drummer
Footballguy
He's like one of the cheapest starting if not the cheapest starting QB in the NFL due to where he was drafted, and could had made more money as a UFDA. Salary wise, he's an absolute steal.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
QB Brock Purdy, SF (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter Faust
- Start date
Neil Beaufort Zod
Footballguy
Question:
How did every single NFL team (including the 49ers) get it wrong about Purdy? How does that guy go past 31 teams seven times and one team six times?
How did every single NFL team (including the 49ers) get it wrong about Purdy? How does that guy go past 31 teams seven times and one team six times?
ohio#1eaglesfan
Footballguy
Might not have liked his personality and athleticism. Idk they get it wrong all the time
TampaMike19
Footballguy
My guess is they thought the ceiling wasn't higher than any UDFA QB so that's why he went last. Fortunately he went to the perfect offense for his strengths.
Just like us fantasy players- the feeling is so much better when you hit on someone with potential vs. owning a Tyler Boyd type of person
zamboni
Footballguy
Just speculating, but scouts seem to love measurables/upside particularly with QBs. That's why a guy like Purdy, who perhaps showed that he does everything reasonably well but not too well and isn't athletically gifted, falls through the cracks, while a guy like Malik Willis, who has immense athleticism, gets drafted in the 3rd round.
Or maybe Purdy just had a bad day at the scouting combine. Shows that these scouts often don't know until they know.
FarFromHome
Footballguy
Don't know for sure. Heard this morning even if Niners wanted to give him new contract they couldn't. Is that true? Seems silly if so.
taylormeetstheismann
Footballguy
SF is averaging an impressive 33.4 PPG. They’ve scored at least 30 points in every game too.
taylormeetstheismann
Footballguy
At this rate, they will one day.
Yes.
IIRC he was viewed as an intriguing prospect after his sophomore year but he had disappointing/unimpressive junior and senior college seasons.
ProstheticRGK
Footballguy
Exactly. And that’s why Purdy is so good. He processes way faster and better than he has any right to, given how green he is.
I think his talent is ‘ok’ compared to other starting caliber QBs. He has good accuracy, has a passably decent arm- but the results on the physical assest are still being written. He has a chance to answer the questions about arm strength, etc.
He’s got a franchise QB head. And, so far, he outcools Joe Cool. Any second year guy isn’t supposed to be that polished and poised. I’m not annointing him the next Brady, but I’m not rolling my eyes anymore when SF fans start wishcasting. Kid is legit.
efactor
Footballguy
For 49er fans that go back to Montana days, a feeling of deja vu has to be coming over them. First time I have ever said this out loud because it seemed almost blasphemes, but it is what it is.
Scooby1974
Footballguy
Well, we've seen what Sam DARNald does under pressure...think Dak.
Tyreek could be in the conversation if he gets 2,000 yards receiving and 15 TDs. Achane near 10 ypc would've also been in the conversation.
taylormeetstheismann
Footballguy
Five games into the season feels too soon to be figuring out the league MVP.
Ghost Rider
Footballguy
Agreed. Scouts fall in love with a strong arm and athleticism, but they always say how much faster the NFL is than college, and it's not always easy to tell by watching college ball if a guy will be good at reading defenses quickly in the NFL. I have an older relative who still jokes about how Tom Brady and Peyton Manning always were throwing to guys who were wide open, and I am like, "yeah, because they read the defenses so quickly, they knew who would be open almost immediately."
We asked nicely for folks to keep it on football and not shots at each other.
Please be more cool if you come back.
Please be more cool if you come back.
taylormeetstheismann
Footballguy
Purdy is about a promising as they come right now. Few new QBs are 12-1 over their first 13 starts. And we all know he was injured in the first quarter of his lone loss. The haters really don’t have a leg to stand on at the moment. I’m not saying he’ll end up in the HOF but he’s off to an incredible start.
Wingnut
Footballguy
When trailing:
Since taking over as QB for #49ers, Brock Purdy has had 13 drives when the team was trailing (excluding NFC title game). Here's what the team has done on those drives:
TD: 7 times
FG: 3 times
Punt: 2 times
INT: once
Purdy is also the first QB in the Super Bowl era to start 5-0 in both his first and second season.
Since taking over as QB for #49ers, Brock Purdy has had 13 drives when the team was trailing (excluding NFC title game). Here's what the team has done on those drives:
TD: 7 times
FG: 3 times
Punt: 2 times
INT: once
Purdy is also the first QB in the Super Bowl era to start 5-0 in both his first and second season.
Scooby1974
Footballguy
And he's young...still learning and hungry. He will only get better with experience.
Wingnut
Footballguy
“No matter what everyone else is saying man, I know that there is another level that I can get to.” - Brock Purdy
Video clip
Video clip
Wingnut
Footballguy
I'm surprised this thread isn't full of celebration for Purdys first bad game.
With all the circumstances yesterday, he still led his team down the field in the last minute and put them in position to win. If that kick is made, Purdy is a hero for the comeback drive. He's a dawg and never lost composure even though things weren't going well.
Look for a nice bounce back game next week on Monday Night Football vs the Vikings.
With all the circumstances yesterday, he still led his team down the field in the last minute and put them in position to win. If that kick is made, Purdy is a hero for the comeback drive. He's a dawg and never lost composure even though things weren't going well.
Look for a nice bounce back game next week on Monday Night Football vs the Vikings.
Wingnut
Footballguy
With Brock Purdy in concussion protocol, 49ers’ QB Sam Darnold now is in line to start Sunday’s game vs. the Bengals.
VikingFrog
Footballguy
Damn. He’s been a nice steady Eddie as my QB2 in SuperFlex.
Welcome to the lineup Baker Mayfield. Which doesn’t sound like fun because I can’t even wait and see if Purdy somehow clears protocol.
But no players seem to clear it within the week these days. Especially after a Monday game.
Wingnut
Footballguy
Yep
No NFL player placed into concussion protocol this season has played the same week. The last player to be in concussion protocol who played the same week was 2022, when Kenny Pickett had a concussion in week 6 and was cleared to play in week 7.
Jacob's Ladder
Footballguy
I am a huge fan of Purdy, his poise, his understanding of defenses, his accuracy (when not concussed), but this offense is tailormade for Darnold's skillset. Things could get interesting here. Darnold is no slouch.
drummer
Footballguy
The offense still goes as CMC goes, DC's might have more to work with defending against Purdy, and let's face it: he is small for a QB. His arm strength still isn't 100% (as he told Aikman before the game) and this was the second game in a row where the 49ers were held not just under 30 points, but 20 points, and that's trending the opposite direction. Maybe it's best to sit Purdy out this one going into the bye week after and see what GEQBUS can do, because if they start Purdy who isn't 100% and lose, or gets further injured (which will bring the whole "Shanahan can't keep his QB's healthy", which even now begs the question if he still can), then you're going into the bye week with all sorts of controversies that are self inflicted. Opposed to say if the 49ers lose with GEQBUS, then you can blame it on GEQBUS.
rockaction
Footballguy
What is GEQBUS? For the grunts here reading your lofty prose.
drummer
Footballguy
It's a Reddit thing:
5 things to know about new 49ers QB Sam Darnold
The San Francisco 49ers added veteran depth at the quarterback position on Monday after agreeing to terms on a one-year deal with former New York Jets and Carolina Panthers signal caller Sam Darnold.
www.49erswebzone.com
Snotbubbles
Footballguy
Because there are 5 phases you have to clear.
The National Football League Concussion Protocol: A Review
Sport-related concussion remains an area of high concern for contact sport athletes and their families, as well as for the medical and scientific communities. The National Football League (NFL), along with the NFL Players Association and experts in the ...
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Wingnut
Footballguy
It's been done this season, but not on a short week.
Maiocco:
The only #49ers player to go into concussion protocol this season was OL Jon Feliciano. He sustained a concussion during the Week 4 game against the Cardinals. He got cleared for Week 5 and played against the Cowboys without sitting out any games.
Snotbubbles
Footballguy
I think the prudent thing is to play it safe here with a bye coming up.
Wingnut
Footballguy
Yep. No way they risk it IMO.
zamboni
Footballguy
I want to wish him a Merry Christmas.
taylormeetstheismann
Footballguy
Maybe a concussion explains the picks.
VikingFrog
Footballguy
Did he get concussed on a tush push!
Maybe it was just a normal QB sneak. But I’ll get my popcorn ready for the tush push thread either way.
Tua had a similar experience in the GB game last year when his head hit the turf hard just before halftime. He had great stats in the 1st half, struggled in the 2nd half. At the time, I thought it was an excuse. Maybe it wasn't. He didn't play again until the 2023 season, since it was his 3rd concussion.
drummer
Footballguy
This can explain the last quarter of football that Purdy had played (and I don't know exact time the sneak play occurred), but his previous 7 quarters of football he threw only 2 TDs to 1 INT. Now it's fair to say that post the sneak play where he got hit in the helmet, that did have an effect, but it's also fair to say that the 49er offense as a whole has dropped off considerably over the past two games, and Purdy's arm that is still not 100% after his surgery might be showing some fatigue. Also, CMC is not 100% either, and there is no Deebo or Trent Williams as starters against MIN.
The weird thing is Brian Griese didn't see anything wrong with him on the sideline, we were all in the game thread and we didn't think there was anything wrong as far as he being concussed. The most important issue that Shanahan has put in his mind is keeping key players healthy, maybe throw Darnold in there for sneaks instead of Purdy.
Wingnut
Footballguy
There's a common denominator over the last 8 quarters where the offense dropped off: no Deebo.
The offense is missing Deebo more than people realize. The attention he demands helps CMC do his thing, and his intensity amd attitude set the tone.
We don't have anyone else that can do what Deebo does. The other WRs scare no one when they run Deebo plays with them (jet sweeps, screens, etc). Deebo is a hammer and gives the offense that mentality and style when he's on the field.
Without Aiyuk Week 3, the 49ers cruised to 30 points. Without Deebo, theyve been bullied on offense 2 weeks in a row and held to less than 20 in both games.
We need both Deebo and CMC healthy for the offense to click and bully defenses.
The offense is missing Deebo more than people realize. The attention he demands helps CMC do his thing, and his intensity amd attitude set the tone.
We don't have anyone else that can do what Deebo does. The other WRs scare no one when they run Deebo plays with them (jet sweeps, screens, etc). Deebo is a hammer and gives the offense that mentality and style when he's on the field.
Without Aiyuk Week 3, the 49ers cruised to 30 points. Without Deebo, theyve been bullied on offense 2 weeks in a row and held to less than 20 in both games.
We need both Deebo and CMC healthy for the offense to click and bully defenses.
drummer
Footballguy
Yeah, exactly. The 49er offense is built like a game of Jenga - you pull one key piece out, and the whole structure becomes shaky. Of course every offense can point to that, but a lot of top teams in the NFL have a QB who can mitigate that. Take Tyreek Hill away from Patrick Mahomes, Mahomes still wins MVP and the Super Bowl. Now it's completely unfair to compare Mahomes to Purdy (although people had after the Dallas game, even though physically these QB's are very disparate from each other physically), but it also lends to the rub on Purdy when it comes to his success being surrounded by All Pro talent. Now, no one should knock a QB who is successful with that. Yet it's the QB who is successful and wins a game without a Justin Jefferson yet win with Jordan Addison after Addison turned the ball over is much different than Purdy throwing to CMC for the only TD pass he threw.
If the offensive dropoff is because Deebo isn't available, CMC is not 100%, and Trent Williams isn't available, then the only person you can point to is the QB. Who also is by his own admission not 100%, before he suffered a concussion. The 49ers offense reminds me of a quote from Lester Freamon in The Wire:
"All the pieces matter".
Wingnut
Footballguy
Purdy practiced today (non contact) which means hes in the 4th of 5 steps.
Phase Four: Club-Based Non-Contact Training Drills
The player-patient may continue cardiovascular conditioning, strength and balance training, team-based sport-specific exercise, and participate in non-contact football activities such as throwing, catching, running and other position-specific activities, progressing to participation in non-contact team practice activities. To be clear, all activities at this Phase remain non-contact (i.e., no contact with other players or objects, such as tackling dummies or sleds).
Full explanation of the 5 steps:
Phase Four: Club-Based Non-Contact Training Drills
The player-patient may continue cardiovascular conditioning, strength and balance training, team-based sport-specific exercise, and participate in non-contact football activities such as throwing, catching, running and other position-specific activities, progressing to participation in non-contact team practice activities. To be clear, all activities at this Phase remain non-contact (i.e., no contact with other players or objects, such as tackling dummies or sleds).
Full explanation of the 5 steps:
VikingFrog
Footballguy
Makes it tough with my only other choice being a Thursday option and his name is not Josh Allen.
no shot he plays this week. Again, not one NFL player has played the week following a concussion, AND SF has their bye in week 9.
