Question...why didn't the Iggles just keep Stallworth when they had him?
Follow up question...Do you guys think he's better than anything you have now?
They did make him an offer, he took a better one from New England. Stallworth was given a contract proposal, his agent said they could get more and the Eagles told him to feel free and take a look at the open market; and the deal would be waiting for him if they didn't see anything better. Stallworth wasn't then, nor is he now the kind of player you break out of your valuation model to retain.
Considering the contract he signed in NE, they should have kept him. Stallworth and Brown on the outside with Curtis in the slot would have been a dynamic group. Stallworth had great chemistry with McNabb (not as great with noodle armed Garcia). Stallworth had a hamstring issue for 4 games early in the season but played from Week 7 on including 2 playoff games and played well catching a TD in each of the playoff games.
Stallworth is over-rated. I'm an Eagles homer and was glad to see him go.
He's talented but always hurt. Sprinkle in off-field issues and he's just not worth the big contract. Think about this... Brady threw 50 TDs and he only caught three! Journeyman Jabar Gaffney outplayed him down the stretch.
You Eagles fans are unbelievable. He played one year in Philly. He missed 4 games early in the season and then played from game 7 on and was your best receiver in the playoffs. What off field issues has Stallworth had? He doesnt cost a lot and he's better than any other WR currently on your roster.
Eagles fans are different from Pats fans in many ways.He played one year in Philly, but
the fact that he has a perrenial hamstring injury remains.
He doesn't have offfield issues? I'll buy that. He's getting paid from good franchises so I can see that might be bad information.
He doesn't cost a lot? I wonder where he ranks in overall WR salaries...
It is very debatable as to how much better he is than Brown and Curtis. I think they are close and many experts would have different opinions.