I wrote a short novel and you're complaining I left stuff out. He was fired the day he took the job and if you scroll back to the beginning of this thread you can see fans wanted him gone so quickly.
You "can't" say the Jags we're a bad team if they made the playoffs. I agree they imploded but this was a prob before Urban. They were the worst last year and he's taking all the blame.
I don't think it's fair people expected success for any QB their rookie year nevermind Lawrence. He's showing he's got the goods and taking his lumps like oh so many before him. We often look for a big improvement in year two and I expect that from him.
The Jags need trenches help and it's been a systemic problem. Even when they assemble a decent line it doesn't last but for like one year. Bottles and other QBs were sacked similarly often. They should spend every pick on trenches or else I don't think a new coach is going to do very well.
And don't add a Bills castoff either
If you write a short novel about Ted Bundy and leave out the murder and cannibalism he seems like a charming guy. Leave out the genocide and ww2 and Hitler seems like a great orator with a sweet tooth. Leave out the fight for racial equality and Martin Luther King Jr is a regular old preacher. Point is - if you decide to ignore the key points then sure, you can look at reality any way you want.
As for why the Jags fans and people with knowledge of football in general hated the hire
@Ministry of Paini started off the thread with a lovely series of bullet points as to why.
I don't believe I said the Jags were a bad team when they made the playoffs, but I disagree with the idea. Bad teams sneak into the playoffs all the time. Hell the entire Nfc east was a train wreck last year and they had to send a team to the playoffs - are you going to tell me any of those teams was deserving, let alone good? Now what I did say was that after their playoff run the Jags had a mass exodus of great players, mostly because of poor coaching (at least I remember at the time jags players telling others not to come while the current regime was in the building). Eventually it lead to them catering last year and the flashy hire of Meyer, which was never a good move from a football perspective.
Rookie qbs are extremely easy to evaluate. They only need to answer one question: as the season goes on did they improve? In Lawrence's case the answer is no, and what's worse is he, and the offense as a whole, is back sliding. Remember Meyer's claim to fame in college was his offenses. But that was years ago, and if you watch the offenses the Jaguars run they're some of the most boring least inventive in the league. If Meyer was a defense oriented coach in his first hc position then you could blame this on the oc, but he's not. He's a multiple time HC with an offensive background. No excuse.
The Jaguars need a complete culture shift. I don't like Dan Campbell as a coach and think he's way out of his depth, but nobody will argue that the culture in Detroit is a billion times better than it was last year because Campbell genuinely gives a #### and puts all of himself into the team. That's what the Jags need more than anything - a leader who will leave their entire heart and soul in the building. Then you can focus on building a winning team. But as it is now the locker room culture is never going to breed success and Meyer is just another in a long line of terrible jags front office moves.