fatguyinalittlecoat said:
Trump's quote was at a rally and wasn't really in response to anything except himself. On his own accord, he told the audience that there was "nothing they could do" if Hillary got to appoint justices. And then he suggested that maybe there was something that could be done. To me, that seems at least a step or two closer to suggesting that someone should do something.
With that said, I don't think Trump was actually trying to get someone to kill Hillary or threatening Hillary or anything. I just think he said every dumb thing that pops in his head. But instead of apologizing like Hillary, he now claims that his words meant something completely different from the way most people understood them.
I think "Well, the Second Amendment people, maybe there is" is exactly analogous to "Maybe a rope."
In both cases, Trump made a statement (Mexicans who climb the wall with a ladder will have no way to get down / When Hillary wins and starts appointing Justices there will be nothing anyone can do about it). In both cases, after making the statement, he realized that the statement may not be entirely correct because there's a loophole (Maybe a rope / Maybe take up arms). And in both cases, as soon as the loophole popped into his head, he said it out loud -- because that's how someone without an internal censor works.
But he was not advocating or hoping that people would assassinat Hillary or conduct an armed rebellion any more than he was advocating or hoping that his precious wall would be breached by the use of a rope. He was simply acknowledging the possibility out of -- well, probably a lack of impulse control, but let's be charitable and call it a desire to self-correct his own inaccurate statements for the sake of full disclosure.
He obviously should have apologized for saying something that could be misconstrued as wishing his opponent dead, same as Hillary did after her remark.
But I don't think the statement itself was at all nefarious. Accurately acknowledging that something might be possible is not at all the same as hoping that it happens -- and in that respect, I think Trump's and Hillary's gaffes were quite similar.