DiGiorgio over Posluszny a camp ploy for Bills?
By Anthony Bialy on July 23, 2007 12:22 AM
Wait, Paul Posluszny is the starting middle linebacker for the Buffalo Bills . Um, right? Most thought that was the plan when the Bills maneuvered to pick up a player that, if not for their excruciatingly desperate need for a stud running back, they might have nabbed with their first pick at 12th overall (they managed to get Posluszny early in the second round; RB Marshawn Lynch was the team's first-rounder). The idea was that, on the draft's opening day, Buffalo needed two starters at noon and were cleverly all set before dinnertime.
But the news is that Posluszny faces competition for a starting spot in the form of . . . John DiGiorgio. His name may not be as prominent as erstwhile Bills linebackers Takeo Spikes or London Fletcher, but he's still trying to squirm his way into the starting lineup. Accounts are he played well in the post-draft, pre-camp workouts, and the second-year man, a former undrafted free agent, got most of the first-team snaps. He's also currently listed as the first-string middle linebacker on the Bills' depth chart. Could he possibly, conceivably stay there through September?
It's feasible that the smaller DiGiorgio could have more range in the middle than the player from, ahem, Linebacker U (Penn State). DiGiorgio has one asset that, next to hitting a baseball, is the hardest sporting skill to teach: speed. His ability to get in gear quickly has allowed him to obtain at least a tenuous hold on the starting MLB spot, but no matter how well he did without pads in the spring, this can't be for real.
DiGiorgio, as with Josh Stamer and Mario Haggan, seems better suited for depth. The Bills are blessed with solid linebacker reserves: They have guys who work hard, excel at special teams, and could fill in competently in a disaster situation. And keeping them in backup roles is also the logically inevitable move, especially when one watches the newest Bills linebacker compete.
All evidence about Posluszny, particularly footage of him wreaking destruction as a Nittany Lion, indicates he was placed on Earth for the purpose of corralling ball carriers. He's fast for someone as big and powerful as he is, but more importantly, he has a sense for where the play is headed and how to stop it as soon as possible. I changed my mind: Football instincts are harder to teach than batting. Forget baseball, because diagnosing, then ruining, an offense's play is a talent that one simply can't learn. Posluszny's instincts and athleticism lead one to conclude that DiGiorgio is just holding the former's place right now.
So why is the promising rookie still technically a backup? This could be a case where **** Jauron knows full well that Posluszny will be on the field for the Bills' first play of the season, against the Denver Broncos , and the coach just doesn't want to announce that he's handing the rookie a job. Maybe the staff intends for Posluszny to work his way into the lineup as a motivation tactic for the player and as a signal to the rest of the team that future stars don't get cushy treatment.
After all, Jauron had to clean up the mess that Mike Mularkey created with J.P. Losman by handing him the starting job; if Mularkey had enough sense to at least go through the motions of holding a competition before anointing Losman the starter, it could have aided both team and player. Jauron might be thinking that even the appearance of a competition with DiGiorgio playing the Kelly Holcomb role would benefit Posluszny. The coach didn't exactly turn to the news cameras and wink when he announced that there would be a quarterback competition before last season, but he could have, and the same scenario could be playing out this year at middle linebacker.
It would be a shame if Jauron wasn't simply treating Posluszny in the same manner he dealt with Losman going into the previous training camp. Not starting Posluszny would be a waste, like going to a theme park and doing nothing all day but drive those old timey cars on the rail: If you've paid the admission, ride the coasters, already. I'm positive the game will slow down for Posluszny in the midst of training camp, and he'll start from the initial game of his career. It's nothing against DiGiorgio, but Posluszny needs to be on the field.