Anarchy99
Footballguy
We should have at least a partial answer after Purdy’s surgery. Either he has the cleanup procedure or the full reconstruction (which they generally don’t have a solid opinion on until they open up the elbow).
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
QB Brock Purdy, SF (5 Viewers)
- Thread starter Faust
- Start date
Boston
Footballguy
I love what I saw with the kid last year but he is still not a definite and regardless of how the surgery goes it will be a tough offseason for him...after last season's QB debacle I just can't see SF gambling at QB...they need to plan for a worst-case scenario now and not in August...and IMO they are too good of an organization not to.
Wingnut
Footballguy
Purdy surgery expected next week
www.ninersnation.com
49ers QB Brock Purdy is expected to undergo elbow surgery next week
It appears the swelling in the Purdy’s elbow has gone down enough to undergo surgery.
www.ninersnation.com
Wingnut
Footballguy
He won't be out all year. If he gets surgery next week as planned, he should be 100% and cleared to play by early to mid September (barring any setbacks). Whether or not Lance holds him off is the question.
Kiddnets
Footballguy
not exactly true - they wont know the extent of the damage until they are in there. Its possible when they are in they pivot to a more intensive procedure that could lead to him being out the entire season. Wont know for sure until post op which should be this week finally
Wingnut
Footballguy
Yeah, that's been mentioned a ton in here. My post is assuming everything goes as planned with the internal brace.
Wingnut
Footballguy
Disagree there. With SFs QB injury history under Shanahan, it's almost a guarantee whoever signs will see playing time, and what QB wouldn't want to run this offense?
Leroy Hoard
Footballguy
Maybe not from our POV, but SF should have a chance to give Lance the preseason and first few games to show whatever. That would give them a chance to plug in Purdy at their option.
I'd think its very attractive to a certain kind of FA. Obviously its not where a guy like Carr would want to go, and Rodgers/Lamar are way too pricey.
I keep coming back to Matt Ryan. Experienced, little no learning curve with the offense, and likely willing to accept backup job, but more than capable of starting in a pinch. Basically a good insurance policy that would be more likely than not to be needed.
I do think its highly unlikely SF goes into camp with Lance/Purdy and no capable other option, even if they'd prefer 1 of those 2 win the job.
Dr. Octopus
Footballguy
Ryan would make a lot of sense to initially backup Lance.
Anarchy99
Footballguy
That must be the new math I keep hearing about. Six months where I come from is 26 weeks. Six months from Friday 3/10 would make it approximately 9/10 not 8/25.
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
You probably just live in a different time dimension.
Leroy Hoard
Footballguy
Well Daylight Dimension Time does kick in this weekend.
Wingnut
Footballguy
Peter King in Football Morning in America
the best news the Niners could have gotten from Brock Purdy’s elbow surgery was that it didn’t have to be massively invasive, and there is optimism that he should be able to throw the football without restriction in five to six months. Just another reason why San Francisco won’t overreact and spend/draft significantly on a quarterback. This also gives Trey Lance a runway to be the number one guy through the offseason, with the reps and responsibility that entails. Overall, good news for Kyle Shanahan.
Link
the best news the Niners could have gotten from Brock Purdy’s elbow surgery was that it didn’t have to be massively invasive, and there is optimism that he should be able to throw the football without restriction in five to six months. Just another reason why San Francisco won’t overreact and spend/draft significantly on a quarterback. This also gives Trey Lance a runway to be the number one guy through the offseason, with the reps and responsibility that entails. Overall, good news for Kyle Shanahan.
Link
Wingnut
Footballguy
Shanahan on wide Brock Purdy range of possibilities:
"We'll see in 3 months if he can be ready for camp, or possibly not. Or if it's going to be a little slower, it might be Week 1. I'm hearing at the latest Week 4, but that's all estimations and we'll see what happens."
"We'll see in 3 months if he can be ready for camp, or possibly not. Or if it's going to be a little slower, it might be Week 1. I'm hearing at the latest Week 4, but that's all estimations and we'll see what happens."
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Colts trade a case of beer and a jumbo bag of pork rinds for Trey Lance
Kiddnets
Footballguy
If they truly are all in on Purdy they should deal Lance at the draft. Darnold could easily hold down the fort and this is probably the time to get some value back for Lance...of course nothing close to what they gave up. Im thinking a 2d rder....if they wait one more year hes going into the 4th yr when a team has to make a call on an extension which is likely too late.
zamboni
Footballguy
Possibly mentioned upthread, but seems like several folks are trying to connect the dots between new Titans GM Ran Carthon and his previous ties to the Niners. With the Titans seemingly ready to move away from Tannehill, it makes a lot of sense - on paper at least.
Wingnut
Footballguy
They're not gonna deal Lance any time soon. They had 3 QBs last season and it wasn't enough, and Purdy may not be ready for weeks into the season. Zero chance they move Lance before they even know what they have.
Last edited:
Wingnut
Footballguy
Purdy on schedule.
Per David Lombardi via Twitter:
Good news on 49ers QB Brock Purdy from KNBR: John Lynch expects him to resume throwing 12 weeks post-elbow surgery, which would be in early June. At this point, SF should develop more clarity on an exact return timeline.
Still seems to be a chance Purdy is back Week 1, but SF has been bracing for absence that stretches to Week 4
Per David Lombardi via Twitter:
Good news on 49ers QB Brock Purdy from KNBR: John Lynch expects him to resume throwing 12 weeks post-elbow surgery, which would be in early June. At this point, SF should develop more clarity on an exact return timeline.
Still seems to be a chance Purdy is back Week 1, but SF has been bracing for absence that stretches to Week 4
Wingnut
Footballguy
Per Lombardi on Twitter:
Kyle Shanahan says that barring setbacks, the 49ers expect Brock Purdy back by training camp. Purdy has already been making throwing motions with a towel — not yet with a ball (that’s expected in June)
Kyle Shanahan says that barring setbacks, the 49ers expect Brock Purdy back by training camp. Purdy has already been making throwing motions with a towel — not yet with a ball (that’s expected in June)
Amused to Death
Footballguy
So they basically just expanded the roster by 1. Nothing prevented SF from having 3 QBs active in the NFCCG. They chose to have another player at a different position.
Amused to Death
Footballguy
Who would have been SF's 3rd QB in the NFCCG? Why didn't they dress him?
Amused to Death
Footballguy
Well sure the owners will vote in expanding their game day roster, which is what this essentially does.
Who would have been SF's QB3 for the NFCCG and do you think it would have mattered? If QB3 is injured, what then?
Wingnut
Footballguy
Pelissero:
Here’s the full bylaw that owners approved today. Notably, it limits the third QB exemption to players on the inactive list — not practice squad players who weren’t elevated for the game. Could impact 53-man roster construction for some teams.
Click link for full text
Lombardi:
Emergency third QB must be on the 53-man roster, not the practice squad. In theory, this further incentivizes the 49ers to carry all three — Purdy, Lance and Darnold — on their 53-man roster, as there's roster inefficiency in terms of the 46-man every Sunday (the emergency QB doesn't count vs that)
Here’s the full bylaw that owners approved today. Notably, it limits the third QB exemption to players on the inactive list — not practice squad players who weren’t elevated for the game. Could impact 53-man roster construction for some teams.
Click link for full text
Lombardi:
Emergency third QB must be on the 53-man roster, not the practice squad. In theory, this further incentivizes the 49ers to carry all three — Purdy, Lance and Darnold — on their 53-man roster, as there's roster inefficiency in terms of the 46-man every Sunday (the emergency QB doesn't count vs that)
Wingnut
Footballguy
Brock Purdy’s 8 full starts (including Miami game)
147/220 (66.8%)
1,854 yds
16 TDs
3 INTs
17 game average:
312/467 (66.8%)
3,939 yds
34 TDs
7 INTs (1.5%)
The 34 TDs would be 3rd best in 49ers history, INT% 2nd best (min 400 attempts) & passing yards 7th best.
If Purdy starts 12+ games and takes even a little step in his 2nd year (assuming he recovers fine from the injury and stays healthy), he will be in the running for league MVP. You heard it here first. I even put a few dollars on him for MVP at 50/1 cuz why the hell not.
147/220 (66.8%)
1,854 yds
16 TDs
3 INTs
17 game average:
312/467 (66.8%)
3,939 yds
34 TDs
7 INTs (1.5%)
The 34 TDs would be 3rd best in 49ers history, INT% 2nd best (min 400 attempts) & passing yards 7th best.
If Purdy starts 12+ games and takes even a little step in his 2nd year (assuming he recovers fine from the injury and stays healthy), he will be in the running for league MVP. You heard it here first. I even put a few dollars on him for MVP at 50/1 cuz why the hell not.
Wingnut
Footballguy
Im liking what Im hearing
www.ninersnation.com
Kyle Shanahan spoke after OTAs Tuesday. Shanahan said he’s optimistic that Brock Purdy will be ready to play Week 1: “We’re hoping for Week 1. I feel pretty optimistic about that. Usually, that means that’s not the day he comes back to practice. He’d come back before that.”
Shanahan acknowledged that there’s no timeline set for Purdy’s return, but added they “don’t have any reason to think otherwise” at the moment, which is great news for the 49ers and Purdy.
He’ll begin his throwing program at some point next week. That doesn’t mean Purdy will be launching 50-yarders, but he’ll begin gripping a football and throwing roughly five or so yards.
Brock wasn’t as reticent as Shanahan when it came to returning. He confirmed that he’ll begin throwing next week, saying, “that’s the plan.” Here’s Purdy’s answer when asked if he’d be on track to play Week 1:
The rehab process is a new one for Purdy:
When Purdy was asked to self-reflect on his rookie year, he thought his confidence stood out:
Purdy spoke about how the quarterback room is helping each other out, how the dynamic is great, and that “we all get along really well.
Shanahan is optimistic Purdy will be ready for Week 1
Purdy tempered those expectations once he spoke
www.ninersnation.com
Kyle Shanahan spoke after OTAs Tuesday. Shanahan said he’s optimistic that Brock Purdy will be ready to play Week 1: “We’re hoping for Week 1. I feel pretty optimistic about that. Usually, that means that’s not the day he comes back to practice. He’d come back before that.”
Shanahan acknowledged that there’s no timeline set for Purdy’s return, but added they “don’t have any reason to think otherwise” at the moment, which is great news for the 49ers and Purdy.
He’ll begin his throwing program at some point next week. That doesn’t mean Purdy will be launching 50-yarders, but he’ll begin gripping a football and throwing roughly five or so yards.
Brock wasn’t as reticent as Shanahan when it came to returning. He confirmed that he’ll begin throwing next week, saying, “that’s the plan.” Here’s Purdy’s answer when asked if he’d be on track to play Week 1:
The rehab process is a new one for Purdy:
When Purdy was asked to self-reflect on his rookie year, he thought his confidence stood out:
Purdy spoke about how the quarterback room is helping each other out, how the dynamic is great, and that “we all get along really well.
Wingnut
Footballguy
Purdy:
"We want to win a Super Bowl here—simple as that. And so, for me, I just do my job, and everything else falls into place"
www.49erswebzone.com
"We want to win a Super Bowl here—simple as that. And so, for me, I just do my job, and everything else falls into place"
49ers' Brock Purdy: Recovery going well, Week 1 return still the goal
On Tuesday, San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan said he remains "pretty optimistic" that quarterback Brock Purdy would be available for Week 1 of the 2023 season. The 23-year-old underwent su
www.49erswebzone.com
Wingnut
Footballguy
Kawakami: It’s Brock Purdy QB1 and then everybody else — the 49ers’ situation looks confusing, but it’s not.
Most of the article, which is behind a pay wall, is posted in 49er thread:
*** San Francisco 49ers *** Official thread
How about this for cost efficiency: The 49ers have signed all 21 incoming rookies — 9 draftees and 12 UDFAs — ahead of today's minicamp practice. Total cost on the salary cap: $891,635 Cap wizards, they are.
forums.footballguys.com
Last edited:
League Champion
Footballguy
Or if he regresses, which is much more likely
Wingnut
Footballguy
Disagree, but we will see.
Not sure about regression as far as actual performance goes, but I do see a regression to his statistical output. I was impressed with his tenacity and his leadership....but not so much with his actual play on the field. He didn't seem to have any special traits at all, and his accuracy was merely a little above average. Every time I saw him play (3 or 4 games) it seemed the opposing team dropped what looked like an easy pick, and he certainly benefited from superior talent around him.
The sample size is still pretty small. Maybe I'm just not seeing something that should be obvious, maybe some folks are seeing something that simply isn't there. The most likely scenario is that he's an NFL level starter but not a top 10 type talent. We'll see.
ericttspikes
Footballguy
What Purdy did last year was incredible and deserves first crack at starting, but is he really a better QB than Darnold? I’m interested in seeing what Sam could do if given a chance in a system that has had guys like Mullens, Purdy and Garrappolo have success.
Last edited:
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
This is why I don't think Purdy will have much regression. He's not a gimmick kind of guy that DCs can "figure out" in an offseason. He's a perfect fit for that offense and I see him like an Alex Smith in KC kind of player...good player, but great fit in the system.
efactor
Footballguy
Agree with what you are saying, especially the part about not being a gimmick guy, but I do think he has some special traits people are underestimating. He did what he did last season with basically no prep work. The injury set him back of course, but looking forward to what he can do with a better understanding of the offense. I really hope the 49ers make sure he is 100 percent before he sees the field though.
BobbyLayne
Footballguy
Was supposed to start throwing again 12 weeks post surgery - early June. Hope he makes a full recovery, dude is legit.
wgoldsph
Footballguy
When did this test become a thing? I've been following the draft for decades now and this is the first time I've heard about it. Did we all forget about the Wonderlick or whatever?
Marauder
Footballguy
The S2 test seems to have replaced the Wonderlic as the test of choice for QB's in recent years because it focuses more on processing speed rather than general problem-solving. Supposedly guys like Mahomes, Josh Allen, and Burrow all scored in the high 90's.
