***OFFICIAL*** FFA MLB Draft (3 Viewers)

[Nipsey]

solid pick, not most dominant closer in history. 

You could make an argument for only two other guys and Eckersley in his prime was better than both.

maybe over a 3-year period..but there are two other guys I think were better, for longer.btw, picks updated on page 1

Guy pitched for 24 years! Won a Cy Young ( ) and an MVP as a closer! Was virtually unhittable during 5 year span in the late 80's/early nineties. Hall of famer.I think he's one of those rare players who was available who will actually help me in the vote AND the sim. In his prime, IMO the best closer of all-time. I mean Craig ####### Biggio gets taken, and Dennis Eckersley get's flamed?

 

[Mr. Pickles]

I mean Craig ####### Biggio gets taken, and Dennis Eckersley get's flamed?

Burns you up, doesn't it.

 

[Nipsey]

Not to name names but is one of those two guys ... Bob Stanley?

Al Nipper was the other...

 

[Koya]

Well I was going to take him, then I wasn't, then I was.

Then I did a write up for another guy, then I changed my mind again.

I came down to who I thought would be the most fun guy to have, be fun to see how he sims out.

DENNIS ECKERSLEY

Flame away!

WTF?

Really? Most dominant closer in history not a massive weapon in a 7 game series?

I think it was a good pick.

 

[Nipsey]

I mean Craig ####### Biggio gets taken, and Dennis Eckersley get's flamed?

Burns you up, doesn't it.

Shawn Marion quality....

 

[Koya]

Spock. With all due respect, #### you, and #### you picking Waner. My only consolation is that there are some players out there that provide a lot of what he does... but I am not sure there is anyone that would do it as well, at least not from the '30's on. Thought I might sneak him in as a #2 hitter. Even if he and Mize are lefties. (Waner is left handed, yes? )

 

[Mr. Pickles]

I mean Craig ####### Biggio gets taken, and Dennis Eckersley get's flamed?

Burns you up, doesn't it.

Shawn Marion quality....

Let's not get carried away here.

 

[Koya]

I mean Craig ####### Biggio gets taken, and Dennis Eckersley get's flamed? 

Burns you up, doesn't it.

Shawn Marion quality....

Let's not get carried away here.

Biggio has a very good chance to make the hall. S. Marion, doesnt.

 

[Capella]

solid pick, not most dominant closer in history. 

You could make an argument for only two other guys and Eckersley in his prime was better than both.

maybe over a 3-year period..but there are two other guys I think were better, for longer.btw, picks updated on page 1

Guy pitched for 24 years! Won a Cy Young ( ) and an MVP as a closer! Was virtually unhittable during 5 year span in the late 80's/early nineties. Hall of famer.I think he's one of those rare players who was available who will actually help me in the vote AND the sim. In his prime, IMO the best closer of all-time. I mean Craig ####### Biggio gets taken, and Dennis Eckersley get's flamed?

I don't think it was necessarily a bad pick (at all really)..I'm just saying I don't think he was the most dominant closer in history. I'd like to get into it more, but players are still out there. btw, Biggio was a solid pick there.

 

[Nipsey]

I mean Craig ####### Biggio gets taken, and Dennis Eckersley get's flamed?  

Burns you up, doesn't it.

Shawn Marion quality....

Let's not get carried away here.

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio? How can you do that?Wanna start a poll? Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose. Biggio get's one vote.

 

[Capella]

I liked the section from James' on Biggio (fan of his stuff or not, I thought this was telling)..in 1997 Biggio was hit by 34 pitches and grounded into ZERO double plays..only the 5th player in history to play a full season without grounding into a double play.

the HBP were the second-highest of the 20th century.

as James goes into, those are "little stats", such as sac hits, flies, and intentional walks that don't get any publicity since they don't go into the box scores.

Biggio, according to James, has the best "little stats" of any player in baseball history, which is why he says Biggio is so underrated.

I liked the pick, would've considered him myself.

 

[Mr. Pickles]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio? How can you do that?Wanna start a poll? Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose. Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

 

[Nipsey]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio? How can you do that?Wanna start a poll? Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose. Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

 

[bentley]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio? How can you do that?Wanna start a poll? Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose. Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Thanks for bringing your juggy avatar back. And I don't think that Eck is that bad of a pick, especially considering the season that Nipsey gets to use.

 

[Mr. Pickles]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio? How can you do that?Wanna start a poll? Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose. Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

I don't expect a vote in the FFA will prove much of anything.Are we drafting for public perception?

 

[Capella]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

good point..we've already shown how stupid the FFA is with the basketball draft.

 

[Nipsey]

I liked the section from James' on Biggio (fan of his stuff or not, I thought this was telling)..in 1997 Biggio was hit by 34 pitches and grounded into ZERO double plays..only the 5th player in history to play a full season without grounding into a double play.

Eck gets knocked because of his longevity, then in defending Biggio, you cite this obscure single season statistic?

 

[Koya]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

Ok, I will settle the debate once and forall.FFA, who is better, ARod or Arky Vaughn. Cause SURELY the FFA will take both into proper consideration. Many experts say Arky had the career Arod is "in the middle of" - but has not yet finished. Experts might be 60/40 in favor of either Arky or Arod (im just guessing but thats a fair range). Id put money it is at least 4:1 ration against Arky in the FFA.

 

[Mr. Pickles]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio? How can you do that?Wanna start a poll? Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose. Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Thanks for bringing your juggy avatar back. And I don't think that Eck is that bad of a pick, especially considering the season that Nipsey gets to use.

I was just giving him hell because he was expecting it. Eck isn't a bad pick. But I'm not the one riding him.. he seems to think Biggio is a joke.

 

[bentley]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio? How can you do that?Wanna start a poll? Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose. Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

good point..we already showed how stupid the FFA is with the basketball draft.

I haven't read much of this, but seriously, why not just sim? You'd definitely get more accurate results.

 

[Nipsey]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

I don't expect a vote in the FFA will prove much of anything.Are we drafting for public perception?

Apparently some people are, aren't they? (Pete Rose?)

 

[Koya]

I liked the section from James' on Biggio (fan of his stuff or not, I thought this was telling)..in 1997 Biggio was hit by 34 pitches and grounded into ZERO double plays..only the 5th player in history to play a full season without grounding into a double play.

Eck get knocked because of his longevity, then in defending Biggio, you cite this obscure single season statistic?

Nips, it is a pretty telling stat. It means Big has some wheels, and at least decent bat control.Or never got to the plate with a man on first.

 

[Capella]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

good point..we already showed how stupid the FFA is with the basketball draft.

I haven't read much of this, but seriously, why not just sim? You'd definitely get more accurate results.

we are simming..figured the FFA vote was just a formality.

 

[Mr. Pickles]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio? How can you do that?Wanna start a poll? Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose. Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

I don't expect a vote in the FFA will prove much of anything.Are we drafting for public perception?

Apparently some people are, aren't they? (Pete Rose?)

I think Cappy is definitely going for public sentiment so far.The sim is more interesting to me, frankly.

 

[bentley]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio? How can you do that?Wanna start a poll? Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose. Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Thanks for bringing your juggy avatar back. And I don't think that Eck is that bad of a pick, especially considering the season that Nipsey gets to use.

I was just giving him hell because he was expecting it. Eck isn't a bad pick. But I'm not the one riding him.. he seems to think Biggio is a joke.

Oh. Well in that case, he's a ####### idiot. Carry on.

 

[Koya]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

good point..we already showed how stupid the FFA is with the basketball draft.

I haven't read much of this, but seriously, why not just sim? You'd definitely get more accurate results.

Because we dont want this to become a for sim only, look at the third year stats and "that" will judge on its own who has the be st team.Having both a vote and public forum, PLUS a sim, gives everyone something to shoot for, regardless whether you go obscure older players, or known quantities, or even modern plays that just make our cutoff with 11 years experience.

 

[Capella]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

I don't expect a vote in the FFA will prove much of anything.Are we drafting for public perception?

Apparently some people are, aren't they? (Pete Rose?)

coming from the guy who went 7 pages on how people will look at his cy young pick :rotflmao:

 

[Mr. Pickles]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio? How can you do that?Wanna start a poll? Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose. Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

I don't expect a vote in the FFA will prove much of anything.Are we drafting for public perception?

Apparently some people are, aren't they? (Pete Rose?)

coming from the guy who went 7 pages on how people will look at his cy young pick :rotflmao:

"Ouch."

 

[Nipsey]

I liked the section from James' on Biggio (fan of his stuff or not, I thought this was telling)..in 1997 Biggio was hit by 34 pitches and grounded into ZERO double plays..only the 5th player in history to play a full season without grounding into a double play.

Eck get knocked because of his longevity, then in defending Biggio, you cite this obscure single season statistic?

Nips, it is a pretty telling stat. It means Big has some wheels, and at least decent bat control.Or never got to the plate with a man on first.

Biggio's a great player, don't get me wrong. But he belongs in an all-time MLB draft like Chad Lewis belongs in an all-time NFL draft... :gang:

 

[Nipsey]

I was just giving him hell because he was expecting it. Eck isn't a bad pick. But I'm not the one riding him.. he seems to think Biggio is a joke.

I can tell from your inflection that you're not kidding.

 

[Koya]

I liked the section from James' on Biggio (fan of his stuff or not, I thought this was telling)..in 1997 Biggio was hit by 34 pitches and grounded into ZERO double plays..only the 5th player in history to play a full season without grounding into a double play.

Eck get knocked because of his longevity, then in defending Biggio, you cite this obscure single season statistic?

Nips, it is a pretty telling stat. It means Big has some wheels, and at least decent bat control.Or never got to the plate with a man on first.

Biggio's a great player, don't get me wrong. But he belongs in an all-time MLB draft like Chad Lewis belongs in an all-time NFL draft... :gang:

Nips, go check out his stats. For a catcher, and then a top defensive 2nd baseman, he is very very good. Prototypical #2 hitter and a gold glove.

 

[Kraft...]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

good point..we've already shown how stupid the FFA is with the basketball draft.

 

[Capella]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

I don't expect a vote in the FFA will prove much of anything.Are we drafting for public perception?

Apparently some people are, aren't they? (Pete Rose?)

I think Cappy is definitely going for public sentiment so far.The sim is more interesting to me, frankly.

just haven't got a chance to take any older players yet..few I wanted got selected, and a few others weren't good value where I was picking (or there were players I wanted more).check the NBA draft..Bill Sharman, Bob Cousy, Paul Arizin, George Mikan were all on my team..I had more 'older' players than anybody in that league.

 

[Spartans Rule]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

good point..we already showed how stupid the FFA is with the basketball draft.

I haven't read much of this, but seriously, why not just sim? You'd definitely get more accurate results.

After playing around with the sim, I'm not too sure about that.To me, this isn't about winning, either the vote or the sim. It's just about picking the guys you think were the best in baseball history, then arguing about it.

 

[Capella]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

good point..we've already shown how stupid the FFA is with the basketball draft.

"ouch"

 

[bentley]

So, can I ask a baseball question here? Why in the hell does Peter Gammons call the '86 Mets a "Cinderella story" in the ESPN baseball commercial? They won 90 in '84, and 98 in '85 before their 108 win 1986 season.

 

[Nipsey]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

I don't expect a vote in the FFA will prove much of anything.Are we drafting for public perception?

Apparently some people are, aren't they? (Pete Rose?)

coming from the guy who went 7 pages on how people will look at his cy young pick :rotflmao:

"Hey Capella, good luck on the FFA baseball draft vote today."Thanks.""Who do you start again?""Uhh, Rose, Mays, a couple of others.""Who you playing?""Nipsey.""Who's he got?""Cy young, Shoeless Joe, hank Greenberg, and a few others.""Who's got Eckersley?""Nipsey does.""Ouch."

 

[Capella]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

good point..we already showed how stupid the FFA is with the basketball draft.

I haven't read much of this, but seriously, why not just sim? You'd definitely get more accurate results.

After playing around with the sim, I'm not too sure about that.To me, this isn't about winning, either the vote or the sim. It's just about picking the guys you think were the best in baseball history, then arguing about it.

I think the sim is the closest we'll ever get to a decisive result.far more interesting to me as well, but it all takes a backseat to the actual draft, and debating players and their worth.

 

[Funkley]

To me, this isn't about winning, either the vote or the sim. It's just about picking the guys you think were the best in baseball history, then arguing about it.

That sounded fun until I got my ### handed to me in the NBA draft with a good team.

 

[Kraft...]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

good point..we've already shown how stupid the FFA is with the basketball draft.

"ouch"

Round 1

 

[Spartans Rule]

To me, this isn't about winning, either the vote or the sim. It's just about picking the guys you think were the best in baseball history, then arguing about it.

That sounded fun until I got my ### handed to me in the NBA draft with a good team.

I did too. But who cares? I know they were good. Just because the public hasn't heard of Bob McAdoo even though he was the best player in basketball for 3 years doesn't mean I screwed up.

 

[Nipsey]

To me, this isn't about winning, either the vote or the sim. It's just about picking the guys you think were the best in baseball history, then arguing about it.

That sounded fun until I got my ### handed to me in the NBA draft with a good team.

I did too. But who cares? I know they were good. Just because the public hasn't heard of Bob McAdoo even though he was the best player in basketball for 3 years doesn't mean I screwed up.

Craig Biggio was a better pick than Bob McAdoo.

 

[Capella]

Seriously, how can you knock the Frank Thomas pick, then take Craig Biggio?  How can you do that?Wanna start a poll?  Who's the better all-time baseball player....Frank Thomas/Craig Biggio/Dennis Eckersley....Eck beats Thomas by a nose.  Biggio get's one vote.

That because the public is stupid. What are we proving?

Then why have the silly vote in the first place? Why not just sim?

good point..we've already shown how stupid the FFA is with the basketball draft.

"ouch"

Round 1

hey..you did a good job taking nothing but modern players. pandered well to the audience..look at your opponent's team as well.kudos for that.

 

[Spartans Rule]

To me, this isn't about winning, either the vote or the sim. It's just about picking the guys you think were the best in baseball history, then arguing about it.

That sounded fun until I got my ### handed to me in the NBA draft with a good team.

I did too. But who cares? I know they were good. Just because the public hasn't heard of Bob McAdoo even though he was the best player in basketball for 3 years doesn't mean I screwed up.

Craig Biggio was a better pick than Bob McAdoo.

Bob McAdoo was a better pick than Dennis Eckersley.

 

[Nipsey]

hey..you did a good job taking nothing but modern players. pandered well to the audience..look at your opponent's team as well.kudos for that.

"Ouch."

 

[Nipsey]

To me, this isn't about winning, either the vote or the sim. It's just about picking the guys you think were the best in baseball history, then arguing about it.

That sounded fun until I got my ### handed to me in the NBA draft with a good team.

I did too. But who cares? I know they were good. Just because the public hasn't heard of Bob McAdoo even though he was the best player in basketball for 3 years doesn't mean I screwed up.

Craig Biggio was a better pick than Bob McAdoo.

Bob McAdoo was a better pick than Dennis Eckersley.

 

[Mr. Pickles]

Any picks in here, or more catfighting?

 

[Kraft...]

Eck was a solid pick but I would have thought Closers would slide a few more rounds. He would go very high in the baseball players with hot wives draft, if I remember my 1983 Red Sox year book family section correctly. I like the Biggio pick although a bit early, but only as a Catcher or 2B don't like him much as an OF with what else is out there.

 

[Mr. Pickles]

Eck was a solid pick but I would have thought Closers would slide a few more rounds. He would go very high in the baseball players with hot wives draft, if I remember my 1983 Red Sox year book family section correctly. I like the Biggio pick although a bit early, but only as a Catcher or 2B don't like him much as an OF with what else is out there.

Biggio and Alomar have identical careers. What's "early" about getting him in the 6th round?

 

[Nipsey]

Any picks in here, or more catfighting?

YOU started it.