SSOG said:
MJD justified his draft position last year. His game-by-game numbers were not very consistent, but consistency is overrated, especially from the RB2 position. For my RB1, I want a guy who is going to get his points each and every week. From my RB2, I'm fine with a guy who might get me a couple of stinkers, provided he gives me enough ridiculous, nearly-impossible-to-beat games to balance them out.
I guess we all have different points of view. I can understand that when talking about a WR like Andre Johnson. When he's out, he's out. When he's in he's putting up points. MJD though "played" every game, but was just AWFUL for some of them, and cost his team wins. Sure, he singlehandedly won his team probably 3 games last season, but with what cost? I know the team that drafted MJD in one of my leagues started 0-3 with him as their #2. And I also know a few people who went WR early, and counted on MJD to be their #1, but figured they could get him on the cheap in the 2nd or 3rd round. Those teams totally stunk.There's no way he justified his draft position last year.
5,4,4,17,29,12,5,5,18,9,8,11,4,9,19
I count 10 points as the baseline requirement for my RB 2, that means in 6 games MJD was "startable." In 5 games he probably cost you a win. In the other 5, he may not have cost you a win, but he certainly didn't help you win.
MJD is a very talented RB, without a doubt. The problem is, he had only 2 games with 15+ carries, so his owner's are very dependent on him breaking some long runs for TDs for him to help them win. And while he does it at an amazing rate, he just doesn't do it with enough frequency to overcome his lack of opportunity.
I'd be happy with him as my #2 RB, not because of his production last season, but because of the omnipresent chance of a Fred Taylor injury.