I caught an interesting double feature this weekend. Saturday night I saw
Winter's Bone (still in theaters) and Sunday it was Frozen River.In many ways these are remarkably similar movies. I agree with the consensus about Frozen River and I can say without qualification that if you enjoyed FR you should definitely check out Winter's Bone.
I am always impressed when movies feel so real that you question if you are watching actors on location or real people living their lives on film and Winter's Bone definitely felt like the latter. Jennifer Lawrence delivers an excellent performance as 17 going on 40 year old de facto head of her household (in just about the most destitute setting imaginable. The family in FR are Rockefellers by comparison) caring for two siblings and an ill mother, while she must try to find her drug dealing father who skipped out on his bail bond after putting up the family home as collateral on the bond. Lawrence's performance is all the more impressive considering she was 18 years old when it was filmed.
Dale Dickey and (maybe) John Hawkes deliver Oscar worthy performances as well as the set and costume directors. It truly felt like watching the lives of a small disenfranchised community in the Ozarks that most of us probably do not even imagine exists.
The supporting cast is excellent, and I enjoyed the little Deadwood reunion (Hawkes and Garrett Dillahunt), and the appearance by Sheryl Lee (Laura Palmer from Twin Peaks). While not without flaws the story is very tight and well told.
I don't normally do the rating thing so I won't start now but this comes pretty close to being a perfect movie IMO.
While they are both excellent movies I enjoyed Winter's Bone more than Frozen River (again they are very similar) and I don't think it is because I saw WB first. I felt FR had a few minor issues with pacing and came dangerously close to being cliche at a few points (at the very least there were a couple points in the movie that I found overly convenient ways to advance the plot). This is not a knock on FR, I truly enjoyed, and strongly recommend it.