Rookie 1.05 (1 Viewer)

[jeter23]

1.01 AJ Green 53% (Ingram, 34%)

1.02 Mark Ingram 58% (Jones, 37%)

1.03 Julio Jones 79% (Leshoure, 14%)

1.04 Mikel Leshoure 60% (Williams, 28%)

 

[Ghost of Bill Walsh]

Unless fantasy teams have a need at QB the top QB prospects would not be in the top 5 of my dynasty league so I went with RB Ryan Williams. I feel he has what it takes to be a starter in the NFL and he seems to be the next best player available to me. I'm sure some could offer a fair arguement that a different RB would be picked at 5 instead of Williams but he's my choice of the players listed.

1.05-RB Ryan Williams

 

[loose circuits]

sure some could offer a fair arguement that a different RB would be picked at 5 instead of Williams but he's my choice of the players listed.

you mean like Hunter, Thomas, Vereen, Todman, Lewis, Rodgers, Helu, Murray, Jones, or Carter?so many, I wasn't sure who to ask for in the next poll

 

[rzrback77]

Thanks Jeter23 for doing these. I think that the information is interesting even withour scoring parameters, but the PPR leagues vs Non-PPR scoring would vary greatly. Thanks again for all the hard work keeping these threads active.

Great contribution to the Shark Pool in my opinion.

 

[jeter23]

Thanks Jeter23 for doing these. I think that the information is interesting even withour scoring parameters, but the PPR leagues vs Non-PPR scoring would vary greatly. Thanks again for all the hard work keeping these threads active.Great contribution to the Shark Pool in my opinion.

Thanks, someone suggested holding 2 polls in 1 (PPR and non PPR). I liked the idea but didn't want to change after the first couple of polls. I will try and do another quick series after the draft with both scoring standards.

 

[Faust]

Thanks Jeter23 for doing these. I think that the information is interesting even withour scoring parameters, but the PPR leagues vs Non-PPR scoring would vary greatly. Thanks again for all the hard work keeping these threads active.

Great contribution to the Shark Pool in my opinion.

Thanks, someone suggested holding 2 polls in 1 (PPR and non PPR). I liked the idea but didn't want to change after the first couple of polls. I will try and do another quick series after the draft with both scoring standards.

Jeter23,

Take a look at this poll from last year - not suggesting that you need to go with 4 poll options like this one, but the start 2 QB leagues are interesting:

2010 Rookie Poll

 

[Hoss_Cartwright]

sure some could offer a fair arguement that a different RB would be picked at 5 instead of Williams but he's my choice of the players listed.

you mean like Hunter, Thomas, Vereen, Todman, Lewis, Rodgers, Helu, Murray, Jones, or Carter?so many, I wasn't sure who to ask for in the next poll

Watch Kendall Hunter turn out to be the best RB in the draft He should definitely make it to the 1.06 list. I agree that Ryan Williams would be taken over the rest not listed for the 1.05.

 

[purplejesus28]

I like Hankerson as the WR3, but still went with Williams here. So much potential a year ago.

 

[loose circuits]

sure some could offer a fair arguement that a different RB would be picked at 5 instead of Williams but he's my choice of the players listed.

you mean like Hunter, Thomas, Vereen, Todman, Lewis, Rodgers, Helu, Murray, Jones, or Carter?so many, I wasn't sure who to ask for in the next poll

Watch Kendall Hunter turn out to be the best RB in the draft He should definitely make it to the 1.06 list. I agree that Ryan Williams would be taken over the rest not listed for the 1.05.

right now, Williams looks like the logical choice but for my rankings he hasn't distanced himself enough that situation will sway me one way or the other. I think with any of those 11 guys and possibly Green, White, Powell, or Scott that situation will dictate how they are rankedThis one looks over...

 

[Steelerblitz]

I went with Williams. Williams has a fast 10 yard split, which means he can hit the hole fast. Kendall Hunter is not far behind him IMO. Hunter has some great VISION.