Fwiw, every time I watch these teams play each other, RM plays a high, attacking pressure defense- doing their best to pressure the ball before it gets into Xavi/Messi/Iniesta's feet. Seems like most teams that are "good" try to do this vs Barca... but then either run out of steam or get torn apart anyways and are forced to do something else. RM had moments of ok possession, but I've never seen a team so committed to whole-field defense as Barca- I've yet to see a team hold the ball for long against them.When I've seen Barca beaten, it's usually on quick and direct counters that find the seams between the back 3- especially when one of them has pushed up.So for me, I'd go with high pressure for the full 90 minutes and counter my ### off with numbers.
Definitely the way to beat Barca is to counter. Mourinho's twist is to counter but still play high pressure. I think, going forward, the insight is that there have to be spells where you pull back a bit and let Barca pass it around. Otherwise, you end up with what seems to happen pretty often at the end of the first half. The Madrid midfield gets fatigued. Messi senses it, comes back deep for the ball and breaks the press himself with one of those 30 yard dribbles. He's done that in at least three Classicos, usually around the 40 minute mark. If Mourinho made a mistake, for me, it's in selecting Higuain to start. I think Madrid needed Benzema's ability to hold the ball a little, and Benzema also just has nearly perfect timing on his runs, which plays havoc with Barca's high line. I think pressing with flair players, like Kaka and Callejon is a good wrinkle as well. Players who can get the ball off their feet when they win in in the Barca zone. Mou picked a good mix because it allowed him to have the luxury of not having Ozil press too much, which isn't in his nature. I think that means that Di Maria has to sit, because he also lacks the workrate and they can't afford the luxury. Another guy who gets no press, but who is essential to pulling this off is Xabi Alonso. Madrid don't have another deep lying player with his passing range, and that's essential to start those quick counters.