What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Official Kicker (K) Thread (1 Viewer)

fantasycurse42 said:
MindBomb said:
Debating between Santos and Boswell too. Have Santos but Boswell's production over the past five weeks has me reconsidering. Probably will make a gut decision at the last minute.

Anyone concerned about Denver's defense limiting FG attempts?
Click to expand...
Same decision, don't know what to do. I'm leaning Boswell but I'm really torn here.
Click to expand...
Sticking with Santos. KC will have scoring chances...*shrug*

 
BobbyLayne said:
Debating McManus or Catanzaro. Thinking the Broncos have more FGAs but don't feel great about either.
Click to expand...
:oldunsure:

Well, hit on just about everything else this weekend. Guess I'll be rolling with Cat next weekend.

 
The Prater experiment is failing. Those on this train...are you sticking to the end or looking at options?

For me, looking at the following:

Santos home vs. CLE

McManus home vs. CIN

Myers @ NO

Barth vs. Bears

Know its all a crapshoot and sure if I drop Prater, he'll kick 5 FGs against the Niners. What say ye?

 
Big Blue Wrecking Crew said:
The Prater experiment is failing. Those on this train...are you sticking to the end or looking at options?

For me, looking at the following:

Santos home vs. CLE

McManus home vs. CIN

Myers @ NO

Barth vs. Bears

Know its all a crapshoot and sure if I drop Prater, he'll kick 5 FGs against the Niners. What say ye?
Click to expand...
Had Hauschka most of the year and dropped him for Prater. Hoping to get him back but if I cant I'll either roll with Prater or go for Myers, Barth, or another ww option. McManus and Santos are already rostered in my league.

 
Still have Gano. Cam keeps scoring TD's - I like that this is indoors. Carolina has to lose sometime right? Maybe this is the week Atlanta looks good inside the dome.

 
So I escaped playing Randy Bullock last week to make it to the final. But something tells me to play him again vs Patriots -- should I stop drinking?

 
Weather in KC looks like it may be similar to the conditions when they played San Diego and it will be a bit colder. Rainy and windy. Santos had a difficult scoring day against SD and could be in for another bad day this Sunday.

 
Big Blue Wrecking Crew said:
The Prater experiment is failing. Those on this train...are you sticking to the end or looking at options?

For me, looking at the following:

Santos home vs. CLE

McManus home vs. CIN

Myers @ NO

Barth vs. Bears

Know its all a crapshoot and sure if I drop Prater, he'll kick 5 FGs against the Niners. What say ye?
Click to expand...
Thank God I held here...was off (only 4 field goals). Won my league by 4 points in part due to the kicker differential (he had Boswell). Hope others held serve as well with similar results!

 
I'm done with Myers. Looking at the following:

Graham

Novak or Bullock

Sturgis

Forbath

Really want Graham this week. I'd prefer the Jets (Bullock) over the Texans (Novak) but Novak kicking indoors will likely be the deciding factor for me.

 
Suspended K Josh Brown's one-game ban resulted from a domestic violence charge in 2015.
Brown was arrested in May of 2015 for fourth-degree domestic violence. He reportedly "quarreled" with the alleged victim and "grabbed her wrist" as she was picking up a phone. A police report stated the woman had "redness" on the wrist, "and a small cut, possibly from a fingernail." Said Brown in a statement, "While I do not agree with the suspension, I will accept it. I have exhausted the appeals process and have no other options along those lines."

 
 
Source: NJ.com
Aug 17 - 8:56 PM
Click to expand...

 
Title edited to reflect start of 2016 season. Thanks to Faust for bumping.

I still miss the old threads and advice columns from Herman.

Fwiw in NO Forbath got first shot at the job in preseason week 1 and he shanked his kick. I'm really liking the opportunity for Barth this year, hopefully he shows up.

 
You can't make this up:

Eagles K Caleb Sturgis will miss Thursday's preseason game after suffering a concussion in warmups.
Sturgis wasn't wearing a helmet and got blindsided by a ball. It's noteworthy because Sturgis is battling Cody Parkey for the starting job. His injury could decide the competition.
 

Related: Cody Parkey
 
Source: Eagles on Twitter 
Aug 18 - 7:04 PM
Click to expand...


Unbelievable!

 
Texans K Nick Novak is in the NFL's concussion protocol.
This is our second kicker concussion of the preseason after Eagles K Caleb Sturgis suffered one when a football hit him in the head during pregame warmups on Thursday night. Camp leg "Ka'imi Fairbairn" (quad) is also banged up.

 
 
 
Aug 21 - 3:23 PM
Click to expand...

 
Nugent has struggled mightily so far.  Still favored to keep the job in Cincy but Hocker is healthy now so should at least have a chance to compete for the job.

-QG

 
For those looking at bargain basement guys that will likely be on the board the last round, I like Matt Prater. Long foot + dome team and with Megatron no longer there as a RZ threat I see more FG attempts. Still no running game to speak of so not much going for it on 4th & short once inside the 40.

 
Leroy Hoard said:
For those looking at bargain basement guys that will likely be on the board the last round, I like Matt Prater. Long foot + dome team and with Megatron no longer there as a RZ threat I see more FG attempts. Still no running game to speak of so not much going for it on 4th & short once inside the 40.
Click to expand...
Also sounds like they plan to go no huddle and play fast more this year. 

 
Any good links to a kicker job-security list?  I'm doing a draft-only league, and I'm just looking for someone who won't get cut in preseason.

 
Here is my kicker job security list, where the number is something like the probability that the kicker is the yearlong starter for his team, assuming no new injuries. (I posted something similar before the 2014 season.)

1.0    Stephen Gostkowski    NE
1.0    Mason Crosby    GB
1.0    Justin Tucker    BAL
1.0    Adam Vinatieri    IND
1.0    Dan Bailey    DAL
1.0    Robbie Gould    CHI
1.0    Steven Hauschka    SEA
0.95    Chandler Catanzaro    ARI
0.95    Brandon McManus    DEN
0.95    Graham Gano    CAR
0.95    Sebastian Janikowski    OAK
0.95    Matt Prater    DET
0.95    Cairo Santos    KC
0.95    Phil Dawson    SF
0.95    Ryan Succop    TEN
0.90    Chris Boswell    PIT
0.90    Dan Carpenter    BUF
0.90    Dustin Hopkins    WAS
0.90    Josh Lambo    SD
0.90    Jason Myers    JAC
0.90    Roberto Aguayo    TB
0.85    Blair Walsh    MIN
0.85    Nick Folk    NYJ
0.85    Matt Bryant    ATL
0.85    Josh Brown    NYG
0.80    Greg Zuerlein    LARM
0.80    Nick Novak    HOU
0.80    Mike Nugent    CIN
0.75    Travis Coons    CLE
0.75    Andrew Franks    MIA
0.60    Kai Forbath    NO
0.50    Cody Parkey    PHI

 
Basically they're guesses, after looking at obvious sources of information where it seemed relevant (depth charts, Rotoworld blurbs, news, last year's performance, contract, etc).

 
In general those numbers seem high. Good work, just high given the boom/bust high-stakes nature of kickers.  

More specifically, one example is Jags fans were growing impatient with Myers last year. If he blows more PATs, his leash won't be too long. 

 
Hocker got cut.

In NO Barth's kickoffs have been extremely disappointing. Morstead is a great kickoff man but I'm thinking they want to spare him teh duty if they can, so that woudl give Forbath and edge IMO though his KOs are kind of mediocre too, just slightly better IMO.

Aguayo is starting to grow on me. Found his leg last week plus that offense should be moving up and down the 20s this year.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have three guidelines for drafting a kicker, in this order:

1. Dome kicker
2. High Powered Offense
3. Broncos kicker

 
Demian said:
I have three guidelines for drafting a kicker, in this order:

1. Dome kicker
2. High Powered Offense
3. Broncos kicker
Click to expand...
2b. Great defense and average offense that doesn't commit turnovers. Walsh was top 5 last year, and this year he kicks in a  dome 10 times, and has December games in Dallas and Jacksonville. I think Bradford = Bridgewater.

 
SoBeDad said:
2b. Great defense and average offense that doesn't commit turnovers. Walsh was top 5 last year, and this year he kicks in a  dome 10 times, and has December games in Dallas and Jacksonville. I think Bradford = Bridgewater.
Click to expand...
Cairo Santos in the last round = free $

 
What about Prater? I could see Detroit marching down field but not being able to punch it in with their rbs, leading to some fgs.

 
Saints released K Kai Forbath.
 
The Saints are going with UDFA Wil Lutz. Forbath beat Connor Barth in a summer competition, but evidently didn't convince the coaching staff he deserved to keep his job. Lutz is coming from small-school Georgia State, so it's definitely a gamble for a team that can never seem to settle on a kicker.

Related: Saints
 
Source: Ian Rapoport on Twitter
Click to expand...

 
I had no idea what the Saints were doing but I took a look at Lutz's work in Baltimore during the PS and things are looking up from my POV. He has a big leg.

 
Prater is my under the radar guy this year at K.  Detroit will be slinging it and if the last half of 2015 is any indication, they'll be able to move the ball and put points on the board.  With the loss of Calvin and a questionable ground game, I think they'll be settling for 3's on a frequent basis.  

 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Hot Sauce Guy
Can we talk about people taking K & D/ST earlier and earlier?
Replies
48
Views
3K
Hot Sauce Guy
Hot Sauce Guy
Hot Sauce Guy
Officially Unofficial K Contest! Week 9 Kickers, so plenty of time to enter.
2
Replies
54
Views
2K
Saint
Saint
Joe Bryant
Why Chris Boswell Is Ranked So Low...
2
Replies
59
Views
5K
Adam Harstad
Adam Harstad

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top