What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The FBG Top 300 Books of All Time (fiction edition) | We are currently up to #34 | Running list in posts #3 and #4 (37 Viewers)

Two books tied at 42nd.


42Invisible ManRalph EllisonOliver Humanzee, krista4, Psychopav
Heart of DarknessJoseph ConradDr. Octopus, chaos34, KeithR, Oliver Humanzee, Long Ball Larry

42. Invisible Man by Ralph Ellison
krista4: #3 :clap:
Oliver Humanzee: #6 :clap:
Psychopav: #46
Total points: 270
Average: 90.0

42. Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad
KeithR: #8 :clap:
Long Ball Larry: #18
chaos34: #24
Oliver Humanzee: #29
Dr. Octopus: #61
Total points: 270
Average: 54.0

There's only two more ties, but one of them is tomorrow, so only doing two today.
 
Interested in the Heart of Darkness writeup(s). I found it sort of impenetrable as a teen and I'm wondering if it's worth a revisit.
I had the same issue. I think I was just too young and, for some reason, I never went back to it.

My English teacher showed us Apocalypse Now in class over a few days after we read Heart of Darkness since it was based on the book so maybe that influenced me a little but I do remember liking the narrative style of the book.
 
Interested in the Heart of Darkness writeup(s). I found it sort of impenetrable as a teen and I'm wondering if it's worth a revisit.
I had the same issue. I think I was just too young and, for some reason, I never went back to it.
My favorite Simpsons episode is titled "Bart of Darkness". I could write about that... :shrug:
That's a good episode, but doesn't hold a candle to "Last Exit to Springfield"
 
Two books tied at 42nd.


42Invisible ManRalph EllisonOliver Humanzee, krista4, Psychopav
Heart of DarknessJoseph ConradDr. Octopus, chaos34, KeithR, Oliver Humanzee, Long Ball Larry

42. Invisible Man by Ralph Ellison
krista4: #3 :clap:
Oliver Humanzee: #6 :clap:
Psychopav: #46
Total points: 270
Average: 90.0

42. Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad
KeithR: #8 :clap:
Long Ball Larry: #18
chaos34: #24
Oliver Humanzee: #29
Dr. Octopus: #61
Total points: 270
Average: 54.0

There's only two more ties, but one of them is tomorrow, so only doing two today.
Two books I feel like I should have read
 
Interested in the Heart of Darkness writeup(s). I found it sort of impenetrable as a teen and I'm wondering if it's worth a revisit.
I had the same issue. I think I was just too young and, for some reason, I never went back to it.
My favorite Simpsons episode is titled "Bart of Darkness". I could write about that... :shrug:
That's a good episode, but doesn't hold a candle to "Last Exit to Springfield"
Fight me.

Also, why must you turn this thread into a den of lies??
 
Interested in the Heart of Darkness writeup(s). I found it sort of impenetrable as a teen and I'm wondering if it's worth a revisit.
I had the same issue. I think I was just too young and, for some reason, I never went back to it.
My favorite Simpsons episode is titled "Bart of Darkness". I could write about that... :shrug:
That's a good episode, but doesn't hold a candle to "Last Exit to Springfield"
Fight me.

Also, why must you turn this thread into a den of lies??
On one hand, "Bart of Darkness" has some great Martin Prince lines. On the other hand, I'm beginning to think you're not the brilliant tactician I thought you were. Also, I prefer the hands-on touch you only get with hired goons.
 
Interested in the Heart of Darkness writeup(s). I found it sort of impenetrable as a teen and I'm wondering if it's worth a revisit.
I had the same issue. I think I was just too young and, for some reason, I never went back to it.
My favorite Simpsons episode is titled "Bart of Darkness". I could write about that... :shrug:
That's a good episode, but doesn't hold a candle to "Last Exit to Springfield"
Fight me.

Also, why must you turn this thread into a den of lies??
On one hand, "Bart of Darkness" has some great Martin Prince lines. On the other hand, I'm beginning to think you're not the brilliant tactician I thought you were. Also, I prefer the hands-on touch you only get with hired goons.
Buy him out, boys!

Sorry, I've strayed from the conversation but couldn't help myself. My home network is named "Compuglobalhypermeganet". ;)

Also I love the song "Summer Wind" and the movie "Rear Window". Add in Bart's play and nothing will ever usurp Bart of Darkness for me. But there are so many great episodes. Wrong thread I guess lol
 
One Hundred Years of Solitude - Gabriel Garcia Marquez

Many years later, as he faced the firing squad, Colonel Aureliano Buendía was to remember that distant afternoon when his father took him to discover ice.

The most frequent phrase that comes up with One Hundred Years of Solitude is “magical realism.” Salman Rushdie called it the greatest book in any language in the past 50 years — you can see how it informed something like Midnight’s Children. Toni Morrison called it one of the five most important books of the world, and you can see how it informed Beloved.

But its influence is not why it is a favorite of mine. Not even really the plot. It is the story of the Buendía family over seven generations, showing the rise and fall and cycles of events that befall the family. Its themes are similar to those of Latin American history and the colonial experience in Colombia.

It’s really the prose that wowed me when I read it. I can’t remember how many times I read a line or a passage or a description of something and needed to re-read it because I thought it was so dang beautifully written. It was originally released in Spanish, and while I’m tempted to learn Spanish just I could read it in its original form, I also know that Marquez called Rabassa’s translation superior to the original Spanish.

I still need to watch the Netflix series that came out a few months ago. I started watching it, but was having a little trouble getting into it, and made me worry it would lower my estimation of the book.
Reading this book is one of my 2025 goals. I relate to watching a series about a favorite book--I'm always reading something before the show or movie comes out and then skipping the adaptation because I loved the book too much and didn't want anything to ruin it.
 
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
 
Last edited:
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turrnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
I’m pretty shocked that The Godfather is so high up. I know it was a huge best seller and obviously the movies are even bigger but I guess I didn’t realize the book was still so loved.
 
Did you guys see this miniseries? The Offer

It's a docudrama about the making of the Godfather. Not on my list of Top 70 tv shows but pretty good imo.
 
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turrnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
I’m pretty shocked that The Godfather is so high up. I know it was a huge best seller and obviously the movies are even bigger but I guess I didn’t realize the book was still so loved.
Let me first say that The Godfather is a much better movie than a book. The movie trimmed a lot of pulpy fat from the book, most notably the life of a mistress after her lover's death and the nefarious habits of a movie studio president.

Still, it is a book I have enjoyed and the rare novel I have read more than once. I only read it after seeing the movie multiple times but the core of the story is there, with all the lush characters and family dynamics that really elevate the story above standard fare for the genre. Some muscle was trimmed with the fat when making the movie and it is nice to see Sonny's skills on display, Genco being a presence, and some personal interaction between Carmella (Mama) Corleone and Kay Adams. I'll never be able to judge it as a standalone but it is a nice companion piece to the movie.
 
I can see I'm behind. Let me try to catch up some today.

First up, The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams

I can't say this is my favourite book of the series but I can't say it wasn't. It started it all, after all, and there's no forgetting the opening salvo of Arthur Dent trying to protect his home from being demolished so that the government can build an interstate bypass through his front yard. Not only does the series provide a surprisingly cohesive plot with memorable characters (if not, exactly, character development), this book - this (increasingly inaccurately named) trilogy - comes as close to written word Monty Python as anything could. From Marvin the Paranoid Android to the improbability drive, Ford Prefect and Zaphod Beeblebrox, this series is so rich with quotable quotes and memorable vignettes that it's hard to pick just one. But that's what I'm going to do anyway. You can look up for yourselves my runners up, both of which may be also be found in the inaugural novel. Just google "Hitchhiker's Guide Towel" or "Hitchhiker's Guide Whale Passage" if you like. In the mean time, here for your reading enjoyment is Adam's description of Vogon poetry - also from Book 1:

“Vogon poetry is of course, the third worst in the universe.
The second worst is that of the Azgoths of Kria. During a recitation by their poet master Grunthos the Flatulent of his poem "Ode to a Small Lump of Green Putty I Found in My Armpit One Midsummer Morning" four of his audience died of internal haemorrhaging and the president of the Mid-Galactic Arts Nobbling Council survived by gnawing one of his own legs off. Grunthos was reported to have been "disappointed" by the poem's reception, and was about to embark on a reading of his 12-book epic entitled "My Favourite Bathtime Gurgles" when his own major intestine, in a desperate attempt to save humanity, leapt straight up through his neck and throttled his brain.
The very worst poetry of all perished along with its creator, Paul Neil Milne Johnstone of Redbridge, in the destruction of the planet Earth. Vogon poetry is mild by comparison.”

Yes, Paul Neil Milne Johnstone was an actual poet who, as it happens, went to school with Adams. More on that here, including a sample of his poetry.
I just wish it ended up being ranked #42
 
Last edited:
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turrnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
I’m pretty shocked that The Godfather is so high up. I know it was a huge best seller and obviously the movies are even bigger but I guess I didn’t realize the book was still so loved.

I'm also surprised to see The Godfather on here so high. But the Fiver Rule is in effect. Amazing movies! I write this having just arrived in Palermo, Sicily last night, so I guess it's fitting. :)

Sorry that OH and I haven't been and won't be participating much. I'm traveling, and he's working, and really he doesn't participate in this stuff unless I egg him on. I'll be back starting May 11 before heading out of town again on the 16th. Maybe we can catch up then.
 
Last edited:
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turrnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
I’m pretty shocked that The Godfather is so high up. I know it was a huge best seller and obviously the movies are even bigger but I guess I didn’t realize the book was still so loved.

I'm also surprised to see The Godfather on here so high. But the Fiver Rule is in effect. Amazing movies, though! I write this having just arrived in Palermo, Sicily last night, so I guess it's fitting. :)

Sorry that OH and I won't be participating much. I'm traveling, and he's working, and really he doesn't participate in this stuff unless I egg him on. I'll be back starting May 11 before heading out of town again on the 16th. Maybe we can catch up then.
I’ve never read it so I can’t comment on it. Just was surprised. Enjoy your trip, it sounds wonderful!
 
I saw The Godfather as a teen and thought it was boring. Many years later I read the book and loved it, made me do a re-watch and I loved that too. I understand why they cut Lucy out, it was already a long movie. Is it only the people who saw the movie first that think the Lucy storyline didn't fit?
 
I saw The Godfather as a teen and thought it was boring. Many years later I read the book and loved it, made me do a re-watch and I loved that too. I understand why they cut Lucy out, it was already a long movie. Is it only the people who saw the movie first that think the Lucy storyline didn't fit?
Lucy was in the movie exactly as long as she needed to be. Had they included her whole story in the movie, it would have greatly devalued the whole thing.

eta - Though it might have spared us from GF III
 
I'm hesitant to post these two books together as they're so darn similar. But I don't want to start posting only one book at a time, so here goes...



39The ShiningStephen Kingtimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Psychopav, shuke
38Of Mice and MenJohn Steinbeckturrnjose7, guru_007, scoobus, chaos34, Oliver Humanzee, Dr_Zaius, krista4, Psychopav

39. The Shining by Stephen King
shuke: #5 :clap:
Frostillicus: #16
timschochet: #21
Psychopav: #42
turnjose7: #65
Total points: 280
Average: 56.0

38. Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck
chaos34: #15
scoobus: #21
krista4: #26
Oliver Humanzee: #39
turnjose7: #40
Dr_Zaius: #49
Psychopav: #56
guru_007: #59
Total points: 286
Average: 35.8

Here we have Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, our first book receiving 8 nominations. Although no one had it ranked higher than 15th, volume matters.

If you haven't read it, it's the story of a young mouse whose father is appointed caretaker of a barn over a particularly harsh winter. It's a very mysterious barn, filled with ghosts, ghouls and goblins. Oh, and the mouse has ESP. It's a good read.
 
I'm hesitant to post these two books together as they're so darn similar. But I don't want to start posting only one book at a time, so here goes...



39The ShiningStephen Kingtimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Psychopav, shuke
38Of Mice and MenJohn Steinbeckturrnjose7, guru_007, scoobus, chaos34, Oliver Humanzee, Dr_Zaius, krista4, Psychopav

39. The Shining by Stephen King
shuke: #5 :clap:
Frostillicus: #16
timschochet: #21
Psychopav: #42
turnjose7: #65
Total points: 280
Average: 56.0

38. Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck
chaos34: #15
scoobus: #21
krista4: #26
Oliver Humanzee: #39
turnjose7: #40
Dr_Zaius: #49
Psychopav: #56
guru_007: #59
Total points: 286
Average: 35.8

Here we have Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, our first book receiving 8 nominations. Although no one had it ranked higher than 15th, volume matters.

If you haven't read it, it's the story of a young mouse whose father is appointed caretaker of a barn over a particularly harsh winter. It's a very mysterious barn, filled with ghosts, ghouls and goblins. Oh, and the mouse has ESP. It's a good read.
As a HS teacher, I like and am also so tired of OMAM but no doubt it’s a classic. Barely 100 pages, it also may be the shortest book on the countdown.
 
I'm hesitant to post these two books together as they're so darn similar. But I don't want to start posting only one book at a time, so here goes...



39The ShiningStephen Kingtimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Psychopav, shuke
38Of Mice and MenJohn Steinbeckturrnjose7, guru_007, scoobus, chaos34, Oliver Humanzee, Dr_Zaius, krista4, Psychopav

39. The Shining by Stephen King
shuke: #5 :clap:
Frostillicus: #16
timschochet: #21
Psychopav: #42
turnjose7: #65
Total points: 280
Average: 56.0

38. Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck
chaos34: #15
scoobus: #21
krista4: #26
Oliver Humanzee: #39
turnjose7: #40
Dr_Zaius: #49
Psychopav: #56
guru_007: #59
Total points: 286
Average: 35.8

Here we have Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, our first book receiving 8 nominations. Although no one had it ranked higher than 15th, volume matters.

If you haven't read it, it's the story of a young mouse whose father is appointed caretaker of a barn over a particularly harsh winter. It's a very mysterious barn, filled with ghosts, ghouls and goblins. Oh, and the mouse has ESP. It's a good read.
As a HS teacher, I like and am also so tired of OMAM but no doubt it’s a classic. Barely 100 pages, it also may be the shortest book on the countdown.
Mr.Hunter ?
 
I'm hesitant to post these two books together as they're so darn similar. But I don't want to start posting only one book at a time, so here goes...

39The ShiningStephen Kingtimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Psychopav, shuke
38Of Mice and MenJohn Steinbeckturrnjose7, guru_007, scoobus, chaos34, Oliver Humanzee, Dr_Zaius, krista4, Psychopav

Similar enough that more than one of us included both books.

The most interesting part in Of Mice and Men is trying to figure out the meaning of why the mouse sees einneL written everywhere.
 
The Shining by Stephen King

One of only a few books that gave me nightmares. I saw, and fell in love with, the movie long before I read the movie. I'm not going to get into a debate on which is better, because I look at them as entirely different things, each being a masterpiece in its form of media. I highly recommend this, even for non-King fans.
 
I have this on deck to read next.
There's a lot to like about the book. Among my favorite things are:

1. The guy who discovers a time portal in his diner's dry storage and just uses it to buy cheap ground beef.

2. King neatly sidestepping the narrative-crushing pseudo-philosophical cul-de-sacs of time travel paradoxes with this exchange:

"What if I go back in time and kill my grandfather?"

"Why the hell would you do that?"
 
Two oldies but goodies for today.

37DraculaBram Stokerturnjose7, Dr. Octopus, chaos34, Frostillicus, KeithR, krista4
36The Old Man and the SeaErnest Hemingwayturrnjose7, ilov80s, Don Quixote, KeithR

37. Dracula by Bram Stoker
KeithR: #2 :clap:
Frostillicus: #26
Dr. Octopus: #31
turnjose7: #39
chaos34: #39
krista4: #68
Total points: 287
Average: 47.8

36. The Old Man and the Sea by Ernest Hemingway
ilov80s: #5 :clap:
KeithR: #6 :clap:
turnjose7: #20
Don Quixote: #69
Total points: 295
Average: 73.8

Barely 100 pages, it also may be the shortest book on the countdown.
It held the record for 1 day. :D

BTW, @turnjose7 has come up 5 times in a row in the countdown, placing books at #40, #39, #38, #37 and #36 in the countdown. That's noteworthy, but later on, someone will have placed 7 in a row.
 
The Old Man and the Sea by Ernest Hemingway

I think I read this entire thing on a single flight to Mexico. Started it and just couldn’t put it down. It’s a fast read and I actually don’t remember too much about it except just being captivated and finishing it thinking it was just perfect. But I’m pretty sure it’s exactly what the title suggests, an old man goes fishing. Yet obviously about so much more than that: Goals and purpose and resolve in the face of age. Obviously Hemingway’s writing style just works on me as this is the third of his books on my list and I almost put 2 others.

Let him think that I am more man than I am and I will be so
 
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
Funnily enough, both of these are better on the screen than the book versions.
My memory is a bit hazy on the Godfather book, but isn’t it set in a different time than the movie?
Whatever the case, Coppola worked with Puzo on the movie version and all his changes were spot on. The novel I thought was quite trashy in parts. Still the source material it gave the movie is worth every little nitpick.

As for the Handmaid’s Tale, its so much more relevant that when it was written, which i guess is the sign of a good dystopian book. Or not.
The TV show was able to distill what the original movie couldnt and the book wasnt as well written as others in the genre.
 
Here is another #1 for you, and it is one I've never read.


35The Bonfire of the VanitiesTom Wolfekupcho1, Dr. Octopus, chaos34, krista4
34SiddharthaHermann Hesseguru_007, Psychopav, Long Ball Larry

35. The Bonfire of the Vanities by Tom Wolfe
krista4: #4 :clap:
Dr. Octopus: #13
kupcho1: #22
chaos34: #35
Total points: 296
Average: 74.0

34. Siddhartha by Hermann Hesse
guru_007: #1 :towelwave:
Long Ball Larry: #7 :clap:
Psychopav: #24
Total points: 299
Average: 99.7

Siddhartha will be one of the books I read from this exercise. I'll probably credit it to @guru_007 as it is his #1 (plus both @Psychopav and @Long Ball Larry have highly ranked books I've not read that I can choose from).
 
Last edited:
My #22 book, The Bonfire of the Vanities by Tom Wolfe, is the quintessential 80s novel set in NYC. It explores class, racism, politics and greed.

In doing a little research (right now) on the book, I discovered it was originally written Dickens style, serialized in Rolling Stone starting in 1984. It was revised by Wolfe and published as a novel in 1987.

The book is named for the historical bonfire of the vanities, which happened in 1497 in Florence, Italy, when the city was under the sway of the Dominican priest Girolamo Savonarola, who ordered the burning of objects that church authorities considered sinful, such as cosmetics, mirrors, books, and art.

I think the book perfectly captures the mix of "Greed is good" Wall Street and the powder keg NYC was in the 1980s. There's an element of schadenfreude in seeing what happens to the characters, particularly the main one, "Master of The Universe" Sherman McCoy.

I think the horrific movie adaptation - arguably the worst adaptation of all time - has retroactively soured people on the novel, which is a damn shame. I won't say too much about it, but the casting is absolutely terrible.

We need someone to play Peter Fallow, an alcoholic British tabloid reporter ... Bruce Willis seems right.
Embittered Jewish judge Abe Weiss? Morgan Freeman's available.
I could go on, but what would be the point. Someone needs to redo this, maybe as a streaming miniseries. FX did a great job with Shōgun. Maybe them?
 
Here is another #1 for you, and it is one I've never read.


35The Bonfire of the VanitiesTom Wolfekupcho1, Dr. Octopus, chaos34, krista4
34SiddharthaHermann Hesseguru_007, Psychopav, Long Ball Larry

35. The Bonfire of the Vanities by Tom Wolfe
krista4: #4 :clap:
Dr. Octopus: #13
kupcho1: #22
chaos34: #35
Total points: 296
Average: 74.0

34. Siddhartha by Hermann Hesse
guru_007: #1 :towelwave:
Long Ball Larry: #7 :clap:
Psychopav: #24
Total points: 299
Average: 99.7

Siddhartha will be one of the books I read from this exercise. I'll probably credit it to @guru_007 as it is his #1 (plus both @Psychopav and @Long Ball Larry have highly ranked books I've not read that I can choose from).
Removing formatting.

@kupcho1 - The flush text at the end on it being guru’s #1 does not match the ranks listed. (ETA: FIXED NOW.)
 
Last edited:
So many great scenes in Bonfire. One of my favorites is when Sherman is forced to tell his father he’s been arrested. Sherman’s father offers to talk to a few old buddies that are judges; maybe they can quash it! Sherman then ponders the futility of a bunch of old men in a club somewhere thinking they can stop the power of the media and populist sentiment once it starts moving. In just a few sentences, Wolfe totally obliterated the political concept of the “Power Elite” in modern America.

I got to meet Tom Wolfe once and shake his hand; he was the guest speaker at a shopping center convention in Vegas. As always he wore, as his signature, a white suit, white hat, white shirt, tie and shoes.
 
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
I forgot to come back and say something about The Godfather since it is my #3 book. I suppose all you really need to know is that I read it before I had ever seen the movie. And for those who don't know or don't remember, the book is basically movie 1 and movie 2. So imagine reading that when you haven't seen the movies and that's why it is my #3.
 
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
I forgot to come back and say something about The Godfather since it is my #3 book. I suppose all you really need to know is that I read it before I had ever seen the movie. And for those who don't know or don't remember, the book is basically movie 1 and movie 2. So imagine reading that when you haven't seen the movies and that's why it is my #3.
Ok I just double checked myself lest I be called a liar on the internet and it seems Movie 2 is more inspired/based on a couple of chapters in the book with mostly new material for the movie. Point still stands!
 
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
Funnily enough, both of these are better on the screen than the book versions.
My memory is a bit hazy on the Godfather book, but isn’t it set in a different time than the movie?
Whatever the case, Coppola worked with Puzo on the movie version and all his changes were spot on. The novel I thought was quite trashy in parts. Still the source material it gave the movie is worth every little nitpick.

As for the Handmaid’s Tale, its so much more relevant that when it was written, which i guess is the sign of a good dystopian book. Or not.
The TV show was able to distill what the original movie couldnt and the book wasnt as well written as others in the genre.
A full 30% of The Godfather novel was dedicated to that ludicrous storyline about the woman with the large vagina.
 
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
Funnily enough, both of these are better on the screen than the book versions.
My memory is a bit hazy on the Godfather book, but isn’t it set in a different time than the movie?
Whatever the case, Coppola worked with Puzo on the movie version and all his changes were spot on. The novel I thought was quite trashy in parts. Still the source material it gave the movie is worth every little nitpick.

As for the Handmaid’s Tale, its so much more relevant that when it was written, which i guess is the sign of a good dystopian book. Or not.
The TV show was able to distill what the original movie couldnt and the book wasnt as well written as others in the genre.
A full 30% of The Godfather novel was dedicated to that ludicrous storyline about the woman with the large vagina.
That's also why it is my #3 book.
 
Siddhartha by Hermann Hesse

When I started making my list, my top 3 were the easiest picks ever as they were no doubters. We haven't seen either my #2 or #3 pop up yet, but I'm fairly sure they will later on. But Siddhartha was my without a doubt #1. The first time I read it, it was magic. Perfection. It's a simple story of a young man searching, and the search doesn't always yield what is expected. It talks about friendship, love, spirituality and more I suppose. Hesse just is my muse and all of his books I find fantastic, but Siddhartha is leaps and bounds above the rest. I don't really have much more to say about it other than I suppose everyone will get something different out of it, but as it's a short read, I do think everyone would do well to take a few hours and read this one day. If you don't like it, hell, it's just a few hours wasted. But I think it's a quick and meaningful ride and always recommend this book.
~fin
 
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
Funnily enough, both of these are better on the screen than the book versions.
My memory is a bit hazy on the Godfather book, but isn’t it set in a different time than the movie?
Whatever the case, Coppola worked with Puzo on the movie version and all his changes were spot on. The novel I thought was quite trashy in parts. Still the source material it gave the movie is worth every little nitpick.

As for the Handmaid’s Tale, its so much more relevant that when it was written, which i guess is the sign of a good dystopian book. Or not.
The TV show was able to distill what the original movie couldnt and the book wasnt as well written as others in the genre.
A full 30% of The Godfather novel was dedicated to that ludicrous storyline about the woman with the large vagina.
This is not true; you’re misremembering. At most it’s about 20 pages of a 400 page novel.

Now the whole Johnny Fontaine (Frank Sinatra) story does take a lot of space.
 
Another tie, this one for 40th place


40The Handmaid’s TaleMargaret Atwoodkupcho1, Mrs.Marco, krista4, shuke
The GodfatherMario Puzotimschochet, turnjose7, Frostillicus, Barry2, KeithR

40. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
krista4: #6 :clap:
Mrs.Marco: #18
shuke: #18
kupcho1: #38
Total points: 276
Average: 69.0

40. The Godfather by Mario Puzo
Frostillicus: #3 :clap:
timschochet: #20
KeithR: #22
Barry2: #37
turrnjose7: #70
Total points: 276
Average: 55.2

I've read The Handmaid’s Tale, but not seen the series. I've seen The Godfather, but never read the book. I think there's a correlation.
Funnily enough, both of these are better on the screen than the book versions.
My memory is a bit hazy on the Godfather book, but isn’t it set in a different time than the movie?
Whatever the case, Coppola worked with Puzo on the movie version and all his changes were spot on. The novel I thought was quite trashy in parts. Still the source material it gave the movie is worth every little nitpick.

As for the Handmaid’s Tale, its so much more relevant that when it was written, which i guess is the sign of a good dystopian book. Or not.
The TV show was able to distill what the original movie couldnt and the book wasnt as well written as others in the genre.
A full 30% of The Godfather novel was dedicated to that ludicrous storyline about the woman with the large vagina.
This is not true; you’re misremembering. At most it’s about 20 pages of a 400 page novel.

Now the whole Johnny Fontaine (Frank Sinatra) story does take a lot of space.
You, of all people, should get hyperbole.
 
Siddhartha by Hermann Hesse

When I started making my list, my top 3 were the easiest picks ever as they were no doubters. We haven't seen either my #2 or #3 pop up yet, but I'm fairly sure they will later on. But Siddhartha was my without a doubt #1. The first time I read it, it was magic. Perfection. It's a simple story of a young man searching, and the search doesn't always yield what is expected. It talks about friendship, love, spirituality and more I suppose. Hesse just is my muse and all of his books I find fantastic, but Siddhartha is leaps and bounds above the rest. I don't really have much more to say about it other than I suppose everyone will get something different out of it, but as it's a short read, I do think everyone would do well to take a few hours and read this one day. If you don't like it, hell, it's just a few hours wasted. But I think it's a quick and meaningful ride and always recommend this book.
~fin
Trivia time again: River Phoenix was named after the river in this novel.

I first read this when I was a senior in high school, and I have re-read it every few years since.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top