El Floppo
Footballguy
I pretty much agree with all this.Saw Marcy May Martha McGuffin.
First off-Olson Jr. Very hot. I liked her performance, but felt like she relied on looking down a lot to convey her character... dunno- maybe that's a genuine trait of "lost" people but it felt a bit forced by the end.
The movie was pretty ravishing to look at though, and the director did a nice job telling the story in a fairly subtle way. Dialogue was spare and often misguided in a very believable way. That helped the actors do their jobs uniformly well, IMO. Also thought the cinematography was amazing- some really beautiful imagery throughout. I did find the narrative structure of jumping back and forth in time pretty cliche, and felt like it became really obvious when the jumps were about to happen... maybe not a terrible thing, but annoying to me.
I think Krista used a word like "empty" or "trifle" in describing this, and ultimately I don't disagree. I had the feeling while watching that this was a Sofia Coppola movie- beautifully rendered but ultimately shallow. I still enjoyed it, and found the subject matter interesting even if it didn't hit any highs for me.
Oh- a question about the end (and I actually love having questions about endings, rather than having everything pat and clear):
She gets in the car... with her sister and BIL, and they pass somebody walking? Who then gets in the car that starts following them? What went on in that last scene? Is it implied that those were the cult people who were following her?
The last scene depicts the first time she gets driven to the cult ranch. So it's a flashback.
are you sure? I'd swear that the male voice in the car is english- and so the BIL.
Also- how old was Jr supposed to be when she shows up at the farm? She acts like she's never seen or been aware of anything- kinda like she's 7 or 8. And yet it's implied she's from NYC, where 7 and 8 year olds have seen and done more than most people have in their entire lives. I guess I'm saying I didn't buy just how naive/idiotic she was- unless she was seriously mentally handicapped/sick.
Olson Jr. Very hot. I liked her performance, but felt like she relied on looking down a lot to convey her character... dunno- maybe that's a genuine trait of "lost" people but it felt a bit forced by the end.
Wasn't she an adult when she got to the ranch?? I was under the impression that she wasn't there for more than a year or so.
Sold.
I done told that bolded part wrong. "I definitely was NOT an insider".

It really wasn't. This is one where seeing it on the small screen will make it even worse. Not quite the same thing as "worth" seeing it on the big screen.
What a stupid movie.