I don't really have the time to go point by point on this one, as I have approached this topic from 18 directions over the last few months.
But I can say that Turner has had some solid WR to work with over the years and even had a year with 3 guys topping 1,000 receiving yards. He's also coached some teams with very bad defenses. And he rarely has varied too much on his play calling up until last year.
I concur that Jordan is a far cry from Dickerson, Emmitt, Davis, Williams, LT, and a couple others I might have missed, which is why I rated Jordan at a C for ability.
Bottom line, Turner's system has been very kind to RB production over the years and not as kind to passing production. Clearly the Raiders have more talent in the passing/receiving game than the ground game and that may tip the scales more to the pass in terms of play calling. But I doubt we will see the extreme ratio we did last season.
Appreciate the response.Would you mind identifying the team of Turner's that had 3 1000 yard WRs? As far as I know, he has been Dallas OC 1991-1993, Washington HC 1994-2000, San Diego OC 2001, Miami OC 2002-2003, Oakland HC 2004-present. I know he coached the Rams' WRs before that, but to my knowledge he never had another position in which he called the offensive plays. And I'm not aware of any of those teams having 3 1000 yard WRs.
Smith excelled on those 3 Dallas teams with Irvin also dominant. But Dallas had an excellent defense and possibly had one of the best offensive lines of all time. Apples and oranges IMO.
In 1994 Ellard had a great year for Turner in Washington, but there was no particularly good RB. However, in 1999, Westbrook and Connell each had over 1100 yards, and Davis performed well, while the Washington defense was awful (29th in yards allowed). That's one good example.
In San Diego Conway had a good season while Tomlinson excelled. San Diego's defense was very good though, and Conway is obviously no Moss.
There are no other good examples in Miami or last year in Oakland.
So in 14 seasons, it appears to me that there was one occasion that comes close to the current situation. I still don't see his hype as justified, but at least that is some ammunition for the pro-Jordan folks.
Davis was RB4 that season, but that was primarily due to him scoring 17 TDs. That's probably the only way Jordan can get close to the top 10 himself... lots of TDs. Reasons why he may not get too many TDs have already been addressed.
Oh, and since Davis appears to be the best comparison I can find, note that he had 23/111/0 that season in 14 games. I'm sure everyone here will respond that Jordan is a better receiver, which is very possible... just thought it was of possible interest.