KarmaPolice
Footballguy
Personally, I struggle with how to rank it. I would agree that it is probably about as good as a movie could get from that source material, but part of my problem is that I read the book for the first time around the same time the movie came out and thought the book was much better than I was expecting, and the weird ideas and characters I liked won't translate well on the big screen. I also don't like how each of the movies end, and ding them a little for that, but that is a me thing as well.I really expected to see a full sweep of Dune for reboot.
It doesn't hold a candle to the 21 Jump Street reboot.
