in a different post "each season we have between 20k and 50k flu deaths.  If this season we doubled the flu death it wouldn't be that bad."

That slippery slope crap is what a lot of people are starting to do and it's going to get a ton of people killed. 

You have a right to believe whatever you want.  But when your belief is in direct contradiction to what the entire scientific and healthcare community believes, you're not going to post it in here without being told you're wrong.
I can tell that you dont work with projections for a living.  The way you speak about estimates and projections makes it clear you dont understand what they are about.  Good luck to you my friend :lmao:

Also - the entire scientific and healthcare community agrees with me.  Feel free to post articles detailing the current NPIs we are taking and what their new projected mortality rates are.

 
The CDC actually used something like that here in NJ for the Red Bank Regional high school case. That's how they identified the 51 students that had close contact with the girl and quarantined them and their families. My friend and his daughter were part of it so that's how I know. The high school makes all the kids register their phones at the beginning of the school year, so they already had that monitoring in place.
Wow - that is super duper scary

 
My brother is General Counsel for a public company that has hundreds of labs globally. He is in charge of his company’s response, covering 15k employees across those labs. In text exchange with family, he lamented that he is working 20 hour days and agrees with Trump that everyone is blowing this way out of proportion. Most of what goes on in those labs isn’t essential, so concerning to me that the attitude of someone directing the responses across that number of people is essentially eye rolling about it.
It's honestly heartbreaking to see that attitude so prevalent, it will directly lead to untold needless deaths.

I can't fathom people seeing the below things and much more happen in the past two weeks:

  • Stock market historic single day losses
  • China shutting down major industrial cities for weeks
  • Postponed: Olympics, NBA, MLB, NHL
  • Schools closed across the nation
  • Governors across the nation issuing Shelter at Home orders
  • Heartbreaking accounts of death and despair in Italy
  • Daily, relentless increases in confirmed sick and dead in the USA
and then somehow concluding this:  "I think people are overreacting".

 
It's honestly heartbreaking to see that attitude so prevalent, it will directly lead to untold needless deaths.

I can't fathom people seeing the below things and much more happen in the past two weeks:

  • Stock market historic single day losses
  • China shutting down major industrial cities for weeks
  • Postponed: Olympics, NBA, MLB, NHL
  • Schools closed across the nation
  • Governors across the nation issuing Shelter at Home orders
  • Heartbreaking accounts of death and despair in Italy
  • Daily, relentless increases in confirmed sick and dead in the USA
and then somehow concluding this:  "I think people are overreacting".
We live in a society where everyone feels their opinion is just as important as anyone else’s. 

 
Younger, fully healthy people are in the hospital with this. And even if you have a mild case you can pass to someone like you described above. There are bunch of cases already in my neighborhood. I'm staying on lockdown.
Yes. Younger people are in the hospital. Some will even die. 

However the risks are night and day different. If you were 78 with issues there is literally no excuse to go to three places shopping today. 

If you are 40 and healthy, sanitize hands, keep spacing, etc, you have pretty much zero risk and can justify such a run. 

 
Went through the front door of my apartment for the first time in 14 days. Hit 3 stores for supplies. Based on what I saw I can say with reasonable certainty that we're all screwed. No chance this thing slows down any time soon. Half the people out there acting like it's just a normal summer day off from work. Store checker taking bites of a chocolate bar between guests.

Why am I sheltering indoors and social distancing at the store if people are still walking around in groups while shoveling popcorn into their mouths like they're kids at the carnival?

I would say chances I get the virus based on that trip alone is >10%. Out of Woodford at TJ's to boot.
Regarding the bolded, I know you know this, but it's still good to remember that everyone who is taking great care to not get infected themself or to transmit the virus, you are one of the dots in the second half of this animation:

https://external-preview.redd.it/Br0D6A1cDVZdnJARzB1QOWefuHEeVQtfKXwbpd9uY4Y.gif?format=mp4&s=a9e9ef0d6b0674fc552be3ee1af5d4f45b64e49f

 
Yes. Younger people are in the hospital. Some will even die. 

However the risks are night and day different. If you were 78 with issues there is literally no excuse to go to three places shopping today. 

If you are 40 and healthy, sanitize hands, keep spacing, etc, you have pretty much zero risk and can justify such a run. 
Didn't feel like zero risk. You do your best but this thing comes down to pure luck

 
Are we still arguing death rates here?  The biggest obstacle with this virus is the people who DON'T DIE but are in intensive care for weeks.  Or are in intensive care for weeks THEN die!  The massive volume of patients is overwhelming these hospitals and health care professionals.  Scoffing off the death rate as being low doesn't take the entire perspective as to why this virus is a HUGE problem.   

 
Reported cases...
agreed.  given the late start and total lack of testing in many places across America, combined with a significant percentage of the population basically ignoring stay in place rules, i suspect the cases in america are significantly under reported.

 
Optimism/positivity as a fig leaf for denialism? That's a sliding scale, admittedly. But a certain level of optimism can give cover to those who don't want to countenance the case-count information as best as we currently know it. And sometimes, even denialism is understandable on an individual level as a means of self-comfort.
I don't think anyone is denying that there's a virus out there, and that it has claimed lives.  But there seem to be a lot of people denying that 12 to 14 months of acting this way is not doable.  It's a non-starter.  There seems to be a prevailing belief in some that if I go out and shake my neighbors hand that we're going to end up killing everyone we come into contact with afterwards.  The "well, 2,000 people died yesterday - that means 4,000 will die tomorrow" crowd are instilling fear and panic into people that by and large won't be killed by this thing. The vast majority of people who get this will recover just fine.

Related: Inaccurate virus models are panicking officials into ill advised lockdowns

Should people who are at risk take special precautions?  Yes.  Absolutely.  The elderly, infirm and those with chronic respiratory, autoimmune or coronary conditions...those are the people that should be quarantined and shut out from the rest of the public, because if they get the virus there's a good chance they could die.  They should be afraid of being around large groups (or people in general) and making sure they wipe down things they come into contact with.  The rest of the world shouldn't have to be shut down because Pop Pop can't stop going to the supper club to play poker on Wednesdays.

There's a lot of talk about flattening the curve, but at some point we need to flatten the unemployment curve.  Most of the people proposing a months long lockdown are not going without a paycheck right now.  At a certain point people that are not at high risk of dying from this have to be able to stop living like they're under siege.  Where's the sympathy for the millions of people that are going to be economically destroyed because of this shut down?

Full disclosure: My wife and I are following the guidelines.  We haven't been within 6 feet of someone other than each other in 8 days.  I'm doing my part and I hope others are as well.  But let's not cut off our leg because our nose itches.  This has got to end at some point.  /rant

Secondary disclosure: Doug B is awesome and has been great in this thread.  If he writes something that conflicts with what I say, you should probably listen to him.

 
It's honestly heartbreaking to see that attitude so prevalent, it will directly lead to untold needless deaths.

I can't fathom people seeing the below things and much more happen in the past two weeks:

  • Stock market historic single day losses
  • China shutting down major industrial cities for weeks
  • Postponed: Olympics, NBA, MLB, NHL
  • Schools closed across the nation
  • Governors across the nation issuing Shelter at Home orders
  • Heartbreaking accounts of death and despair in Italy
  • Daily, relentless increases in confirmed sick and dead in the USA
and then somehow concluding this:  "I think people are overreacting".
Well said

I started paying attention when they cancelled* the NCAA tourney.  That's like flushing a few billion dollars down the toilet.  I started trying to qualify what it would take, what sort of projections must their be, for those in charge to flush that cash.  Thinking through those scenarios opened my eyes.

* - IMO when we look back at this, the NCAA will look like geniuses and saints at the same time.

 
Went through the front door of my apartment for the first time in 14 days. Hit 3 stores for supplies. Based on what I saw I can say with reasonable certainty that we're all screwed. No chance this thing slows down any time soon. Half the people out there acting like it's just a normal summer day off from work. Store checker taking bites of a chocolate bar between guests.

Why am I sheltering indoors and social distancing at the store if people are still walking around in groups while shoveling popcorn into their mouths like they're kids at the carnival?

I would say chances I get the virus based on that trip alone is >10%. Out of Woodford at TJ's to boot.
Regarding the bolded, I know you know this, but it's still good to remember that everyone who is taking great care to not get infected themself or to transmit the virus, you are one of the dots in the second half of this animation:

https://external-preview.redd.it/Br0D6A1cDVZdnJARzB1QOWefuHEeVQtfKXwbpd9uY4Y.gif?format=mp4&s=a9e9ef0d6b0674fc552be3ee1af5d4f45b64e49f
Right - when you get sick you want there to be a bed for you

 
Geez, I’m outta here for awhile.
Ive been taking long breaks from here everyday. Super helpful.

I watch the daily update on YT from Dr John Campbell (UK) in the morning, & then I watch Cuomo’s presser everyday around noon.

Check in here a few times a day. Then I lay off Twitter or news until the evening.

Though not always. I want to be informed but there’s nothing I can do to change anything. I’m fine with not knowing the case/death count for 12–18 hours.

Stay reasonably well informed but don’t obsess. There are 40 foot refrigerated trailers at every NYC hospital to store bodies, we know it’s gonna be bad for awhile.

One day it will end. We will get through this.

 
Are we still arguing death rates here?  The biggest obstacle with this virus is the people who DON'T DIE but are in intensive care for weeks.  Or are in intensive care for weeks THEN die!  The massive volume of patients is overwhelming these hospitals and health care professionals.  Scoffing off the death rate as being low doesn't take the entire perspective as to why this virus is a HUGE problem.   
Mortality rate takes those into account (fundamentally).  This is exactly why flattening the curve is so important.  While ~70% may get infected, we want it to happen over 5-10 months, not 3 months

 
Well said

I started paying attention when they cancelled* the NCAA tourney.  That's like flushing a few billion dollars down the toilet.  I started trying to qualify what it would take, what sort of projections must their be, for those in charge to flush that cash.  Thinking through those scenarios opened my eyes.

* - IMO when we look back at this, the NCAA will look like geniuses and saints at the same time.
That was me, except when they shut down Italy. You just know that was an excruciating decision to have to make. That's what woke me up to all this. As I expressed a few hundred pages ago, aka yesterday, I only regret that I didn't check into this thread about a month ago, to have a better idea of what was going on and potentially, if not definitely, heading our way.

 
First person in the county  I live died today. 40 years old and all I know is he was the counties first reported positive case, which was a few days ago, and he got infected locally.

I find it super annoying they won't give out any more information. I'm not expecting them to blast his name out or anything out of respect to him and his family  but letting us know places he'd been lately and if he had a pre-existing health condition are things I'd really like to know.

 
I don't think anyone is denying that there's a virus out there, and that it has claimed lives.  But there seem to be a lot of people denying that 12 to 14 months of acting this way is not doable.  It's a non-starter.  There seems to be a prevailing belief in some that if I go out and shake my neighbors hand that we're going to end up killing everyone we come into contact with afterwards.  The "well, 2,000 people died yesterday - that means 4,000 will die tomorrow" crowd are instilling fear and panic into people that by and large won't be killed by this thing. The vast majority of people who get this will recover just fine.

Related: Inaccurate virus models are panicking officials into ill advised lockdowns

Should people who are at risk take special precautions?  Yes.  Absolutely.  The elderly, infirm and those with chronic respiratory, autoimmune or coronary conditions...those are the people that should be quarantined and shut out from the rest of the public, because if they get the virus there's a good chance they could die.  They should be afraid of being around large groups (or people in general) and making sure they wipe down things they come into contact with.  The rest of the world shouldn't have to be shut down because Pop Pop can't stop going to the supper club to play poker on Wednesdays.

There's a lot of talk about flattening the curve, but at some point we need to flatten the unemployment curve.  Most of the people proposing a months long lockdown are not going without a paycheck right now.  At a certain point people that are not at high risk of dying from this have to be able to stop living like they're under siege.  Where's the sympathy for the millions of people that are going to be economically destroyed because of this shut down?

Full disclosure: My wife and I are following the guidelines.  We haven't been within 6 feet of someone other than each other in 8 days.  I'm doing my part and I hope others are as well.  But let's not cut off our leg because our nose itches.  This has got to end at some point.  /rant

Secondary disclosure: Doug B is awesome and has been great in this thread.  If he writes something that conflicts with what I say, you should probably listen to him.
Have you read What are the economic consequences of an influenza pandemic?

Abstract

What are the economic consequences of an influenza pandemic? And given the pandemic, what are the economic costs and benefits of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPI)? Using geographic variation in mortality during the 1918 Flu Pandemic in the U.S., we find that more exposed areas experience a sharp and persistent decline in economic activity. The estimates imply that the pandemic reduced manufacturing output by 18%. The downturn is driven by both supply and demand-side channels. Further, building on findings from the epidemiology literature establishing that NPIs decrease influenza mortality, we use variation in the timing and intensity of NPIs across U.S. cities to study their economic effects. We find that cities that intervened earlier and more aggressively do not perform worse and, if anything, grow faster after the pandemic is over. Our findings thus indicate that NPIs not only lower mortality; they also mitigate the adverse economic consequences of a pandemic.

 
Wow. Seems to be a real rosy analysis going on. Not sure to be hopeful or even more worried.
Step 1: rosy analysis from non-experts

Step 2: stock market goes up

Step 3: analysis is wrong, stock market goes down

Step 4: repeat Step 1

Just keep recycling the same playbook until the analysis stops being wrong, then declare victory and say you knew it all along.

 
Just prior to Alabama announcing schools shut out down, we got an email that my daughters school had a middle school teacher test positive.  Last day was monday march 16.  No symptoms, but started "shortly after". Took test monday march 23.  Positive result came back today.

The email is very general..."came in contact with many students", "felt Ill shortly after monday", etc.  No name obviously.  

I coach the JV and Varsity boys soccer teams (not a teacher though) and there are 13 middle schoolers on the team.  I'm not sure how high risk we are at them moment.  We have been good, distancing, hand washing, etc. No symptoms.  Gotta say my level of worry has increased a little.

 
I’m not betting on a death rate man.  Geez, I’m outta here for awhile.
:lmao:  - thanks for ... again ... reminding everyone you dont understand projections.  A projection is a defacto bet with a confidence interval.
I don't have a dog in this hunt overall, but I'd presume he is not betting because betting on this is incredibly distasteful.  C'mon, GBJAA.
I'm of course being facetious, but it was for a point.  Projections are just that ... speculations.  Just like the stock market, just like sporting events, prop bets, etc.  I understand that people dont like to speculate about death, it is rather morbid.  However, if someone comes in with a speculation based on logic and reason, then someone else comes in and says its impossible ... the quickest way to dispel that impossibility is with some skin in the game, i.e. money.

BTW - the stock market is de facto betting on human life.  Not to be political, but political decisions are being made based on mortality rates.  The US military makes risk of death decisions all the time.

Regardless, i'm happy to drop it.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top