Or pretty much every video game site on the net. The XBox Reveal got trashed by ALL critics. And I'm talking about the most respected individuals in the industry.
Can you blame em, it was an absolutely horrible reveal and the console is quickly shaping up to be dead on arrival.
It was definitely a bad reveal. I think Microsoft can rebound during E3, but it's gonna take some really awesome exclusives. And they need to stop beating around the bush and just come clean on the details. The confusion was either on purpose or terrible communication on their part. But Microsoft has been blaming the press, saying that it's their fault for reporting incorrect info.
I can absolutely see the XB1 turning it around at E3. First, like you said, they show a bunch of exclusives. Not Kinect games, and not just another Forza or Gears, but new IPs. And not Kinect games. Second, again like you said, they clarify what's going on with DRM and used games. The PR disaster from the reveal wouldn't have been quite so bad if they hadn't offered up so many slimy, lawyer-like answers to very basic questions.
Here's the key thing though.
If Sony announces a bunch of DRM and used-game-blocking features like the XB1, then that immediately takes a lot of heat off MSFT. And Sony will absolutely get pressed on this issue at E3 for good reason. If Sony and Microsoft are hand-in-hand on this issue, then they'll both take lots of bad press, but it's probably something like a wash in terms of positioning for the next round of console wars, but if Sony backs off their rumored DRM plans, then Microsoft might as well cancel production unless they have really dug-in developer support.