The Place Beyond The Pines...I can understand the complaints Ive read from reviews of this here and elsewhere, and its usually the same few things because so much of this film was excellent, but I personally disagree with the complaints Ive seen most frequently. I am surprised by many disliking the last act of Pines. While I would agree its not as riveting as the first 2 acts, with how the storyline and the path of the main characters went, as well as the jump in time, I thought the final act fulfilled its purpose masterfully. Without it, the major themes of the first two acts - namely family relationships & the consequences our decisions have on them - would never have been fully realized. The last act to me is what takes this film to the next level and made it great. If Pines is only 90-100 minutes, it is instead just a well made character drama that ultimately falls short with its screenplay. Each act was about 45 minutes, and all of them took some time to really heat up. The last act was no different, and with a focus on newly introduced characters, naturally it took some time to build. While it is 2 hours15min, I didnt think there were wasted scenes here and I have a hard time understanding those who think this film wouldve been better if it was considerably shorter. Last but not least, the length of it also didnt bother me because this was carried by a strong ensemble cast. Gosling and Cooper will get a lot of credit and rightly so, but Dane DeHaan (Gosling's son) and Ben Mendelsohn really stood out in smaller roles, IMO. This will certainly end up being one of my favorites of 2013...4.5/5
I don't like introducing characters near the end of the movie whose sole purpose is to add a little more dramatic weight to what happened before. Doesn't flow well and comes off as a structural error, at least to me.
In general, I agree, but this is almost like 3 separate short films if you will, wrapped into one. I thought the flow from 2nd to 3rd act was fine despite the time jump because of Cooper's aspirations. However, if they just continued where the 2nd act was going - or in another direction with the same characters - with more detail instead of having the final act, youre left with a film whose first 45 minutes would be, for the most part, useless. If they went that route, really the 1st act couldve just been the final bank robbery scene because Cooper knew nothing about Gosling's character, so that entire first act is rendered irrelevant to the film except for that scene in regards to the 2nd act. If you believe the final act and new characters was just to add dramatic weight, then I dont see why you wouldnt say the same about the 1st act had the film stuck with the path it was on.
As I said in my post you replied to, without the final act Pines would just be an above average character drama that is well made but with an incomplete screenplay. The overall key to the movie and what IMO elevated it was the storyline and what it conveyed to the viewer and made you think about. That picture was being painted in the first 2 acts, and completed with the final act.