What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Manning to Tyree play the greatest in Super Bowl (1 Viewer)

Mustang Man

Footballguy
Man from start to finish that play was the bomb Eli scrambling around then getting grabbed getting outa that rolling back to the right then throwing a bomb that Tyree has to to jump up and get at the highest point with R.Harrison all over his back hand on the ball Tyree one hand on the ball and the ball pinned against his helmet both come down together and Tyree holding on to it.

####!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 
Like Peyton said last night, you'd be hard pressed to find a better play than that in Superbowl history. Tyree will never be forgotten in these parts, I can tell you that.

 
Ufortunately that usually requires a touchdown...but agreed. On both the QB and the WR part. :lmao:

 
Usually there's too much hyperbole around here the day after the SB, but the more I think about, I can't really come up with an obviously "bigger" play than this one. Manning-to-Tyree certainly at least belongs in that discussion given the combination of Manning's escape act, Tyree's circus catch and the fact that it was on the game-winning drive.

 
i think i have talked myself into it being the MOST IMPORTANT play ever in Super Bowl history

(and third only to the Immaculate Reception and the Music City Miracle in playoff history and just ahead of The Catch)

BEST play in super bowl history i still rank the Swann juggling catch while tripping over the defender

 
i think i have talked myself into it being the MOST IMPORTANT play ever in Super Bowl history

(and third only to the Immaculate Reception and the Music City Miracle in playoff history and just ahead of The Catch)

BEST play in super bowl history i still rank the Swann juggling catch while tripping over the defender
The Levitating Leap was incredible. But I was amazed watching that play last night. How Tyree managed to keep that ball secure against his helmet with a defenders arm in between was unbelievable. These two plays would be 1a and 1b in my book.
 
The Mark Ingram 3rd and 13 play in SB XXV was pretty special too. As a Bills fan I remember that oh too well. It was the critical play in the 9 plus minute drive to begin the 3rd quarter. At the time, the Giants trailed 12-10. That scoring drive put them up 17-12 and totally gassed the Bills defense for the remainder of the game. Its hard to say if Buffalo makes that play, that they would go on to win, but not making that play sure did put fire into the Giants that lasted the rest of the game.

 
Riggin's 4th and 1 play

Elway's helicopter spin for the first down

Montana to Taylor (for the win)

Mike Jones' tackle of Kevin Dyson on the two-inch line

And Marcus Allen's long cut back play on Black Sunday

 
The Mark Ingram 3rd and 13 play in SB XXV was pretty special too. As a Bills fan I remember that oh too well. It was the critical play in the 9 plus minute drive to begin the 3rd quarter. At the time, the Giants trailed 12-10. That scoring drive put them up 17-12 and totally gassed the Bills defense for the remainder of the game. Its hard to say if Buffalo makes that play, that they would go on to win, but not making that play sure did put fire into the Giants that lasted the rest of the game.
Hey that play was a good one but not nearly as exciting and remarkable as the escape by Eli and the Tyree one hand and Helmet catch with Harrison all over him and the ball. Nice rac by Ingram though. Bigtime play!
 
Riggin's 4th and 1 playElway's helicopter spin for the first downMontana to Taylor (for the win)Mike Jones' tackle of Kevin Dyson on the two-inch lineAnd Marcus Allen's long cut back play on Black Sunday
Outa them plays I would say the Mike Jones tackle was a big play that was right there if not better.Good call!
 
What clever name will future generations come to know this play as?

I'll posit "The Great Escape" but I'm not real fond of that one

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Riggin's 4th and 1 play

Elway's helicopter spin for the first down

Montana to Taylor (for the win)

Mike Jones' tackle of Kevin Dyson on the two-inch line

And Marcus Allen's long cut back play on Black Sunday
That play is not ever to be spoken of :bengalsfan:What made this play so special was the degree of difficulty from both QB and WR. All of those plays were huge, but this stands out even more.

 
That'll get Tyree into the Hall of Fame, if he can only grab a few dozen more passes.

:lynnswann: :loco:

 
Riggin's 4th and 1 playElway's helicopter spin for the first downMontana to Taylor (for the win)Mike Jones' tackle of Kevin Dyson on the two-inch lineAnd Marcus Allen's long cut back play on Black Sunday
Outa them plays I would say the Mike Jones tackle was a big play that was right there if not better.Good call!
Eh, it only prevented overtime - the Rams would not have lost on that play.
 
What clever name will future generations come to know this play as?I'll posit "The Great Escape" but I'm not real fond of that one
Remember that year that sorry ### Giants team beat the supposed all mighty Patriots? That one guy had a great catch.
 
I've never witnessed a play that made me jump up in disbelief and yell in amazement.... "Did that just happen?". David Tyrre...who would have thunk it?! Amazing....best Super Bowl Play ever for me.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
What clever name will future generations come to know this play as?I'll posit "The Great Escape" but I'm not real fond of that one
Someone posted "The Immacuhelmet Reception", which I think is pretty "catchy" :loco:eta: It's probably not the most important play in SB history. You have to reserve that for a game ending - winning play because if Tyree doesn't make the catch, there's the chance of another play succeeding. But certainly it was one of the most exciting and memorable, and I'm glad to have been witness (via TV, of course.)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
i think i have talked myself into it being the MOST IMPORTANT play ever in Super Bowl history

(and third only to the Immaculate Reception and the Music City Miracle in playoff history and just ahead of The Catch)

BEST play in super bowl history i still rank the Swann juggling catch while tripping over the defender
Tyree will no doubt be forever remembered for that, just as Dwight Clark is for his "catch".Incredible indeed.

The defender Swann was tripping over was Randy Hughes.

 
The correct answer is no, there has never been a more significant play ever made in a Superbowl. Clutch performance by both players. :bye:

 
I'll vote for Riggins 4th and one play. 70-Chip and Don McNeal. 43 yards to paydirt and a Redskins Super Bowl win.

Everyone of a certain age in Washington will remember that play until they day they die, like Pearl Harbor, JFK's shooting and 9-11.

 
I'll vote for Riggins 4th and one play. 70-Chip and Don McNeal. 43 yards to paydirt and a Redskins Super Bowl win.Everyone of a certain age in Washington will remember that play until they day they die, like Pearl Harbor, JFK's shooting and 9-11.
Gee imagine that.
 
I'll vote for Riggins 4th and one play. 70-Chip and Don McNeal. 43 yards to paydirt and a Redskins Super Bowl win.

Everyone of a certain age in Washington will remember that play until they day they die, like Pearl Harbor, JFK's shooting and 9-11.
I agree as a Redskins fan, but objectively speaking I'm not sure it's the best. It's certainly in the top 5 though.
 
What makes this play SO special is not only when and where it happened but the fact that not one, but TWO players have to pull magic out of their asses from absolutely nothing. Just for Eli to avoid a DEVASTATING sack would have been very big - giving the giants at least a 4th and 5 and not 4th and 15. The catch on its own would be one of the great postseason catches in NFL history.

But to have BOTH players do EVERYTHING necessary to make an impossible broken play work is what makes this so special. That is why it is ahead of Riggins... yeah, going for the TD was huge and it was 4th and 1, but a run up the middle compared to Eli's great escape to Tyrees unbelievable catch?

Maybe that is why we are having such a tough time coming up with a name for the spinning miracle.

 
is there still a debate over Tyree vs Gaffney? :rolleyes:

The point in time of that catch makes it the greatest in SB history.

 
What makes this play SO special is not only when and where it happened but the fact that not one, but TWO players have to pull magic out of their asses from absolutely nothing. Just for Eli to avoid a DEVASTATING sack would have been very big - giving the giants at least a 4th and 5 and not 4th and 15. The catch on its own would be one of the great postseason catches in NFL history.But to have BOTH players do EVERYTHING necessary to make an impossible broken play work is what makes this so special. That is why it is ahead of Riggins... yeah, going for the TD was huge and it was 4th and 1, but a run up the middle compared to Eli's great escape to Tyrees unbelievable catch?Maybe that is why we are having such a tough time coming up with a name for the spinning miracle.
:rolleyes: I can't disagree. It's also especially special because neither guy was particularly known for what he did on that play: Eli's no scrambler, and Tyree is probably less known going into yesterday's game than three other WR's on that team. Two superb individual performances at a critical time of the game on a game-winning drive. It doesn't get better than that.
 
Eli Manning gets the Brett Favre stamp of approval for spinning out of the defenders grasp twice and heaving a pass into heavy coverage for a ridiculous completion. :thumbup:

Tyree's catch. Unbelievable.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Eli Manning gets the Brett Favre stamp of approval for spinning out of the defenders grasp twice and heaving a pass into heavy coverage for a ridiculous completion. :thumbup:Tyree's catch. Unbelievable.
What else is impressive is that while there was a lot of coverage downfield, Tyree was manned up and only one defender was around him - had another gotten there even at the end, a slight swat of the ball likely would have dislodged it. Eli's ability to recognize and then throw a perfect ball... wow.You know, Manning has really thrown the ball so much better these past few weeks... I dont mean just results,but he is so much more accurate with much tighter spirals and less ducks than ever in his career. He's been throwing a beautiful ball and that had never been Eli until this stretch.
 
Eli Manning gets the Brett Favre stamp of approval for spinning out of the defenders grasp twice and heaving a pass into heavy coverage for a ridiculous completion. :thumbup:
:lmao: At least Eli did it on 3rd down while trailing on a final drive. ;)
 
Eli Manning gets the Brett Favre stamp of approval for spinning out of the defenders grasp twice and heaving a pass into heavy coverage for a ridiculous completion. :thumbup:Tyree's catch. Unbelievable.
What else is impressive is that while there was a lot of coverage downfield, Tyree was manned up and only one defender was around him - had another gotten there even at the end, a slight swat of the ball likely would have dislodged it. Eli's ability to recognize and then throw a perfect ball... wow.You know, Manning has really thrown the ball so much better these past few weeks... I dont mean just results,but he is so much more accurate with much tighter spirals and less ducks than ever in his career. He's been throwing a beautiful ball and that had never been Eli until this stretch.
He looks more confident. That's the difference. He truly has "come of age".
 
What makes this play SO special is not only when and where it happened but the fact that not one, but TWO players have to pull magic out of their asses from absolutely nothing. Just for Eli to avoid a DEVASTATING sack would have been very big - giving the giants at least a 4th and 5 and not 4th and 15. The catch on its own would be one of the great postseason catches in NFL history.

But to have BOTH players do EVERYTHING necessary to make an impossible broken play work is what makes this so special. That is why it is ahead of Riggins... yeah, going for the TD was huge and it was 4th and 1, but a run up the middle compared to Eli's great escape to Tyrees unbelievable catch?

Maybe that is why we are having such a tough time coming up with a name for the spinning miracle.
:thumbup: As well as your other post on this catch. Not only was it a great play, but the catch seemed to defy gravity, being jostled around on his helmet in mid air with defenders trying to sat it away. It reminded me of the Tyrone Prothro catch that won an ESPY for Best Play and it wasn't even a big game.
 
I'm surprised nobody mentioned the reverse pass by Randle El to H.Ward two years ago, at least THAT was a SCORING play in the fourth quarter in a one possesion game, to me that play won the game for them...the play by Manning didn't win it but it gave them a chance, still one of the top plays, but a non-scoring play.

The Randle El to Ward is one of the greatest plays in any SB considering when it happened during the game and they scored on that play, if Ward gets tackled we never know if they score on that drive or not...Eli still had another down to get a first down and the way they were playing they likely get it anyway as the Patriots looked tired by that time.

 
What makes this play SO special is not only when and where it happened but the fact that not one, but TWO players have to pull magic out of their asses from absolutely nothing. Just for Eli to avoid a DEVASTATING sack would have been very big - giving the giants at least a 4th and 5 and not 4th and 15. The catch on its own would be one of the great postseason catches in NFL history.

But to have BOTH players do EVERYTHING necessary to make an impossible broken play work is what makes this so special. That is why it is ahead of Riggins... yeah, going for the TD was huge and it was 4th and 1, but a run up the middle compared to Eli's great escape to Tyrees unbelievable catch?

Maybe that is why we are having such a tough time coming up with a name for the spinning miracle.
:shrug: That's why I voted for calling it "Manning's Miracle" ...

 
As an outsider (not a fan of the Pats or Giants), I must say that if it's not THE best play ever in Super Bowl history, it

most certainly should be in the top 2 or 3. That was amazing. To watch Eli miraculously avoid the sack, air it out, and

for Tyree to jump up with that many defenders there and "catch" it and hold it against his helmet, and not drop it when he

hits the ground... WOW

 
I've never witnessed a play that made me jump up in disbelief and yell in amazement.... "Did that just happen?". David Tyrre...who would have thunk it?! Amazing....best Super Bowl Play ever for me.
Devin Hester's KO return for a TD to start the game last year for the Bears against the Colts did just that for me. It was unbelievable. Although I wouldn't say its the best play in Superbowl history, it should be considered a finalist.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm looking for a high resolution photo of "The Catch II" Does anyone have a link to it?
:angry: Please stop with this madness. It was a lucky ### catch. A great catch, amazing in fact, but luck had a lot to do with it.
Many of the greatest plays in football history saw a bit of luck, so how is this one any different?
I've never witnessed a play that made me jump up in disbelief and yell in amazement.... "Did that just happen?". David Tyrre...who would have thunk it?! Amazing....best Super Bowl Play ever for me.
Devin Hester's KO return for a TD to start the game last year for the Bears against the Colts did just that for me. It was unbelievable. Although I wouldn't say its the best play in Superbowl history, it should be considered a finalist.
No.
 
I've never witnessed a play that made me jump up in disbelief and yell in amazement.... "Did that just happen?". David Tyrre...who would have thunk it?! Amazing....best Super Bowl Play ever for me.
Devin Hester's KO return for a TD to start the game last year for the Bears against the Colts did just that for me. It was unbelievable. Although I wouldn't say its the best play in Superbowl history, it should be considered a finalist.
best play in super bowl history? not even close to top 10. my best chicago bears memory? yes
 
I'm looking for a high resolution photo of "The Catch II" Does anyone have a link to it?
:hifive: Please stop with this madness. It was a lucky ### catch. A great catch, amazing in fact, but luck had a lot to do with it.
Sour grapes, dude.
Why am I sour? Im happy he caught it. Im just realistic. Im also not in the new school thing that everything has to be the greatest of alllll tiiiiiiime!!!! I swear to God people today have the shortest memories of all time!

 
I'm looking for a high resolution photo of "The Catch II" Does anyone have a link to it?
:thumbup: Please stop with this madness. It was a lucky ### catch. A great catch, amazing in fact, but luck had a lot to do with it.
Sour grapes, dude.
Why am I sour? Im happy he caught it. Im just realistic. Im also not in the new school thing that everything has to be the greatest of alllll tiiiiiiime!!!! I swear to God people today have the shortest memories of all time!
Dude, honestly, it was one of the greatest of all time. And that not only comes from Giants fans and footballguy posters either....listen to the experts, ex-pros, coaches.....everyone is saying it. Open your eyes.
 
I'm looking for a high resolution photo of "The Catch II" Does anyone have a link to it?
:excited: Please stop with this madness. It was a lucky ### catch. A great catch, amazing in fact, but luck had a lot to do with it.
Many of the greatest plays in football history saw a bit of luck, so how is this one any different?
Manning escaping was skill. The throw was a complete toss up, the catch was insane, but hardly indicative of Tyree's normal ability. Please don't act like I am the only one who thinks it had a lot of luck involved. That play earlier where Toomer caught the ball near the sideline and had to barely drag his feet in was 3 times as difficult.Im not trying to take anything away from it. It was a spectacular play, but hardly the best I have ever seen.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top