So no one came up with anything after I took the time to compile and post the data that people were asking for?
Just saw the data for the first time this morning, but something I'll throw out there is that, at least for the 2012 season, and using the MFL D/ST point system of:
>
Points Allowed
0 = 5 points
1-6 = 3 points
7-13 = 1 point
14+ = 0 points
Total Yards Allowed
0-199 = 5 points
200-249 = 3 points
250-299 = 1 point
300+ = 0 points
Sack = 1 point
INT = 2 points
Fumble Recovery = 2 points
Safety = 2 points
TD (inc. ST) = 6 points
... the bottom five elements (i.e. "base" D/ST scoring) accounted for 86% of the total D/ST scoring.
If, as has been noted upthread, the correlation between ADP and "base" scoring, or between last year's and this year's "base" scoring, are weak at best, I have a hard time believing that the addition of anything less than
very generous scoring with regards to yards / points allowed will change that conclusion one whit.