What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

***OFFICIAL*** FFA MLB Draft (1 Viewer)

MLB PLAYER DRAFTUpdated picksROUND ONE1.1 pumpnick -- SP Walter Johnson1.2 Spock -- SP Sandy Koufax1.3 lastresort -- OF Babe Ruth1.4 Capella -- OF Willie Mays1.5 Nipsey -- P CY Young1.6 Sammy3469 --OF Ted Williams1.7 Pickles -- 1B Lou Gehrig1.8 Harrier -- OF Barry Bonds1.9 Doug B -- OF Stan Musial1.10 bogart -- 2B Rogers Hornsby1.11 Koya -- P Lefty Grove1.12 funkley -- OF Ty Cobb1.13 Kraft -- OF Hank Aaron1.14 UCONN -- OF Mickey Mantle1.15 Spartans -- SS Honus Wagner1.16 LarryBoy -- SP Christy Mathewson2.1 Larryboy -- SP Roger Clemens2.2 Spartans -- SP Pedro Martinez2.3 UCONN -- OF Tris Speaker2.4 Kraft -- OF Joltin' Joe DiMaggio2.5 funkley -- 1B Jimmy Foxx2.6 koya -- 3B Mike Schmidt2.7 Bogart -- OF Rickey Henderson2.8 Doug B -- SP Warren Spahn2.9 Harrier -- SP Grover Cleveland Alexander2.10 Pickles -- OF Frank Robinson2.11 Sammy -- ON THE CLOCK2.12 Nipsey2.13 Capella2.14 Last Resort2.15 Spock2.16 Pumpnick
 
Last edited by a moderator:
People w/ Disease draft:1. Gehrig (Gehrig)2. Bonds (for "future" unnamed disease)3. Dravecky (arm cancer)4. Kruk (testicular cancer)5. Magic (HIV/homosexuality)6. Ali (Parkinsons)7. Chamberlain (STD's)8. '99 Cowboys (Drugs)9. Harry Caray (Not sure)10. Lance Armstrong (Testicular cancer/drugs)11. Arthur Ashe (HIV)12. Lindsay Lohan (Crack/whore)13.14.15.16.
pickles is up
 
People w/ Disease draft:1. Gehrig (Gehrig)2. Bonds (for "future" unnamed disease)3. Dravecky (arm cancer)4. Kruk (testicular cancer)5. Magic (HIV/homosexuality)6. Ali (Parkinsons)7. Chamberlain (STD's)8. '99 Cowboys (Drugs)9. Harry Caray (Not sure)10. Lance Armstrong (Testicular cancer/drugs)11. Arthur Ashe (HIV)12. Lindsay Lohan (Crack/whore)13.14.15.16.
pickles is up
I'd like Stephen Hawking, please.
 
People w/ Disease draft:1. Gehrig (Gehrig)2. Bonds (for "future" unnamed disease)3. Dravecky (arm cancer)4. Kruk (testicular cancer)5. Magic (HIV/homosexuality)6. Ali (Parkinsons)7. Chamberlain (STD's)8. '99 Cowboys (Drugs)9. Harry Caray (Not sure)10. Lance Armstrong (Testicular cancer/drugs)11. Arthur Ashe (HIV)12. Lindsay Lohan (Crack/whore)13. Stephen Hawking (Gehrig)14.15.16.
Who took Dravecky?
 
People w/ Disease draft:1. Gehrig (Gehrig)2. Bonds (for "future" unnamed disease)3. Dravecky (arm cancer)4. Kruk (testicular cancer)5. Magic (HIV/homosexuality)6. Ali (Parkinsons)7. Chamberlain (STD's)8. '99 Cowboys (Drugs)9. Harry Caray (Not sure)10. Lance Armstrong (Testicular cancer/drugs)11. Arthur Ashe (HIV)12. Lindsay Lohan (Crack/whore)13. Stephen Hawking (Gehrig)14.15.16.
Who took Dravecky?
I did......i'll go with Mike Piazza (homosexuality)
 
People w/ Disease draft:1. Gehrig (Gehrig)2. Bonds (for "future" unnamed disease)3. Dravecky (arm cancer)4. Kruk (testicular cancer)5. Magic (HIV/homosexuality)6. Ali (Parkinsons)7. Chamberlain (STD's)8. '99 Cowboys (Drugs)9. Harry Caray (Not sure)10. Lance Armstrong (Testicular cancer/drugs)11. Arthur Ashe (HIV)12. Lindsay Lohan (Crack/whore)13. Stephen Hawking (Gehrig)14. Mike Piazza (homosexuality)15.16.
Who took Bonds?
 
People w/ Disease draft:1. Gehrig (Gehrig)2. Bonds (for "future" unnamed disease)3. Dravecky (arm cancer)4. Kruk (testicular cancer)5. Magic (HIV/homosexuality)6. Ali (Parkinsons)7. Chamberlain (STD's)8. '99 Cowboys (Drugs)9. Harry Caray (Not sure)10. Lance Armstrong (Testicular cancer/drugs)11. Arthur Ashe (HIV)12. Lindsay Lohan (Crack/whore)13. Stephen Hawking (Gehrig)14. Mike Piazza (homosexuality)15.16.
Who took Bonds?
Capella
 
And I'll finish the draft by taking:

STEPHEN CHRISTMAS

Stephen Christmas (1947-1993) was a 5 year old boy when he became the first patient described to have Christmas disease (or Haemophilia B) in 1952 by a group of British doctors.

[edit]

Biography

Steven was born to a British family in Canada, and was investigated for his severe bleeding disorder in Oxford, where it was discovered that he was not deficient in Factor VIII, which is normally decreased in classic haemophilia, but a different protein, which received the name Christmas factor in his honour (and later Factor IX).

Stephen was dependant on blood and plasma transfusions, and was infected with HIV in the period during which blood was not routinely screened for this virus. He campaigned for transfusion safety ever since getting infected, but developed AIDS, of which he died in 1993.

 
People w/ Disease draft:1. Gehrig (Gehrig)2. Bonds (for "future" unnamed disease)3. Dravecky (arm cancer)4. Kruk (testicular cancer)5. Magic (HIV/homosexuality)6. Ali (Parkinsons)7. Chamberlain (STD's)8. '99 Cowboys (Drugs)9. Harry Caray (Not sure)10. Lance Armstrong (Testicular cancer/drugs)11. Arthur Ashe (HIV)12. Lindsay Lohan (Crack/whore)13. Stephen Hawking (Gehrig)14.  Mike Piazza (homosexuality)15.  Karl Mecklenberg (unknown)16.  Stephen Christmas (Christmas/Aids)
Let the debate begin!!!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
People w/ Disease draft:1. Gehrig (Gehrig)2. Bonds (for "future" unnamed disease)3. Dravecky (arm cancer)4. Kruk (testicular cancer)5. Magic (HIV/homosexuality)6. Ali (Parkinsons)7. Chamberlain (STD's)8. '99 Cowboys (Drugs)9. Harry Caray (Not sure)10. Lance Armstrong (Testicular cancer/drugs)11. Arthur Ashe (HIV)12. Lindsay Lohan (Crack/whore)13. Stephen Hawking (Gehrig)14. Mike Piazza (homosexuality)15. Karl Mecklenberg (unknown)16. Stephen Christmas (Christmas/Aids)
Let the debate begin!!!
Well you guys ruined it by going non-sports in the 2nd round
 
Last edited by a moderator:
John "Uniball" Kruk still available?
WHY ARE YOU PEOPLE ONLY TAKING BALL PLAYERS? YOU CAN TAKE ANYBODY.
Nothing was ruined. This was laid out up front. Nobody said regular people couldn't be drafted.Let the debate begin!!!
You said non-ballplayers... so I figured Ali was eligble. Not Stephen Hawking.
Stephen Hawking played ball??
Yeah, he can still ball. Hell, he divorced his wife and married his assistant. Dude's got game.
 
If anyone wants to say how they can even come close to beating my two guys, would love to hear it....Stephen Christmas should have gone #2 overall, right behind the Iron Horse....

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pickles just PM'd me his pick...he selects:

RON KARKOVICE

June 7, 1982: Drafted by the Chicago White Sox in the 1st round (14th pick) of the 1982 amateur draft.

October 31, 1997: Granted Free Agency.

January 13, 1998: Signed as a Free Agent with the Cleveland Indians

Who's up?
:rant: I wanted Dave Kingman..
Kingman is definately a candidate for a last round pick though. Just to have him on your team.
 
I have Bonds, Magic and Lohan'Roids/AIDS/Homsexuality/Slut and a jungle gym of other STDs from Magic and Lindsey.CANNOT BE BEAT

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have Bonds, Magic and Lohan

'Roids/AIDS/Homsexuality/Slut and a jungle gym of other STDs from Magic and Lindsey.

CANNOT BE BEAT
"Hey Capella. Good luck in the people w/diseases draft.""Thanks."

"Who did you draft?

"Magic, Bonds and Lohan."

"Nice picks. 'Roids, HIV, sluttiness....really nice. Who are you playing?"

"Nipsey. He has Gehrig and Christmas."

"Wow. Who are the people he drafted?"

"Those are the people."

"Ouch."

:own3d:

 
I had pm Capella my pick, but I think I'm going to change what I'd told him. I need power and I'm going to take a guy at one of the weakest position. So I'll take Eddie Mathews 3BStats and the like forthcoming

 
I had pm Capella my pick, but I think I'm going to change what I'd told him. I need power and I'm going to take a guy at one of the weakest position. So I'll take Eddie Mathews 3BStats and the like forthcoming
sorry, was gone right before pickles' selection..
 
Nice pick on Matthews. Probably the only guy that can contend for top ever at 3B. I did not know how far he would drop, but you are correct... the talent at 3B is pretty thin.

 
Honestly, I'm having trouble with this pick. Are we drafting guys to win a vote? Or to win the sim? I guarantee who ever wins the vote WILL NOT win the sim. Are guys drafting to win the sim or the vote? And the "third best season" thing is a HUGE factor in terms of the sim. Some guys had one or two monster years followed by 10 decent ones. I'm torn.Pick upcoming....

 
I'll start with a Ty Cobb quote:

"I've only known three or four perfect swings in my time. This lad has one of them."
So now I've got two of the sweetest swings ever. To start, during his career he played in arguably the 2nd best pitchers park in his era. (There were 73 home runs hit there in 1958 and 173 in Braves road games), putting up some increadible top line numbers for any era or season. In 1959 he hit 46 HR, batted .306, SLG .593, and had 119 RBI (see stats). He finished in the top 5 in the league in HRs for 9 straight years while drawing an amazing number of walks for the era. Again playing in a pitchers park. More importantly for this team, he was a fly ball hitter. He'll be playing half his games in Tiger stadium, a notorious fly-ball hitters park. I'm just drooling over the numbers he'll put up in the sim.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Honestly, I'm having trouble with this pick. Are we drafting guys to win a vote? Or to win the sim? I guarantee who ever wins the vote WILL NOT win the sim. Are guys drafting to win the sim or the vote? And the "third best season" thing is a HUGE factor in terms of the sim. Some guys had one or two monster years followed by 10 decent ones. I'm torn.Pick upcoming....
1 or 2 doesn't equal 3...not many guys have 3 all-time great seasons and not a great career....trust me, I ran the numbers.edited to add plenty have one, a few have 2...if you had 3 that make you draftable in this you had a great career in every case I looked at.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Honestly, I'm having trouble with this pick.  Are we drafting guys to win a vote?  Or to win the sim?  I guarantee who ever wins the vote WILL NOT win the sim.  Are guys drafting to win the sim or the vote?  And the "third best season" thing is a HUGE factor in terms of the sim.  Some guys had one or two monster years followed by 10 decent ones.  I'm torn.Pick upcoming....
1 or 2 doesn't equal 3...not many guys have 3 all-time great seasons and not a great career....trust me, I ran the numbers.edited to add plenty have one, a few have 2...if you had 3 that make you draftable in this you had a great career in every case I looked at.
Is the sim actually going to happen? If it is, I have a guy, if it's not, I'm taking someone else. Is the sim optional?
 
Honestly, I'm having trouble with this pick.  Are we drafting guys to win a vote?  Or to win the sim?  I guarantee who ever wins the vote WILL NOT win the sim.  Are guys drafting to win the sim or the vote?  And the "third best season" thing is a HUGE factor in terms of the sim.  Some guys had one or two monster years followed by 10 decent ones.  I'm torn.Pick upcoming....
1 or 2 doesn't equal 3...not many guys have 3 all-time great seasons and not a great career....trust me, I ran the numbers.edited to add plenty have one, a few have 2...if you had 3 that make you draftable in this you had a great career in every case I looked at.
Is the sim actually going to happen? If it is, I have a guy, if it's not, I'm taking someone else. Is the sim optional?
First post. I assume all the rules will be followed. Sim is in the rules. If you honestly found a guy whose third best season jumps him up dramatically in value I'll be flat out shocked...edited to add if you use just the BEST season yes....some guys have a 3rd season that might jump them up a little higher than their career....nothing drastic I could find though...definately not enough to change where I'd draft anybody.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Honestly, I'm having trouble with this pick.  Are we drafting guys to win a vote?  Or to win the sim?  I guarantee who ever wins the vote WILL NOT win the sim. 

Are guys drafting to win the sim or the vote?  And the "third best season" thing is a HUGE factor in terms of the sim.  Some guys had one or two monster years followed by 10 decent ones. 

I'm torn.

Pick upcoming....
1 or 2 doesn't equal 3...not many guys have 3 all-time great seasons and not a great career....trust me, I ran the numbers.edited to add plenty have one, a few have 2...if you had 3 that make you draftable in this you had a great career in every case I looked at.
Is the sim actually going to happen? If it is, I have a guy, if it's not, I'm taking someone else. Is the sim optional?
First post. I assume all the rules will be followed. Sim is in the rules. If you honestly found a guy whose third best season jumps him up dramatically in value I'll be flat out shocked...
I'm not saying I did, but there are "name" players that have very low 3rd year salaries and not so sexy players that have very high third year salaries. All I'm saying is, do we have to do the vote? Can't we just do the sim? That would help....
 
BTW: I win the "disease draft". Ali / Ashe and a few other also-rans did well. But, for pure entertainment value, you will not beat the '99 Cowboys with Caray play-by-playing the shenanigans....."Muhycel Irvin dropped duh bonggg!! Muhycel Irvin dropped duh bonggg!!"....

 
I feel sorry for Sammy....the people around him always come in and then don't pick....
:confused: I've been waiting all day. What are you saying? It's not like we're going to make more than 3 or four picks the rest of the night...do the salaries = results? I don't know how that site works. And relax.
 
Honestly, I'm having trouble with this pick.  Are we drafting guys to win a vote?  Or to win the sim?  I guarantee who ever wins the vote WILL NOT win the sim. 

Are guys drafting to win the sim or the vote?  And the "third best season" thing is a HUGE factor in terms of the sim.  Some guys had one or two monster years followed by 10 decent ones. 

I'm torn.

Pick upcoming....
1 or 2 doesn't equal 3...not many guys have 3 all-time great seasons and not a great career....trust me, I ran the numbers.edited to add plenty have one, a few have 2...if you had 3 that make you draftable in this you had a great career in every case I looked at.
Is the sim actually going to happen? If it is, I have a guy, if it's not, I'm taking someone else. Is the sim optional?
First post. I assume all the rules will be followed. Sim is in the rules. If you honestly found a guy whose third best season jumps him up dramatically in value I'll be flat out shocked...
I'm not saying I did, but there are "name" players that have very low 3rd year salaries and not so sexy players that have very high third year salaries. All I'm saying is, do we have to do the vote? Can't we just do the sim? That would help....
Don't know what to tell you....maybe the "sexy" pick aint the best pick then...I dunno. I think everybody is drafting guys they like and feel are deserving. I'd be very against changing any of the rules (sim or tourney). It don't seem that hard.
 
It don't seem that hard.
I'm not saying it's harfd, just saying the vote and the sim are two completely different things. Kind of need to pick which one you want to go for....
 
I feel sorry for Sammy....the people around him always come in and then don't pick....
:confused: I've been waiting all day. What are you saying? It's not like we're going to make more than 3 or four picks the rest of the night...do the salaries = results? I don't know how that site works. And relax.
I don't know either. I've looked at the salaries myself. Most the "good" players seemed to have pretty high ones and the "not so good" players had lower ones. I've never played the sim.
 
It don't seem that hard.
I'm not saying it's harfd, just saying the vote and the sim are two completely different things. Kind of need to pick which one you want to go for....
I'm trying to get the best players based on my opinions...hopefully the vote and/or sim recognize that...if they don't, I dunno. I still like my basketball team. Would rather draft the team that I think would be best than to try to tailor it to something....if you need better answers I'd pm Cappy. I'm pretty sure he has experience w/ the sim if it's that important to you. Maybe he could give you more detail.
 
I see several factors at play here. Players could be extraordinarily consistent, but not overly flashy (Hank Aaron, Frank Robinson, etc.). Then you have the guys who put up mad numbers, but for limited stretches (Koufax). Then you've got the guys that were extraordinary for their era/position (Wagner). It's all pretty impossible to weight these all properly.I guess I'm going for something of a balance here. I want to pick guys that had a long stretch of productivity (which I think should be rewarded), but the sim sort of doesn't really take that into account. I'm thinking modern era guys like Joey Belle (that's just for you larry) would do exceptionally well in a sim, but probably don't have HOF numbers. It's a tough call.

 
Nice pick Nipsey. Morgan was another guy I considered. I'd have considered trading up w/ my third round pick to get him to tell the truth if this was a draft w/ trades.

 
I tend to agree with Pickles. I have a feeling the FFA voting will favor longer career guys while the sim will reward the shorter career guys more, but what so I know. At this stage I think is kind of moot since the best guys are worth the most in the sim.

 
Nice pick Nipsey. Morgan was another guy I considered. I'd have considered trading up w/ my third round pick to get him to tell the truth if this was a draft w/ trades.
Guys a great player and will be great for the sim...but I think taking him so high will be a liabilty in the voting. i don't know. This draft is tough. I narrowed it down to 14 guys and could have made a case for any one of them.
 
Honestly, I'm having trouble with this pick. Are we drafting guys to win a vote? Or to win the sim? I guarantee who ever wins the vote WILL NOT win the sim. Are guys drafting to win the sim or the vote? And the "third best season" thing is a HUGE factor in terms of the sim. Some guys had one or two monster years followed by 10 decent ones. I'm torn.Pick upcoming....
Im sorta picking for both. And neither. Just picking for the "best team" and let the voting and sim chips fall where they may. Just no snippets, please. :P
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top