domDavis has gotten more out his talent and statswise he is a better players, but if you lined up the NFL running backs and went DomDavis or your guy he is probably not in the top 20 maybe even 25.
Carr has a poor career winning percentage, and below average passer rating, but the state of NFL Qbs is pretty sorry, so if you went Carr or your guy he probably is in the Top 20. For a multitude of reasons Carr has not performed anywhere close to his talent.
Really? The state of NFL QBing is sorry? I think the opposite - I think we're entering an era of great QBing:Brady, Manning, Palmer, Roethlisberger, Leftwich, McNair, Plummer, Green, Collins, Brees, Bledsoe, EManning, McNabb, Favre, Culpepper, Vick, Delhomme, Warner, Bulger, and Hasslebeck are all clearly better than Carr. That's 20. Arguable, guys like Pennington, Brunell, and Griese are also better, while the jury is still out on Alex Smith, JP Losman, Frye, and Grossman/Orton. Put simply, if David Carr got cut tomorrow, there's not a single place in the NFL he could walk into and be the undisputed starter.