wikkidpissah
Footballguy
There is no comparison. I have never looked fwd to ANYTHING from Hollywood the way i presently am toward the '12 seasons of Sherlock & Downton Abbey from the Beeb. The Brett will always be the standard (i'm packing for a move & am keeping very few of the 100s of videocassettes ive recorded over 15 yrs here, but my compleat Holmes was first in the box), but i was delighted by the BBC update.The movie was entertaining. I'm not claiming it sucked. But I can't help but compare it to the vastly superior new BBC version of Sherlock set in the modern era.I was surprised by how little i hated Ritchie's Holmes. Of course, i didnt see it til my expectations were ground down to the point that anything less ridiculous than that inane fisticuffs scene would have improved my impression. As a purist, i had intended on boycotting it, but Frostilicus sent it to me amongst a treasure trove of DVDs in return for a kindness, so i watched. Not only did i find a way to enjoy it, but my major concern - that the franchise would cheapen a cultural institution - was largely assuaged. The sequel will be a larger challenge. I know from my cousin's recent experience directing Pirates4 that producers use the huuuuge backend $ involved in sequels to get their grubby fingers on projects in ways no one would ever let them in originals in order to give ascendancy to market-tested over creation decisions. There were a lot of bitter pills which powerful creative people swallowed on P4 (and now its looking like cousin & Depp et al WILL be shooting P5&6 late in '12) with profit participation in a $billion-grosser as incentive & that scares me. Though the hiring of the great Stephen Fry as Mycroft is a step in the right direction, i still worry about the Smartest Man in Cinema History being dumbed down for an entire generation by the series.completely different genres. BBC/Masterpiece school vs Ritchie/Hollywood. i don't think we'll be seeing guy helming any Masterpiece projects anytime soon. although it would be a great mash-up opportunity...'jdoggydogg said:I really enjoy Downey. But being a fan of the Jeremy Brett BBC Sherlock series, I think the movie was too fluffy.'saintfool said:i liked the first one well enough. it bogs down like most ritchie and big hollywood films do. RDJr makes it fun, if not interesting.'jdoggydogg said:First official trailer for Guy Ritchie's Sherlock Holmes sequel, Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows.
I thought the first movies was disappointing. The second looks like more of the same.
I like this movie a good bit, and I dont see what there is to actually consider it bad. Some said Brando mailed it in, okay, he's in the movie for what, 5-8minutes overall?! I thought DeNiro was solid in a role unlike others where he doesnt take risks and is thorough, and Norton comes back with the Primal Fear/multiple personality angle and thought he was great. I didnt think people disliked this movie until reading this thead tonight.
