What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

Reunion rosters (1 Viewer)

pigskin pimp

Footballguy
Family Matters

QB Donovan McNabb PHI 5

QB Phillip Rivers SD 7

RB LaDainian Tomlinson SD 7

RB Vernand Morency GB 7

RB Brandon Jackson GB 7

RB Corey Dillon FA ?

WR Anquan Boldin ARZ 8

WR Roy Williams DET 6

WR Terry Glenn DAL 8

WR Bobby Wade MIN 5

WR Craig Davis SD 7

WR Nate Washington PIT 6

TE Vernon Davis SF 6

TE Desmond Clark CHI 9

DEF Carolina Panthers 7

DEF Buffalo Bills 6

K Adam Vinateri IND 6

K Phil Dawson CLE 7

Fiddles

QB Tom Brady NE 10

QB Jon Kitna DET 6

RB Steven Jackson STL 9

RB Thomas Jones NYJ 10

RB Leon Washington NYJ 10

RB Adrian Peterson CHI 9

RB Brian Leonard STL 9

WR Lee Evans BUF 6

WR DJ Hackett SEA 8

WR Eddie Kennison KC 8

WR Sidney Rice MIN 5

WR Wes Welker NE 10

WR Demetrius Williams BAL 8

WR Maurice Stovall TB 10

TE Chris Cooley WAS 4

DEF Jacksonville Jaguars 4

DEF San Francisco 49ers 6

K David Akers PHI 5

valence

QB Marc Bulger STL 9

QB Tavaris Jackson MIN 5

RB Larry Johnson KC 8

RB Adrian Peterson MIN 5

RB Fred Taylor JAX 4

RB Kevin Faulk NE 10

WR Terrell Owens DAL 8

WR Randy Moss NE 10

WR Greg Jennings GB 7

WR Bobby Engram SEA 8

WR Joe Jurivicius CLE 7

WR Tab Perry CIN 5

WR Justin Gage TEN 4

TE Heath Miller PIT 6

TE Marcus Pollard SEA 8

DEF Baltimore Ravens 8

DEF New York Jets 10

K Jason Hanson DET 6

Twilight

QB Drew Brees NO 4

QB Trent Green MIA 9

RB Frank Gore SF 6

RB Ronnie Brown MIA 9

RB Tatum Bell DET 6

RB Lorenzo Booker MIA 9

WR Donald Driver GB 7

WR Santana Moss WAS 4

WR Santonio Holmes PIT 6

WR Joe Horn ATL 8

WR Arnaz Battle SF 6

WR Eric Parker SD 7

WR Mike Wallker CAR 7

TE Randy McMichael STL 9

TE Eric Johnson NO 4

DEF Pittsburgh Steelers 6

DEF Tennessee Titans 4

K John Kasay CAR 7

Grouse

QB Jake Delhomme CAR 7

QB Byron Leftwich JAX 4

QB Jeff Garcia TB 10

RB Brian Westbrook PHI 5

RB Edjerrin James ARZ 8

RB Cedric Benson CHI 9

RB Jamal Lewis CLE 7

WR Reggie Brown PHI 5

WR Donte Stallworth NE 10

WR Vincent Jackson SD 7

WR Brandon Jones TEN 4

WR Ronald Curry OAK 5

WR Patrick Crayton DAL 8

TE Dallas Clark IND 6

TE Greg Olsen CHI 9

DEF Minnesota Vikings 5

DEF Seattle Seahawks 8

K Rib Bironas TEN 4

Team Legacy

QB Eli Manning NYG 9

QB Brett Farve GB 7

QB Chad Pennington NYJ 10

RB Joseph Addai IND 6

RB Brandon Jacobs NYG 9

RB Chester Taylor MIN 5

WR Marvin Harrison IND 6

WR Marques Colston NO 4

WR Joey Galloway TB 10

WR Dwayne Bowe KC 8

WR Terrance Cooper NO 4

WR Derrick Hagan MIA 9

TE Tony Gonzales KC 8

TE Visanth Shiancoe MIN 5

DEF Miami Dolphins 9

DEF Oakland Raiders 5

K Neil Rackers ARZ 8

K Joe Nedney SF 6

Captain Hook

QB Jay Cutler DEN 6

QB Jason Campbell WAS 4

RB Reggie Bush NO 4

RB Marion Barber DAL 8

RB Julius Jones DAL 8

RB Reuben Droughns NYG 9

WR Reggie Wayne IND 6

WR TJ Houshmanzadeh CIN 5

WR Isaac Bruce STL 9

WR Drew Carter CAR 7

WR Bryant Johnson ARZ 8

WR Brad Smith NYJ 10

TE Kellen Winslow CLE 7

TE Ben Troupe TEN 4

DEF Denver Broncos 6

DEF Atlanta Falcons 8

K Josh Brown SEA 8

K Ryan Longwell GB 7

Pigskin Pimp

QB Peyton Manning IND 6

QB Damon Huard KC 8

RB Shaun Alexander SEA 8

RB LaMont Jordan OAK 5

RB Kevin Jones DET 6

RB Michael Turner SD 7

RB TJ Duckett DET 6

WR Andre Johnson HOU 10

WR Bernard Berrian CHI 9

WR Troy Williamson MIN 5

WR Anthony Gonzales IND 6

WR Nate Burleson SEA 8

TE Jeremy Shockey NYG 9

TE Daniel Graham DEN 6

DEF New England Patriots 10

DEF New Orlean Saints 4

K Nate Kaeding SD 7

K Josh Scobee JAX 4

Shadowmaster

QB Matt Hasselbeck SEA 8

QB Alex Smith SF 6

QB Rex Grossman CHI 9

RB Willie Parker PIT 6

RB Willis McGahee BUF 6

RB Lendale White TEN 4

WR Javon Walker DEN 6

WR Deion Branch SEA 8

WR Darrell Jackson SF 6

WR Michael Jenkins ATL 8

WR Ted Ginn Jr. MIA 9

KR Devin Hester CHI 9

WR David Givens TEN 4

TE Jason Witten DAL 8

DEF Chicago Bears 9

DEF Cincinnati Bengals 5

K Stephen Gostrowski NE 10

K Olindo Mare NO 4

Frank Black

QB Michael Vick ATL 8

QB Tony Romo DAL 8

RB Travis Henry DEN 6

RB Deuce McAllister NO 4

RB Chris Brown TEN 4

RB Anthony Thomas BUF 6

WR Steve Smith CAR 7

WR Laveranues Coles NYJ 10

WR Kevin Curtis STL 9

WR Mushin Muhammad CHI 9

WR Michael Clayton TB 10

WR Kevin Walter HOU 10

WR Hank Baskett PHI 5

TE Alge Crumpler ATL 8

TE Tony Scheffler DEN 6

DEF Philadelphia Eagles 5

K Jason Elam DEN 6

K Kris Brown HOU 10

ravnzfan

QB Vince Young TEN 4

QB Steve McNair BAL 8

RB Rudi Johnson CIN 5

RB Cadilliac Williams TB 10

RB Jerious Norwood ATL 8

RB Mewelde Moore MIN 5

WR Larry Fitzgerald ARZ 8

WR Hines Ward PIT 6

WR Brandon Marshall DEN 6

WR Mike Furrey DET 6

WR Marty Booker MIA 9

WR Chris Henry CIN 5

TE Ben Watson NE 10

TE David Martin MIA 9

DEF San Diego Chargers 7

DEF New York Giants 9

K Robbie Gould CHI 9

K Matt Stover BAL 8

radballs

QB Matt Leinart ARZ 8

QB JP Losman BUF 6

RB Maurice Drew-Jones JAX 4

RB DeAngelo Williams CAR 7

RB Warrick Dunn ATL 8

RB Mike Bell DEN 6

WR Chad Johnson CIN 5

WR Plaxico Burress NYG 9

WR Braylon Edwards CLE 7

WR Derrick Mason BAL 8

WR Brandon Lloyd WAS 4

WR Peerless Price BUF 6

TE LJ Smith PHI 5

TE Owen Daniels HOU 10

DEF Dallas Cowboys 8

DEF Tampa Bay Buccaneers 10

K Shane Graham CIN 5

K Jeff Reed PIT

rzrback77

QB Ben Roethlisberger PIT 6

QB Matt Schaub HOU 10

RB Marshall Lynch BUF 6

RB Ahmad Greeen HOU 10

RB DeShaun Foster CAR 7

RB Michael Pittman TB 10

WR Torry Holt STL 9

WR Mark Clayton BAL 8

WR Jerrico Cotchery NYJ 10

WR Joey Porter OAK 5

WR Drew Bennett STL 9

WR Dwayne Jarrett CAR 7

WR Robert Meachem NO 4

TE Antonio Gates SD 7

TE Zach Miller OAK 5

DEF Green Bay Packers 7

DEF Arizona Cardinals 8

K Mike Nugent NYJ 10

Pimpin'AintEasy

QB Carson Palmer CIN 5

QB Bradie Croyle KC 8

RB Clinton Portis WAS 4

RB Laurence Maroney NE 10

RB LaDell Betts WAS 4

RB Dominic Rhodes OAK 5

WR Chris Chambers MIA 9

WR Calvin Johnson DET 6

WR Devery Henderson NO 4

WR Matt Jones JAX 4

WR Reggie Williams JAX 4

WR Amani Toomer NYG 9

WR Steve Smith NYG 9

TE Todd Heap BAL 8

TE Alex Smith TB 10

DEF Indianapolis Colts 6

DEF Washington Redskins 4

K Jeff Wilkins STL 9

 
Last edited by a moderator:
My comments for each team. Nice draft everyone and good luck this season!

Family Matters

QB Donovan McNabb PHI 5

QB Phillip Rivers SD 7

RB LaDainian Tomlinson SD 7

RB Vernand Morency GB 7

RB Brandon Jackson GB 7

RB Corey Dillon FA ?

WR Anquan Boldin ARZ 8

WR Roy Williams DET 6

WR Terry Glenn DAL 8

WR Bobby Wade MIN 5

WR Craig Davis SD 7

WR Nate Washington PIT 6

TE Vernon Davis SF 6

TE Desmond Clark CHI 9

DEF Carolina Panthers 7

DEF Buffalo Bills 6

K Adam Vinateri IND 6

K Phil Dawson CLE 7

Fiddles

QB Tom Brady NE 10

QB Jon Kitna DET 6

RB Steven Jackson STL 9

RB Thomas Jones NYJ 10

RB Leon Washington NYJ 10

RB Adrian Peterson CHI 9

RB Brian Leonard STL 9

WR Lee Evans BUF 6

WR DJ Hackett SEA 8

WR Eddie Kennison KC 8

WR Sidney Rice MIN 5

WR Wes Welker NE 10

WR Demetrius Williams BAL 8

WR Maurice Stovall TB 10

TE Chris Cooley WAS 4

DEF Jacksonville Jaguars 4

DEF San Francisco 49ers 6

K David Akers PHI 5

I love your QB's. You should score very well all year. I also like your RB's. WR has a few question marks but Evans isn't one of them. DJ should do well but the rest leave you with some worries. Some worry about Kennison but I think he'll be ok and should still garner 800+ yards which isn't bad for your WR3. If Stoval emerges as a starter then you might find this group more likeable. Only 1 TE and PK leave you somewhat vulnerable so you're banking on no injuries to these 2. That's just uncomfortable.

valence

QB Marc Bulger STL 9

QB Tavaris Jackson MIN 5

RB Larry Johnson KC 8

RB Adrian Peterson MIN 5

RB Fred Taylor JAX 4

RB Kevin Faulk NE 10

WR Terrell Owens DAL 8

WR Randy Moss NE 10

WR Greg Jennings GB 7

WR Bobby Engram SEA 8

WR Joe Jurivicius CLE 7

WR Tab Perry CIN 5

WR Justin Gage TEN 4

TE Heath Miller PIT 6

TE Marcus Pollard SEA 8

DEF Baltimore Ravens 8

DEF New York Jets 10

K Jason Hanson DET 6

I like this team except for your TE's. Bulger is a top 5 but Jackson is a big concern for playing and performance. AP will play but I think Taylor will steal significant touches this year. More like Bush and Duece last year so he will be used a lot. I'm a big LJ fan so you're sitting good with potentially the #1 RB this year. Your WR corp is very good if Moss comes through, and he should. Engram is a nice fit in this format as he will give you some usable games all year long. He's very underrated this year. Your TE's may disappoint you. Miller is not a top 10 and Pollard will have a similar year. So you might find yourself wishing you had something more but I think you're RB2 will make upo for it for you. Nice team.

Twilight

QB Drew Brees NO 4

QB Trent Green MIA 9

RB Frank Gore SF 6

RB Ronnie Brown MIA 9

RB Tatum Bell DET 6

RB Lorenzo Booker MIA 9

WR Donald Driver GB 7

WR Santana Moss WAS 4

WR Santonio Holmes PIT 6

WR Joe Horn ATL 8

WR Arnaz Battle SF 6

WR Eric Parker SD 7

WR Mike Wallker CAR 7

TE Randy McMichael STL 9

TE Eric Johnson NO 4

DEF Pittsburgh Steelers 6

DEF Tennessee Titans 4

K John Kasay CAR 7

First off, congrats on your team and your vacation. For having limited access you did a great job. I would of had difficulty drafting with limited access. QB is sweet with Brees. RB may be one of the best if Brown performs top 12. Then if Bell becomes a player in Det you've got a great group. I really like your WR's. Solid starting group and depth. Your TE combo is pretty good as well. They have some nice upside. If Pitts is their usuall strong D then you can have some great weeks from them as well.

Grouse

QB Jake Delhomme CAR 7

QB Byron Leftwich JAX 4

QB Jeff Garcia TB 10

RB Brian Westbrook PHI 5

RB Edjerrin James ARZ 8

RB Cedric Benson CHI 9

RB Jamal Lewis CLE 7

WR Reggie Brown PHI 5

WR Donte Stallworth NE 10

WR Vincent Jackson SD 7

WR Brandon Jones TEN 4

WR Ronald Curry OAK 5

WR Patrick Crayton DAL 8

TE Dallas Clark IND 6

TE Greg Olsen CHI 9

DEF Minnesota Vikings 5

DEF Seattle Seahawks 8

K Rib Bironas TEN 4

Obviously the RB's are strong. But I think you hurt your team's overall strength in order to have depth. Who knows if that will pan out for you but I feel like you put your team in a huge hole to start. Your QB's have depth but no one that will score for you so you will suffer all year. RB is great and I think Edge is in for a solid year. I'm not a Brown fan for your WR's and Stallworth will only get check down looks most of the time as Moss will be the main target. A guy I really like and wanted was Curry. I think he's a steal and might help you immensely. TE is ok but will be better if Olsen gets the looks. All in all this team will compete but unless these QB's can outperform every week you'll be in trouble. It's possible but I'm not hopeful with what we know right now.

Team Legacy

QB Eli Manning NYG 9

QB Brett Farve GB 7

QB Chad Pennington NYJ 10

RB Joseph Addai IND 6

RB Brandon Jacobs NYG 9

RB Chester Taylor MIN 5

WR Marvin Harrison IND 6

WR Marques Colston NO 4

WR Joey Galloway TB 10

WR Dwayne Bowe KC 8

WR Terrance Cooper NO 4

WR Derrick Hagan MIA 9

TE Tony Gonzales KC 8

TE Visanth Shiancoe MIN 5

DEF Miami Dolphins 9

DEF Oakland Raiders 5

K Neil Rackers ARZ 8

K Joe Nedney SF 6

I'm sure the first criticism of this team from most will be the RB's with only 3. But I like what you've done. All 3 are solid and will provide solid scoring all year. As long as 2 stay healthy (I know that's a concern) you'll be fine. Your QB's are a very good group and that will help. WR is a nice group as well and you have some key depth protecting Colston with Cooper. Nice move. TE is one of the best and PK will provide very good upside weeks as well. Nice team overall.

Captain Hook

QB Jay Cutler DEN 6

QB Jason Campbell WAS 4

RB Reggie Bush NO 4

RB Marion Barber DAL 8

RB Julius Jones DAL 8

RB Reuben Droughns NYG 9

WR Reggie Wayne IND 6

WR TJ Houshmanzadeh CIN 5

WR Isaac Bruce STL 9

WR Drew Carter CAR 7

WR Bryant Johnson ARZ 8

WR Brad Smith NYJ 10

TE Kellen Winslow CLE 7

TE Ben Troupe TEN 4

DEF Denver Broncos 6

DEF Atlanta Falcons 8

K Josh Brown SEA 8

K Ryan Longwell GB 7

All in alll I like this team. I understand your concern about QB but I really like Cutler this year. Campbell is the one I'm most worried about but I really don't see him as a risk of playing but rather as a performance risk. My greatest concern for your team is at TE. Winslow is not a lock to play this year let alone 16 games. In fact Troupe has injury worries as well so that leaves you in tight nut at TE. I will say however, if KWII starts all year you should be in great shape.

Pigskin Pimp

QB Peyton Manning IND 6

QB Damon Huard KC 8

RB Shaun Alexander SEA 8

RB LaMont Jordan OAK 5

RB Kevin Jones DET 6

RB Michael Turner SD 7

RB TJ Duckett DET 6

WR Andre Johnson HOU 10

WR Bernard Berrian CHI 9

WR Troy Williamson MIN 5

WR Anthony Gonzales IND 6

WR Nate Burleson SEA 8

TE Jeremy Shockey NYG 9

TE Daniel Graham DEN 6

DEF New England Patriots 10

DEF New Orlean Saints 4

K Nate Kaeding SD 7

K Josh Scobee JAX 4

Didn't know the rules? No comment. ;) Gotta love Manning. No doubt what he'll do for you. Getting Alexander at 8 is an absolute steal. Nice bargin. Jordan and Jones have big question marks but I must say that if just 1 of them performs then you are in great shape. WR is likely a problem. I love AJ but the rest is a big issue. As for your comment that if you knew it was best ball you would have drafted differently, then I have to wonder what you were thinking when you drafted Williamson and Berrian as starters? :drive: What exactly is it about them that makes you feel they are starter material? Best ball may save you on them but you're still in trouble.I agree that TE is a strength for sure. Graham will make some nice games until Scheffler comes back. And yes NE will be a nice play this year. But I really feel you will lose this because of your WR's.

Shadowmaster

QB Matt Hasselbeck SEA 8

QB Alex Smith SF 6

QB Rex Grossman CHI 9

RB Willie Parker PIT 6

RB Willis McGahee BUF 6

RB Lendale White TEN 4

WR Javon Walker DEN 6

WR Deion Branch SEA 8

WR Darrell Jackson SF 6

WR Michael Jenkins ATL 8

WR Ted Ginn Jr. MIA 9

KR Devin Hester CHI 9

WR David Givens TEN 4

TE Jason Witten DAL 8

DEF Chicago Bears 9

DEF Cincinnati Bengals 5

K Stephen Gostrowski NE 10

K Olindo Mare NO 4

Like TL the first criticism will likely be the RB, or lack thereof. However, unlike TL I don't really think you accomplished what he did. White will not see enough carries early on to help much. I'm not sure that will change much later either but who knows. Still, if Parker and McGahee remain healthy all year you should be ok. I like your WR group. You got Jackson at a point that he will easily outperform his draft position. Ginn might surprise this year. He's that good. QB has good play and depth and is another strength for you. Going Witten alone might be problamatic wekk to week. I know he'll have some good weeks just not sure if he'll be consistent enought for you. Your D's may bail you out. Cinn can have some big games when healthy. Chicago won't be as strong as last year as they've had too many changes. But they're still very good.

Frank Black

QB Michael Vick ATL 8

QB Tony Romo DAL 8

RB Travis Henry DEN 6

RB Deuce McAllister NO 4

RB Chris Brown TEN 4

RB Anthony Thomas BUF 6

WR Steve Smith CAR 7

WR Laveranues Coles NYJ 10

WR Kevin Curtis STL 9

WR Mushin Muhammad CHI 9

WR Michael Clayton TB 10

WR Kevin Walter HOU 10

WR Hank Baskett PHI 5

TE Alge Crumpler ATL 8

TE Tony Scheffler DEN 6

DEF Philadelphia Eagles 5

K Jason Elam DEN 6

K Kris Brown HOU 10

QB makes you wonder about Vick. I am avoid ing as usual but this year he might not actually play 16 games. Even if he does he'll being dodging the media all year and will be distracted to the point of suffering on the field I'm afarid. OTOH-I really like Romo. RB isn't spectatular but very solid and should allow for some nice scoring. I love your WR's. Very good group and I think Curtis is seriously undervalued. Remember that Reid left is family (from that all important family sabattical crisis) to talk to Curtis. They really like him so he'll get plenty of looks. I like the TE's as well especially if Scheffler makes a full recovery. Relying on 1 D might be an issue but you can survive that.

ravnzfan

QB Vince Young TEN 4

QB Steve McNair BAL 8

RB Rudi Johnson CIN 5

RB Cadilliac Williams TB 10

RB Jerious Norwood ATL 8

RB Mewelde Moore MIN 5

WR Larry Fitzgerald ARZ 8

WR Hines Ward PIT 6

WR Brandon Marshall DEN 6

WR Mike Furrey DET 6

WR Marty Booker MIA 9

WR Chris Henry CIN 5

TE Ben Watson NE 10

TE David Martin MIA 9

DEF San Diego Chargers 7

DEF New York Giants 9

K Robbie Gould CHI 9

K Matt Stover BAL 8

I'm really worried about Young. I know he will make plays with his feet but I wonder if that'll be enough. Teams may be on to him because he's not a good passer and he has no one that will scare D's. They may play to stop his running. If that happens he's in for a long season. I like Rudi and he's consistent. Caddy is one that disappoints and I think he still will. Your WR's will be solid if Marshall pans out. If Henry comes back the 2nd half and you're still in the hunt this team might be very dangerous.

radballs

QB Matt Leinart ARZ 8

QB JP Losman BUF 6

RB Maurice Drew-Jones JAX 4

RB DeAngelo Williams CAR 7

RB Warrick Dunn ATL 8

RB Mike Bell DEN 6

WR Chad Johnson CIN 5

WR Plaxico Burress NYG 9

WR Braylon Edwards CLE 7

WR Derrick Mason BAL 8

WR Brandon Lloyd WAS 4

WR Peerless Price BUF 6

TE LJ Smith PHI 5

TE Owen Daniels HOU 10

DEF Dallas Cowboys 8

DEF Tampa Bay Buccaneers 10

K Shane Graham CIN 5

K Jeff Reed PIT

Your QB's don't excite but they should provide decent scoring all year. Leinart has some nice upside. RB is the part I question the most. Part of me says MJD will not perform like he did last year. Slitting with a Taylor is 1 thing but expecting him to have a few of the games they did last year isn't very likely and that alone should cause dissapointment. DWil provides similar questions but for different reasons. If he gets 200 touches then you'll get some nice scoring. Just not sure that will happen. Dunn was nice value where you got him. Not sure why people think he won't get 225+ carries again. He's going to do just fine. Your WR corp is solid. You'll be pleased with this group all year. TE will be up and down but I think for where you drafted LJ you'll love his good weeks. Daniels might surprise some. I really don't know if Schaub will go to him or not but he has potential to do very well. You should compete all year and if RB pans out you could be a very dangerous team.

rzrback77

QB Ben Roethlisberger PIT 6

QB Matt Schaub HOU 10

RB Marshall Lynch BUF 6

RB Ahmad Greeen HOU 10

RB DeShaun Foster CAR 7

RB Michael Pittman TB 10

WR Torry Holt STL 9

WR Mark Clayton BAL 8

WR Jerrico Cotchery NYJ 10

WR Joey Porter OAK 5

WR Drew Bennett STL 9

WR Dwayne Jarrett CAR 7

WR Robert Meachem NO 4

TE Antonio Gates SD 7

TE Zach Miller OAK 5

DEF Green Bay Packers 7

DEF Arizona Cardinals 8

K Mike Nugent NYJ 10

I agree that WR is your strength along with TE. Gates will carry you a long way. Your top 3 WR's are sweet and Bennett will surprise and give some nice weeks. I really don't like 2 rookies in this format but they might help. They really have upside. It's just that rookies don't usually do well their couple of years. QB might hamper you unless Schaub surprises. Ben will be incocnsistent. RB is a big question mark but I think Lynch is the key. He may do well in Buff if he gets enough touches. Expect Green to do well too.

Pimpin'AintEasy

QB Carson Palmer CIN 5

QB Bradie Croyle KC 8

RB Clinton Portis WAS 4

RB Laurence Maroney NE 10

RB LaDell Betts WAS 4

RB Dominic Rhodes OAK 5

WR Chris Chambers MIA 9

WR Calvin Johnson DET 6

WR Devery Henderson NO 4

WR Matt Jones JAX 4

WR Reggie Williams JAX 4

WR Amani Toomer NYG 9

WR Steve Smith NYG 9

TE Todd Heap BAL 8

TE Alex Smith TB 10

DEF Indianapolis Colts 6

DEF Washington Redskins 4

K Jeff Wilkins STL 9

I love Palmer but you might be hrting on his bye as Croyle probably isn't the starter in KC. Won't really matter however cause that's just 1 week. RB play looks solid. Portis and Maroney may both be undervalued. If they stay healthy you will score nicely. You have lots of questionn marks at WR. Will Chambers rebound? Will CJ fall victim to the rookie jinx? If they come throug, and I think they will then this group is solid. Henderson may in fact be the starter in NO and he can produce some big games. Toomer should rebound and do decently. TE is solid with Heap. You did what some others did and cheated at PK so hopefully that will work out.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
radballs

QB Matt Leinart ARZ 8

QB JP Losman BUF 6

RB Maurice Drew-Jones JAX 4

RB DeAngelo Williams CAR 7

RB Warrick Dunn ATL 8

RB Mike Bell DEN 6

WR Chad Johnson CIN 5

WR Plaxico Burress NYG 9

WR Braylon Edwards CLE 7

WR Derrick Mason BAL 8

WR Brandon Lloyd WAS 4

WR Peerless Price BUF 6

TE LJ Smith PHI 5

TE Owen Daniels HOU 10

DEF Dallas Cowboys 8

DEF Tampa Bay Buccaneers 10

K Shane Graham CIN 5

K Jeff Reed PIT

 
Thanks for the analysis FM. I happen to agree with just about all of it too.

Just for ####s and giggles I looked at some team analysis through the DD.

The top 3 in team strength for starters only was:

1. FM - 1991

2. Shadowmaster - 1989

3. Team Legacy - 1989

The top 3 in team strength for total team strength was:

1. Capt Hook - 2720

2. radballs - 2714

3. FM - 2647

If I had the schedule, I could take the SOS data and make predictions on records and playoff participants for fun. It does a predicted amount of total points for each team by week and a grand total for the season.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks for the analysis FM. I happen to agree with just about all of it too. Just for ####s and giggles I looked at some team analysis through the DD.The top 3 in team strength for starters only was:1. FM - 1991 #1 slot2. Shadowmaster - 1989 #9 slot3. Team Legacy - 1989 #6 slotThe top 3 in team strength for total team strength was:1. Capt Hook - 2720 #7 slot2. radballs - 2714 #12 slot3. FM - 2647 #1 slotIf I had the schedule, I could take the SOS data and make predictions on records and playoff participants for fun. It does a predicted amount of total points for each team by week and a grand total for the season.
Nice job Rads. I added the draft slots to see how this wroked out. This proves how good the owners in this draft are. We don't yet know how everything will shake out but this illustrates that value can be found from top to bottom.
 
I'm sitting here trying to pick apart these rosters, but I might as well :wall:

What I know in year 3 is that everyone looks good this time of year. Everyone has some plus points. We should - we all pay alot of attention to this stuff! :porked:

Random Opinions

grouse has the strongest RB stable

Radballs has the best WR corps

I like PAE's starting RB set of Moreny and Portis

I like Vals cobo of Bulger, LJ, TO, and Moss - could be VERY tough

To analyze further today - I'm going to ignore all of the ? players, and focus on the deeper areas of the score card. Specifically QB1, RB2, WR3, and TE1

Obvisously, since I picked them AND focused my draft on these areas - I like my sqaud here.

Shadow: Hass, McGahee, DJax, Witten

Others who look strong right now IMO:

Fiddles: Brady, T.Jones, Kinneson, and Cooley

Radballs: Leinart, Dunn/DWill, B.Edwards/Mason, LJ

Rzrback: Roth, Green/Foster, Crothery, Gates

GONNA BE FUN - THIS I DO KNOW!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Family, it's interesting what you say about my QBs. In some ways, I actually think of Romo as my #1QB. However, I believe that Vick is one of the best QBs to have in non-lineup format as long as you have a good reliable #2. When Vick goes off, he puts up fantastic numbers.

Romo is reliable and has big games himself. I actually believe that except week 8, I have one of the best QB tandems in the league. I can't say that about my other positions though.

 
Family, it's interesting what you say about my QBs. In some ways, I actually think of Romo as my #1QB. However, I believe that Vick is one of the best QBs to have in non-lineup format as long as you have a good reliable #2. When Vick goes off, he puts up fantastic numbers. Romo is reliable and has big games himself. I actually believe that except week 8, I have one of the best QB tandems in the league. I can't say that about my other positions though.
I will say this and that is if Vick is good for 16 games then you do have one of the best tandems for sure. No doubt Vick will give you a few great games. It's the other weeks when he "no shows" that leaves you with that empty feeling. The inconsistency is what I worry about with him. As for Romo, I really like him and think he will do well this year. Considering what he did last year you have to like his propects this year.
 
Hey Guys,

Cap'n Hook asked me to check in if I had the chance.

As you've probably figured out as of late, I was pretty busy (and probably will be) getting O.F.F.E.R. off of the ground. That's one of the reasons I bowed out for this year.

Feel free to let me know what you think of the concept.

As for the Reunion teams, I'll walk thru it now and comment.

 
Family Matters

QB Donovan McNabb PHI 5

QB Phillip Rivers SD 7

RB LaDainian Tomlinson SD 7

RB Vernand Morency GB 7

RB Brandon Jackson GB 7

RB Corey Dillon FA ?

WR Anquan Boldin ARZ 8

WR Roy Williams DET 6

WR Terry Glenn DAL 8

WR Bobby Wade MIN 5

WR Craig Davis SD 7

WR Nate Washington PIT 6

TE Vernon Davis SF 6

TE Desmond Clark CHI 9

DEF Carolina Panthers 7

DEF Buffalo Bills 6

K Adam Vinateri IND 6

K Phil Dawson CLE 7
I'm sure you are shocked to hear I don't like Rivers - but I do like McNabb. Playoffs should reward you if you get there.Dillon might be a wasted pick.

WTF did you do here for RB week 7? Giving up that week?

I guess in H2H you can try this but that seems like a very weird strategy. :goodposting:

First 3 WRs look good, not a fan of MIN or SD WRs this year. NWash is a good pick.

Nice TEs, Good D and K.

The RB still has me puzzled and not a fan of the WR depth. Decent team / leaning good with McNabb and LT2.

I'll give it a "B" for those two, but I think it could have turned out better.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Fiddles

QB Tom Brady NE 10

QB Jon Kitna DET 6

RB Steven Jackson STL 9

RB Thomas Jones NYJ 10

RB Leon Washington NYJ 10

RB Adrian Peterson CHI 9

RB Brian Leonard STL 9

WR Lee Evans BUF 6

WR DJ Hackett SEA 8

WR Eddie Kennison KC 8

WR Sidney Rice MIN 5

WR Wes Welker NE 10

WR Demetrius Williams BAL 8

WR Maurice Stovall TB 10

TE Chris Cooley WAS 4

DEF Jacksonville Jaguars 4

DEF San Francisco 49ers 6

K David Akers PHI 5
Brady and Kitna. VERY nice.SJax/Leonard, TJones/LWash, AP (1.0). Also well played.

WRs are a little thin, as one might expect with such prowess at QB and RB. Week 8 looks rough, but Evans and Hackett with Kennison or DemWill contributing looks ok.

Cooley, 2 Ds, and Akers. Some depth would be nice (maybe drop a WR or RB) but not bad.

Pretty good team. "B+"

 
valence

QB Marc Bulger STL 9

QB Tavaris Jackson MIN 5

RB Larry Johnson KC 8

RB Adrian Peterson MIN 5

RB Fred Taylor JAX 4

RB Kevin Faulk NE 10

WR Terrell Owens DAL 8

WR Randy Moss NE 10

WR Greg Jennings GB 7

WR Bobby Engram SEA 8

WR Joe Jurivicius CLE 7

WR Tab Perry CIN 5

WR Justin Gage TEN 4

TE Heath Miller PIT 6

TE Marcus Pollard SEA 8

DEF Baltimore Ravens 8

DEF New York Jets 10

K Jason Hanson DET 6
Bulger is $ and I like Tarv. LJ, AP (2.0)/ADP and Fraud - I like that.

WRs - TO, Moss and Jennings are a nice 1-2-3. Decent contributions maybe from 4/5, but not sold on Perry or Gage. Might have sured up another spot.

TEs are good, as is D. A second K would be nice, but not mandatory.

Good team - should be very competitive. "A-".

 
Twilight

QB Drew Brees NO 4

QB Trent Green MIA 9

RB Frank Gore SF 6

RB Ronnie Brown MIA 9

RB Tatum Bell DET 6

RB Lorenzo Booker MIA 9

WR Donald Driver GB 7

WR Santana Moss WAS 4

WR Santonio Holmes PIT 6

WR Joe Horn ATL 8

WR Arnaz Battle SF 6

WR Eric Parker SD 7

WR Mike Wallker CAR 7

TE Randy McMichael STL 9

TE Eric Johnson NO 4

DEF Pittsburgh Steelers 6

DEF Tennessee Titans 4

K John Kasay CAR 7

Huh - cut and paste works with color and all - who knew.

Brees and Green - good 1-2.

Gore/TB/Brown/Booker - interesting. Some health concerns and KJ may be an issue, but pretty good.

Driver/SMoss/Holmes - I really like these 3 this year. Holmes should break out nicely if PITT really throws more, and SMoss will benefit with a TC with Campbell.

Horn and Battle are solid 4/5s. Not a fan of SD, but Eric Parker at 6 is hard to argue.

Mike Walker could be a waste.

Eric Johnson could be WAY overrated. I've heard that he still has to beat out Miller. RMike w/Linehan should do well.

Kasay's good - I like 2 Ks more often than not.

Two good Ds - quite good.

16 teams and you'll never have a truly studly team, but this is a pretty good team. I like to overall, warts and all (QB, RB could be better, as could TE2 and a 2nd K instead of Walker). Overall, very competitive.

"A".

 
Grouse

QB Jake Delhomme CAR 7

QB Byron Leftwich JAX 4

QB Jeff Garcia TB 10

RB Brian Westbrook PHI 5

RB Edjerrin James ARZ 8

RB Cedric Benson CHI 9

RB Jamal Lewis CLE 7

WR Reggie Brown PHI 5

WR Donte Stallworth NE 10

WR Vincent Jackson SD 7

WR Brandon Jones TEN 4

WR Ronald Curry OAK 5

WR Patrick Crayton DAL 8

TE Dallas Clark IND 6

TE Greg Olsen CHI 9

DEF Minnesota Vikings 5

DEF Seattle Seahawks 8

K Rib Bironas TEN 4
3 QBs - interesting. Seems like overkill.Solid quartet at RB.

Brown as a #1 WR - seems like asking a bit much. Donte when healthy can be good. VJax at 3. I think WRs overall look shaky here.

TE - good pair. Clark needs to be healthy.

D - Seattle should do most of the work here.

PK - Only 1 again in Bironas. Not sure if I'd trade QB3 for K2.

Overall pretty good aside from WRs. That could be a downfall. "B-" as a result as WRs are key to this.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Team Legacy

QB Eli Manning NYG 9

QB Brett Farve GB 7

QB Chad Pennington NYJ 10

RB Joseph Addai IND 6

RB Brandon Jacobs NYG 9

RB Chester Taylor MIN 5

WR Marvin Harrison IND 6

WR Marques Colston NO 4

WR Joey Galloway TB 10

WR Dwayne Bowe KC 8

WR Terrance Cooper NO 4

WR Derrick Hagan MIA 9

TE Tony Gonzales KC 8

TE Visanth Shiancoe MIN 5

DEF Miami Dolphins 9

DEF Oakland Raiders 5

K Neil Rackers ARZ 8

K Joe Nedney SF 6
Let's see how our GB TL did here....3 QBs - not sure I get this strategy. I do like the 3-some though. I'd say Favre is starting all 16 and Eli will "start" whenever Favre doesn't do well - so I'm saying QB3 (Chad) was a waste.

3 RBs - here's the price you paid. No sure if the well ran dry at RB4, but I'd have found one if I could. Penny at QB is a nice value, but RB2 needed the help. I'm not sold on Jacobs and I think CT may be riding pine more come the 2nd half of the year. With good odds 1 of these 3 lose time to injury, 3 RBs feels risky.

WRs - looking good here. Colston (with Copper to back up), Harrison and Galloway. Rock solid. Bowe at 4. Don't like Hagan, but WR6 - mostly a "whatever" in this group.

TE - Gonzo and Shiancoe - I like that pair.

Two good and underrated Ds in Miami and Oakland. Kickers also good.

Overall, I give it an "A-/B+" with my only issue RB depth. Overall, nice job and should compete - as long as the RBs stay healthy.

 
Captain Hook

QB Jay Cutler DEN 6

QB Jason Campbell WAS 4

RB Reggie Bush NO 4

RB Marion Barber DAL 8

RB Julius Jones DAL 8

RB Reuben Droughns NYG 9

WR Reggie Wayne IND 6

WR TJ Houshmanzadeh CIN 5

WR Isaac Bruce STL 9

WR Drew Carter CAR 7

WR Bryant Johnson ARZ 8

WR Brad Smith NYJ 10

TE Kellen Winslow CLE 7

TE Ben Troupe TEN 4

DEF Denver Broncos 6

DEF Atlanta Falcons 8

K Josh Brown SEA 8

K Ryan Longwell GB 7
Cutler and Campbell are an interesting pair. Both 2nd year players with a partial year under center, I think these are high risk/reward picks. Hopefully both don't tank in the same week.Good RBs, covering the Dallas running game and Reggie Bush. Nice group here with Droughns as the 4th.

WRs - excellent group. Wayne and Housh, along with either Drew Carter or Isaac Bruce. Johnson and Smith are afterthoughts with those 4.

TE - Shaky health with KW2 and then Troupe had ankle issues last year.

D - DEN /ATL should be a nice pair.

PK - Two starters that are pretty good.

Overall a good team - with some weaknesses at QB and TE(s). The team is pretty good otherwise and outstanding at WR. I give it a "B+" hoping that the QBBC does ok.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pigskin Pimp

QB Peyton Manning IND 6

QB Damon Huard KC 8

RB Shaun Alexander SEA 8

RB LaMont Jordan OAK 5

RB Kevin Jones DET 6

RB Michael Turner SD 7

RB TJ Duckett DET 6

WR Andre Johnson HOU 10

WR Bernard Berrian CHI 9

WR Troy Williamson MIN 5

WR Anthony Gonzales IND 6

WR Nate Burleson SEA 8

TE Jeremy Shockey NYG 9

TE Daniel Graham DEN 6

DEF New England Patriots 10

DEF New Orlean Saints 4

K Nate Kaeding SD 7

K Josh Scobee JAX 4
Manning and Huard. With Peyton you almost don't need a QB2 - hence you waited and just grabbed Huard. He would be lucky to post 1 score for you.5 RBs - Good RBs, but 5 seems like 1 too many. SA and LamJ with KJ - this might be the best group in the league. Turner and Duckett at insurance is fine, but it's quite possible neither ever post a score.

WRs - 5 - Here's the issue. 5 is shallow, especially these 5. I'll give you AJ as a #1 and I'll even flex enough to say Berrian can be #2, but where's the 3rd? Three reaches IMHO to try and get a 3rd, probably too late.

TE - I like these two, but I think Graham's contributions are short lived until a Scheffler's health is 100%.

D - NE is good and NO gives you Bush for cheap.

PK - Two starters.

Overall a good team - except at WR. That's the big Achilles' heel. If they were better this is an "A" caliber team - but they aren't. As such, "C".

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Captain Hook said:
Jeff Pasquino said:
Jeff - THANKS VERY MUCH for the contributions. :eek: Sure we all look forward to the next batch. :thumbup: Good Luck with OFFERS (guess I HAVE to join) :yes:
Thanks on all fronts.Hopefully these Survivors will be included somehow in OFFER next year :eek: .I'll try and do the 2nd half as I watch guys turning left this evening. (That's NASCAR....)
 
Jeff Pasquino said:
Family Matters

QB Donovan McNabb PHI 5

QB Phillip Rivers SD 7

RB LaDainian Tomlinson SD 7

RB Vernand Morency GB 7

RB Brandon Jackson GB 7

RB Corey Dillon FA ?

WR Anquan Boldin ARZ 8

WR Roy Williams DET 6

WR Terry Glenn DAL 8

WR Bobby Wade MIN 5

WR Craig Davis SD 7

WR Nate Washington PIT 6

TE Vernon Davis SF 6

TE Desmond Clark CHI 9

DEF Carolina Panthers 7

DEF Buffalo Bills 6

K Adam Vinateri IND 6

K Phil Dawson CLE 7
I'm sure you are shocked to hear I don't like Rivers - but I do like McNabb. Playoffs should reward you if you get there.Dillon might be a wasted pick.

WTF did you do here for RB week 7? Giving up that week?

I guess in H2H you can try this but that seems like a very weird strategy. :thumbup:

First 3 WRs look good, not a fan of MIN or SD WRs this year. NWash is a good pick.

Nice TEs, Good D and K.

The RB still has me puzzled and not a fan of the WR depth. Decent team / leaning good with McNabb and LT2.

I'll give it a "B" for those two, but I think it could have turned out better.
Thanks for the feedback Jeff. To answer some of your questions:The RB issues are not as worrisome to me as you. Week 7 is a bit of a blow off I agree but I think that's going to be fine. You can earn a playoff spot by having 1 of the 2 best records or highest remaining top scoring team. Knowing I can finish 3rd or lower in record and still earn a playoff spot I decided to not be too concerned about the wekk 7 byes. Considering I probably locked up the GB running game (and that's usually good numbers) by drafting Morency in the 6th and Jackson in the 9th, I think that's good value. In this format (bestball) it doesn't matter which one becomes the man. As for Dillon, he may not amount to anything but I got him in the 15th round (very low risk) so if he doesn't pan out it's no big deal. Or he might end up in GB. Besides, what was left to pick from after the 6th round they had just as many question marks and I wouldn't of had the RBBC locked up as I do in this situation.

My QB situation is something I really like. Not a big Rivers fan either but as my QB2, I love him. Also, I'm one of the few that think McNabb will be just fine this year.

Finally, in a 14 team league, no one has great starters at every position and depth as well. I think I balanced this very nicely. My starting WR's are good as any, not the best but very good, and I still grabbed some starters, although not exciting, to add to my depth. So I'm feeling pretty good now that I've had time to reflect. I think this team can win if:

1. McNabb is healthy.

2. I indeed have the GB RBBC solved.

3. Roy Williams stays healthy.

Not a ton of question marks but still I think those will be the key.

 
Jeff Pasquino said:
Family Matters

QB Donovan McNabb PHI 5

QB Phillip Rivers SD 7

RB LaDainian Tomlinson SD 7

RB Vernand Morency GB 7

RB Brandon Jackson GB 7

RB Corey Dillon FA ?

WR Anquan Boldin ARZ 8

WR Roy Williams DET 6

WR Terry Glenn DAL 8

WR Bobby Wade MIN 5

WR Craig Davis SD 7

WR Nate Washington PIT 6

TE Vernon Davis SF 6

TE Desmond Clark CHI 9

DEF Carolina Panthers 7

DEF Buffalo Bills 6

K Adam Vinateri IND 6

K Phil Dawson CLE 7
I'm sure you are shocked to hear I don't like Rivers - but I do like McNabb. Playoffs should reward you if you get there.Dillon might be a wasted pick.

WTF did you do here for RB week 7? Giving up that week?

I guess in H2H you can try this but that seems like a very weird strategy. :lmao:

First 3 WRs look good, not a fan of MIN or SD WRs this year. NWash is a good pick.

Nice TEs, Good D and K.

The RB still has me puzzled and not a fan of the WR depth. Decent team / leaning good with McNabb and LT2.

I'll give it a "B" for those two, but I think it could have turned out better.
Thanks for the feedback Jeff. To answer some of your questions:The RB issues are not as worrisome to me as you. Week 7 is a bit of a blow off I agree but I think that's going to be fine. You can earn a playoff spot by having 1 of the 2 best records or highest remaining top scoring team. Knowing I can finish 3rd or lower in record and still earn a playoff spot I decided to not be too concerned about the wekk 7 byes. Considering I probably locked up the GB running game (and that's usually good numbers) by drafting Morency in the 6th and Jackson in the 9th, I think that's good value. In this format (bestball) it doesn't matter which one becomes the man. As for Dillon, he may not amount to anything but I got him in the 15th round (very low risk) so if he doesn't pan out it's no big deal. Or he might end up in GB. Besides, what was left to pick from after the 6th round they had just as many question marks and I wouldn't of had the RBBC locked up as I do in this situation.

My QB situation is something I really like. Not a big Rivers fan either but as my QB2, I love him. Also, I'm one of the few that think McNabb will be just fine this year.

Finally, in a 14 team league, no one has great starters at every position and depth as well. I think I balanced this very nicely. My starting WR's are good as any, not the best but very good, and I still grabbed some starters, although not exciting, to add to my depth. So I'm feeling pretty good now that I've had time to reflect. I think this team can win if:

1. McNabb is healthy.

2. I indeed have the GB RBBC solved.

3. Roy Williams stays healthy.

Not a ton of question marks but still I think those will be the key.
FM - are you drinking again? "WR's are as good as any, not the best" - if they are as good as any (and they are not), they would be the best.
 
Shadowmaster

QB Matt Hasselbeck SEA 8

QB Alex Smith SF 6

QB Rex Grossman CHI 9

RB Willie Parker PIT 6

RB Willis McGahee BUF 6

RB Lendale White TEN 4

WR Javon Walker DEN 6

WR Deion Branch SEA 8

WR Darrell Jackson SF 6

WR Michael Jenkins ATL 8

WR Ted Ginn Jr. MIA 9

KR Devin Hester CHI 9

WR David Givens TEN 4

TE Jason Witten DAL 8

DEF Chicago Bears 9

DEF Cincinnati Bengals 5

K Stephen Gostrowski NE 10

K Olindo Mare NO 4
3QBs - Interesting. I like Hass and I really like Rexy in best ball, so I'm confused by having 3. This is compounded by only 3 RBs, two of which that also share a bye. Seven WRs helps, but not just ANY seven. Givens is likely to be a wasted pick, and I don't trust Ginn to contribute much. I'm not high on Walker (he actually did worse with Cutler than with Plummer) and DJax is hurt once again (shocker), so this group looks like a weakness when it should have been a strength.Witten was a good choice, but no backup might hurt. With the Bears at D and other weaknesses, two Ds and two Ks at the expense of other depth also look like bad decisions.

I don't like this team at all, sorry. I'll be kind and just give a "C-".

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Frank Black

QB Michael Vick ATL 8

QB Tony Romo DAL 8

RB Travis Henry DEN 6

RB Deuce McAllister NO 4

RB Chris Brown TEN 4

RB Anthony Thomas BUF 6

WR Steve Smith CAR 7

WR Laveranues Coles NYJ 10

WR Kevin Curtis STL 9

WR Mushin Muhammad CHI 9

WR Michael Clayton TB 10

WR Kevin Walter HOU 10

WR Hank Baskett PHI 5

TE Alge Crumpler ATL 8

TE Tony Scheffler DEN 6

DEF Philadelphia Eagles 5

K Jason Elam DEN 6

K Kris Brown HOU 10
QBs - Vick and Romo. Great duo except for that "who plays Week 8" issue. (I just drafted in a staff league and was looking at both - saying I can only get one due to that bye week). Curious what the plan was there.RBs - THenry could be Shanny's man, but is he done with RBBC? Only he knows.... Deuce is $ and I think A-Train gets much more work than many think. CBrown should be hurt by the time I'm done typing.

WR - Baskett!!!! :unsure: Ok seriously, SSmith, Coles and either Curtis or Muhammad at the 3. Nice group. Only issues I see are Weeks 9 and 10, where you lose 2 and 3 each. Kevin Walter is a #2 for Schaub, but that's a total wildcard right now. MClayton is closer to bust than good right now. Baskett could throw in a few TDs. Good group, with 1-2 weeks of an issue.

TE - I love Crumpler, we all know that. Scheffler's a Cutler favorite. I can argue that this is the best pair in this league.

D - Philly is good, but I always like 2. Early bye helps in survivor, but not so much in H2H.

Ks - Two solid ones, and Brown's underrated.

Overall a good team, but not great. Bye issues all over the place (No D2, WRs Weeks 9 and 10, QBs in 8, RBs in Weeks 4 and 6....). For that reason alone your down a grade. "B".

 
Last edited by a moderator:
ravnzfan

QB Vince Young TEN 4

QB Steve McNair BAL 8

RB Rudi Johnson CIN 5

RB Cadilliac Williams TB 10

RB Jerious Norwood ATL 8

RB Mewelde Moore MIN 5

WR Larry Fitzgerald ARZ 8

WR Hines Ward PIT 6

WR Brandon Marshall DEN 6

WR Mike Furrey DET 6

WR Marty Booker MIA 9

WR Chris Henry CIN 5

TE Ben Watson NE 10

TE David Martin MIA 9

DEF San Diego Chargers 7

DEF New York Giants 9

K Robbie Gould CHI 9

K Matt Stover BAL 8
QBs - Young and McNair should be very good. I like that combo.RBs - Rudi and Caddy should be ok, especially if Caddy gets the rumored-to-be 60+ catches. Moore is underrated but may not crack your lineup. Norwood has big play / home run ability, so that's a nice boost to your team.

WRs - Fitz / Ward / Marshall is a nice set of starters. Furrey is underrated this year as he could be the Stokley type role to CJ2/RoyW's best Harrison/Wayne impersonation. I'm not saying 50 TDs is possible, but as your 4th option that's pretty good.

Booker is a wild card, but should be steady enough to contribute a little. Henry is a HR hitter and could help you out in the second half. I like this group.

TE - Not great here with Troupe and Martin, but they could produce decent numbers. Not a team strength, but I wouldn't label it a major weakness either.

D - SD and NYG - SD should be good, I don't know how much the G-men will help.

Ks - two solid performers.

Overall this is a good team. Not great at RB or TE, but not bad either. Pretty steady throughout and WRs could lead the way. "A-".

 
Last edited by a moderator:
radballs

QB Matt Leinart ARZ 8

QB JP Losman BUF 6

RB Maurice Drew-Jones JAX 4

RB DeAngelo Williams CAR 7

RB Warrick Dunn ATL 8

RB Mike Bell DEN 6

WR Chad Johnson CIN 5

WR Plaxico Burress NYG 9

WR Braylon Edwards CLE 7

WR Derrick Mason BAL 8

WR Brandon Lloyd WAS 4

WR Peerless Price BUF 6

TE LJ Smith PHI 5

TE Owen Daniels HOU 10

DEF Dallas Cowboys 8

DEF Tampa Bay Buccaneers 10

K Shane Graham CIN 5

K Jeff Reed PIT
Leinart and Losman might drive you nuts in redraft, but I like this unorthodox pair for best ball. That uniqueness probably afforded radballs some good values elsewhere. Let's see....MJD/ DeW are two sophomore RBs who could perform quite well. Dunn is underrated, especially with Vick trying to increase his completion %age this year. Even Bell might add some points a few times. Good crew.

Chad, Plax and Braylon - nice threesome here. Six WRs, no shared byes. Mason and Lloyd may post some PPR help, and if Price has a good week or two Losman might benefit as well. I like the group overall.

TEs - LJ and ODaniels should work fine. Dallas / TB looks good, and two solid kickers.

This is arguably the best team on the board. Well done. "A".

 
Last edited by a moderator:
rzrback77

QB Ben Roethlisberger PIT 6

QB Matt Schaub HOU 10

RB Marshall Lynch BUF 6

RB Ahmad Greeen HOU 10

RB DeShaun Foster CAR 7

RB Michael Pittman TB 10

WR Torry Holt STL 9

WR Mark Clayton BAL 8

WR Jerrico Cotchery NYJ 10

WR Joey Porter OAK 5

WR Drew Bennett STL 9

WR Dwayne Jarrett CAR 7

WR Robert Meachem NO 4

TE Antonio Gates SD 7

TE Zach Miller OAK 5

DEF Green Bay Packers 7

DEF Arizona Cardinals 8

K Mike Nugent NYJ 10
Big Ben should be very helpful here. Schaub (with AJ's help) could add in a few weeks. RBs are interesting with a rook (Lynch) and two older vets (Green, Foster), but all 3 are likely not to get more than 70% of their team's work. Adequate, but no one great. I'm guessing a later draft slot for rzr.WRs - 7 and well spread out byes. Holt, Clayton and Cotchery are a nice trio. Porter and Bennett could also step up and contribute, and two rooks might as well. Very nice.

TE is a great pair (almost any pair would be with Gates), GB and AZ are underrated for D, and the Jets K should be fine (but no K2).

This is a pretty good team without major defects, but unimpressive at RB. That might hold rzr back, but overall looks competitive. "B+".

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pimpin'AintEasy

QB Carson Palmer CIN 5

QB Bradie Croyle KC 8

RB Clinton Portis WAS 4

RB Laurence Maroney NE 10

RB LaDell Betts WAS 4

RB Dominic Rhodes OAK 5

WR Chris Chambers MIA 9

WR Calvin Johnson DET 6

WR Devery Henderson NO 4

WR Matt Jones JAX 4

WR Reggie Williams JAX 4

WR Amani Toomer NYG 9

WR Steve Smith NYG 9

TE Todd Heap BAL 8

TE Alex Smith TB 10

DEF Indianapolis Colts 6

DEF Washington Redskins 4

K Jeff Wilkins STL 9
Palmer's a good choice at QB, but QB2 is a weakness with just Croyle. Locking up the Wash RB situation is a nice move, but with no Rhodes for 4 weeks Week 4 will now hurt with just Maroney (who also has health issues). WRs - 3 off Week 4 (kissing that one goodbye?) and 3 more off on Week 9. Chambers is a question mark as usual, but in best ball that's less of a headache. Not a fan of the WRs in JAX, but if you had to pick one I like Williams more. Toomer is underrated, and Steve Smith could contribute some. Not sure how to read this eclectic group (including CJ2, who should be very good) - it's just all over the place. I like Henderson - but he's not consistent either - so it looks like WR1/2/3/BC.

TEs are very good, D's are ok, and Wilkins did fine last year (but again, no K2).

A bunch of issues in here and kissing Week 4 goodbye looks like a tactical error, but I guess we'll see.

"B-".

 
Jeff Pasquino said:
Family Matters

QB Donovan McNabb PHI 5

QB Phillip Rivers SD 7

RB LaDainian Tomlinson SD 7

RB Vernand Morency GB 7

RB Brandon Jackson GB 7

RB Corey Dillon FA ?

WR Anquan Boldin ARZ 8

WR Roy Williams DET 6

WR Terry Glenn DAL 8

WR Bobby Wade MIN 5

WR Craig Davis SD 7

WR Nate Washington PIT 6

TE Vernon Davis SF 6

TE Desmond Clark CHI 9

DEF Carolina Panthers 7

DEF Buffalo Bills 6

K Adam Vinateri IND 6

K Phil Dawson CLE 7
I'm sure you are shocked to hear I don't like Rivers - but I do like McNabb. Playoffs should reward you if you get there.Dillon might be a wasted pick.

WTF did you do here for RB week 7? Giving up that week?

I guess in H2H you can try this but that seems like a very weird strategy. :scared:

First 3 WRs look good, not a fan of MIN or SD WRs this year. NWash is a good pick.

Nice TEs, Good D and K.

The RB still has me puzzled and not a fan of the WR depth. Decent team / leaning good with McNabb and LT2.

I'll give it a "B" for those two, but I think it could have turned out better.
Thanks for the feedback Jeff. To answer some of your questions:The RB issues are not as worrisome to me as you. Week 7 is a bit of a blow off I agree but I think that's going to be fine. You can earn a playoff spot by having 1 of the 2 best records or highest remaining top scoring team. Knowing I can finish 3rd or lower in record and still earn a playoff spot I decided to not be too concerned about the wekk 7 byes. Considering I probably locked up the GB running game (and that's usually good numbers) by drafting Morency in the 6th and Jackson in the 9th, I think that's good value. In this format (bestball) it doesn't matter which one becomes the man. As for Dillon, he may not amount to anything but I got him in the 15th round (very low risk) so if he doesn't pan out it's no big deal. Or he might end up in GB. Besides, what was left to pick from after the 6th round they had just as many question marks and I wouldn't of had the RBBC locked up as I do in this situation.

My QB situation is something I really like. Not a big Rivers fan either but as my QB2, I love him. Also, I'm one of the few that think McNabb will be just fine this year.

Finally, in a 14 team league, no one has great starters at every position and depth as well. I think I balanced this very nicely. My starting WR's are good as any, not the best but very good, and I still grabbed some starters, although not exciting, to add to my depth. So I'm feeling pretty good now that I've had time to reflect. I think this team can win if:

1. McNabb is healthy.

2. I indeed have the GB RBBC solved.

3. Roy Williams stays healthy.

Not a ton of question marks but still I think those will be the key.
FM - are you drinking again? "WR's are as good as any, not the best" - if they are as good as any (and they are not), they would be the best.
Hook, your comment doesn't make a lot of sense. But take a closer look at the average starting WR ranking per FBG's. Guess I'm basing this on FBG's rankings. Looks like I stack up just fine. Not the best but pretty darn good:Williams=WR8

Boldin=WR11

Glenn=WR30

Avg ranking: WR16

In a 14 team league whereby you are starting 42 WR's I think that's as good as any there is. Here's some others:

Valence:

TO=WR5

Moss=WR14

Jennings=WR33

Avg: WR17

Twilight:

Driver=WR13

Moss=WR17

Holmes=WR35

Avg: WR21

Team Legacy:

Harrison=WR5

Colston=WR12

Galloway=WR22

Avg: WR13

Hook:

Wayne=WR4

Houshmandzadeh=WR16

Bruce=WR37

Avg WR:19

ShadowMaster:

Walker=WR10

Jackson=WR22

Branch=WR25

Avg WR:19

Frank Black:

Smith=WR2

Coles=WR20

Muhammad=WR36

Avg WR:19

ravnzfan:

Fitzgerald:WR7

Ward: WR:19

Marshall: WR41

Avg. WR:22

Radballs:

Johnson: WR1

Burress: WR17

Edwards: WR21

Avg WR:13

rzrback77:

Holt: WR3

Cotchery: WR26

Clayton: WR29

Avg WR: 19

 
I think I graded them all, so I guess a summary is in order:

Family Matters - B
Fiddles - B+
valence - A-
Twilight - A
Grouse - B-
Team Legacy - A-/B+
Captain Hook - B+
Pigskin Pimp - C
Shadowmaster - C-
Frank Black - B
ravnzfan - A-
radballs - A
rzrback77 - B+
PAE - B-IIRC 6 teams make the playoffs (?), but I'll go Top 4 and then Next 2 I guess.

I see radballs, ravnzfan, valence and Twilight as the Top 4 with Team Legacy a close 5th. rzrback77, Captain Hook and Fiddles have a shot at 6th or sneaking up a little. Those are my "Top Half" or so.

Good luck to all.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think I graded them all, so I guess a summary is in order:

Family Matters - B
Fiddles - B+
valence - A-
Twilight - A
Grouse - B-
Team Legacy - A-/B+
Captain Hook - B+
Pigskin Pimp - C
Shadowmaster - C-
Frank Black - B
ravnzfan - A-
radballs - A
rzrback77 - B+
PAE - B-IIRC 6 teams make the playoffs (?), but I'll go Top 4 and then Next 2 I guess.

I see radballs, ravnzfan, valence and Twilight as the Top 4 with Team Legacy a close 5th. rzrback77, Captain Hook and Fiddles have a shot at 6th or sneaking up a little. Those are my "Top Half" or so.

Good luck to all.
Thanks for grading Jeff. I lnow it takes alot of time to do 14 teams and we appreciate you doing that. :lmao:
 
3QBs - Interesting. I like Hass and I really like Rexy in best ball, so I'm confused by having 3. This is compounded by only 3 RBs, two of which that also share a bye. Seven WRs helps, but not just ANY seven. Givens is likely to be a wasted pick, and I don't trust Ginn to contribute much. I'm not high on Walker (he actually did worse with Cutler than with Plummer) and DJax is hurt once again (shocker), so this group looks like a weakness when it should have been a strength.Witten was a good choice, but no backup might hurt. With the Bears at D and other weaknesses, two Ds and two Ks at the expense of other depth also look like bad decisions.I don't like this team at all, sorry. I'll be kind and just give a "C-".
Wow Jeff - appreciate the input but I gotta disagree with the grade. I feel real good about this roster in this format.2 proven starting RBs on run first teams, and a possible 3rd. No depth, but all my players play each week. Kenny Irons or Micheal Bennett types are wasted roster space in this format unless your getting a handcuff.4 WR1s - 2 on pass first teams and pass in the red zone teams. Givens was a 18th round flyer. 2 QBs on pass first, pass in the red zone teams. 3rd QB over the backup TE who would have only scored 1 week for me.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top