What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rank the NFL's top ten units (1 Viewer)

PadresLakers

Footballguy
Ravens D tops the charts among all league units

Best unit in football.

Since the New England Patriots landed receiver Randy Moss in a trade last week, that's all anyone is saying about the Patriots offense.

Can you imagine Tom Brady throwing to Moss? Not only that, but the Patriots added Donte' Stallworth and Wes Welker to the passing game, so the presumption is this unit has ascended to the top among all 64 -- we don't count special-teams -- in the league.

But are they the best unit in the NFL?

They're close, but the answer is no. The best unit in the NFL is the Baltimore Ravens defense.

The Ravens ranked first last year in total defense, and they have 10 of 11 starters back and are still led by one of the best defensive minds in football in Rex Ryan.

The Ravens head into the 2007 season needing to replace only Adalius Thomas -- who signed with the Patriots -- and they're excited about replacement Jarrett Johnson. The Patriots offense and others have a chance to unseat the Ravens defense, but as of right now, Moss, Brady and that gang are still behind a unit that played at the highest level in 2006.

1. Baltimore Ravens defense

The skinny: Ryan's unit finished as the top-ranked defense in the league last season, and returns everybody except Thomas. But the Ravens feel that Johnson is a capable replacement. This is a star-studded group with Trevor Pryce, Terrell Suggs, Bart Scott, Ed Reed, Chris McAlister and, of course, Ray Lewis.

Key addition: Nobody. They just need to get Johnson to play close to the level of Thomas.

Player needed to make unit special: Corner Samari Rolle didn't play all that well last season. He has to revert close to his former self for this defense to move to an even higher level.

Still an area of concern: Age. With Rolle, Lewis, McAlister and Pryce getting up in years, it's starting to become an issue.

2. New England Patriots offense

The skinny: This is an offense that finished 11th in the league last season in total yards, despite not having any real go-to players in the passing game. The Pats were 12th in passing, but had just eight passing plays of 40 yards or more. Now they've added a bunch of receivers, the biggest threat being Moss. But don't forget that Stallworth can run, Welker is a crafty intermediate route runner and Kelley Washington has had some success with the Bengals. Brady should be one happy man, and we're not just talking about Gisele.

Key addition: Moss. He will revert back to his Pro Bowl form. This will be one of those deals we'll look back on and wonder how it got made.

Player needed to make unit special: Running back Laurence Maroney. He played well as a rookie, but then was bothered by an injury late in the season and his production tailed off. If he can be a 1,400-yard rusher, this will be an offense that is really scary.

Still an area of concern: It's being a nitpicky, since the line is so well-coached, but the talent up front isn't as good as some teams. If there is a little ***** in the offense, the line might be it. Again, that's nitpicking.

3. Indianapolis Colts offense

The skinny: The Colts won the Super Bowl last year, and the starting offense is back intact. Not only that, but they've added a speed receiver in Anthony Gonzalez, who should excel in the slot. Second-year back Joseph Addai, who was good as a rookie, will be even better now. He has to be with Dominic Rhodes gone.

Player needed to make unit special: You hate to put it on a rookie, but it's Gonzalez. When Brandon Stokley was lost last year with an injury, it forced the Colts to use fewer three-receiver sets. That's a staple of their offense, which is why Gonzalez makes a lot of sense.

Still an area of concern: Backup running back. Losing Rhodes will force the Colts to rely on a more inexperienced player. The good news is that means Addai will get more carries. He's ready for it.

4. San Diego Chargers offense

The skinny: The Chargers return the entire starting offense from a unit that ranked fourth in the league in total offense. With LaDainian Tomlinson and Antonio Gates, this is a star-studded unit. New coach Norv Tuner is considered an offensive wizard.

Key addition: First-round pick Craig Davis has to help the deep passing game. They love this kid. We shall see.

Player needed to make unit special: Quarterback Philip Rivers. He showed well in his first year as a starter, but watch for even better play from him this season.

Still an area of concern: The receivers. Even with Davis on board, there are still questions about the go-to guy. It takes time for a rookie receiver to make an impact, so Vincent Jackson has to come up big.

5. Jacksonville Jaguars defense

The skinny: This is a unit that ranked third in the league last season, despite losing its best pass rusher (Reggie Hayward), starting middle linebacker (Mike Peterson), starting weak-side linebacker (Pat Thomas) and starting strong safety (Donovin Darius) for most of the 2006 season. Those four are all expected back healthy in 2007. Coordinator Mike Smith is the most-underrated coach in the league.

Key addition: First-round pick Reggie Nelson is a playmaking safety in the Ed Reed mold. He should be an immediate starter.

Player needed to make unit special: Defensive end Bobby McCray. He had 10 sacks in a situational role last year, but he has to prove he wasn't a one-year wonder.

Still an area of concern: Pass rush. With Hayward coming off a torn Achilles tendon and the right end spot still unsettled, that's a worry. They have to find a way to get more pressure on the quarterback.

6. Oakland Raiders defense

The skinny: It might seem crazy to see this unit here but Rob Ryan has the makings of a nice group. The Raiders ranked third in the league last year, and should be even better as young players like safety Michael Huff improve.

Key addition: They hope third-round pick Quentin Moses can impact their pass rush. There isn't a lot different on this unit from last season.

Player needed to make unit special: Huff. If he can become a Pro Bowl player, their secondary will be one of the best.

Still an area of concern: They need to get more than 34 sacks this season. Maybe Moses will help make that happen.

7. Chargers defense

The skinny: This defense finished 10th last season in yards given up and seventh in points allowed, which is good, but the unit's reputation is a lot better than that. The problem is the pass defense. The Chargers ranked 13th last season, and seventh against the run.

Key addition: They traded up to get safety Eric Weddle in the second round. He better be an impact safety right away for the pass defense to improve.

Player needed to make unit special: Corner Antonio Cromartie can become an elite corner. If he does, it will really help the pass coverage.

Still an area of concern: Inside linebacker. They let Donnie Edwards go, which means Matt Wilhelm takes over at one of the inside linebacker spots. He has to play well or the run defense will fall off.

8. New Orleans Saints offense

The skinny: The Saints were the fifth-ranked scoring offense last year, and top-ranked offense in terms of yards. With Reggie Bush a year older and Drew Brees more comfortable with the offense, they should be even better. Plus, Sean Payton is the best play-caller in the NFL.

Key addition: First-round pick Robert Meachem is another weapon that Payton can have at his disposal. This team needs Meachem's speed.

Player needed to make unit special: Bush. He will get more touches and he has to have more home-run plays.

Still an area of concern: Despite having Deuce McAllister and Bush, the Saints were only 19th in rushing last season. That has to improve.

9. Chicago Bears defense

The skinny: This unit carried the Bears to the Super Bowl, finishing fifth in the league in total defense and third in scoring defense. The Cover-2 scheme has a new coordinator with Ron Rivera gone. Bob Babich takes over, moving up from linebackers coach.

Key addition: The Bears added strong safety Adam Archuleta, a guy they think can become their John Lynch. Good luck. He was awful for the Redskins last year.

Player needed to make unit special: Dusty Dvoracek. They drafted him in the third round and he missed the season with an injury. With Tank Johnson facing suspension and Tommie Harris coming off injury, they need him to step in and play well at defensive tackle.

Still an area of concern: The Lance Briggs situation. Will he or won't he play for the Bears?

10. Cincinnati Bengals offense

The skinny: The Bengals were eighth in scoring offense last season and they should be near the top again. With Carson Palmer another year removed from that torn ACL, he should be even better.

Key addition: Second-round pick Kenny Irons could provide the big plays from the running back spot that this team has lacked.

Player needed to make unit special: Palmer. He's already good, damn good, but he needs to get in the Peyton Manning class. If he does, watch out.

Still an area of concern: Third receiver. With Chris Henry suspended for the first part of the season, they need a young player to emerge from a group of question marks.

http://www.sportsline.com/nfl/story/10164800

My top ten

1. Colts offense

2. Chargers offense

3. Ravens defense

4. Bengals offense

5. Bears defense

6. Jaguars defense

7. Saints offense

8. Patriots defense

9. Chargers defense

10. Patriots offense

 
1. Colts offense

2. Chargers offense

3. Patriots offense

4. Ravens defense

5. Bears defense

6. Chargers defense

7. Jaguars defense

8. Saints offense

9. Bengals offense

10. Raiders defense

 
1. Whatever special teams unit Devin Hester suits up for.

Seriously, though, I think the Broncos D could deserve some attention in the bottom half of the top-10.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I do agree with Prisco (even though he's an idiot most of the time) on #1. Ravens D is the best. I severely disagree with the Pats offense being #2 - they haven't been on the field together yet and chemistry does count in football.

 
;) to the Jags D being recognized (though this is Prisco, so it's to be expected)

:lmao: to the Pats offense somehow being ahead of the Colts offense. Manning over Brady, Wayne/Harrison/Gonzalez over Moss/Stallworth/Welker, D. Clark over Ben Watson, Addai and Maroney is a push. O-line a push too, maybe a slight edge to the Pats.

Clearly, the Pats owned the Colts for that time because of the terrible Colts D and the exceptional Pats D.

 
I do agree with Prisco (even though he's an idiot most of the time) on #1. Ravens D is the best. I severely disagree with the Pats offense being #2 - they haven't been on the field together yet and chemistry does count in football.
I agree. As much as the media gets high and mighty and critical of real NFL owners playing fantasy football, they sure do get in a hurry to annoint clubs active in FA as the Next Big Thing. We're seeing this year with the Patriots that same haste to annoint them as champs as we saw in 2000 with the Redskins. I don't think that that offense will be in the top 6 through the first half of the season.
 
4. San Diego Chargers offenseThe skinny: The Chargers return the entire starting offense from a unit that ranked fourth in the league in total offense.
Funny how they didn't mention that this was last year's highest scoring unit. I guess they left it off because it would be too difficult to warrant them being no better than the 3rd best offense.
 
My top ten1. Colts offense2. Chargers offense3. Ravens defense
1. Colts offense2. Chargers offense...4. Ravens defense
I'm intrigued by these rankings since last year the Ravens Defense held these offenses to a an average of 0.5 touchdowns in the two games against them. I realize each year is different (Thomas is gone, Rhodes gone, Gonzalez added, etc.), but the I don't think the units have changed all that drastically since last season, and I get the sense these sentiments would have been roughly the same just based on last year as well. :popcorn:
 
My top 10:

1. NE D - Why this unit is not getting more attention in this thread is mind boggling to me. They were the 6th best unit vs yards last year despite all the injuries. They added the best (overall) FA on the market in Thomas. They added the much needed depth in the secondary. They will be healthy again.

2. Indy O - Not much to say. Manning and those WRs are just killer. Having a dominant Oline and solid Rb also help.

3. Chi D - What in the world has made so many people forget just how dominant this unit was before injuries to 2 KEY players riddled them last year? The Bears are going to be getting back both Harris and Brown this year and they are impact players. I don't care if Briggs holds out or not, the former 2 guys will bring this unit back to the leagues very best with or with out him.

4. Balt D - This unit would rank a bit higher had they only held onto Thomas. I'm sure Balt feels they have an adequate replacement, but you don't just replace a guy as versatile and dominate as Thomas and not miss a beat.

5. NE O - This is possibly the most talented group in the NFL, but early hick-ups are to be expected with so many new faces. Brady should need a little time to develop chemistry with his new and improved weapons. Still, by mid-season this unit should be ready to roll. Moss and Stallworth are simply enormous upgrades.

6. Jack D - I found it awful hard to drop the #2 D form last year this low, but some how did. In reality, I think they fixed the only ***** in this units armor. Drafting Nelson at S is exactly what this already dominate D needed. The rangy ball hawk from Fla will allow far more freedom of scheme for the front 7 and that is scary.

7. NO O - I really think this unit could be on the brink of greatness. Depending on how fast Meachem matures, we very well could be looking at "greatest show on turf" part 2. Brees, Bush, McAlister, Colston, Johnson, Henderson, Meachem and a borderline great Oline! Oh my! Still, I see some growing pains in the future of this unit, mainly a D that does not properly support them.

8. SD D - If this team could just add a few play makers in the secondary they may very well move into the top 3. The front 7 is about as good as it gets.

9. Cinci O - If they can stay healthy and out of trouble, Cinci has all the tools to be great on O. Palmer, Johnson, Johnson, Housh and a fantastic Oline.

10. SF D - This is my sleeper pick. Personally, I just can't emphasize how big I think the additions of Clements and Willis are.

 
5. Jacksonville Jaguars defense

The skinny: This is a unit that ranked third in the league last season, despite losing its best pass rusher (Reggie Hayward), starting middle linebacker (Mike Peterson), starting weak-side linebacker (Pat Thomas) and starting strong safety (Donovin Darius) for most of the 2006 season. Those four are all expected back healthy in 2007. Coordinator Mike Smith is the most-underrated coach in the league.

Key addition: First-round pick Reggie Nelson is a playmaking safety in the Ed Reed mold. He should be an immediate starter.

Player needed to make unit special: Defensive end Bobby McCray. He had 10 sacks in a situational role last year, but he has to prove he wasn't a one-year wonder.

Still an area of concern: Pass rush. With Hayward coming off a torn Achilles tendon and the right end spot still unsettled, that's a worry. They have to find a way to get more pressure on the quarterback.

6. Oakland Raiders defense

The skinny: It might seem crazy to see this unit here but Rob Ryan has the makings of a nice group. The Raiders ranked third in the league last year, and should be even better as young players like safety Michael Huff improve.
:lmao:
 
My top 10:
So the team that had the highest scoring offense, he third highest yardage offense, and the #1 offensive weapon doesn't make your top ten and is ranked below four other offenses? I'm assuming that's an oversight, right?
 
My top 10:
So the team that had the highest scoring offense, he third highest yardage offense, and the #1 offensive weapon doesn't make your top ten and is ranked below four other offenses? I'm assuming that's an oversight, right?
Unless he feel that losing Cam Cameron will have a big impact.I don't agree with him though. You've got to consider the Bolts a top-3 offense in the NFL for 2007 IMO.
 
Colts Offense

Bears Defense/Special Teams

Chargers Offense

New England Defense

New England Offense

New Orleans Offense

Cinci Offense

Baltimore Defense

Jax. Defense

San Diego Defense

 
Workhorse said:
Despyzer said:
My top 10:
So the team that had the highest scoring offense, he third highest yardage offense, and the #1 offensive weapon doesn't make your top ten and is ranked below four other offenses? I'm assuming that's an oversight, right?
Unless he feel that losing Cam Cameron will have a big impact.I don't agree with him though. You've got to consider the Bolts a top-3 offense in the NFL for 2007 IMO.
It was certainly not easy to leave SD off, but yes I think there will be some fall back with the coaching losses. I'm not sure why Despyzer is saying SD ranked 3rd in yards last year. SD was 4th in yards per game and it seems several teams were right on their heels. SD also only ranked 7th in total yards. I'm not sure why the 2 sites have different totals for passing yards but at any rate, SD does not seem to have ranked 3rd. It's not so much that I think CC will have a big impact. It's just that I think he will have some impact and not in a good way. There is a fine gap between SD being top 3 (or top 10 unit for the purposes of this thread) and still being good. I'd still put the SD O in the top 15 and more likely top 12. I'd say that is still pretty darn good. I only have 4 offensive units on the list BTW. There are many units that could easily be argued to be placed on this list. SD is a valid one. Another that I have not seen mentioned is Philly's O. This team ranked 2nd in yards per game last year and was well above SD in that regard. They get their best player back in McNabb and added the power RB they needed in Hunt. What about Dal's O who finished only 4 yards bellow SD on a yards per game basis last year? Romo gets a year under his belt and the Oline looks to have improved. Both Pitt and St.L have offensive units that could very well crack that list as well. Then we have some very strong D's in Oak, Mia, Car and Minn that all did not make the list. A case can be made for probably 25 units to be in this list of top 10. This just happens to be mine.

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top