Shrek said:
I am still puzzled as to why this show has flown under the radar for so long. If half the number of people that watched The Sopranos had watched The Wire, this thread would be 100 pages long.
Arguably, the show didn't really hit it's stride until S3 and S4. S2 is universally considered the show's weakest season, I think that hurt the show tremendously. S1, I think the show was still trying to find it's way. It appears The Wire started out as a typical police procedural and evolved into a much more complex show over time.
The show is a critical darling, but it's not without flaws.
The "street" and "politics" side of the show is riveting. It's electric. The "law enforcement" side however is not as strong, often it's the weakest element in the show. The criminals and the politicians are truly three dimensional, I have my doubts if the cops shown are the same.
I think if the law enforcement side was kept as a much more minor component, this would have been a much more popular show. I could watch an hour straight of Omar, Avon, Stringer, D'Angelo, the four kids, Cutty, etc but I couldn't handle McNulty and crew for more than 5 minutes at a time.