CR69
Footballguy
I too would be very curious to look at data showing the relationship of QE to GDP in response to SARS-CoV-2 but am struggling to find that info. The best I could come up with is linked below.Well I appreciate you linking the milkshake theory here but the milkshake theory is more a consequence of the USD being the reserve currency than saying the USD will remain the world reserve currency. He even acknowledged it towards the end. There could be a near-term short squeeze in the USD but that doesn't necessarily change things.
The point about every central bank doing it is fair but it does seem the Fed's response is greater than the rest of the world. Not just by size obviously but on a % basis although I'd have to look into it more. But I think our response is the greater and obviously the QT side of things remains to be seen. The fact that everyone is doing it may reduce some of the pressures to switch. But I am of the belief a lot of the USD strength, as discussed by the milkshake theory, is the need for the USD by outsiders. What is the driver of that? I think it's all the borrowing in the USD. So I think as we get through this, there will be a lot less borrowing in the USD by foreign countries and countries. Now obviously, something needs to replace it and BTC acts too much like equity at the moment.
The Roach article below is a different piece and touches on more fundamental economic activity. Roach also talks about our pull back from the rest of the world in terms of trade and protectionism possibly exacerbating things. Now of course, things could change in the fall but conversely, Johnson mentioned Trump made the US a more attractive place to invest which could also reverse. So you have puts and takes there. But my thesis is that we'll print our way out of this mess but folks will realize the pain associated with funding foreign debt in the US, wonder why they're helping the US print its way out when they're helpless and want to change things. That would be exacerbated if the Fed ever loses control.
https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-06-08/a-crash-in-the-dollar-is-coming
I just don't feel the USD will be replaced as the reserve currency until a true global currency is created. What other option is there right now? Also, the Fed (and US government) have been banking on inflating our way out of this debt but if this really drags on our economy we may be headed for some deflation which makes our debt more attractive, right?
https://www.nber.org/papers/w27339
https://www.visualcapitalist.com/global-central-banks-policy-response-covid-19/