What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

QB Baker Mayfield, TB (2 Viewers)

Fans might "disrespect" him but when the guy gets the heisman and was the number one pick, it's clear he isn't disrespected by people with power in the business.
i actually made that point earlier. 

not sure what you’re trying to say at this point?

i also agreed that things like OROY are largely irrelevant.  

maybe you just like arguing or you just don’t like Mayfield?

regardless, i look forward to what he can do with the Browns over the next several years. 

have a good night. 

 
i actually made that point earlier. 

not sure what you’re trying to say at this point?

i also agreed that things like OROY are largely irrelevant.  

maybe you just like arguing or you just don’t like Mayfield?

regardless, i look forward to what he can do with the Browns over the next several years. 

have a good night. 
I must have missed your point earlier. I'm just not seeing the disrespect here. 

FWIW, I don't particularly like Mayfield but I respect his football ability. 

 
I must have missed your point earlier. I'm just not seeing the disrespect here. 

FWIW, I don't particularly like Mayfield but I respect his football ability. 
Same here. Looks like he could be a good one. But I'm already tired of his act. Hoping he matures quickly. 

 
The guy was a punk with no $$$ , with $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ , ugh.  It's just a matter of time before the big F-up, being a mini smartass won't work in the NFL for very long.

Coach talking to some bench warming DE........sic him. We got your back.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
What "act"? He's just being real and having fun. And being good at football. Good for him. 
The cocky, grab his D, stare at coaches, put flag in opposition's symbol punk act.  Like I said, I hope he grows out of it. I'm sure some people like it.  I just personally can't stand people like that. A little too full of themselves. I will keep his age in mind before fully judging though.  

 
The guy was a punk with no $$$ , with $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ , ugh.  It's just a matter of time before the big F-up, being a mini smartass won't work in the NFL for very long.

Coach talking to some bench warming DE........sic him. We got your back.
After this post, you talking about anyone's maturity level is pretty ironic.

 
obviously biased, but imo, there is no way he wouldn't be OROY. 

it's a QB driven league. the NFL needs its next "rookie QB hero" (yes, i know mahomes and watson etc, but no longer rookies)

i'd actually be floored if it was saquon.

this kid took a winless team, could potentially bring them to a winning record this week... and a good chunk of these losses weren't even his.

 
this isnt the NHL, and this is beyond far fetched.

DId you see anyone try to knock Jalen Ramsey out cold? No?

And no one will touch Baker.
Well that simple not true.

you're probably / hopefully right that anything other than a legal sack wouldn't be coach sanctioned.

 
between the o-line dorsey will put together and baker's elusiveness, odds are 6 will be the first QB to never get touched in a 16 game season. 

 
obviously biased, but imo, there is no way he wouldn't be OROY. 

it's a QB driven league. the NFL needs its next "rookie QB hero" (yes, i know mahomes and watson etc, but no longer rookies)

i'd actually be floored if it was saquon.

this kid took a winless team, could potentially bring them to a winning record this week... and a good chunk of these losses weren't even his.
Rookie of the year? If he takes the Browns to a winning season after not even starting the first games he should be freaking MVP. No joke. 

 
Rookie of the year? If he takes the Browns to a winning season after not even starting the first games he should be freaking MVP. No joke. 
They tied the Steelers with Tyrod. Yes they're better with Baker (a lot) but they were already improving. 

 
They tied the Steelers with Tyrod. Yes they're better with Baker (a lot) but they were already improving. 
1-33-1 (4-46-1 if you go back another season) before him. 7-5 with him. If the Browns knock the Ravens out of the playoffs Baker should be in the MVP conversation. Rookie of the year should be a slam dunk. 

 
There are sound arguments for both Mayfield and Barkley as OROYs.  From an unbiased standpoint, you couldn’t fault either getting the award.  But if CLE beats BAL this week, Mayfield would have a winning record as a starter for a team that had won exactly one game over the previous 2 seasons and also had a midseason coaching change.  That kind of stuff is in-your-grill impossible to dismiss and would figure to weigh pretty strongly in his favor.

 
There are sound arguments for both Mayfield and Barkley as OROYs.  From an unbiased standpoint, you couldn’t fault either getting the award.  But if CLE beats BAL this week, Mayfield would have a winning record as a starter for a team that had won exactly one game over the previous 2 seasons and also had a midseason coaching change.  That kind of stuff is in-your-grill impossible to dismiss and would figure to weigh pretty strongly in his favor.
Only thing going in Saquan's favor is the semantics the title of the award can bring about. It's call Offensive Rookie of the Year. It's not necessarily the rookie "MVP". Offensive player of the year is generally stats driven. Offensive rookie of the year? No idea really. I tend to want to think of it more like I think of the MVP (Brees) award as opposed to offensive player of the year (Mahomes). 

 
1-33-1 (4-46-1 if you go back another season) before him. 7-5 with him. If the Browns knock the Ravens out of the playoffs Baker should be in the MVP conversation. Rookie of the year should be a slam dunk. 
Nobody is going to argue whether Baker made the team better, he clearly did. I'm just saying the 2018 browns were better even outside the QB.  

I'll absolutely give Baker credit, and if he got the OROY, that would be fine, he deserves it. So does Barkley for having what is arguably the best season ever for a rookie RB.

 
Only thing going in Saquan's favor is the semantics the title of the award can bring about. It's call Offensive Rookie of the Year. It's not necessarily the rookie "MVP". Offensive player of the year is generally stats driven. Offensive rookie of the year? No idea really. I tend to want to think of it more like I think of the MVP (Brees) award as opposed to offensive player of the year (Mahomes). 
I'll go with the award that sounds the most similar.

Although I think Mahomes has a good argument for MVP too, but that's not the point of this thread.

 
You are the one advocating intentionally trying to hurt someone. It's very child-like.
Are you working at not getting it?

I;m not talking about what I would do, ok?  If you think the guy can g around getting in the face of NFL coaches without some retaliation, you need to stay indoors.  If Mayfield starts being a legit problem, you better believe he will pay for it,  don't be naive.

Work with me here.

I couldn;t care less what the punk did, personally, ok?

 
Ghost Rider said:
I think he is, which is kinda frightening. 
I realize it's mostly just browns fans, but Mayfield mania is really out of control. They are a much-improved team around. It's not like Mayfield took over the same team that won one game last two years. He's surrounded by a ton of talent

 
Non browns fans posting in here are really under selling how bad this team was before October 29.
I'm not a Browns fan! Even worse for me! Redskins! I wish I was a Browns fan. Oh man. See that? No one had ever uttered those words until Baker Dangerously was there. 

 
Non browns fans posting in here are really under selling how bad this team was before October 29.
Young players take a while to gain confidence. Are you pretending that Mayfield is the only talent on that team?  They have been hoarding draft picks for years. And Dorsey nailed it this year.  Everyone in the world knew they were going to be much improved this year. 

 
Young players take a while to gain confidence. Are you pretending that Mayfield is the only talent on that team?  They have been hoarding draft picks for years. And Dorsey nailed it this year.  Everyone in the world knew they were going to be much improved this year. 
The team was regressing as the season went on. Getting rid of the problems was step one. But step two was not supposed to be an instantaneous one. It takes time to go from being that bad to this good. Unless you have a special character like this guy to lead. 

 
The team was regressing as the season went on. Getting rid of the problems was step one. But step two was not supposed to be an instantaneous one. It takes time to go from being that bad to this good. Unless you have a special character like this guy to lead. 
Cleveland made a great pick in taking him first overall. No one is denying that. Even the ROY talk is warranted. I'd personally have him second, but wouldn't be shocked if he won it. It was the MVP mention that was mind boggling. Kind of thought someone was joking. 

 
Lol. Are you stealing the shtick Soulfly used for Gordon? 
Oh god no. I'm just a Baker fan. Grabbed him in dynasty and just on board in general. I like the way he plays and carries himself. Reminds of Drew Brees if Drew didn't give a ####. The only thing I'm really worried about with him is The SoulCurse. 

 
Cleveland made a great pick in taking him first overall. No one is denying that. Even the ROY talk is warranted. I'd personally have him second, but wouldn't be shocked if he won it. It was the MVP mention that was mind boggling. Kind of thought someone was joking. 
It really isnt. This team won one game in two years. And I'll only give this team credit for one win before October 29 this year. Because the Jets win was all Baker. That game was over until he came in and said this one is ours. The coaching staff simply didnt have the opportunity to poison him yet. And despite all of that we are a win tomorrow away from finishing above 500.

So if you're talking most valuable player that's a pretty good case. Especially when you consider he is just a rookie. MVP is different though. Despite it translating to that. MVP goes to the best player on one of the best teams. No matter if that player actually is the most valuable, meaning leading to x wins. 

 
Cleveland made a great pick in taking him first overall. No one is denying that. Even the ROY talk is warranted. I'd personally have him second, but wouldn't be shocked if he won it. It was the MVP mention that was mind boggling. Kind of thought someone was joking. 
He has less losses than Andrew Luck and people are talking about him as a MVP candidate. 

 
It really isnt. This team won one game in two years. And I'll only give this team credit for one win before October 29 this year. Because the Jets win was all Baker. That game was over until he came in and said this one is ours. The coaching staff simply didnt have the opportunity to poison him yet. And despite all of that we are a win tomorrow away from finishing above 500.

So if you're talking most valuable player that's a pretty good case. Especially when you consider he is just a rookie. MVP is different though. Despite it translating to that. MVP goes to the best player on one of the best teams. No matter if that player actually is the most valuable, meaning leading to x wins. 
Mayfield is 18th in quarterback rating.  18th.  I know it's been a while since Cleveland was competitive, but my God. Get into the top half of quarterbacks before talking MVP. 

 
Mayfield is 18th in quarterback rating.  18th.  I know it's been a while since Cleveland was competitive, but my God. Get into the top half of quarterbacks before talking MVP. 
First of all, qb rating is not a good metric.

Check his meaningful metrics week 9 and beyond. And the only reason they aren't better is because they took the foot off the gas amidst three blowouts. 

 
First of all, qb rating is not a good metric.

Check his meaningful metrics week 9 and beyond. And the only reason they aren't better is because they took the foot off the gas amidst three blowouts. 
As a guy who is a fan of a team who was 0 for 51 in attempts to get a ring (Eagles), I truly appreciate and understand your excitement. This year's improvement is just the beginning. Anyone knowledgeable about football can see that Cleveland is going to be even better next year and has a very bright future. A 500 record is kind of like Super Bowl for a team that had one win in two years. And that's not meant as a dig. Going from hopeless to on the verge of playoff caliber is awesome.  Especially when it's not a fluky season. It's legitimate improvement and built around a young quarterback. I find myself rooting for Cleveland in most games. And I will be again against the Ravens on Sunday. Football is going to be fun for you again. And for a long time. I'm going to bow out because I don't want my outsider opinion to seem like I'm trying to douse that excitement.  Good luck on Sunday. And in 2019.  👍

 
Young players take a while to gain confidence. Are you pretending that Mayfield is the only talent on that team?  They have been hoarding draft picks for years. And Dorsey nailed it this year.  Everyone in the world knew they were going to be much improved this year. 
Exactly.  They had gotten a bunch of talent and getting rid of a terrible head coach sure did help.  Getting a good rookie QB has obviously helped as well, but to pretend that this 7-7-1 season is all Baker Mayfield is a bit of a reach. 

He has less losses than Andrew Luck and people are talking about him as a MVP candidate. 
No they aren't.  Delusional Browns fans do not count.  Almost no one with any objectivity considers Baker Mayfield a legitimate MVP candidate. 

 
Mayfield is 18th in quarterback rating.  18th.  I know it's been a while since Cleveland was competitive, but my God. Get into the top half of quarterbacks before talking MVP. 
MVP talk is not real but he is a rookie playing the most difficult position so improvements tend to be judged over years and in fits and spurts meaning up-and-down performances.  Mayfield is the only rookie QB who had a coaching change which tend to be disruptive to any rookie but his numbers significantly improved.

After an initial adjustment period from the coaching change here are Baker Mayfield's numbers.

Over the past six games:  Baker Mayfield

  • Att - 179
  • Comp - 128
  • Comp 71%
  • Yards - 1,581
  • TDs - 14
  • INTs - 4
  • Sacks - 5
  • W/L 5-1
Before the last 6 games with poor coaching, a coaching change, WRs were adjusting to his throws (Browns WRs lead league in dropped passes ).  Kitchens adjusted to shorter/quick hitting routes, added protection which cut down sacks/pressures. 

  • Att -  265
  • Comp - 171
  • Comp 64%
  • Yards -  1,768
  •  TDs - 10
  •  INTs - 7
  • Sacks - 20
  • W/L -  1-5
Bottom line, it is a night-and-day comparison over the final six games.  His rookie season shows a massive statistical split. 

Agreed that production over the year is so-so which makes the last six/seven games more impressive IMHO.  He is not loaded with talent supporting him.  Heck the team traded away its most talented WR a week into the season and traded away its starting veteran RB and is on its fourth OLT.  The poor coaching by Haley held him and Chubb back and Baker has taken the entire team on his back.  Remarkable for a rookie playing the toughest position in all of pro sports and the numbers show he has put up MVP-like stats over the past month and a half.

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top