What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

***Official MLB 2013 Season Thread (1 Viewer)

Is Bud Selig and MLB aware of how ridiculous it is not having the two leagues uniform with the DH?? With inter-league every day now, it's pretty ####### stupid not to have the same rules for both sides. Either both DH or no DH, when will they fix this?
I honestly have no idea why this bothers people.
I honestly have no idea how someone would think it's normal. :shrug:
I don't think its normal. I just don't care. I much prefer the NL and I watch a ton more NL, but its not like watching an interleague or AL game sends me into a tizzy. Keep your grubby hands off the beauty of pitchers hitting and I'll continue to ignore your DH perversion.
LOL at the 'beauty' of pitchers hitting.
 
They should just have a hitting squad and a fielding squad, and designated runners too. That would create scoring!

Let me enjoy real 9-on-9 baseball while I still can please, thx

 
Bautista's wrist is okay.
That's great, now his ankle isn't. :angry:
Uh oh, went from probably playing Friday to missing his second straight today. And away we go.
He had a bat in hand and was ready to pinch hit, then sat down after Rasmus went deep.
Good to hear hope he's back soon. Sitting out again today though.
Bautista DHing today.

 
The record for strikeouts in a season is 1529 by the 2010 Diamondbacks. They struck out at a rate of 28% of the time. Right now the Stros are striking out at a rate of 36%. :eek: Basing off of the D'Backs at bats for the year (5473), the Astos will shatter the record and finish with 1970 K's. :lmao:
They'll just bunt the last month of the season.

 
I like the idea of pitchers hitting in theory, they're just so terrible at it, plus, I think most minor leagues now use the DH as well, so they're not going to get any better.

 
Is Bud Selig and MLB aware of how ridiculous it is not having the two leagues uniform with the DH?? With inter-league every day now, it's pretty ####### stupid not to have the same rules for both sides. Either both DH or no DH, when will they fix this?
I honestly have no idea why this bothers people.
I honestly have no idea how someone would think it's normal. :shrug:
I don't think its normal. I just don't care. I much prefer the NL and I watch a ton more NL, but its not like watching an interleague or AL game sends me into a tizzy.
Guess it doesn't matter because the N.L. teams you are competing against have the same obstacle but A.L. teams are built with a DH in mind. Seems like an unfair advantage. Your D. Ortiz vs. my guy not good enough to start. Obviously not so always so extreme but A.L. has a built in advantage.

Last time N.L. had the edge over the course of a season was 2003. 12-4, A.L. yearly advantage since 1997.
AL teams win interleague because they're more talented top to bottom, not because of the DH. In World Series games, both leagues have significant homefield advantages the effectively cancel each other out. Afterall, an NL team needing to bat a bench guy is about the same deficit as trying to make Papi play the field.
Used to be and probably will be again, but not right now. The NL is pretty loaded right now and with Yanks being down, I think the balance has shifted for the time being.

 
I like the idea of pitchers hitting in theory, they're just so terrible at it, plus, I think most minor leagues now use the DH as well, so they're not going to get any better.
It's only a matter of time until the NL switches, but I'm OK with waiting as long as possible. I guess my anti-DH OCD is stronger than my everyone-is-not-the-same OCD.

This new schedule format will probably move that along, as people on TV are already griping about it more too.

 
Bautista's wrist is okay.
That's great, now his ankle isn't. :angry:
Uh oh, went from probably playing Friday to missing his second straight today. And away we go.
He had a bat in hand and was ready to pinch hit, then sat down after Rasmus went deep.
Good to hear hope he's back soon. Sitting out again today though.
Bautista DHing today.
:hifive: Just coming in to post the update. :thumbup:

 
Is Bud Selig and MLB aware of how ridiculous it is not having the two leagues uniform with the DH?? With inter-league every day now, it's pretty ####### stupid not to have the same rules for both sides. Either both DH or no DH, when will they fix this?
I honestly have no idea why this bothers people.
I honestly have no idea how someone would think it's normal. :shrug:
I don't think its normal. I just don't care. I much prefer the NL and I watch a ton more NL, but its not like watching an interleague or AL game sends me into a tizzy.
Guess it doesn't matter because the N.L. teams you are competing against have the same obstacle but A.L. teams are built with a DH in mind. Seems like an unfair advantage. Your D. Ortiz vs. my guy not good enough to start. Obviously not so always so extreme but A.L. has a built in advantage.

Last time N.L. had the edge over the course of a season was 2003. 12-4, A.L. yearly advantage since 1997.
AL teams win interleague because they're more talented top to bottom, not because of the DH. In World Series games, both leagues have significant homefield advantages the effectively cancel each other out. Afterall, an NL team needing to bat a bench guy is about the same deficit as trying to make Papi play the field.
I bet this changes going forward with the Houston move.
Doubt it. Sure they suck this season, but that's a major market with some guys coming into the organization with pretty decent track records. While payroll doesn't entirely track winning, they are correlated and AL has more of the big spenders.
Houston will be bad for 2-3 more years. But that was just part of why I expect it to change. The AL East doesn't have several of the best teams in baseball like it did for much of the last decade. And the spending will even out too, with the Dodgers leading the way. Yeah, the AL has 7 of the top 10 spenders in terms of opening day rosters, but 11-14 are all N teams with young rosters that'll be spending a lot more in the next couple years.

 
Bo Porter pulled J.D. Martinez from the game Monday after Martinez swung at a first pitch and popped out:

“From a baseball standpoint, I made a mistake today,” Martinez said. “I had a mental error going up to the plate and was totally my fault. I understand everything that Bo did, taking me out and everything. I hold nothing against him, in that sense, because what I did was unacceptable and it was just a mental mistake that will never happen again.”

Martinez hinted that he went against the approach that was discussed at the hitter’s meeting prior to the game.“It was just something going up to the plate, our plan and everything,” he said. “I got caught in the moment and really didn’t take a step back. The game was moving quick, and I totally slipped, and I take full responsibility for it.”
I'm kind of torn on this. On the one hand, the Astros have been striking out at an alarming rate. Taking the first pitch forces their young hitters to be a little less aggressive. But the opposing team aren't idiots. It won't take too long to realize that they can get a free strike one.

It didn't help. Houston got shut out again.

 
rodg12 said:
dparker713 said:
Billy Bats said:
dparker713 said:
Is Bud Selig and MLB aware of how ridiculous it is not having the two leagues uniform with the DH?? With inter-league every day now, it's pretty ####### stupid not to have the same rules for both sides. Either both DH or no DH, when will they fix this?
I honestly have no idea why this bothers people.
I honestly have no idea how someone would think it's normal. :shrug:
I don't think its normal. I just don't care. I much prefer the NL and I watch a ton more NL, but its not like watching an interleague or AL game sends me into a tizzy. Keep your grubby hands off the beauty of pitchers hitting and I'll continue to ignore your DH perversion.
LOL at the 'beauty' of pitchers hitting.
Most exciting play of Opening Day - Kershaw's homerun off of Cain.

 
Bo Porter pulled J.D. Martinez from the game Monday after Martinez swung at a first pitch and popped out:

“From a baseball standpoint, I made a mistake today,” Martinez said. “I had a mental error going up to the plate and was totally my fault. I understand everything that Bo did, taking me out and everything. I hold nothing against him, in that sense, because what I did was unacceptable and it was just a mental mistake that will never happen again.”

Martinez hinted that he went against the approach that was discussed at the hitter’s meeting prior to the game.“It was just something going up to the plate, our plan and everything,” he said. “I got caught in the moment and really didn’t take a step back. The game was moving quick, and I totally slipped, and I take full responsibility for it.”
I'm kind of torn on this. On the one hand, the Astros have been striking out at an alarming rate. Taking the first pitch forces their young hitters to be a little less aggressive. But the opposing team aren't idiots. It won't take too long to realize that they can get a free strike one.

It didn't help. Houston got shut out again.
This is absolutely ridiculous.

I don't care if you're striking out an extreme rate - sometimes the best pitch you get is the first one. You're team is not scoring and now you're telling your CLEAN UP hitter to lose his aggression? This is not a 19-20 year old kid in his first season, Martinez will be 26 this year and this is his third season.

I'm not going to kill Porter for this, but telling your clean up pitchers to take pitches is playing not to win (something the Astros do well).

They have zero aggression, and if you're team can't hit, why take the bat out of their hands and have them fall behind in the count? It's not like Joe Saunders is a k machine out there, he's a junk throwing, 4 or 5 starter.

And speaking of lack of aggression, the Astros have zero stolen bases this year. They have zero ATTEMPTED stolen bases this year. WTF they think they are going to do, string together a bunch of hits to produce runs?

I hope the Astros have a season of epic proportions. 125 losses, 2000+k's. Poor Bo Porter, enjoy your season, and keep taking the bats out of the hands of your players :thumbup:

 
Bo Porter pulled J.D. Martinez from the game Monday after Martinez swung at a first pitch and popped out:

“From a baseball standpoint, I made a mistake today,” Martinez said. “I had a mental error going up to the plate and was totally my fault. I understand everything that Bo did, taking me out and everything. I hold nothing against him, in that sense, because what I did was unacceptable and it was just a mental mistake that will never happen again.”

Martinez hinted that he went against the approach that was discussed at the hitter’s meeting prior to the game.“It was just something going up to the plate, our plan and everything,” he said. “I got caught in the moment and really didn’t take a step back. The game was moving quick, and I totally slipped, and I take full responsibility for it.”
I'm kind of torn on this. On the one hand, the Astros have been striking out at an alarming rate. Taking the first pitch forces their young hitters to be a little less aggressive. But the opposing team aren't idiots. It won't take too long to realize that they can get a free strike one.

It didn't help. Houston got shut out again.
This is absolutely ridiculous.

I don't care if you're striking out an extreme rate - sometimes the best pitch you get is the first one. You're team is not scoring and now you're telling your CLEAN UP hitter to lose his aggression? This is not a 19-20 year old kid in his first season, Martinez will be 26 this year and this is his third season.

I'm not going to kill Porter for this, but telling your clean up pitchers to take pitches is playing not to win (something the Astros do well).

They have zero aggression, and if you're team can't hit, why take the bat out of their hands and have them fall behind in the count? It's not like Joe Saunders is a k machine out there, he's a junk throwing, 4 or 5 starter.

And speaking of lack of aggression, the Astros have zero stolen bases this year. They have zero ATTEMPTED stolen bases this year. WTF they think they are going to do, string together a bunch of hits to produce runs?

I hope the Astros have a season of epic proportions. 125 losses, 2000+k's. Poor Bo Porter, enjoy your season, and keep taking the bats out of the hands of your players :thumbup:
The team OBP is .234. You can't steal first base.

This team isn't built to steal bases either. Altuve and Maxwell are the only base stealing threats in the lineup.

 
Jered Weaver out 4 to 6 weeks with a broken left elbow.
Going to be awfully hard for the Angels to catch up with Texas/Oakland this year. Their rotation was already questionable and now they lose their ace? Looks like another third place or worse if Seattle improves.

 
Bo Porter pulled J.D. Martinez from the game Monday after Martinez swung at a first pitch and popped out:

“From a baseball standpoint, I made a mistake today,” Martinez said. “I had a mental error going up to the plate and was totally my fault. I understand everything that Bo did, taking me out and everything. I hold nothing against him, in that sense, because what I did was unacceptable and it was just a mental mistake that will never happen again.”

Martinez hinted that he went against the approach that was discussed at the hitter’s meeting prior to the game.“It was just something going up to the plate, our plan and everything,” he said. “I got caught in the moment and really didn’t take a step back. The game was moving quick, and I totally slipped, and I take full responsibility for it.”
I'm kind of torn on this. On the one hand, the Astros have been striking out at an alarming rate. Taking the first pitch forces their young hitters to be a little less aggressive. But the opposing team aren't idiots. It won't take too long to realize that they can get a free strike one.

It didn't help. Houston got shut out again.
This is absolutely ridiculous.

I don't care if you're striking out an extreme rate - sometimes the best pitch you get is the first one. You're team is not scoring and now you're telling your CLEAN UP hitter to lose his aggression? This is not a 19-20 year old kid in his first season, Martinez will be 26 this year and this is his third season.

I'm not going to kill Porter for this, but telling your clean up pitchers to take pitches is playing not to win (something the Astros do well).

They have zero aggression, and if you're team can't hit, why take the bat out of their hands and have them fall behind in the count? It's not like Joe Saunders is a k machine out there, he's a junk throwing, 4 or 5 starter.

And speaking of lack of aggression, the Astros have zero stolen bases this year. They have zero ATTEMPTED stolen bases this year. WTF they think they are going to do, string together a bunch of hits to produce runs?

I hope the Astros have a season of epic proportions. 125 losses, 2000+k's. Poor Bo Porter, enjoy your season, and keep taking the bats out of the hands of your players :thumbup:
Saunders clearly had control issues in his previous start. Plus if he doesn't have swing and miss stuff, it's less costly to put yourself behind in the count. And I'm no expert on the Seattle bullpen, but just looking at their roster it looks mediocre at best. Kinda seems like taking a few pitches would be a solid plan. :shrug:

 
Bo Porter pulled J.D. Martinez from the game Monday after Martinez swung at a first pitch and popped out:

“From a baseball standpoint, I made a mistake today,” Martinez said. “I had a mental error going up to the plate and was totally my fault. I understand everything that Bo did, taking me out and everything. I hold nothing against him, in that sense, because what I did was unacceptable and it was just a mental mistake that will never happen again.”

Martinez hinted that he went against the approach that was discussed at the hitter’s meeting prior to the game.“It was just something going up to the plate, our plan and everything,” he said. “I got caught in the moment and really didn’t take a step back. The game was moving quick, and I totally slipped, and I take full responsibility for it.”
I'm kind of torn on this. On the one hand, the Astros have been striking out at an alarming rate. Taking the first pitch forces their young hitters to be a little less aggressive. But the opposing team aren't idiots. It won't take too long to realize that they can get a free strike one.

It didn't help. Houston got shut out again.
This is absolutely ridiculous.

I don't care if you're striking out an extreme rate - sometimes the best pitch you get is the first one. You're team is not scoring and now you're telling your CLEAN UP hitter to lose his aggression? This is not a 19-20 year old kid in his first season, Martinez will be 26 this year and this is his third season.

I'm not going to kill Porter for this, but telling your clean up pitchers to take pitches is playing not to win (something the Astros do well).

They have zero aggression, and if you're team can't hit, why take the bat out of their hands and have them fall behind in the count? It's not like Joe Saunders is a k machine out there, he's a junk throwing, 4 or 5 starter.

And speaking of lack of aggression, the Astros have zero stolen bases this year. They have zero ATTEMPTED stolen bases this year. WTF they think they are going to do, string together a bunch of hits to produce runs?

I hope the Astros have a season of epic proportions. 125 losses, 2000+k's. Poor Bo Porter, enjoy your season, and keep taking the bats out of the hands of your players :thumbup:
Saunders clearly had control issues in his previous start. Plus if he doesn't have swing and miss stuff, it's less costly to put yourself behind in the count. And I'm no expert on the Seattle bullpen, but just looking at their roster it looks mediocre at best. Kinda seems like taking a few pitches would be a solid plan. :shrug:
I think it would be worse if this was the Stros logic. They aren't going anywhere this year. They are essentially an extension of their farm system. So if you are trying to teach your players patience in hitting, that might be one thing. But if you are pulling a guy b/c you are trying this hard to win a game in April when you might win 70 games this year, I think that is ridiculous. This just sounds like a new manager over managing and then doling out punishment b/c he is new.

 
Bo Porter pulled J.D. Martinez from the game Monday after Martinez swung at a first pitch and popped out:

“From a baseball standpoint, I made a mistake today,” Martinez said. “I had a mental error going up to the plate and was totally my fault. I understand everything that Bo did, taking me out and everything. I hold nothing against him, in that sense, because what I did was unacceptable and it was just a mental mistake that will never happen again.”

Martinez hinted that he went against the approach that was discussed at the hitter’s meeting prior to the game.“It was just something going up to the plate, our plan and everything,” he said. “I got caught in the moment and really didn’t take a step back. The game was moving quick, and I totally slipped, and I take full responsibility for it.”
I'm kind of torn on this. On the one hand, the Astros have been striking out at an alarming rate. Taking the first pitch forces their young hitters to be a little less aggressive. But the opposing team aren't idiots. It won't take too long to realize that they can get a free strike one.

It didn't help. Houston got shut out again.
This is absolutely ridiculous.

I don't care if you're striking out an extreme rate - sometimes the best pitch you get is the first one. You're team is not scoring and now you're telling your CLEAN UP hitter to lose his aggression? This is not a 19-20 year old kid in his first season, Martinez will be 26 this year and this is his third season.

I'm not going to kill Porter for this, but telling your clean up pitchers to take pitches is playing not to win (something the Astros do well).

They have zero aggression, and if you're team can't hit, why take the bat out of their hands and have them fall behind in the count? It's not like Joe Saunders is a k machine out there, he's a junk throwing, 4 or 5 starter.

And speaking of lack of aggression, the Astros have zero stolen bases this year. They have zero ATTEMPTED stolen bases this year. WTF they think they are going to do, string together a bunch of hits to produce runs?

I hope the Astros have a season of epic proportions. 125 losses, 2000+k's. Poor Bo Porter, enjoy your season, and keep taking the bats out of the hands of your players :thumbup:
Saunders clearly had control issues in his previous start. Plus if he doesn't have swing and miss stuff, it's less costly to put yourself behind in the count. And I'm no expert on the Seattle bullpen, but just looking at their roster it looks mediocre at best. Kinda seems like taking a few pitches would be a solid plan. :shrug:
I think it would be worse if this was the Stros logic. They aren't going anywhere this year. They are essentially an extension of their farm system. So if you are trying to teach your players patience in hitting, that might be one thing. But if you are pulling a guy b/c you are trying this hard to win a game in April when you might win 70 games this year, I think that is ridiculous. This just sounds like a new manager over managing and then doling out punishment b/c he is new.
The incident fits perfectly with what I know about him from his time in DC. To borrow from Herm Edwards, he's a "you play to win the game" type, no exceptions to the rule. He was most well known in DC for getting into it with the Cubs' entire dugout when they got uspet about someone stealing third when the Nats were up several runs. The fact that the Astros aren't going anywhere wouldn't even enter into his decision. He'd say what he's trying to "teach" them is how to win baseball games. Not that I agree, but I'm pretty sure that's his thought process.

 
Bo Porter pulled J.D. Martinez from the game Monday after Martinez swung at a first pitch and popped out:

“From a baseball standpoint, I made a mistake today,” Martinez said. “I had a mental error going up to the plate and was totally my fault. I understand everything that Bo did, taking me out and everything. I hold nothing against him, in that sense, because what I did was unacceptable and it was just a mental mistake that will never happen again.”

Martinez hinted that he went against the approach that was discussed at the hitter’s meeting prior to the game.“It was just something going up to the plate, our plan and everything,” he said. “I got caught in the moment and really didn’t take a step back. The game was moving quick, and I totally slipped, and I take full responsibility for it.”
I'm kind of torn on this. On the one hand, the Astros have been striking out at an alarming rate. Taking the first pitch forces their young hitters to be a little less aggressive. But the opposing team aren't idiots. It won't take too long to realize that they can get a free strike one.

It didn't help. Houston got shut out again.
This is absolutely ridiculous.

I don't care if you're striking out an extreme rate - sometimes the best pitch you get is the first one. You're team is not scoring and now you're telling your CLEAN UP hitter to lose his aggression? This is not a 19-20 year old kid in his first season, Martinez will be 26 this year and this is his third season.

I'm not going to kill Porter for this, but telling your clean up pitchers to take pitches is playing not to win (something the Astros do well).

They have zero aggression, and if you're team can't hit, why take the bat out of their hands and have them fall behind in the count? It's not like Joe Saunders is a k machine out there, he's a junk throwing, 4 or 5 starter.

And speaking of lack of aggression, the Astros have zero stolen bases this year. They have zero ATTEMPTED stolen bases this year. WTF they think they are going to do, string together a bunch of hits to produce runs?

I hope the Astros have a season of epic proportions. 125 losses, 2000+k's. Poor Bo Porter, enjoy your season, and keep taking the bats out of the hands of your players :thumbup:
Saunders clearly had control issues in his previous start. Plus if he doesn't have swing and miss stuff, it's less costly to put yourself behind in the count. And I'm no expert on the Seattle bullpen, but just looking at their roster it looks mediocre at best. Kinda seems like taking a few pitches would be a solid plan. :shrug:
I think it would be worse if this was the Stros logic. They aren't going anywhere this year. They are essentially an extension of their farm system. So if you are trying to teach your players patience in hitting, that might be one thing. But if you are pulling a guy b/c you are trying this hard to win a game in April when you might win 70 games this year, I think that is ridiculous. This just sounds like a new manager over managing and then doling out punishment b/c he is new.
The incident fits perfectly with what I know about him from his time in DC. To borrow from Herm Edwards, he's a "you play to win the game" type, no exceptions to the rule. He was most well known in DC for getting into it with the Cubs' entire dugout when they got uspet about someone stealing third when the Nats were up several runs. The fact that the Astros aren't going anywhere wouldn't even enter into his decision. He'd say what he's trying to "teach" them is how to win baseball games. Not that I agree, but I'm pretty sure that's his thought process.
I don't have a problem with a manager yanking a guy for disobeying an order or missing a sign. It's been happening that way for over a century. Porter is new and his team is young. If this his way to make a point that he's in charge,

The question is whether it's a good strategy to tell your team to always take the first pitch. I checked the game log. Every Astros batter up to Martinez' second AB took the first pitch except for two batters. Five took called strike 1, five took a ball. Barnes and Carter swung at the first offering in earlier ABs.

 
Premier said:
Rays game just ended with a pitch that was a foot outside and literally almost bounced. :lmao:
As soon as that happened, my first thought was "Man, I need to apologize to Cappy and Collette."

 
Last edited by a moderator:
You know what else is wrong, T.R.E.? Since they're not separate leagues anymore and are governed by one office, they should be the American and National Conferences, not Leagues, since they are all one league now. Makes having separate rules even dumber.

 
Less Billybats, more anything else.
What's your beef with me, cuz? Gonna go into overdrive now little man.
:lmao: Your interleague ranting is awful.
The T.R.E. votes for different rules in the same sport. Noted. Keep on sharing your baseball brilliance, I'm looking forward to more. :thumbup:
At least I'm succinct, motormouth McGee.
:lmao: I know, I've always had trouble putting my thoughts down to paper/keyboard. Plus I'm Italian, bad combo. ;)
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top