Captain Cranks
Footballguy
BTW, thanks to NV for coming up with a great topic. After years on this board, this was the first to pull me into a music draft.
The point on “Mrs” was that those who have that in their name, including Mrs R, usually (always?) have their Mr on the board, too. Mrs Rannous/Val Rannous, Mrs BSR/Brave Sir Robin, etc. Presumably a guy is less likely to do that if the target’s husband is here.Pretty sure the guy who's typing "show me your cans" won't be deterred by a "Mrs."
Yeah, PM me whom you’re thinking of, please. I’m curious!I'll PM you if you want.
Yeah, I wasn't clear on the rules regarding that, either. I'm not sure how it would be interpreted, so I'm sticking with bands and artists' main affiliation, and not concentrating on bands where guys went solo. The only way that'll come into play for me is that I would imagine participation in hip hop troupes don't eliminate solo efforts by those involved, and solo efforts don't eliminate hip hop troupes whose members are also solo, and that's as far as I got determining anything like that.
But yeah, I think if you pick Ebony and Ivory, both Stevie and Paul would be eliminated, no? Or am I misunderstanding the spirit?
100% on the first bolded. There are people I have grown to really dislike in the PSF, but all's good when we are talking about music and movies.
2nd bolded is ridiculous, but then I remembered that guys are mostly predictable and gross. (unless those PMs were from simey ?)
Oh...didn't realize that was a thing. My ex used Mrs _____ on The Nest forum years ago and I guarantee you I was nowhere near that place.The point on “Mrs” was that those who have that in their name, including Mrs R, usually (always?) have their Mr on the board, too. Mrs Rannous/Val Rannous, Mrs BSR/Brave Sir Robin, etc. Presumably a guy is less likely to do that if the target’s husband is here.
You've never heard the hollow pyramid version? They used to sell it at Zody's.Side 3?
I hate to admit, but "Smoke on the Water" is the only Deep Purple song I know. Always liked it, but this is one of those bands from the 70s I never connected with.
Great pick. I'll let the peanut gallery stew on this one before posting my own shortly.Excellent!
1.32: "Wasted Years", Iron Maiden
Adrian Smith's masterpiece for the band. Smith wrote the song, came up with the urgent clarion call of an opening, and played one of the band's most memorable guitar solos over the bridge. Steve Harris tucks in and keeps the energy going on bass, allowing Smith's playing to stand front and center.
Bruce Dickinson, as the Somewhere in Time sessions began, had felt exhausted and listless after the group finished the year-long Power Slavery tour. For "Wasted Years", he dug deep and got right off that schneid with authority.
@Captain Cranks for two.
Good pick - almost certainly in my Soundgarden Top 5. I also enjoy the Johnny Cash cover. I would probably go The Day I Tried to Live. Maybe more controversially, I love Slaves and Bulldozers and still put Outshined in their Top 5.1.22
Soundgarden Rusty Cage.
Tough call for me, but Badmotorfinger was one of my high school sound tracks if you will. This song kicks you in the teeth from the beginning. It showcases Cornell's vocals, and Thayills guitar work. It should get you fired up.....if it doesn't, check ur pulse!
Outshined would be my pick. Wasn't a big Soundgarden fan back in the day but like them more as i've gotten olderGood pick - almost certainly in my Soundgarden Top 5. I also enjoy the Johnny Cash cover. I would probably go The Day I Tried to Live. Maybe more controversially, I love Slaves and Bulldozers and still put Outshined in their Top 5.
She should sign up here with the user name Tennille.Oh...didn't realize that was a thing. My ex used Mrs _____ on The Nest forum years ago and I guarantee you I was nowhere near that place.
Somewhat related, I dated a girl a few years ago and after we realized it wasn't working out, we began helping each other with our Tinder profiles. She'd show me all the messages she was getting from guys and it blew my mind how forward these people were. "Will you have my baby?" was a go-to for some.
Great Pick. Would have been my next pick had it fallen. Roadhouse Blues and Love Me Two Times would be up there too1.33 L.A. Woman, The Doors
Title track from the Doors’ last album. Great lyrics and rollercoaster melodies.
Fun fact - During recording, Jim’s unexpected lyric “Mr. Mojo Risin” helped set the tempo of the song as drummer Jonathan Densmore thought “Risin’” was a signal to speed things up. It wasn’t until after the song was complete that Morrison showed the band that Mr. Mojo Risin was an anagram of his name.
Honorable Mention – Break on Through
I'm not trying to be Posty here, but I mentioned a couple days ago about my BIL's cousin getting murdered in Denver. He said that she (Katie) told her parents a couple weeks ago that her boyfriend had beat her up. They lived together, and she shared custody of her kids with her ex husband. Katie's parents told her to please leave him, and they paid for an apt for her and the kids to move to, and she was supposed to move this weekend. Her ex-husband knew her boyfriend hurt her, and he told her that the kids were staying with him until she left her boyfriend. Monday morning she was getting in her car to go to work, and her boyfriend came out of the house and shot her in the face in the car. The car rolled down the street, and hit another car and caught on fire. Neighbors got her out of the car, but she was dead from the gunshot wound. The boyfriend shot himself inside the house. If the kids were there he probably would have shot them too. My BIL said his Uncle Bob is filled with rage right now. He can't even grieve, because he is so angry. One of my BIL's sisters broke the news to his mom. Katie was like a daughter to her. I'll be seeing some of them at Thanksgiving. It's gonna be a melancholy one. I think even if she had moved to the apt, he would have tracked her down there and killed her, and restraining orders don't really work. Sometimes the only alternative is to move and get a new identity.
Ha! Slaves and Bulldozers and Loud Love were my two other finalistsGood pick - almost certainly in my Soundgarden Top 5. I also enjoy the Johnny Cash cover. I would probably go The Day I Tried to Live. Maybe more controversially, I love Slaves and Bulldozers and still put Outshined in their Top 5.
Was hoping theyd last until round 2. Good song but not in my top 10Excellent!
1.32: "Wasted Years", Iron Maiden
Adrian Smith's masterpiece for the band. Smith wrote the song, came up with the urgent clarion call of an opening, and played one of the band's most memorable guitar solos over the bridge. Steve Harris tucks in and keeps the energy going on bass, allowing Smith's playing to stand front and center.
Bruce Dickinson, as the Somewhere in Time sessions began, had felt exhausted and listless after the group finished the year-long Power Slavery tour. For "Wasted Years", he dug deep and got right off that schneid with authority.
@Captain Cranks for two.
That's just crazy and brutal. So sorry.I'm not trying to be Posty here, but I mentioned a couple days ago about my BIL's cousin getting murdered in Denver. He said that she (Katie) told her parents a couple weeks ago that her boyfriend had beat her up. They lived together, and she shared custody of her kids with her ex husband. Katie's parents told her to please leave him, and they paid for an apt for her and the kids to move to, and she was supposed to move this weekend. Her ex-husband knew her boyfriend hurt her, and he told her that the kids were staying with him until she left her boyfriend. Monday morning she was getting in her car to go to work, and her boyfriend came out of the house and shot her in the face in the car. The car rolled down the street, and hit another car and caught on fire. Neighbors got her out of the car, but she was dead from the gunshot wound. The boyfriend shot himself inside the house. If the kids were there he probably would have shot them too. My BIL said his Uncle Bob is filled with rage right now. He can't even grieve, because he is so angry. One of my BIL's sisters broke the news to his mom. Katie was like a daughter to her. I'll be seeing some of them at Thanksgiving. It's gonna be a melancholy one. I think even if she had moved to the apt, he would have tracked her down there and killed her, and restraining orders don't really work. Sometimes the only alternative is to move and get a new identity.
Iconic song for sure and I can't fault you for taking it. If I took The Doors it'd be between Five to One, Riders on the Storm, Peace Frog or Alabama Song.....now I'm in a Doors mood1.33 L.A. Woman, The Doors
Title track from the Doors’ last album. Great lyrics and rollercoaster melodies.
Fun fact - During recording, Jim’s unexpected lyric “Mr. Mojo Risin” helped set the tempo of the song as drummer Jonathan Densmore thought “Risin’” was a signal to speed things up. It wasn’t until after the song was complete that Morrison showed the band that Mr. Mojo Risin was an anagram of his name.
Honorable Mention – Break on Through
One of the best songs to sing out loud to.1.33 L.A. Woman, The Doors
Title track from the Doors’ last album. Great lyrics and rollercoaster melodies.
Fun fact - During recording, Jim’s unexpected lyric “Mr. Mojo Risin” helped set the tempo of the song as drummer Jonathan Densmore thought “Risin’” was a signal to speed things up. It wasn’t until after the song was complete that Morrison showed the band that Mr. Mojo Risin was an anagram of his name.
Honorable Mention – Break on Through
Used to bewilder my kids by belting out "Mister Mojo Risin" in my best Jim Morrison voice. I think it grew on them over the yearsOne of the best songs to sing out loud to.
. Love L.A. Woman.I was definitely going to take these guys at the turn if they fell to me. You highlighted my favorite part of the song as well. I was probably going to go Right in Two. Aenema is my favorite out of the songs that got heavy airplay.2.01 Schism, Tool
One of the most intelligent, innovative rock bands in history. The crescendo that starts at 4:00 and builds to 5:53 gives me chills every time. What makes it even more special is that James Maynard Keenan writes his lyrics to the music after it’s completed, so he purposely delays ending the sentence with “…between supposed lovers” at the song’s climax.
Damn you Cranks! I was really close to going with Tool in the first round! Shoulda figured they wouldn't get back to me..... My favorite Tool song is always kind of changing. So much to take in! Currently, Right In Two would be my choice. Schism is an excellent choice, though, and one of my faves as well.2.01 Schism, Tool
One of the most intelligent, innovative rock bands in history. The crescendo that starts at 4:00 and builds to 5:53 gives me chills every time. What makes it even more special is that James Maynard Keenan writes his lyrics to the music after it’s completed, so he purposely delays ending the sentence with “…between supposed lovers” at the song’s climax.
Honorable mention - Parabola
Does @Doug Bgo or should we PM @shuke for the revised 11th pick?
Haha... no way! I swear I did not see your post before I posted mine below! Right in Two is sooooooo good!I was definitely going to take these guys at the turn if they fell to me. You highlighted my favorite part of the song as well. I was probably going to go Right in Two. Aenema is my favorite out of the songs that got heavy airplay.
The lyrical theme of the song just fits the music so well, and the build up from ~5:24 to ~7:30 is amazing.Haha... no way! I swear I did not see your post before I posted mine below! Right in Two is sooooooo good!
Yeah although there are a ton of genres we haven't even touched yet.I'm feeling as if some of my more obscure picks may not be as obscure as I think with some of y'all
L.A. Woman will forever remind me of Dan's Cafe in Washington, D.C., a bar in Adams Morgan where they sold alcohol by the flask (if that sounds like a bad idea, it was) and had L.A. Woman on the jukebox. That #### got played every weekend we were out, with the requisite singing out loud (if that sounds like a bad idea, it was) and merrymaking. Good times, and I can barely remember any of them.1.33 L.A. Woman, The Doors
Title track from the Doors’ last album. Great lyrics and rollercoaster melodies.
Fun fact - During recording, Jim’s unexpected lyric “Mr. Mojo Risin” helped set the tempo of the song as drummer Jonathan Densmore thought “Risin’” was a signal to speed things up. It wasn’t until after the song was complete that Morrison showed the band that Mr. Mojo Risin was an anagram of his name.
Honorable Mention – Break on Through
You just wait til @landrys hat turns his gaze your way.Yeah although there are a ton of genres we haven't even touched yet.
It is a powerful song, even for Tool standards, which makes it high on the list for most powerful song ever writtenThe lyrical theme of the song just fits the music so well, and the build up from ~5:24 to ~7:30 is amazing.
I'd agree with that. I wasn't so much disagreeing that adolescent ties to music don't exist, more that they are broken, often without a ton of thought. To wit: I didn't consciously decide "I'm going to dislike late 80s glam metal because that's what I want to do," I just wound up that way. I didn't say "I'm going to think that the sociological outlook of thrash is unappealing," it just happened. Same with some of the grunge I loved, even. The personal loathing and depression/drug addiction involved in it makes me a bit squeamish now. I don't necessarily love the music that shaped my youth, is all. I had a good time as a young man, just could do without a lot of the flamboyance and angst that the music provided, I guess. I think that's part of growing up, too.I think the connections E was talking about just makes it harder to break those emotional connections for the negative or positive? There's still a handful of bands that I will forever have that emotional connection to from the HS/college days - RH, Pumpkins, Soundgarden, etc.. There are a handful of bands now that I love like Black Crowes and Pink Floyd that in order to get there with those bands there was a lot more negative b.s. to get over because of groups that listened to them or just my perception of the bands and songs.
I think you and k4 should be (mostly) safe this go round.You just wait til @landrys hat turns his gaze your way.
The first four songs of Badmotorfinger are to Gen Xers what side 1 of Zeppelin IV is to boomers.Good pick - almost certainly in my Soundgarden Top 5. I also enjoy the Johnny Cash cover. I would probably go The Day I Tried to Live. Maybe more controversially, I love Slaves and Bulldozers and still put Outshined in their Top 5.
This is a fantastic song. I'm sure I've heard it many times before, but it sounds pretty fresh to my ears.Rd 2: My World is Empty Without You by The Supremes
Holland-Dozier-Holland masterclass that somehow didn’t reach number 1 on the US Pop Charts and failed to chart in the UK. The Supremes were so red hot that this was one of the only singles to not hit number 1. It should have.
Rd 2: My World is Empty Without You by The Supremes
Holland-Dozier-Holland masterclass that somehow didn’t reach number 1 on the US Pop Charts and failed to chart in the UK. The Supremes were so red hot that this was one of the only singles to not hit number 1. It should have.
Berry Gordy's First Commandment was "hook the listener from the get-go and don't let up". This record is a perfect example of that.Rd 2: My World is Empty Without You by The Supremes
Holland-Dozier-Holland masterclass that somehow didn’t reach number 1 on the US Pop Charts and failed to chart in the UK. The Supremes were so red hot that this was one of the only singles to not hit number 1. It should have.
Awfully hard to quibble with this selection. "You Keep Me Hangin' On" might be the winner for me, but there are so many classics by them that it's hard to say that one is definitively or even subjectively better. This is where ranking songs is tough and where "best" becomes simply preference, if that's even not varied from one day to the next.Rd 2: My World is Empty Without You by The Supremes
Holland-Dozier-Holland masterclass that somehow didn’t reach number 1 on the US Pop Charts and failed to chart in the UK. The Supremes were so red hot that this was one of the only singles to not hit number 1. It should have.